7.1 Plastic analysis and design of beams and portal frames
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain the plastic moment, the shape factor, plastic hinges and collapse mechanisms, and state the three theorems of plastic collapse.
- Find collapse loads of propped-cantilever, fixed-ended and portal-frame problems by the virtual-work (mechanism) method, and confirm the result with a static moment check.
- Apply the IS 800:2007 conditions for plastic analysis (cl. 4.5.2 and its sub-clauses) and the design bending strength of cl. 8.2.1.2 to select a section.
Theory
In elastic design a steel beam is taken as failing when the extreme fibre first reaches yield. A ductile steel section can carry more: as the moment rises, yielding spreads from the extreme fibres inward until the whole section has yielded, the full plastic moment Mp = Zp fy is reached, and the section rotates at almost constant moment. That zone is a plastic hinge (IS 800:2007 cl. 1.3.75 and 1.3.76). The ratio Zp/Ze is the shape factor: 1.5 for a solid rectangle and roughly 1.10 to 1.15 for rolled I-sections bent about the major axis.
In a statically indeterminate beam or frame the first hinge does not end the structure’s life. Moments redistribute to less-stressed sections until enough hinges form to turn the structure, or part of it, into a mechanism. That is plastic collapse (cl. 1.3.73). Plastic analysis finds the load at which this happens. A structure with redundancy r generally needs r + 1 hinges for complete collapse, although a local (partial) mechanism such as a beam mechanism in a frame needs fewer.
Three theorems make the method practical. The kinematic (upper-bound) theorem: the load computed for any assumed mechanism is equal to or greater than the true collapse load, so the lowest mechanism load governs. The static (lower-bound) theorem: any moment distribution in equilibrium with the loads and nowhere exceeding Mp gives a load equal to or less than the collapse load. The uniqueness theorem: a load that satisfies equilibrium, the mechanism condition and the yield condition (|M| ≤ Mp everywhere) is the true collapse load. In practice one tries the likely mechanisms by virtual work, takes the lowest load, and then checks that the moment diagram nowhere exceeds Mp.
For a portal frame, the critical sections are the column bases (if fixed), the knees and the points under concentrated loads. If n is the number of possible hinge positions and r the redundancy, the number of independent mechanisms is n − r. A fixed-base portal with a mid-span load has n = 5 and r = 3, giving two independent mechanisms (beam and sway) and their combination; in the combined mechanism the hinge at the windward knee closes, which is why it often gives a lower load than adding the two.
IS 800:2007 permits plastic analysis (cl. 4.5.1) only when the conditions of cl. 4.5.2 are met. In summary: the yield stress must not exceed 450 MPa; the stress-strain curve must have a yield plateau at least six times the yield strain; fu/fy must be at least 1.2; elongation must be at least 15 percent, with strain hardening; steels to IS 2062 are deemed to satisfy these. Members are hot-rolled or fabricated from hot-rolled material. Sections where hinges form must be plastic (Class 1, cl. 3.7.2) so they can rotate without local buckling (cl. 3.7.1.1); other members must be at least compact unless elastic-analysis strength checks are met.
Further detailing conditions follow. Torsional restraint against lateral buckling should be provided at each hinge or within D/2 of it (cl. 4.5.2.1), with limits on the distance to the next restraint. A web stiffener is needed where a concentrated load larger than 10 percent of the shear capacity acts within D/2 of a hinge (cl. 4.5.2.2). The frame must be supported against sway and out-of-plane buckling (cl. 4.5.2.3). Near hinges, holes in the tension flange are drilled, or punched undersize and reamed, and cut edges are finished smooth (cl. 4.5.2.4). Connections must let the hinges develop and have enough rotation capacity (cl. 4.5.3). Plastic collapse is then a recognised limit state (cl. 5.5.3).
In limit-state terms the designer applies factored loads and compares the required plastic moment with the design plastic resistance Md = βb Zp fy/γm0, with βb = 1.0 for plastic and compact sections and γm0 = 1.10 (cl. 8.2.1.2, valid when the factored shear does not exceed 0.6 Vd). Cl. 8.2.1.2 also caps Md at 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 for simply supported beams (1.5 for cantilevers) to avoid irreversible deformation under service loads. EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 also allow plastic or inelastic analysis under their own ductility and bracing rules; they are named here for comparison only and are not ranked.
Derivation
- Plastic moment of a section: Mp = fy Zp, where Zp is the sum of the first moments of the areas above and below the equal-area axis. Shape factor S = Zp/Ze.
- Virtual work for a mechanism with a small hinge rotation θ: external work Σ W δ = internal work Σ Mp |θi|. Solve for the load W.
- Propped cantilever, central load W (fixed at A, propped at B): hinges at A (θ) and under the load (2θ); W (L/2) θ = Mp θ + 2 Mp θ, so W = 6 Mp/L.
- Fixed-ended beam, uniform load w: hinges at both ends (θ each) and mid-span (2θ); external work = w L × (L/4) θ; so w L² θ/4 = 4 Mp θ and w = 16 Mp/L².
- Fixed-base portal (span L, height h, load V at mid-span, H at beam level): beam mechanism V (L/2) θ = 4 Mp θ → V = 8 Mp/L; sway H h θ = 4 Mp θ → H = 4 Mp/h; combined H h θ + V (L/2) θ = 6 Mp θ.
- Static check (moments positive when causing tension on the inside face): beam equation V L/4 = MC − (MB + MD)/2; sway equation H h = −MA + MB − MD + ME. Choose the free moments so that |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.
Mp = fy Zp (N·mm); design value Md = βb Zp fy/γm0, βb = 1.0 (plastic/compact), γm0 = 1.10Shape factor S = Zp/Ze (rectangle 1.5; rolled I about z–z ≈ 1.10–1.15)Simply supported, central W: Wc = 4 Mp/L; uniform w: wc = 8 Mp/L²Propped cantilever, central W: Wc = 6 Mp/LFixed-ended, central W: Wc = 8 Mp/L; uniform w: wc = 16 Mp/L²Fixed-base portal: beam V = 8 Mp/L; sway H = 4 Mp/h; combined H h + V L/2 = 6 MpIndependent mechanisms = n − r (n possible hinge positions, r redundancy)Shear: Vd = Av fy/(√3 γm0); Md by cl. 8.2.1.2 applies when V ≤ 0.6 Vd
- Elastic–perfectly-plastic material; hinges form at points and the members between them stay elastic.
- Deflections at collapse are small enough not to change the geometry (first-order rigid-plastic analysis); frame instability is handled separately (cl. 4.5.2.3, Section 4 second-order provisions).
- Mp is not reduced by axial force or shear in the examples; for columns with significant axial load the reduced plastic moment of Section 9 applies.
- Lateral-torsional and local buckling are prevented by the restraint and plastic-section rules of cl. 4.5.2 and 3.7.2.
- Loads are proportional (a single load factor λ on all loads) and not repeated so many times that alternating plasticity or fatigue governs.
- Section properties in the examples are given design data, not handbook values for a named section.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 1.3.73–1.3.77 (definitions), cl. 3.7.1.1 and 3.7.2 (plastic sections; Table 2 by number only), cl. 4.5.1 (application of plastic analysis), cl. 4.5.2 (material, member and section requirements), cl. 4.5.2.1 (restraints), cl. 4.5.2.2 (stiffeners at hinges), cl. 4.5.2.3 (sway and out-of-plane support), cl. 4.5.2.4 (fabrication near hinges), cl. 4.5.3 (connections), cl. 5.5.3 (plastic collapse), cl. 8.2.1.2 (design bending strength and serviceability cap), cl. 8.4 (shear strength).
- Background: N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, 2008; S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
- EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 also permit plastic or inelastic analysis under their own rules; named for comparison only, not ranked.
Worked examples
Problem. A beam of span L = 6 m is fixed at A and simply supported at B. It carries a factored central point load Wu = 270 kN. Using plastic analysis, find the required design plastic moment and Zp (fy = 250 N/mm², γm0 = 1.10). A plastic rolled I-section with Zpz = 1 220 × 10³ mm³, Zez = 1 080 × 10³ mm³ and shear area Av = 3 600 mm² (given data) is proposed. Check bending and shear, and state whether a web stiffener is needed at the load.
- Mechanism: hinges at A (rotation θ) and under the load (2θ). Virtual work: Wu (L/2) θ = Mp θ + 2 Mp θ, so Mp,req = Wu L/6 = 270 × 6/6 = 270.0 kN·m.
- Zp,req = Mp,req γm0/fy = 270 × 10⁶ × 1.10/250 = 1 188 × 10³ mm³.
- Md = Zp fy/γm0 = 1 220 × 10³ × 250/1.10 = 277.3 kN·m ≥ 270.0 kN·m — OK (shape factor 1 220/1 080 = 1.130).
- Reactions at collapse: RB = Wu/2 − Mp/L = 135 − 270/6 = 90.0 kN; RA = 270 − 90 = 180.0 kN. Check: moment under load = RB × 3 = 270.0 kN·m = Mp, so the yield condition holds.
- Shear: Vd = Av fy/(√3 γm0) = 3 600 × 250/(1.732 × 1.10)/1 000 = 472.4 kN; 0.6 Vd = 283.4 kN ≥ 180.0 kN, so cl. 8.2.1.2 applies without shear reduction.
- Stiffener (cl. 4.5.2.2): the 270 kN load sits at a hinge and exceeds 10 percent of the shear capacity (47.2 kN), so a web stiffener is required within D/2 of the hinge. Provide torsional restraint at both hinges (cl. 4.5.2.1).
Answer. Mp,req = 270.0 kN·m; Zp,req = 1 188 × 10³ mm³; Md = 277.3 kN·m OK; stiffener needed at the load
Problem. A fixed-ended floor beam of span 8 m uses the section of Example 1 (Md = 277.3 kN·m). Find the factored uniform load at plastic collapse, the load at which the first hinge forms in an elastic analysis, and the reserve between them.
- Plastic collapse: wc = 16 Md/L² = 16 × 277.3/8² = 69.32 kN/m.
- First hinge (elastic end moment w L²/12 reaches Md): w1 = 12 × 277.3/64 = 51.99 kN/m.
- Reserve from redistribution: 69.32/51.99 = 1.333.
- At collapse the end moments and the mid-span moment all equal Md: check w L²/8 = 69.32 × 64/8 = 554.5 = 2 × 277.3 kN·m, as equilibrium requires (free moment = end + mid-span moments).
- Site note: the extra third is real only if the end connections are full-strength and have rotation capacity (cl. 4.5.3); a nominally pinned end gives the simply supported value 8 Md/L² = 34.7 kN/m instead.
Answer. wc = 69.32 kN/m; first hinge at 51.99 kN/m; reserve 1.333
Problem. A fixed-base portal frame has span L = 8 m, height h = 4 m and uniform design plastic moment Mp = 150 kN·m. Factored loads are V = 120 kN at mid-span and H = 40 kN at beam level. Find the collapse load factor λc and the required Zp.
- Beam mechanism: λ × 120 × 4 = 4 × 150 → λ = 600/480 = 1.250.
- Sway mechanism: λ × 40 × 4 = 4 × 150 → λ = 600/160 = 3.750.
- Combined mechanism: λ(40 × 4 + 120 × 4) = 6 × 150 → λ = 900/640 = 1.406.
- Lowest = 1.250 (beam). Static check at λ = 1.25 (H = 50 kN): set MB = MD = −150, MC = +150 kN·m; sway equation 50 × 4 = −MA − 150 + 150 + ME gives ME − MA = 200, so MA = −100 and ME = +100 kN·m both satisfy |M| ≤ 150 kN·m. The moment field is safe and statically admissible, so λc = 1.25 by the uniqueness theorem.
- λc = 1.25 ≥ 1.0, so the frame is adequate for the factored loads. Required Zp = Mp γm0/fy = 150 × 10⁶ × 1.10/250 = 660 × 10³ mm³.
Answer. λc = 1.25 (beam mechanism); Zp ≥ 660 × 10³ mm³
Step-by-step procedure
- Confirm that the steel, the members and the connections satisfy cl. 4.5.2 and 4.5.3; check that sections where hinges may form are plastic (cl. 3.7.2, Table 2).
- Apply factored loads (Table 4 load factors) and list the possible hinge positions: supports, joints and points under concentrated loads.
- Find the independent mechanisms (n − r) and their useful combinations; compute the load factor of each by virtual work.
- Take the lowest load factor, then draw the moment diagram for that mechanism and check |M| ≤ Mp everywhere (static check). If it fails, a lower mechanism exists — try more combinations.
- Select the section from Zp ≥ Mp,req γm0/fy; check shear (V ≤ 0.6 Vd for full Md), the cl. 8.2.1.2 serviceability cap where it applies, and the deflection at service loads by elastic analysis.
- Detail restraints at hinges (cl. 4.5.2.1), stiffeners (cl. 4.5.2.2), sway bracing (cl. 4.5.2.3) and fabrication limits near hinges (cl. 4.5.2.4).
Site notes
- Plastic design relies on rotation at hinges; site welds, cut-outs or holes near a planned hinge can remove that ductility. Fabrication drawings should flag hinge zones (cl. 4.5.2.4).
- Bracing at hinge locations is part of the design, not an extra; missing fly braces or purlin ties at a portal knee can let the rafter buckle before the hinge forms.
- Moment connections at portal knees and fixed bases must be full-strength or designed partial-strength with known rotation capacity (cl. 4.5.3).
- Service deflections are still checked elastically; a plastically designed portal can be economical in strength but governed by sway or deflection limits.
- Steel test certificates should confirm the grade (IS 2062 steels are deemed to satisfy cl. 4.5.2); substitute materials need the ductility checks.
- Taking the first hinge load as the collapse load of an indeterminate beam.
- Stopping at the first mechanism tried without a static moment check; the kinematic method gives an upper bound.
- Adding beam and sway loads instead of forming the combined mechanism, in which the knee hinge closes.
- Using plastic analysis with semi-compact or slender sections that cannot rotate (cl. 3.7.2).
- Ignoring the shear limit V ≤ 0.6 Vd or the reduction of Mp by axial force in columns.
- Forgetting restraints and stiffeners at hinge locations (cl. 4.5.2.1 and 4.5.2.2).
- Using γm1 = 1.25 instead of γm0 = 1.10 for the design plastic moment.
Quick check: for uniform load, wc L²/Mp is 8 (simply supported), 11.66 (propped cantilever, hinge at about 0.414 L from the prop) and 16 (fixed both ends). For a fixed-base portal, compare V L/(8 Mp) and H h/(4 Mp) — whichever is larger shows whether beam or sway action dominates — and always try the combined mechanism. Valid for prismatic members with uniform Mp and no axial-force reduction.
Summary
- Mp = Zp fy; shape factor Zp/Ze ≈ 1.10–1.15 for rolled I-sections, 1.5 for rectangles.
- Collapse needs enough hinges for a mechanism; the lowest mechanism load that passes the static check is the collapse load.
- Propped cantilever (central W) 6 Mp/L; fixed beam (UDL) 16 Mp/L²; portal: beam 8 Mp/L, sway 4 Mp/h, combined H h + V L/2 = 6 Mp.
- IS 800:2007 allows plastic analysis only under cl. 4.5.2 (material ductility, plastic sections, restraints, stiffeners, sway support, fabrication).
- Design: Md = βb Zp fy/γm0 with γm0 = 1.10 when V ≤ 0.6 Vd (cl. 8.2.1.2); check service deflections elastically.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the shape factor of a solid rectangle b × d.
Zp = b d²/4, Ze = b d²/6, so S = 1.5.
2A simply supported beam of span 5 m has Md = 200 kN·m. Find the factored uniform collapse load.
wc = 8 × 200/25 = 64.0 kN/m.
3A fixed-ended beam of span 6 m carries a central point load. Md = 180 kN·m. Find Wc.
Wc = 8 Md/L = 8 × 180/6 = 240.0 kN.
4How many independent mechanisms does a fixed-base portal with one mid-span load have?
n = 5 possible hinges, r = 3, so n − r = 2 (beam and sway), plus their combination.
5A steel has fy = 350 MPa and fu = 490 MPa. Does it meet the fu/fy condition of cl. 4.5.2?
490/350 = 1.40 ≥ 1.2, so yes (the other cl. 4.5.2 conditions must also hold).
6A beam at a plastic hinge has overall depth D = 450 mm. Within what distance of the hinge must torsional restraint be provided if it cannot be at the hinge?
Within D/2 = 225 mm (cl. 4.5.2.1).
7A portal (L = 10 m, h = 5 m, Mp = 200 kN·m) has factored loads V = 100 kN and H = 30 kN. Find the three mechanism load factors and λc (before the static check).
Beam: 800/(100 × 5) = 1.600; sway: 800/(30 × 5) = 5.333; combined: 1 200/(150 + 500) = 1.846; lowest 1.600 (beam).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.