1.2 Limit state design of steel structures
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain the limit state philosophy of IS 800:2007 Section 5: characteristic values, partial safety factors for loads and materials, and the limit states of strength and serviceability.
- Form factored load combinations with the partial safety factors of IS 800:2007 Table 4, including the 0.9 dead-load factor where dead load helps stability, and design strengths with the factors of Table 5.
- Classify a cross-section as plastic, compact or semi-compact by IS 800:2007 cl. 3.7.2 and Table 2, and check a laterally supported beam for bending, shear and deflection.
Theory
A limit state is a condition beyond which a structure no longer does its job. IS 800:2007 cl. 5.2.2 divides them into two groups. The limit states of strength (cl. 5.2.2.1) cover loss of equilibrium, loss of stability including sway and overturning, failure by excessive deformation or rupture, fatigue fracture and brittle fracture. The limit states of serviceability (cl. 5.2.2.2) cover deflection, vibration, repairable fatigue damage, corrosion and durability, and fire. The design must keep the chance of reaching any of them during the life of the structure acceptably small. Under cl. 3.1.2.1 and 5.1.4 structures are normally designed by the limit state method, with the working stress method of Section 11 as the alternative where limit state design cannot conveniently be adopted.
Loads and strengths both scatter. IS 800:2007 cl. 5.3.2.1 defines characteristic actions as values not expected to be exceeded with more than 5 per cent probability during the life of the structure, taken in practice from IS 875 and IS 1893; cl. 2.1 makes the nominal material properties the characteristic strengths. Partial safety factors then move each side towards safety separately. Under cl. 5.3.3 the design action is Qd = Σ γfk Qck, with the load factors of Table 4. Under cl. 5.4.1 the design strength is Sd = Su/γm, with the material factors of Table 5: γm0 = 1.10 for resistance governed by yielding and for buckling, γm1 = 1.25 for resistance governed by ultimate stress, 1.25 for bolts and rivets, and 1.25 for shop welds and 1.50 for field welds. The basic requirement of cl. 5.2.1 is simply design action ≤ design strength.
Table 4 gives the load factors for each combination of cl. 3.5.1. For the limit state of strength: dead load plus imposed load uses 1.5 on each; dead load plus imposed load plus wind or earthquake uses 1.2 on each when there are no cranes (the row also gives a 0.6 wind factor with the imposed load leading); dead load plus wind or earthquake uses 1.5 on each, with 0.9 on the dead load where it helps stability against overturning or reduces the stress caused by the other loads. For the limit state of serviceability the factors are 1.0 for dead plus imposed load, and 1.0, 0.8 and 0.8 on dead, imposed and wind load together. Under cl. 3.5.2 wind and earthquake are never taken to act at the same time.
Steel members are made of thin plates, so a compressed plate can buckle locally before the section reaches its full strength. IS 800:2007 cl. 3.7.2 sorts sections into four classes by the width-to-thickness ratio of their plate elements (Table 2). Plastic (class 1) sections can form plastic hinges with enough rotation for a collapse mechanism; compact (class 2) sections reach the plastic moment but cannot rotate much further; semi-compact (class 3) sections reach first yield at the extreme fibre but not the plastic moment; slender (class 4) sections buckle locally before yield. The limits are written in terms of ε = (250/fy)^0.5, so stronger steel needs stockier plates. For a rolled I-section in bending, the flange outstand limit b/tf is 9.4ε, 10.5ε and 15.7ε for plastic, compact and semi-compact, and a web with its neutral axis at mid-depth has the limits d/tw of 84ε, 105ε and 126ε. The section takes the class of its worst element.
The class decides the bending strength. For a laterally supported beam with low shear (factored shear not more than 0.6 Vd), cl. 8.2.1.2 gives Md = βb Zp fy/γm0, with βb = 1.0 for plastic and compact sections and Ze/Zp for semi-compact ones, but not more than 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 for a simply supported beam, so that the beam does not yield permanently under service loads. The shear strength is Vd = Vn/γm0 with the plastic shear resistance Vp = Av fyw/√3 of cl. 8.4.1, where Av = h tw for a hot-rolled I-section bending about its major axis (cl. 8.4.1.1). Deflection is checked under service loads, using the serviceability load factors of Table 4 (cl. 5.6.1 as revised by Amendment No. 1 of January 2012; 1.0 on dead and imposed load), against the limits of Table 6, for example span/300 for floor and roof elements not susceptible to cracking and span/360 for elements susceptible to cracking. The same amendment makes the live load of Table 6 include all post-construction loads, including superimposed dead loads.
Derivation
- Reliability requirement: failure means the resistance R falls below the load effect S. Both scatter, so instead of a single factor of safety the method takes an upper characteristic load (about 5 per cent chance of being exceeded) and a lower characteristic strength (about 5 per cent chance of falling below), and puts separate factors on each: γf Sk ≤ Rk/γm.
- Overall margin: with γf = 1.5 and γm0 = 1.10 a member governed by yielding has a margin of 1.5 × 1.10 = 1.65 between characteristic strength and characteristic load; a member governed by rupture at a bolt hole, with γm1 = 1.25, has 1.5 × 1.25 = 1.875, because fracture gives no warning and fu scatters more.
- Why ε = (250/fy)^0.5: the elastic local buckling stress of a plate is σcr = k π² E/(12(1 − ν²)) (t/b)². Requiring σcr to reach fy gives b/t ∝ √(E/fy). Since E is the same for all grades, the limit for any grade is the E250 limit times √(250/fy) = ε.
- Design yield of a tension member: the gross section yields when T = Ag fy; dividing by γm0 gives Tdg = Ag fy/γm0 (cl. 6.2). Rupture at the net section across bolt holes gives Tdn = 0.9 An fu/γm1 (cl. 6.3.1), the 0.9 allowing for stress concentration and eccentricity at the holes.
- Plastic shear: by the von Mises criterion a web in pure shear yields at τy = fy/√3, so the web carries Vp = Av fy/√3.
- Deflection of a simply supported beam under a uniform load w: δ = 5 w L⁴/(384 E I), checked with service loads and the serviceability factors of Table 4 (1.0 on imposed load).
Design action Qd = Σ γfk Qck (kN, kN m); design strength Sd = Su/γm (IS 800:2007 cl. 5.3.3, 5.4.1)Strength combinations (Table 4, no cranes): 1.5 DL + 1.5 LL; 1.2 DL + 1.2 LL + 1.2 WL (or EL); 1.5 DL + 1.5 WL (or EL); 0.9 DL + 1.5 WL where dead load resists overturning or upliftServiceability factors (Table 4): 1.0 DL + 1.0 LL; 1.0 DL + 0.8 LL + 0.8 WL; 1.0 DL + 1.0 WLMaterial factors (Table 5): γm0 = 1.10 (yielding, buckling); γm1 = 1.25 (ultimate stress); bolts 1.25; welds 1.25 shop, 1.50 fieldε = (250/fy)^0.5 (fy in N/mm²); rolled I flange outstand b/tf ≤ 9.4ε, 10.5ε, 15.7ε; web (neutral axis at mid-depth) d/tw ≤ 84ε, 105ε, 126ε for plastic, compact, semi-compactTension (cl. 6.2, 6.3.1): Tdg = Ag fy/γm0; Tdn = 0.9 An fu/γm1 (N; areas in mm², stresses in N/mm²)Bending, low shear (cl. 8.2.1.2): Md = βb Zp fy/γm0 ≤ 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 (simply supported) (N mm)Shear (cl. 8.4, 8.4.1): Vd = Av fyw/(√3 γm0) (N), Av = h tw for hot-rolled I-sections, major axisDeflection limits (Table 6, floors and roofs under live load): span/300 not susceptible to cracking; span/360 susceptible to cracking
- Characteristic loads come from IS 875 and IS 1893 and characteristic strengths are the nominal values of IS 800 Section 2.
- The beam checks here assume full lateral restraint of the compression flange (for example by a slab); laterally unsupported beams need the lateral-torsional buckling check of a later chapter.
- Low shear (Vu ≤ 0.6 Vd) is assumed for the bending strength; above that the moment capacity is reduced.
- Web shear buckling is not checked when d/tw is not more than 67ε (Table 2, note 3); deeper, thinner webs need it.
- Linear elastic analysis is used to find the load effects; plastic analysis is allowed only under the conditions of cl. 4.5 and for plastic sections.
- Wind and earthquake are not combined (cl. 3.5.2).
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 3.1.2.1 and 5.1.4 (limit state method is the normal method; working stress design of Section 11 where it cannot conveniently be adopted), cl. 5.2.1 (design based on characteristic values with partial safety factors; design action ≤ design strength), cl. 5.2.2, 5.2.2.1 and 5.2.2.2 (limit states of strength and serviceability), cl. 5.3.2.1 (characteristic actions, 5 per cent probability), cl. 5.3.3 with Table 4 (partial safety factors for loads), cl. 5.4.1 with Table 5 (partial safety factors for materials), cl. 5.5.1.1 (stability against overturning with 0.9 on the permanent actions that resist), cl. 3.5.1 and 3.5.2 (load combinations; wind and earthquake not together).
- IS 800:2007 cl. 3.7.1, 3.7.2 with Table 2 (classes of cross-section, ε = (250/fy)^0.5, web shear buckling check above d/t of 67ε), cl. 6.2 and 6.3.1 (tension yielding and rupture), cl. 8.2.1.2 (bending strength at low shear and the 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 limit), cl. 8.4 and 8.4.1, 8.4.1.1 (shear strength, Av = h tw for hot-rolled sections), cl. 5.6.1 with Table 6 (deflection limits under service loads, with the serviceability load factors of Table 4 and live load including post-construction loads, as revised by Amendment No. 1 of January 2012). Loads to IS 875 (Part 1) and (Part 2) and IS 1893 (Part 1), named by number only.
- EN 1993-1-1 also designs by limit states with partial factors γM0, γM1 and γM2 on resistance, takes load factors and combinations from EN 1990, and has four cross-section classes. AISC 360 offers two routes in one specification: load and resistance factor design (LRFD), with load factors from ASCE 7 and resistance factors φ, and allowable strength design (ASD), with safety factors Ω; it classifies elements as compact, noncompact or slender. The approaches are listed side by side, not ranked.
Worked examples
Problem. A column of an industrial shed carries characteristic axial loads of dead load 300 kN, imposed load 200 kN and wind load 150 kN (wind can act as compression or as uplift). Find the design axial forces for the limit state of strength by IS 800:2007 Table 4, and check whether the column base can see net uplift.
- 1.5 DL + 1.5 LL = 1.5 × (300 + 200) = 750 kN compression.
- 1.2 DL + 1.2 LL + 1.2 WL (wind compressive) = 1.2 × (300 + 200 + 150) = 780 kN compression. This governs the compression design.
- 1.5 DL + 1.5 WL (wind compressive) = 1.5 × (300 + 150) = 675 kN.
- Uplift case, dead load resisting: 0.9 DL − 1.5 WL = 0.9 × 300 − 1.5 × 150 = 270 − 225 = 45 kN, still compression, so no net uplift on the base. Imposed load is left out because it may be absent.
- Serviceability values for deflection checks: 1.0 DL + 1.0 LL = 500 kN; 1.0 DL + 0.8 LL + 0.8 WL = 300 + 160 + 120 = 580 kN.
Answer. Design compression 780 kN (1.2 DL + 1.2 LL + 1.2 WL); minimum 45 kN compression, no net uplift
Problem. A 200 mm × 10 mm plate of E250 steel (fy = 250 MPa, fu = 410 MPa) is connected by bolts with two 22 mm holes across the width in one line. Find the design tensile strength by yielding of the gross section and by rupture of the net section (block shear is checked separately in the tension-member chapter).
- Ag = 200 × 10 = 2 000 mm². Tdg = 2 000 × 250/1.10 = 454 545 N = 454.5 kN (cl. 6.2).
- An = (200 − 2 × 22) × 10 = 1 560 mm². Tdn = 0.9 × 1 560 × 410/1.25 = 460 512 N = 460.5 kN (cl. 6.3.1).
- Design strength = lower value = 454.5 kN, governed by gross-section yielding: the plate stretches visibly before it can tear at the holes, the ductile outcome a designer wants.
- Allowed factored tension at γf = 1.5: service tension up to 454.5/1.5 = 303.0 kN.
Answer. Td = 454.5 kN (yielding governs; rupture 460.5 kN)
Problem. A simply supported floor beam spans 8 m and carries characteristic loads of dead load 12 kN/m (self-weight of the beam and the floor slab, with no finishes added later) and imposed load 8 kN/m. It uses the 400 mm I-section of lesson 1.1, Example 2 (bf 180, tf 14, tw 8 mm; Ze = 1.111 × 10⁶ mm³, Zp = 1.249 × 10⁶ mm³, Ix = 2.221 × 10⁸ mm⁴) in E250 steel, with the compression flange held by the floor slab. Classify the section and check bending, shear and imposed-load deflection (span/360, finishes susceptible to cracking).
- ε = (250/250)^0.5 = 1. Flange outstand b/tf = 90/14 = 6.43 ≤ 9.4: plastic. Web d/tw = 372/8 = 46.5 ≤ 84: plastic. Section is plastic, βb = 1.0; 46.5 ≤ 67, so no shear-buckling check.
- wu = 1.5 × (12 + 8) = 30 kN/m. Mu = 30 × 8²/8 = 240 kN m; Vu = 30 × 8/2 = 120 kN.
- Shear: Av = 400 × 8 = 3 200 mm²; Vd = 3 200 × 250/(√3 × 1.10) = 419.9 kN. Vu = 120 kN ≤ 0.6 Vd = 251.9 kN, so low shear.
- Md = 1.0 × 1.249 × 10⁶ × 250/1.10 = 284.0 kN m, not more than 1.2 × 1.111 × 10⁶ × 250/1.10 = 302.9 kN m. Mu/Md = 240/284.0 = 0.85: safe.
- All the dead load is in place before the floor is used, so the Table 6 live load is the 8 kN/m imposed load (superimposed dead load such as finishes would be added to it). Deflection under 8 kN/m: δ = 5 × 8 × 8 000⁴/(384 × 2.0 × 10⁵ × 2.221 × 10⁸) = 9.6 mm ≤ 8 000/360 = 22.2 mm: satisfactory.
Answer. Plastic section; Mu 240 ≤ Md 284.0 kN m; Vu 120 ≤ Vd 419.9 kN (low shear); deflection 9.6 mm ≤ 22.2 mm
Step-by-step procedure
- Collect characteristic loads from IS 875 and IS 1893 and set up the combinations of cl. 3.5.1 (wind and earthquake never together).
- Apply the strength factors of Table 4 to each combination and find the design forces; use 0.9 on dead load where it resists overturning or uplift.
- Choose a trial section; find ε and classify each plate element by Table 2; the worst element fixes the class.
- Find the design strengths with γm0 or γm1 from Table 5 for the relevant failure modes (yielding, rupture, buckling, bending, shear).
- Check design action ≤ design strength for every member and combination.
- Check deflection and vibration with service loads and the serviceability factors of Table 4 against Table 6 and the client's needs.
- Revise the section if a check fails, or if the utilisation is very low.
Site notes
- The design assumes the steel grade and section on the drawing; a substitution by a lighter section or a lower grade has to go back to the designer, because both the strength and the class can change.
- Lateral restraint assumed in design (slab, decking, bracing) must be in place before the beam takes its full load; during erection an unrestrained beam is weaker than the design value.
- Field welds carry a higher material factor than shop welds (1.50 against 1.25), so as much welding as possible is done in the shop and site joints are bolted.
- Holding-down bolts are designed for the uplift case with 0.9 on dead load; they are set to template before the foundation is cast.
- Camber for dead-load deflection can be specified on long beams so that the floor ends up level.
- Using 1.5 on dead load in the uplift or overturning case; where dead load resists, its factor is 0.9.
- Dividing rupture strength by γm0 instead of γm1 = 1.25, or forgetting the 0.9 factor on An fu.
- Forgetting ε when classifying a higher grade: for E350 the plastic flange limit is 9.4 × 0.845 = 7.94, not 9.4.
- Using Zp for a semi-compact section; its bending strength is based on Ze.
- Checking deflection with the strength-level factored loads; serviceability uses service loads with the serviceability factors of Table 4 (1.0 for dead plus imposed load).
- Combining wind and earthquake in one load case.
For a laterally supported plastic or compact I-beam in E250 steel, Md in kN m is about 0.227 times Zp in cm³ (250/1.10/1 000). For Example 3: 0.227 × 1 249 = 284 kN m. The shortcut holds for low shear and plates under 20 mm thick; thicker plates and other grades change fy.
Summary
- Limit state design puts separate partial factors on loads (Table 4) and on material strengths (Table 5) and requires design action ≤ design strength.
- Strength combinations without cranes: 1.5 DL + 1.5 LL; 1.2 (DL + LL + WL); 1.5 (DL + WL); 0.9 DL where dead load helps stability.
- γm0 = 1.10 for yielding and buckling, γm1 = 1.25 for ultimate stress; welds 1.25 shop and 1.50 field.
- Sections are plastic, compact, semi-compact or slender by Table 2, with limits scaled by ε = (250/fy)^0.5.
- A laterally supported beam at low shear has Md = βb Zp fy/γm0 ≤ 1.2 Ze fy/γm0; deflection is checked at service load against Table 6.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the design tensile strength by gross yielding of a 150 mm × 8 mm E250 plate.
Tdg = 1 200 × 250/1.10 = 272 727 N = 272.7 kN.
2A beam carries a dead load moment of 20 kN m and an imposed load moment of 15 kN m. Find the design moment for the limit state of strength.
Mu = 1.5 × (20 + 15) = 52.5 kN m.
3Find ε for E410 steel (fy = 410 MPa) and the plastic limit for a rolled flange outstand.
ε = (250/410)^0.5 = 0.781; limit 9.4 × 0.781 = 7.34.
4Why is γm1 larger than γm0?
γm1 applies to failure at the ultimate stress (rupture), which is sudden and shows more scatter; γm0 applies to yielding, which is ductile and gives warning.
5Find the imposed-load deflection limit for a 7.5 m floor beam carrying brittle finishes.
Span/360 = 7 500/360 = 20.8 mm.
6A roof column has dead load 100 kN and wind uplift 70 kN. Is there net uplift at the base?
0.9 × 100 − 1.5 × 70 = 90 − 105 = −15 kN, so there is a net uplift of 15 kN; holding-down bolts must be designed for it.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.