5.2 Laterally unsupported beams
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain lateral-torsional buckling (LTB) of an unbraced beam from first principles and why it lowers the bending strength below the laterally supported value of lesson 5.1.
- Compute the elastic critical moment Mcr with the simplified I-section equation of IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.2.1 and with the classical doubly symmetric expression (Annex E), using It, Iw, Iy and the effective length LLT of cl. 8.3 / Table 15.
- Find λLT, φLT, χLT, fbd and Md = βb Zp fbd under cl. 8.2.2 with αLT = 0.21 (rolled) or 0.49 (welded), and show how intermediate lateral restraints and destabilizing loads change the answer.
Theory
A deep I-beam bent about its strong axis has a compression flange that behaves like a slender strut. If nothing holds that flange sideways, at some moment it moves out of plane, and because the tension flange resists that movement, the whole section also twists. This combined sideways bending and twisting is lateral-torsional buckling. It happens at a moment that may be far below the yield moment of the section, so an unbraced beam can fail with the steel still mostly elastic. Lesson 5.1 dealt with beams whose compression flange is held; this lesson covers IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.2, Laterally Unsupported Beams.
From first principles, consider a simply supported, doubly symmetric I-beam under uniform moment M, with the ends prevented from twisting and moving sideways but free to rotate on plan and free to warp. Writing the equilibrium of the slightly buckled shape gives two coupled equations: lateral bending EIy u″ = −M φ and torsion GIt φ′ − EIw φ‴ = M u′, where u is the sideways movement and φ the twist. With sine-shaped modes u and φ ∝ sin(πz/LLT), the lowest non-trivial solution is the elastic critical moment Mcr = √[(π² E Iy / LLT²)(G It + π² E Iw / LLT²)]. The first bracket is the Euler load of the beam about its weak axis; inside the second bracket G It is the St Venant torsional stiffness and π² E Iw / LLT² is the warping stiffness. This is the classical result found in elastic-stability texts, and IS 800:2007 Annex E states it for a doubly symmetric prismatic beam under uniform moment with torsionally restraining supports.
The section constants are simple for plate I-sections. The St Venant torsion constant of an open section is It = Σ b t³ / 3 (cl. 8.2.2.1), summed over the flanges and web. For a doubly symmetric I the warping constant is Iw = If hf² / 2, where If = tf bf³ / 12 is the weak-axis second moment of one flange and hf is the centre-to-centre distance between flanges; this equals Iy hf² / 4 when the web’s small contribution to Iy is ignored. E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm² and G = 0.769 × 10⁵ N/mm² are the Section 2 values.
For standard rolled I-sections and welded doubly symmetric I-sections cl. 8.2.2.1 gives a simplified form: Mcr = (π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²)) × [1 + (1/20) ((LLT / ry) / (hf / tf))²]^0.5, with ry the weak-axis radius of gyration and tf the flange thickness. Table 14 of the code lists fcr,b values prepared from this equation, and Mcr = βb Zp fcr,b. Annex E explains that the simplified equation is generally on the safe side but not exact. Where loading acts away from the shear centre, the moment is not uniform, the section is mono-symmetric, or the ends have special restraint, Annex E (E-1.2) gives the general equation with factors c1, c2, c3 from Table 42, the effective length factors K and Kw (Kw = 1.0 unless warping is specially restrained), the load height yg and the mono-symmetry term yj. A c1 above 1.0 for a moment gradient raises Mcr compared with uniform moment.
Real beams have initial crookedness, residual stresses and twist, so they never reach Mcr cleanly; the design curve blends yielding and elastic buckling. Cl. 8.2.2 defines the non-dimensional slenderness λLT = √(βb Zp fy / Mcr) = √(fy / fcr,b), then φLT = 0.5 [1 + αLT (λLT − 0.2) + λLT²] and the reduction factor χLT = 1 / [φLT + √(φLT² − λLT²)], not more than 1.0. The imperfection parameter is αLT = 0.21 for rolled sections and 0.49 for welded sections, because welding leaves larger residual stresses. The design bending compressive stress is fbd = χLT fy / γm0 (Tables 13(a) and 13(b) tabulate it), and the design bending strength is Md = βb Zp fbd, with βb = 1.0 for plastic and compact sections and Ze / Zp for semi-compact sections. γm0 = 1.10 (Table 5).
Cl. 8.2.2 also says when LTB need not be checked separately and the member may be treated as laterally supported: bending about the minor axis, hollow (rectangular or tubular) or solid bar sections, and major-axis bending with λLT less than 0.4. The last case covers short or well-braced spans, where the curve is close to the yield plateau anyway.
Everything depends on LLT, the effective length for LTB (cl. 8.3). For a simply supported beam with no lateral restraint to the compression flange but with each end restrained against torsion, cl. 8.3.1 takes LLT from Table 15. In the common case of supports fully restrained against torsion with warping not restrained in either flange, LLT = 1.00 L under normal loading and 1.20 L under destabilizing loading. A load applied on the top flange that can move sideways with the beam is destabilizing: as the section twists, the load swings outward and adds to the twist. A load hung below the shear centre or applied through a restrained element is not. Table 15 gives other rows for stronger or weaker end restraint (from 0.70 L when both flanges are fully restrained up to 1.2 L + 2D or 1.4 L + 2D for supports that only bear on the bottom flange, D being the overall depth).
Amendment No. 1 (January 2012) rewrote the second paragraph of cl. 8.3.1: in simply supported beams with intermediate lateral restraints against LTB, LLT is the length of the relevant segment between the restraints, and for intermediate partial lateral restraints LLT is 1.2 times that segment length. Because Mcr falls roughly with 1 / LLT² for slender cases, one effective brace at mid-span can almost double Md. The brace itself must be strong and stiff enough to hold the compression flange; cl. 8.3.2 deals with the restraining force such braces must carry.
EN 1993-1-1 (cl. 6.3.2, lateral torsional buckling of members with a reduction factor and imperfection factors) and AISC 360 (Chapter F, with unbraced length limits and the moment-gradient factor Cb) treat the same instability with different notation and calibration. This lesson follows IS 800:2007 and names those documents only for comparison; it does not rank them or quote their values.
Derivation
- Equilibrium of the buckled beam under uniform moment M: EIy u″ = −M φ (lateral bending) and GIt φ′ − EIw φ‴ = M u′ (torsion).
- Trial modes u = u0 sin(πz / LLT), φ = φ0 sin(πz / LLT) satisfy the pinned-and-torsionally-restrained ends; substituting gives a 2 × 2 homogeneous system.
- Non-trivial solution: M² = (π² E Iy / LLT²)(G It + π² E Iw / LLT²) → Mcr = √[(π² E Iy / LLT²)(G It + π² E Iw / LLT²)] (Annex E, doubly symmetric, uniform moment).
- Plate I-section constants: It = Σ b t³ / 3; Iw = (tf bf³ / 12) hf² / 2 ≈ Iy hf² / 4.
- Simplified form for rolled I and welded doubly symmetric I (cl. 8.2.2.1): Mcr = (π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²)) [1 + (1/20)((LLT / ry)/(hf / tf))²]^0.5.
- Design (cl. 8.2.2): λLT = √(βb Zp fy / Mcr); φLT = 0.5[1 + αLT(λLT − 0.2) + λLT²]; χLT = 1 / [φLT + √(φLT² − λLT²)] ≤ 1.0; fbd = χLT fy / γm0; Md = βb Zp fbd.
Mcr = √[(π² E Iy / LLT²)(G It + π² E Iw / LLT²)] (Annex E, doubly symmetric I, uniform moment) — N·mmMcr = (π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²)) [1 + (1/20)((LLT / ry)/(hf / tf))²]^0.5 (cl. 8.2.2.1, simplified) — N·mm with mm, N/mm²It = Σ b t³ / 3 (mm⁴); Iw = (tf bf³ / 12) hf² / 2 (mm⁶)λLT = √(βb Zp fy / Mcr) = √(fy / fcr,b); no separate LTB check if λLT < 0.4 (cl. 8.2.2)φLT = 0.5 [1 + αLT (λLT − 0.2) + λLT²]; χLT = 1 / [φLT + √(φLT² − λLT²)] ≤ 1.0; αLT = 0.21 rolled, 0.49 weldedfbd = χLT fy / γm0 (N/mm²); Md = βb Zp fbd (N·mm); γm0 = 1.10 (Table 5)LLT (Table 15, ends torsionally fully restrained, warping free): 1.00 L normal load, 1.20 L destabilizing load; intermediate restraints: segment length, × 1.2 if partial (Amend No. 1, cl. 8.3.1)E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm²; G = 0.769 × 10⁵ N/mm² (Section 2)
- Prismatic, doubly symmetric I-section bent about its major axis; the classical and simplified Mcr expressions apply to that case only (mono-symmetric or tapered members need Annex E E-1.2 or specialist literature).
- Ends restrained against twist and sideways movement (torsional restraint), free to rotate on plan and free to warp unless stated; uniform-moment Mcr is used, which is conservative for most moment gradients (c1 ≥ 1.0).
- Loads act at the shear centre for normal loading; destabilizing loads are covered through Table 15, not through the yg term.
- Examples use E250 steel with fy = 250 N/mm², γm0 = 1.10; section class (plastic) is given design data, so βb = 1.0.
- Section properties of the rolled section are given design data; the welded section is idealised from plates with root fillets and welds ignored.
- Low shear (V ≤ 0.6 Vd) and no axial force; combined actions follow Section 9.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.2 (laterally unsupported beams: Md = βb Zp fbd, fbd = χLT fy / γm0, φLT, χLT, αLT = 0.21 rolled and 0.49 welded, λLT, cases where LTB need not be checked including λLT < 0.4).
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.2.1 (elastic lateral torsional buckling moment, simplified I-section equation, It = Σ b t³ / 3) and Table 14 (fcr,b), Tables 13(a) and 13(b) (fbd).
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.3 and cl. 8.3.1 with Table 15 (effective length for LTB of simply supported beams); Amendment No. 1 (January 2012) to cl. 8.3.1 (intermediate full and partial lateral restraints); cl. 8.3.2 (restraint forces, named).
- IS 800:2007 Annex E (E-1.1, E-1.2, Table 42: general elastic critical moment with c1, c2, c3, K, Kw).
- IS 800:2007 Section 2 (E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm², G = 0.769 × 10⁵ N/mm²) and Table 5 (γm0 = 1.10); cl. 8.2.1 (laterally supported case, lesson 5.1).
- For comparison only: EN 1993-1-1 cl. 6.3.2 and AISC 360 Chapter F. Not ranked; no values quoted.
Worked examples
Problem. A simply supported rolled I-beam of span L = 6 m carries a factored UDL wu = 30 kN/m at its shear centre (normal loading). The compression flange has no intermediate lateral restraint; both ends are fully restrained against torsion, warping is not restrained. Given design data (plastic section, E250): h = 450 mm, tf = 17.4 mm, Iy = 834 × 10⁴ mm⁴, ry = 30.1 mm, Zp = 1 533 × 10³ mm³. E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm², γm0 = 1.10. Find Md under cl. 8.2.2 and compare with the laterally supported value.
- Mu = wu L² / 8 = 30 × 6² / 8 = 135 kNm.
- Table 15 (torsion fully restrained, warping free, normal load): LLT = 1.00 L = 6 000 mm.
- hf = h − tf = 450 − 17.4 = 432.6 mm; LLT / ry = 6 000 / 30.1 = 199.3; hf / tf = 432.6 / 17.4 = 24.86; ratio = 199.3 / 24.86 = 8.018.
- π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²) = π² × 2 × 10⁵ × 834 × 10⁴ × 432.6 / (2 × 6 000²) = 98.91 kNm; [1 + 8.018² / 20]^0.5 = 4.214^0.5 = 2.053.
- Mcr = 98.91 × 2.053 = 203.1 kNm (cl. 8.2.2.1).
- λLT = √(1.0 × 1 533 × 10³ × 250 / 203.1 × 10⁶) = √1.887 = 1.374 (> 0.4, so LTB must be checked).
- Rolled: αLT = 0.21. φLT = 0.5 [1 + 0.21 (1.374 − 0.2) + 1.374²] = 1.567; χLT = 1 / [1.567 + √(1.567² − 1.374²)] = 0.431.
- fbd = 0.431 × 250 / 1.10 = 97.9 N/mm²; Md = 1.0 × 1 533 × 10³ × 97.9 / 10⁶ = 150.1 kNm ≥ 135 kNm — OK (utilisation 0.90).
- If the same beam were laterally supported (lesson 5.1): Zp fy / γm0 = 348.4 kNm. LTB has cut the strength to about 43 percent.
- Destabilizing check: if the load sat on a top flange free to move sideways, LLT = 1.20 L = 7 200 mm gives Mcr = 163.0 kNm, λLT = 1.534, χLT = 0.359, fbd = 81.5 N/mm² and Md = 124.9 kNm < 135 kNm — not OK. Load position matters.
Answer. LLT = 6 m: Mcr = 203.1 kNm, λLT = 1.374, χLT = 0.431, Md = 150.1 kNm ≥ 135 kNm; destabilizing load Md = 124.9 kNm fails
Problem. Take the beam of Example 1 (normal loading) and add one lateral restraint to the compression flange at mid-span. Find Md (a) for a full restraint and (b) for a partial restraint, using Amendment No. 1 to cl. 8.3.1.
- (a) Full intermediate restraint: LLT = segment length = 6 / 2 = 3 m = 3 000 mm.
- LLT / ry = 3 000 / 30.1 = 99.67; ratio = 99.67 / 24.86 = 4.009; [1 + 4.009² / 20]^0.5 = 1.8035^0.5 = 1.343.
- π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²) = 395.6 kNm (four times Example 1, because LLT is halved); Mcr = 395.6 × 1.343 = 531.3 kNm.
- λLT = √(1 533 × 10³ × 250 / 531.3 × 10⁶) = 0.849; φLT = 0.5 [1 + 0.21 (0.849 − 0.2) + 0.849²] = 0.929; χLT = 0.766.
- fbd = 0.766 × 250 / 1.10 = 174.2 N/mm²; Md = 1 533 × 10³ × 174.2 / 10⁶ = 267.0 kNm (about 1.78 times Example 1).
- (b) Partial intermediate restraint: LLT = 1.2 × 3 000 = 3 600 mm → Mcr = 403.5 kNm, λLT = 0.975, φLT = 1.056, χLT = 0.683, fbd = 155.3 N/mm², Md = 238.1 kNm.
- Both cases now carry Mu = 135 kNm with a large margin; the brace must itself be designed for the restraint force (cl. 8.3.2).
Answer. Full mid-span restraint: LLT = 3 m, Md = 267.0 kNm; partial: LLT = 3.6 m, Md = 238.1 kNm (vs 150.1 kNm unbraced)
Problem. A welded doubly symmetric I-girder has flanges 250 × 16 mm and a web 600 × 10 mm (h = 632 mm), E250, classified plastic (given), simply supported over L = 8 m with ends torsionally restrained, warping free, normal loading (LLT = 8 m). G = 0.769 × 10⁵ N/mm². Compute section constants, Mcr by the classical formula and by the simplified formula, then Md with αLT = 0.49.
- A = 2 × 250 × 16 + 600 × 10 = 14 000 mm². Iy = 2 × 16 × 250³ / 12 + 600 × 10³ / 12 = 4.172 × 10⁷ mm⁴; ry = √(Iy / A) = 54.59 mm.
- Zp = 250 × 16 × 616 + 10 × 600² / 4 = 2 464 000 + 900 000 = 3.364 × 10⁶ mm³ (hf = 632 − 16 = 616 mm).
- It = 2 × 250 × 16³ / 3 + 600 × 10³ / 3 = 682 667 + 200 000 = 882 667 mm⁴. Iw = (16 × 250³ / 12) × 616² / 2 = 3.953 × 10¹² mm⁶.
- π² E Iy / LLT² = π² × 2 × 10⁵ × 4.172 × 10⁷ / 8 000² = 1 286.6 kN. G It = 0.769 × 10⁵ × 882 667 = 67.88 × 10⁹ N·mm². π² E Iw / LLT² = 121.91 × 10⁹ N·mm².
- Classical (Annex E, uniform moment): Mcr = √[1 286.6 × 10³ × (67.88 + 121.91) × 10⁹] = 494.2 kNm.
- Simplified (cl. 8.2.2.1): LLT / ry = 146.6; hf / tf = 38.5; ratio 3.807; [1 + 3.807² / 20]^0.5 = 1.313; π² E Iy hf / (2 LLT²) = 396.3 kNm; Mcr = 520.4 kNm.
- Here the simplified value is about 5 percent above the classical one, so take the classical Mcr = 494.2 kNm for design.
- λLT = √(3.364 × 10⁶ × 250 / 494.2 × 10⁶) = 1.305; welded αLT = 0.49: φLT = 0.5 [1 + 0.49 (1.305 − 0.2) + 1.305²] = 1.622; χLT = 0.387.
- fbd = 0.387 × 250 / 1.10 = 87.9 N/mm²; Md = 3.364 × 10⁶ × 87.9 / 10⁶ = 295.8 kNm. (With the simplified Mcr it would be 306.7 kNm; laterally supported it would be 764.5 kNm.)
Answer. It = 882 667 mm⁴, Iw = 3.953 × 10¹² mm⁶, Mcr = 494.2 kNm (classical) vs 520.4 kNm (simplified); λLT = 1.305, χLT = 0.387, Md = 295.8 kNm
Step-by-step procedure
- Decide whether the compression flange is laterally supported (cl. 8.2.1, lesson 5.1). If not, or only at discrete points, follow cl. 8.2.2.
- Skip a separate LTB check only for minor-axis bending, hollow or solid bar sections, or major-axis bending with λLT < 0.4.
- Classify the section (Table 2) to get βb (1.0 plastic/compact; Ze/Zp semi-compact). Note whether it is rolled (αLT = 0.21) or welded (αLT = 0.49).
- Fix LLT from cl. 8.3.1 and Table 15 (end restraint, normal or destabilizing load) or from the restraint spacing (Amend No. 1: segment length, × 1.2 for partial restraint).
- Compute Mcr: simplified equation of cl. 8.2.2.1 (or Table 14) for rolled and welded doubly symmetric I-sections; Annex E for moment gradients, load height, mono-symmetry or when the simplified value is doubtful.
- λLT = √(βb Zp fy / Mcr); φLT; χLT ≤ 1.0; fbd = χLT fy / γm0; Md = βb Zp fbd. Check Mu ≤ Md.
- If Md is short, add lateral restraints to the compression flange (and design them, cl. 8.3.2), choose a section with wider flanges (larger Iy and It), or move the load to a non-destabilizing position.
Site notes
- Before the deck slab is cast, a floor beam is unbraced: check it for LTB under wet concrete and construction loads with the actual temporary bracing spacing, not the final restrained condition.
- Gantry girders, lintels over wide openings, crane runway beams and long purlins under wind suction (where the bottom flange is in compression) are typical laterally unsupported members.
- A brace only helps if it holds the compression flange and is itself anchored to something stiff; a tie between two beams that can sway together does not restrain LTB.
- Erection of long plate girders in pairs is often done with temporary cross-bracing for this reason; single girders lifted alone can twist and buckle under self-weight.
- Loads hung from the bottom flange (pipes, hoists) are less critical than loads placed on a top flange free to move sideways; record load position on the drawings so the right LLT is used.
- Using the laterally supported Md = Zp fy / γm0 for an unbraced span, which can overstate strength by a factor of two or more.
- Taking LLT as the span when the load is destabilizing (Table 15 asks for 1.20 L in the common case) or ignoring partial-restraint factor 1.2 from Amendment No. 1.
- Using αLT = 0.21 for a welded plate girder; welded sections take 0.49.
- Mixing units in Mcr (kN with mm, or m with mm⁴) — work in N and mm and convert at the end.
- Forgetting that the reduction factor χLT cannot exceed 1.0, or skipping the λLT < 0.4 shortcut check and doing unnecessary work.
- Counting a brace that is attached to the tension flange, or one that is not itself restrained, as an effective lateral restraint.
- Relying on the simplified Mcr without a cross-check for built-up or unusual sections; as Example 3 shows, it is not always conservative.
Quick LTB check (E250, γm0 = 1.10): if λLT = √(Zp × 250 / Mcr) is below 0.4, use lesson 5.1. Halving the unbraced length roughly multiplies Mcr by 2.5 to 4 for slender beams. A rolled beam with LLT / ry near 200 typically keeps only about 40 to 45 percent of its restrained Md.
Summary
- LTB is sideways bending plus twisting of an unbraced beam; it governs before yielding when the compression flange is free over a long length.
- Elastic critical moment: Mcr = √[(π² E Iy / LLT²)(G It + π² E Iw / LLT²)]; simplified I-section form in cl. 8.2.2.1; general cases in Annex E (c1, c2, c3; K, Kw).
- Design (cl. 8.2.2): λLT = √(βb Zp fy / Mcr); φLT = 0.5[1 + αLT(λLT − 0.2) + λLT²]; χLT = 1/[φLT + √(φLT² − λLT²)] ≤ 1; fbd = χLT fy / γm0; Md = βb Zp fbd.
- αLT = 0.21 rolled, 0.49 welded. No separate LTB check for minor-axis bending, hollow or solid sections, or λLT < 0.4.
- LLT from cl. 8.3.1 / Table 15: 1.00 L normal, 1.20 L destabilizing (torsion restrained, warping free); intermediate restraints give segment length (× 1.2 if partial).
- Bracing the compression flange is usually the cheapest way to raise Md.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Name the three cases in which IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.2 does not require a separate LTB check.
Bending about the minor axis; hollow (rectangular or tubular) or solid bar sections; major-axis bending with λLT less than 0.4.
2What imperfection parameter αLT is used for a rolled I-section and for a welded I-section?
αLT = 0.21 for rolled sections and 0.49 for welded sections.
3A rolled plastic beam has Zp = 1 000 × 10³ mm³ and Mcr = 400 kNm, E250, γm0 = 1.10. Find λLT, χLT and Md.
λLT = √(1 000 × 10³ × 250 / 400 × 10⁶) = 0.791; φLT = 0.5 [1 + 0.21 (0.591) + 0.625] = 0.875; χLT = 0.801; fbd = 182.1 N/mm²; Md = 182.1 kNm.
4Find χLT for λLT = 1.0 with αLT = 0.21 and with αLT = 0.49.
αLT = 0.21: φLT = 1.084, χLT = 0.666. αLT = 0.49: φLT = 1.196, χLT = 0.540.
5A simply supported beam of span 5 m has ends fully restrained against torsion and warping free. What is LLT for normal loading and for destabilizing loading (Table 15)?
Normal: 1.00 L = 5.0 m. Destabilizing: 1.20 L = 6.0 m.
6A 9 m simply supported beam has lateral restraints to the compression flange at the third points. Find LLT if the restraints are full and if they are partial.
Segment = 3 m. Full restraints: LLT = 3.0 m. Partial restraints: LLT = 1.2 × 3 = 3.6 m (Amendment No. 1 to cl. 8.3.1).
7Why is a load on a top flange that is free to move sideways called destabilizing?
As the beam twists, the load moves with the top flange away from the shear centre and its lever arm adds to the twist, so the critical moment falls; Table 15 allows for this with a longer LLT.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.