Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Steel Design › Chapter 6 › Lesson 6.1

6.1 Members under combined axial force and bending

Steel Design Chapter 6: Beam-columns Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain why a member carrying axial force together with bending moment must pass two separate checks in IS 800:2007 cl. 9.3: a section strength check (cl. 9.3.1) and an overall member buckling check (cl. 9.3.2).
  • Carry out the section strength check of a plastic or compact rolled I-section by cl. 9.3.1.1 with the reduced moment capacities Mndz and Mndy of cl. 9.3.1.2(c) as substituted by Amendment No. 1, the exponents of Table 17, and the conservative linear check.
  • Check a beam-column by the two interaction equations of cl. 9.3.2.2, computing Pdy, Pdz from the column curves, Ky, Kz and KLT, and the equivalent uniform moment factors of Table 18, and see how bracing and sway change the result; handle bending with axial tension by the effective moment of cl. 9.3.2.1.

Theory

Most real steel members carry more than one kind of force. A column in a building frame carries axial compression from the floors above and bending moments from beams that frame into it eccentrically, from wind or earthquake sway, and from frame action. A rafter in a portal frame carries bending and a smaller axial thrust. A truss chord loaded between its nodes bends as well as stretching or shortening. Such members are called beam-columns, and IS 800:2007 treats them in Section 9, Member Subjected to Combined Forces. Chapter 4 of this textbook covered pure compression and Chapter 5 pure bending; this lesson joins the two.

A note on axes first, because it causes many errors. IS 800:2007 calls the major principal axis of an I-section z–z and the minor axis y–y. So Mz is the moment about the strong axis (the usual case for a beam or column in a frame), My is the moment about the weak axis, Pdz is the compressive strength for buckling about the major axis and Pdy that about the minor axis. The definitions of cl. 9.3.2.2 state this directly: Pdy, Pdz are governed by buckling about the minor (y) and major (z) axis, and Mdy, Mdz are the bending strengths about y (minor) and z (major). Other codes and many textbooks use y for the major axis, so always check which convention a formula belongs to.

Beam-column: forces and interactionPPMzMzz–z majory–y minorN/NdM/Md11plastic curvelinear checkIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 6.1: An I-section beam-column with axial force P at both ends and end moments Mz about the major axis, with the IS 800 axis convention noted, beside an interaction diagram of N/Nd against M/Md showing a bulging plastic interaction curve and the dashed conservative straight-line check. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Cl. 9.3 asks for two checks. The section strength check (cl. 9.3.1) asks whether the most stressed cross-section, usually at a member end where the moment peaks, can carry the axial force and the moments together without the material failing. It ignores buckling. The member strength check (cl. 9.3.2) asks whether the member as a whole can buckle: flexural buckling about either axis, made worse by the moments, and lateral-torsional buckling. A short stocky member is controlled by the first check; a slender one by the second. Both must be satisfied.

Why does axial force reduce the moment capacity of a section? In the fully plastic state, part of the cross-section must be reserved to carry the axial force, so only the rest is available to form the plastic moment couple. For an I-section bent about its major axis the web carries the axial force first, and the flanges, which give most of the moment, are touched only when the axial force is large. That is why the reduced major-axis capacity barely drops at small axial ratios. Cl. 9.3.1.2 gives approximations for plastic and compact sections without bolt holes. For standard I or H sections, as substituted by Amendment No. 1: Mndz = 1.11 Mdz (1 − n) ≤ Mdz about the major axis, and about the minor axis Mndy = Mdy for n ≤ 0.2 and Mndy = 1.56 Mdy (1 − n)(n + 0.6) for n > 0.2. Here n = N/Nd and Nd = Ag fy / γm0 is the axial strength by yielding (cl. 9.3.1.1). For a solid plate, Mnd = Md (1 − n²). Cl. 9.3.1.2 also gives forms for welded I or H sections, rectangular hollow and welded box sections, and circular hollow tubes, which are not used in this lesson.

With the reduced capacities known, cl. 9.3.1.1 combines biaxial moments through a curved interaction: (My / Mndy)^α1 + (Mz / Mndz)^α2 ≤ 1.0. The exponents come from Table 17. For I and channel sections α1 = 5n but not less than 1, and α2 = 2; for circular tubes both are 2; for rectangular tubes both are 1.66 / (1 − 1.13 n²), not more than 6; a row for solid rectangles also exists. Exponents above 1 make the interaction curve bulge outward, which reflects the real plastic behaviour: a section can carry a fair fraction of both moments at once. The clause also allows a conservative straight-line check, N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0, which is quicker by hand and always safe, but can reject a section that the full check accepts.

Semi-compact sections cannot develop the plastic moment, so cl. 9.3.1.3 limits the maximum longitudinal stress under the axial force and moments to fy / γm0, in the absence of high shear. For a cross-section without holes this reduces to the same linear form N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0, with the moment strengths now on the elastic basis of a semi-compact section. Slender sections need effective section properties and are beyond this lesson. Where the shear force is high (more than 60 percent of the design shear strength, cl. 9.2.1), the moment capacity is first reduced for shear by cl. 9.2.2, as described in the beam lessons.

The member check for axial compression with bending is the heart of beam-column design. When a compressed member bends, its lateral deflection adds a second-order moment P × deflection, so the moment along the member grows beyond the first-order value; this is the P–δ effect. Cl. 9.3.2.2 handles this with two interaction equations: P/Pdy + Ky Cmy My/Mdy + KLT Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0 and P/Pdz + 0.6 Ky Cmy My/Mdy + Kz Cmz Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0. The first is led by minor-axis buckling (P/Pdy) and includes lateral-torsional buckling through KLT; the second is led by major-axis buckling (P/Pdz). Pdy and Pdz are the compressive strengths from Section 7 (lesson 4.1), and Mdy and Mdz are the bending strengths considering the laterally unsupported length (Section 8, lessons 5.1 and 5.2). Braced frame members are amplified this way (cl. 4.4.3.2).

The amplification factors grow with the axial ratio and the slenderness: Ky = 1 + (λy − 0.2) ny ≤ 1 + 0.8 ny and Kz = 1 + (λz − 0.2) nz ≤ 1 + 0.8 nz, where ny = P/Pdy, nz = P/Pdz and λy, λz are the non-dimensional slendernesses of lesson 4.1. The lateral-torsional factor is KLT = 1 − 0.1 λLT ny / (CmLT − 0.25), not less than 1 − 0.1 ny / (CmLT − 0.25). The factors Cmy, Cmz and CmLT convert a varying moment diagram into an equivalent uniform moment; a member bent in single curvature by equal end moments is the worst case. Table 18 (as substituted by Amendment No. 1) gives Cm = 0.6 + 0.4ψ ≥ 0.4 for a linear moment diagram with end moment ratio ψ (−1 ≤ ψ ≤ 1), other expressions for diagrams with transverse loads, and Cmy = Cmz = 0.9 for members with a sway buckling mode. Each factor is taken from the moment diagram between the points braced in the relevant direction.

Axial tension with bending is milder: tension straightens the member and works against lateral-torsional buckling. Cl. 9.3.2.1 allows a reduced effective moment Meff = [M − ψ T Zec / A] ≤ Md, where Md is the lateral-torsional buckling strength (cl. 8.2.2), Zec is the elastic section modulus with respect to the extreme compression fibre, and ψ = 0.8 if T and M can vary independently, otherwise 1.0. The section check of cl. 9.3.1 still applies with N = T.

For comparison only, EN 1993-1-1 cl. 6.2.9 (section) and 6.3.3 (member) treat the same problem, as does AISC 360 in Chapter H; the forms differ and are not mixed with IS 800:2007 here. The design aim in all of them is the same: give the section enough capacity for the combined actions, and keep the member stiff and braced enough that second-order bending and buckling do not eat up that capacity.

Derivation

  1. Plastic section under N and Mz (I-section, web carries N first): with n = N/Nd small, the axial force fits inside the web and Mndz ≈ Mdz; once the web is used up, the flanges share N and the capacity falls almost linearly to zero at n = 1. A straight line through (n, M) = (1, 0) with a cut-off at Mdz gives Mndz = 1.11 Mdz (1 − n) ≤ Mdz (cl. 9.3.1.2(c), Amendment No. 1).
  2. Minor axis: the flanges give the minor-axis moment and carry N together with the web, so the capacity stays near Mdy up to n = 0.2 and then follows a curve: Mndy = 1.56 Mdy (1 − n)(n + 0.6). At n = 0.2 this gives 1.56 × 0.8 × 0.8 = 0.998 Mdy, so the two branches meet almost exactly.
  3. Solid rectangle (plate) bent about one axis: a central strip of depth n h carries N, the rest forms the moment couple, so Mnd = Md (1 − n²) (cl. 9.3.1.2(a)).
  4. Biaxial interaction: plastic surfaces for real sections bulge outward; writing them as (My/Mndy)^α1 + (Mz/Mndz)^α2 = 1 with α ≥ 1 fits that shape. Setting α1 = α2 = 1 and Mnd = Md gives the conservative straight line N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz = 1.
  5. Second-order effect: for a pin-ended member with uniform first-order moment M0, the maximum moment is close to M0 / (1 − P/Pcr). The K factors of cl. 9.3.2.2 are a design form of this growth, expressed through λ and n = P/Pd, and capped at 1 + 0.8 n; Cm reduces the uniform-moment result for a moment gradient.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • n = N / Nd; Nd = Ag fy / γm0, γm0 = 1.10 (cl. 9.3.1.1, Table 5) — kN
  • Section, plastic/compact (cl. 9.3.1.1): (My / Mndy)^α1 + (Mz / Mndz)^α2 ≤ 1.0; conservative: N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0
  • Table 17: I and channel α1 = 5n ≥ 1, α2 = 2; circular tubes α1 = α2 = 2; rectangular tubes α1 = α2 = 1.66 / (1 − 1.13 n²) ≤ 6
  • Standard I or H (cl. 9.3.1.2(c), Amendment No. 1): Mndz = 1.11 Mdz (1 − n) ≤ Mdz; Mndy = Mdy (n ≤ 0.2); Mndy = 1.56 Mdy (1 − n)(n + 0.6) (n > 0.2)
  • Plates (cl. 9.3.1.2(a)): Mnd = Md (1 − n²)
  • Semi-compact, no holes (cl. 9.3.1.3): N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0
  • Tension + bending (cl. 9.3.2.1): Meff = M − ψ T Zec / A ≤ Md; ψ = 0.8 (T and M independent) or 1.0
  • Compression + bending (cl. 9.3.2.2): P/Pdy + Ky Cmy My/Mdy + KLT Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0; P/Pdz + 0.6 Ky Cmy My/Mdy + Kz Cmz Mz/Mdz ≤ 1.0
  • Ky = 1 + (λy − 0.2) ny ≤ 1 + 0.8 ny; Kz = 1 + (λz − 0.2) nz ≤ 1 + 0.8 nz; ny = P/Pdy, nz = P/Pdz
  • KLT = 1 − 0.1 λLT ny / (CmLT − 0.25) ≥ 1 − 0.1 ny / (CmLT − 0.25)
  • Table 18: linear moment diagram Cm = 0.6 + 0.4 ψ ≥ 0.4 (−1 ≤ ψ ≤ 1); sway buckling mode Cmy = Cmz = 0.9
  • Column curve (cl. 7.1.2.1, lesson 4.1): λ = (KL/r) / [π √(E / fy)]; φ = 0.5 [1 + α (λ − 0.2) + λ²]; χ = 1 / [φ + √(φ² − λ²)]; fcd = χ fy / γm0; Pd = Ae fcd; E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm²
Assumptions and limits
  • Doubly symmetric rolled I or H section, plastic or compact (Table 2), no bolt holes in the critical cross-section, so cl. 9.3.1.2(c) applies.
  • IS 800:2007 axis convention: z–z major, y–y minor. Mz, Pdz, Mdz belong to the major axis; My, Pdy, Mdy to the minor axis.
  • E250 steel, fy = 250 N/mm², γm0 = 1.10, E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm². Section properties in the examples are idealised design data, close to a heavy rolled H-section, not taken from any table.
  • Shear force below 60 percent of the design shear strength (cl. 9.2.1), so no shear reduction of moment capacity.
  • Moments come from a first-order elastic analysis of a braced frame unless stated; Table 18 gives the Cm factors for the stated end moment ratios. In a sway frame the effective length also changes (lesson 4.1); the sway case in Example 3 keeps KL unchanged only to isolate the effect of Cm.
  • Slender (class 4) sections, welded box and hollow sections and biaxial lateral-torsional details are outside this lesson.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 9.1 (general), 9.2.1 and 9.2.2 (combined shear and bending, named), 9.3 (section strength and member strength both to be checked).
  • IS 800:2007 cl. 9.3.1.1 (plastic and compact sections: interaction with Table 17 exponents, Nd = Ag fy / γm0, conservative linear check) and cl. 9.3.1.2 (a) plates and (c) standard I or H sections as substituted by Amendment No. 1 (January 2012); (b), (d) and (e) named only.
  • IS 800:2007 cl. 9.3.1.3 (semi-compact sections), 9.3.2 (overall member strength), 9.3.2.1 (bending and axial tension, Meff, ψ = 0.8 or 1.0) and 9.3.2.2 (bending and axial compression: two interaction equations, Ky, Kz, KLT).
  • IS 800:2007 Table 18 as substituted by Amendment No. 1 (equivalent uniform moment factors; sway buckling mode 0.9) and cl. 4.4.3.2 (moment amplification of braced members by cl. 9.3.2.2).
  • IS 800:2007 cl. 7.1.2.1 and 7.1.2.2 with Table 10 (buckling classes; rolled I with h/bf ≤ 1.2 and tf ≤ 100 mm: class b about z–z, class c about y–y), cl. 8.2.1.2 and 8.2.2 (bending strengths), Table 5 (γm0 = 1.10), Section 2 (E).
  • For comparison only: EN 1993-1-1 cl. 6.2.9 and 6.3.3; AISC 360 Chapter H. Not ranked; no values quoted.

Worked examples

Example 1 (section strength under axial compression and biaxial bending)

Problem. A plastic rolled H-section column of E250 steel has Ag = 8 000 mm² and Zpz = 960 × 10³ mm³ (major axis); its minor-axis design bending strength is Mdy = 75.0 kN·m (given). At the top of the column the factored actions are N = 500 kN (compression), Mz = 120 kN·m and My = 15 kN·m. Shear is low and there are no bolt holes. Check the section by cl. 9.3.1.1 with cl. 9.3.1.2(c), and by the conservative linear check.

  1. Nd = Ag fy / γm0 = 8 000 × 250 / 1.10 = 1 818.2 kN; n = 500 / 1 818.2 = 0.275.
  2. Mdz = Zpz fy / γm0 = 960 × 10³ × 250 / 1.10 = 218.2 kN·m.
  3. Major axis (Amendment No. 1): Mndz = 1.11 × 218.2 × (1 − 0.275) = 175.6 kN·m ≤ 218.2 kN·m.
  4. Minor axis, n = 0.275 > 0.2: Mndy = 1.56 × 75.0 × (1 − 0.275)(0.275 + 0.6) = 1.56 × 75.0 × 0.725 × 0.875 = 74.2 kN·m.
  5. Table 17, I-section: α1 = 5n = 1.375 (not less than 1); α2 = 2.
  6. Interaction: (15 / 74.2)^1.375 + (120 / 175.6)² = 0.111 + 0.467 = 0.578 ≤ 1.0 — section OK.
  7. Conservative linear check: 0.275 + 15 / 75.0 + 120 / 218.2 = 0.275 + 0.200 + 0.550 = 1.025 > 1.0 — this check would reject the section.
  8. The full plastic interaction shows about 40 percent reserve; the straight line is safe but discards it. A designer short of time may use the line, but should not upsize the section on its result alone.

Answer. n = 0.275; Mndz = 175.6 kN·m, Mndy = 74.2 kN·m; α1 = 1.375, α2 = 2; interaction 0.578 ≤ 1.0 (OK); linear check 1.025 (conservative, not satisfied)

Example 2 (member check of the same column, 4.0 m, braced frame)

Problem. The column of Example 1 is 4.0 m long between floors in a braced frame, effectively pinned for buckling about both axes (KLz = KLy = 4 000 mm). Idealised radii of gyration rz = 127 mm (major) and ry = 53 mm (minor); h/bf ≤ 1.2 and tf ≤ 100 mm, so Table 10 gives class b (α = 0.34) about z–z and class c (α = 0.49) about y–y. P = 500 kN. Major-axis end moments 120 and 60 kN·m in single curvature (ψ = 0.5); minor-axis moment 15 kN·m at the top and zero at the bottom (ψ = 0). λLT = 0.35 (well restrained, so Mdz = 218.2 kN·m with no LTB reduction). Check cl. 9.3.2.2.

  1. Reference slenderness π √(E / fy) = π √(2 × 10⁵ / 250) = 88.86.
  2. Major axis: KL/rz = 4 000 / 127 = 31.50; λz = 0.354; φz = 0.5 [1 + 0.34 (0.354 − 0.2) + 0.354²] = 0.589; χz = 0.944; fcd,z = 214.5 N/mm²; Pdz = 8 000 × 214.5 = 1 715.9 kN.
  3. Minor axis: KL/ry = 4 000 / 53 = 75.47; λy = 0.849; φy = 0.5 [1 + 0.49 (0.849 − 0.2) + 0.849²] = 1.020; χy = 0.631; fcd,y = 143.5 N/mm²; Pdy = 8 000 × 143.5 = 1 147.7 kN.
  4. ny = 500 / 1 147.7 = 0.436; nz = 500 / 1 715.9 = 0.291.
  5. Ky = 1 + (0.849 − 0.2) × 0.436 = 1.283 (cap 1 + 0.8 × 0.436 = 1.349, not governing); Kz = 1 + (0.354 − 0.2) × 0.291 = 1.045 (cap 1.233).
  6. Table 18: Cmz = 0.6 + 0.4 × 0.5 = 0.8; CmLT = 0.8 (same diagram between the same braced points); Cmy = 0.6 + 0.4 × 0 = 0.6.
  7. KLT = 1 − 0.1 × 0.35 × 0.436 / (0.8 − 0.25) = 0.972 (lower limit 1 − 0.1 × 0.436 / 0.55 = 0.921, not governing).
  8. Equation 1: 0.436 + 1.283 × 0.6 × 15 / 75.0 + 0.972 × 120 / 218.2 = 0.436 + 0.154 + 0.535 = 1.124 > 1.0 — fails.
  9. Equation 2: 0.291 + 0.6 × 0.154 + 1.045 × 0.8 × 120 / 218.2 = 0.291 + 0.092 + 0.460 = 0.844 ≤ 1.0.
  10. The section passed comfortably in Example 1, but the member fails because buckling about the weak axis (λy = 0.849) takes 44 percent of the capacity before any moment is added.

Answer. Pdz = 1 715.9 kN, Pdy = 1 147.7 kN; Ky = 1.283, Kz = 1.045, KLT = 0.972; equation 1 = 1.124 (fails), equation 2 = 0.844

Example 3 (effect of minor-axis bracing, and of a sway buckling mode)

Problem. Improve the column of Example 2 by adding a brace that holds it at mid-height against buckling about the minor axis only (KLy = 2 000 mm; KLz stays 4 000 mm). (a) Recheck cl. 9.3.2.2 in the braced frame. (b) For comparison, suppose the same column were in a frame with a sway buckling mode, so Table 18 gives Cmy = Cmz = 0.9; keep KL, CmLT = 0.8 and everything else unchanged to isolate the effect of Cm.

  1. Minor axis with mid-height brace: KL/ry = 2 000 / 53 = 37.74; λy = 0.425; φy = 0.5 [1 + 0.49 (0.425 − 0.2) + 0.425²] = 0.645; χy = 0.884; fcd,y = 201.0 N/mm²; Pdy = 1 607.6 kN; ny = 0.311.
  2. Ky = 1 + (0.425 − 0.2) × 0.311 = 1.070 (cap 1.249); KLT = 1 − 0.1 × 0.35 × 0.311 / 0.55 = 0.980. Major-axis values unchanged: Pdz = 1 715.9 kN, nz = 0.291, Kz = 1.045.
  3. (a) Equation 1: 0.311 + 1.070 × 0.6 × 0.200 + 0.980 × 0.550 = 0.311 + 0.128 + 0.539 = 0.979 ≤ 1.0 — OK.
  4. (a) Equation 2: 0.291 + 0.6 × 0.128 + 1.045 × 0.8 × 0.550 = 0.291 + 0.077 + 0.460 = 0.828 ≤ 1.0 — OK.
  5. (b) Sway, Cmy = Cmz = 0.9: Equation 1: 0.311 + 1.070 × 0.9 × 0.200 + 0.980 × 0.550 = 0.311 + 0.193 + 0.539 = 1.043 > 1.0 — fails.
  6. (b) Equation 2: 0.291 + 0.6 × 0.193 + 1.045 × 0.9 × 0.550 = 0.291 + 0.116 + 0.517 = 0.924 ≤ 1.0.
  7. One brace at mid-height cuts the minor-axis ratio from 0.436 to 0.311 and makes the column work. The same column in a sway frame fails even before its larger effective length is taken into account, which is why sway frames usually need heavier columns or bracing.

Answer. (a) braced, mid-height minor-axis brace: Pdy = 1 607.6 kN, Ky = 1.070, equation 1 = 0.979, equation 2 = 0.828 (OK); (b) sway Cm = 0.9: equation 1 = 1.043 (fails), equation 2 = 0.924

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Get the factored axial force and the end and span moments about both axes from the analysis; note whether the frame is braced or has a sway buckling mode.
  2. Classify the section (Table 2). For plastic and compact sections use cl. 9.3.1.1 and 9.3.1.2; for semi-compact sections use cl. 9.3.1.3. Check shear against 60 percent of Vd (cl. 9.2.1).
  3. Section check at the most stressed section: Nd = Ag fy / γm0, n = N/Nd, Mndz and Mndy (cl. 9.3.1.2(c), Amendment No. 1), α1 and α2 from Table 17, then the interaction (or the conservative linear check).
  4. Member check: KL and r for each axis, buckling classes (Table 10), λ, φ, χ, Pdz and Pdy (cl. 7.1.2.1); Mdz with lateral-torsional buckling (cl. 8.2.2) and Mdy.
  5. Cm factors from Table 18 using the moment diagram between braced points (0.9 for a sway buckling mode); compute Ky, Kz, KLT with their limits.
  6. Evaluate both equations of cl. 9.3.2.2. If either exceeds 1.0, add bracing on the weak axis, choose a section with a larger ry, or reduce moments by better framing; then recheck both the section and the member.
  7. For tension with bending, use Meff = M − ψ T Zec / A ≤ Md (cl. 9.3.2.1) and the section check of cl. 9.3.1 with N = T.

Site notes

  • A brace counts only if it is connected and itself stiff and strong enough; check that wall girts or bracing struts shown on drawings really frame into the column at the assumed level.
  • Column splices are usually placed a little above floor level, where moments are smaller; the splice must carry the axial force and the moment at that point (cl. 7.3.4 on splices covers alignment and bearing).
  • Eccentric beam connections put moment into columns; detailing the beam reaction closer to the column centreline reduces the moment the column must carry.
  • Columns out of plumb or bowed in erection add moment; keep erection tolerances and do not remove temporary bracing until the permanent bracing is complete.
  • Holes cut on site in a column flange near a moment peak take the section out of the "no bolt holes" approximation of cl. 9.3.1.2; any such change needs the designer’s approval.
Common mistakes
  • Mixing axis conventions: in IS 800:2007 z–z is the major axis and y–y the minor axis; using a textbook formula written with y as the major axis swaps Mndy and Mndz and the Table 17 exponents.
  • Doing only the section check. A column can pass cl. 9.3.1 easily and still fail cl. 9.3.2.2 by buckling, as in Example 2.
  • Using the unamended cl. 9.3.1.2(c) expressions; Amendment No. 1 substitutes Mndz = 1.11 Mdz (1 − n) ≤ Mdz and the two-branch Mndy.
  • Taking α1 = 5n without the lower limit of 1 at small axial ratios, which makes the minor-axis term look smaller than it is.
  • Using Cm = 0.6 + 0.4ψ without the lower limit of 0.4, or using it for a member in a sway frame where Table 18 gives 0.9.
  • Taking Cm from the whole member length when the member is braced at mid-height in one direction; Table 18 asks for the moment diagram between the relevant braced points.
  • Forgetting the caps Ky ≤ 1 + 0.8 ny and Kz ≤ 1 + 0.8 nz, or using λ of the wrong axis in K.
  • Applying the plastic interaction to a semi-compact section; cl. 9.3.1.3 limits the elastic stress instead.
Quick check

Beam-column quick screen (E250 rolled I or H): if P/Pdy alone is above about 0.5, the moments will almost always push equation 1 of cl. 9.3.2.2 over 1.0; brace the weak axis or choose a section with a larger ry before refining moments.

Summary

  • Combined axial force and bending needs two checks (cl. 9.3): section strength (cl. 9.3.1) and overall member strength (cl. 9.3.2).
  • IS 800:2007 axes: z–z major, y–y minor. Nd = Ag fy / γm0; n = N/Nd.
  • Plastic/compact I or H (Amendment No. 1): Mndz = 1.11 Mdz (1 − n) ≤ Mdz; Mndy = Mdy (n ≤ 0.2) or 1.56 Mdy (1 − n)(n + 0.6); interaction (My/Mndy)^α1 + (Mz/Mndz)^α2 ≤ 1 with α1 = 5n ≥ 1, α2 = 2 (Table 17). Linear check N/Nd + My/Mdy + Mz/Mdz ≤ 1 is conservative.
  • Beam-columns in compression: P/Pdy + Ky Cmy My/Mdy + KLT Mz/Mdz ≤ 1 and P/Pdz + 0.6 Ky Cmy My/Mdy + Kz Cmz Mz/Mdz ≤ 1, with K = 1 + (λ − 0.2) n ≤ 1 + 0.8 n.
  • Table 18: Cm = 0.6 + 0.4ψ ≥ 0.4 for end moments; 0.9 for a sway buckling mode. Minor-axis bracing is often the cheapest fix.
  • Tension with bending: Meff = M − ψ T Zec / A ≤ Md, ψ = 0.8 or 1.0 (cl. 9.3.2.1).

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1The section of Example 1 (Nd = 1 818.2 kN, Mdz = 218.2 kN·m, Mdy = 75.0 kN·m) carries N = 300 kN. Find n, α1, Mndy and Mndz.

n = 300 / 1 818.2 = 0.165; 5n = 0.825 < 1, so α1 = 1.0; n ≤ 0.2, so Mndy = Mdy = 75.0 kN·m; Mndz = 1.11 × 218.2 × 0.835 = 202.2 kN·m.

2Find Ky for λy = 0.849 and ny = 0.5, and state whether the cap governs.

Ky = 1 + (0.849 − 0.2) × 0.5 = 1.325; cap 1 + 0.8 × 0.5 = 1.40 is not reached, so Ky = 1.325.

3A braced beam-column has end moments in double curvature with ψ = −0.5. Find Cm from Table 18. What is Cm for ψ = −1?

Cm = 0.6 + 0.4 × (−0.5) = 0.40. For ψ = −1: 0.6 − 0.4 = 0.20, but not less than 0.4, so Cm = 0.40.

4A tie with A = 8 000 mm² and Zec = 860 × 10³ mm³ carries T = 200 kN and M = 100 kN·m, which can vary independently. Find Meff by cl. 9.3.2.1.

ψ = 0.8: Meff = 100 − 0.8 × 200 × 10³ × 860 × 10³ / 8 000 / 10⁶ = 100 − 17.2 = 82.8 kN·m, to be checked against Md.

5Find the Table 17 exponent for a rectangular tube at n = 0.4.

α1 = α2 = 1.66 / (1 − 1.13 × 0.4²) = 1.66 / 0.819 = 2.03 (below the limit of 6).

6Find Mnd / Md for a solid plate at n = 0.5, and check that the two branches of the amended Mndy meet at n = 0.2.

Plate: 1 − 0.5² = 0.75. Mndy at n = 0.2: 1.56 × 0.8 × 0.8 = 0.998 Mdy ≈ Mdy, so the branches meet.

7Why must both interaction equations of cl. 9.3.2.2 be checked?

The first is led by buckling about the minor axis (P/Pdy) and includes lateral-torsional buckling (KLT); the second is led by buckling about the major axis (P/Pdz) with full major-axis amplification. Either can govern depending on the slenderness about each axis and the moments.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
  • S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.