Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.2

1.2 Limit state method and partial safety factors

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 1: Design philosophies Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Define a limit state and distinguish the limit states of collapse and of serviceability.
  • Apply partial safety factors for loads (γf) and for materials (γm) to find design loads and design strengths, including the IS 456 load combinations of Table 18.
  • Explain, using the reliability index, why separate factors on loads and materials give a more consistent margin of safety than one overall factor.

Theory

A limit state is a condition beyond which a structure, or part of it, no longer does what it was designed to do. The limit state method (LSM) designs for all of them at once. The limit states of collapse cover failure of critical sections in bending, shear, torsion or compression, buckling and loss of equilibrium such as overturning. The limit states of serviceability cover conditions that make the structure unfit for normal use without collapse: excessive deflection, cracking wide enough to harm durability or appearance, and vibration. IS 456:2000 cl. 35 requires the structure to be designed for the most critical limit state and checked for the others.

Loads and strengths are both uncertain. The method therefore starts from characteristic values (lesson 1.3) and then applies two kinds of partial safety factor. Loads are multiplied by γf, which is larger for imposed and wind loads than the near-certain dead load would need, and smaller when a load helps stability. Strengths are divided by γm, which is larger for concrete, a site-made material, than for factory-made steel. IS 456:2000 cl. 36.4.2.1 takes γm = 1.5 for concrete and 1.15 for steel at the limit state of collapse, so the design yield strength of steel is fy/1.15 = 0.87 fy.

Limit state method: partial safety factorsload effect or resistanceload effect Sresistance RSkSd = γf SkRd = Rk/γmRkfailure zone R < SIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.2: Load effect S and resistance R as probability curves: the design load Sd = γf Sk lies above the characteristic load and the design resistance Rd = Rk/γm below the characteristic resistance, and design requires Rd ≥ Sd; the overlap of the two curves is the failure zone. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For flexure the code also allows for the difference between the strength of a small cube and that of concrete in a real member: the maximum design stress in the compression zone is 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.447 fck, usually written 0.446 fck or about 0.45 fck in Indian design aids and textbooks. The design condition is simply that the design resistance, computed with design strengths, is at least the design load effect, computed with factored loads: Rd ≥ Sd. At the serviceability limit states the load factors are 1.0 or less and the material properties are taken at their characteristic values.

Behind the factors lies a probability argument. If the resistance R and the load effect S are treated as random variables, failure is the event R < S. For normal variables the safety margin R − S has mean μR − μS and standard deviation √(σR² + σS²), and the reliability index β is the number of standard deviations between the mean margin and zero. A higher β means a smaller probability of failure. Splitting the safety into γf and γm lets the designer put the margin where the uncertainty actually is, so structures with different load mixes end up with similar reliability, which one overall factor of safety cannot achieve.

Derivation

  1. Characteristic values: take the characteristic strength fk (a low fractile of strength) and the characteristic load Fk (a high fractile of load), as defined in IS 456:2000 cl. 36.1 and 36.2.
  2. Design values (cl. 36.3): design strength fd = fk/γm and design load Fd = γf Fk.
  3. Design condition: R(fd) ≥ S(Fd), that is the resistance computed with design strengths is not less than the load effect computed with design loads, for every relevant limit state and load combination.
  4. Design strengths at collapse: steel fy/1.15 = 0.870 fy; concrete in the flexural compression zone 0.67 fck/1.5 = 0.447 fck (often written 0.446 fck); IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 also limits the tensile steel strain at failure to at least fy/(1.15 Es) + 0.002 so that the steel yields before the concrete crushes.
  5. Reliability: with R and S normal and independent, the margin M = R − S is normal with μM = μR − μS and σM = √(σR² + σS²). Failure is M < 0, so Pf = Φ(−β) with β = μM/σM, where Φ is the standard normal distribution function.
  6. Comparing formats: for steel yielding under dead plus imposed load the limit state method gives an overall margin of about γf × γm = 1.5 × 1.15 = 1.73 on the characteristic yield, while the working stress method with fy/σst = 415/230 gives 1.80; the numbers are similar, but only the partial factor format lets the margin change with the type of load and material.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Design strength: fd = fk/γm (N/mm²); γm = 1.5 for concrete and 1.15 for steel at collapse (IS 456:2000 cl. 36.4.2.1)
  • Design load: Fd = γf Fk (kN, kN/m or kN m); γf from IS 456:2000 Table 18
  • Collapse combinations (Table 18): 1.5(DL + IL); 1.5(DL + WL) or 0.9 DL + 1.5 WL where the dead load helps stability or stresses reverse; 1.2(DL + IL + WL); with EL in place of WL for earthquake (load effects in kN or kN m)
  • Serviceability combinations (Table 18): 1.0(DL + IL); 1.0(DL + WL); 1.0 DL + 0.8 IL + 0.8 WL (kN or kN m)
  • Design stresses at collapse: steel 0.87 fy; concrete in flexure 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.447 fck, often written 0.446 fck (N/mm²)
  • Minimum steel strain at collapse (cl. 38.1): εs ≥ fy/(1.15 Es) + 0.002 (dimensionless; Es = 200 000 N/mm²)
  • Reliability index: β = (μR − μS)/√(σR² + σS²); probability of failure Pf = Φ(−β) (dimensionless)
Assumptions and limits
  • Characteristic loads and strengths are known (lesson 1.3); the partial factors cover their remaining uncertainty and also inaccuracies of analysis and construction.
  • The load combinations of Table 18 assume the loads act together only in the stated ways; 0.9 DL is used where dead load reduces the effect being checked, such as overturning or stress reversal.
  • The values of γf for serviceability apply to short-term effects; for long-term deflection only dead load and the permanent part of the imposed load are considered (Table 18 notes).
  • The simple reliability formula assumes normal, independent R and S; real codes are calibrated with more refined distributions, so β here illustrates the idea rather than reproducing code calibration.
  • Limits: where failure would have very serious consequences, IS 456:2000 cl. 36.3.3 allows higher γf and γm than the normal values; partial factors do not replace good detailing, quality control or supervision.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 18.2.1 (limit state method is the normal method of design), cl. 35 (safety and serviceability requirements: limit state of collapse, cl. 35.2; limit states of serviceability, cl. 35.3, with crack widths in cl. 35.3.2), cl. 36.1 to 36.3 (characteristic and design values), cl. 36.4.1 with Table 18 (γf for loads) and cl. 36.4.2.1 (γm = 1.5 for concrete and 1.15 for steel), cl. 38.1 (assumptions for flexure at collapse).
  • Loads are taken from IS 875 (Part 1) to (Part 4) and seismic forces from IS 1893, which IS 456:2000 cl. 36.2 adopts as characteristic loads.
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European system (EN 1990 for the basis of design and combinations, EN 1992-1-1 for concrete) uses partial factors on actions and on materials in the same way; the American system (ACI 318, with loads from ASCE 7) uses load factors on the loads and a strength reduction factor on the computed nominal strength instead of factors on each material. Their factor values differ and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: load combinations)

Problem. At the critical section of a roof beam the characteristic bending moments are: dead load 40 kN m, imposed load 25 kN m and wind ±30 kN m (wind can act either way). Find the design moments for the limit state of collapse and the moments for the serviceability checks using IS 456 Table 18.

  1. 1.5(DL + IL) = 1.5 × 65 = 97.5 kN m.
  2. 1.5(DL + WL) = 1.5 × 70 = 105.0 kN m; with wind reversed 1.5(40 − 30) = 15.0 kN m.
  3. Where wind reverses the stress, 0.9 DL − 1.5 WL = 36 − 45 = −9.0 kN m, a hogging moment that the top of the section must resist.
  4. 1.2(DL + IL + WL) = 1.2 × 95 = 114.0 kN m (sagging governs); with wind reversed 1.2 × 35 = 42.0 kN m.
  5. Serviceability: DL + IL = 65 kN m; DL + WL = 70 kN m; DL + 0.8 IL + 0.8 WL = 40 + 20 + 24 = 84 kN m.

Answer. Design sagging moment 114 kN m (1.2 combination); reversal 9 kN m hogging (0.9 DL − 1.5 WL); serviceability up to 84 kN m

Example 2 (design strengths)

Problem. Find the design strengths used at the limit state of collapse for M25 concrete with Fe 415 and with Fe 500 steel, and the minimum tensile strain at failure for each steel.

  1. Concrete in flexure: 0.67 × 25/1.5 = 11.17 N/mm²; the rounded form 0.446 fck gives 11.15 N/mm².
  2. Fe 415: 415/1.15 = 360.9 N/mm² (0.87 × 415 = 361.1).
  3. Fe 500: 500/1.15 = 434.8 N/mm² (0.87 × 500 = 435.0).
  4. Minimum strain Fe 415: 415/(1.15 × 200 000) + 0.002 = 0.00380; Fe 500: 500/(1.15 × 200 000) + 0.002 = 0.00417.
  5. The higher grade needs a larger strain before it yields fully, which is why the limiting neutral-axis depth is smaller for Fe 500 (chapter 2).

Answer. Concrete 11.2 N/mm²; Fe 415: 361 N/mm², εs ≥ 0.0038; Fe 500: 435 N/mm², εs ≥ 0.0042

Example 3 (reliability: why partial factors)

Problem. For a member the resistance has mean 300 kN m and coefficient of variation 0.12; the load effect has mean 150 kN m and coefficient of variation 0.25. Treat both as normal and independent. Find the central factor of safety, the reliability index and the probability of failure. Then find them again if better quality control raises the mean resistance to 330 kN m with the same coefficient of variation.

  1. σR = 0.12 × 300 = 36 kN m and σS = 0.25 × 150 = 37.5 kN m; central factor μR/μS = 2.0.
  2. β = (300 − 150)/√(36² + 37.5²) = 150/51.98 = 2.89.
  3. Pf = Φ(−2.89) = 1.95 × 10⁻³, about 1 in 510.
  4. With μR = 330: σR = 39.6 kN m, β = 180/√(39.6² + 37.5²) = 180/54.54 = 3.30 and Pf = 4.8 × 10⁻⁴, about 1 in 2 070.
  5. A 10 per cent rise in the central factor (2.0 to 2.2) cuts the failure probability about four times; the same central factor with a more variable load would give a lower β. This is why the margin is set separately for loads and materials rather than as one number.

Answer. Central factor 2.0, β = 2.89, Pf ≈ 2 × 10⁻³; with μR = 330 kN m, β = 3.30, Pf ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁴

Step-by-step procedure

  1. List the limit states that matter for the member: collapse (flexure, shear, torsion, compression, stability) and serviceability (deflection, cracking).
  2. Take characteristic loads from the loading codes and characteristic strengths from the material grades.
  3. Form the load combinations with γf from Table 18 for each limit state, including 0.9 DL where dead load helps stability or stresses can reverse.
  4. Analyse the structure for each combination and find the design load effects.
  5. Design the sections for the limit state of collapse using design strengths (0.87 fy for steel and about 0.45 fck for concrete in flexure).
  6. Check the serviceability limit states with serviceability factors and characteristic material properties, and adjust the design if any check fails.

Site notes

  • Partial factors assume the specified grade is actually achieved; poor compaction or curing removes the margin that γm = 1.5 was meant to cover, so site quality control is part of the safety system.
  • Do not apply a 'safety factor' of your own on top of the code factors when preparing quantities or checking a temporary load; use the code combinations and record any extra margin separately.
  • Temporary works and construction stages (stacked materials, early-age concrete, propping) have their own load cases; check them, because the permanent-structure factors do not cover them automatically.
  • For water tanks and other members governed by cracking, the serviceability limit state, not collapse, usually decides the section.
  • When a design note lists only 1.5(DL + IL), ask whether wind or earthquake combinations were also checked, especially for roofs, parapets and cantilevers where reversal is possible.
Common mistakes
  • Factoring the loads and also using permissible (working) stresses, which mixes the two philosophies.
  • Forgetting the 0.9 DL combination where dead load resists overturning or uplift.
  • Using 0.87 fy for concrete-crushing calculations or 0.446 fck as the cube strength; each design stress belongs to its material.
  • Checking deflection with factored loads instead of the serviceability factors.
  • Treating the reliability index as a code requirement in Indian design; it explains the factors but the designer applies γf and γm.
Quick check

For ordinary beams and slabs under dead and imposed load, the design moment is 1.5 times the service moment, and the design strengths are about 0.87 fy for steel and 0.45 fck for concrete in flexure. A limit state design under dead and imposed load gives roughly the same steel area as a working stress design with σst = 230 N/mm² for Fe 415 (overall margins about 1.73 and 1.80). A design moment far from 1.5 times the service moment means a combination or factor has been missed.

Summary

  • A limit state is a condition at which the structure stops serving its purpose; collapse and serviceability limit states are both checked.
  • Design loads are characteristic loads times γf; design strengths are characteristic strengths divided by γm (1.5 for concrete, 1.15 for steel at collapse).
  • IS 456:2000 Table 18 gives the combinations 1.5(DL + IL), 1.5(DL + WL), 0.9 DL + 1.5 WL and 1.2(DL + IL + WL) for collapse, and 1.0 or 0.8 factors for serviceability.
  • The design condition is Rd ≥ Sd for every limit state and combination.
  • The reliability index β = (μR − μS)/√(σR² + σS²) shows why separate factors on loads and materials give more uniform safety than one overall factor.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1What is the design yield strength of Fe 415 steel at the limit state of collapse?

415/1.15 = 360.9 N/mm², written 0.87 fy = 361 N/mm².

2What is the design compressive stress in flexure for M30 concrete?

0.67 × 30/1.5 = 13.4 N/mm² (in the rounded form 0.446 × 30 = 13.38).

3A slab has characteristic moments of 30 kN m (dead) and 20 kN m (imposed). What is the design moment?

1.5 × (30 + 20) = 75 kN m.

4Find β for μR = 200 kN m, σR = 20 kN m, μS = 100 kN m, σS = 25 kN m.

β = 100/√(20² + 25²) = 100/32.0 = 3.12.

5When is the 0.9 DL + 1.5 WL combination used?

When dead load helps stability, such as against overturning or uplift, or when wind can reverse the stress, so the least favourable dead load must be taken.

6What partial factor does Table 18 apply to the imposed load in the serviceability combination DL + IL + WL?

0.8 (dead load 1.0, imposed 0.8, wind 0.8).

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.