Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Steel Design › Chapter 3 › Lesson 3.1

3.1 Yielding, rupture and block shear

Steel Design Chapter 3: Tension members Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Name the three failure modes of a member in tension and write the design strength for each by IS 800:2007 cl. 6.2, 6.3 and 6.4, using the partial safety factors of Table 5.
  • Find the net area of a plate with bolt holes, including a staggered chain of holes, and the shear-lag reduction for an angle connected through one leg.
  • Check a tension member for strength and for the maximum slenderness ratio of Table 3, and say which check governs.

Theory

A tension member is a bar, plate, angle or hanger pulled along its length: a truss tie, a bracing rod, a hanger. Steel in tension cannot buckle, so its strength depends on the material and on how much area is left at the connection. IS 800:2007 Section 6 (cl. 6.1) says the factored tension T must not exceed the design strength Td, and that Td is the lowest of three values: yielding of the gross section, rupture of the critical (net) section, and block shear at an end connection.

Yielding of the gross section (cl. 6.2). If the whole length yields, the member stretches a lot and the structure stops working, even though it has not broken. The strength is the gross area times the yield stress, divided by the partial safety factor for yielding: Tdg = Ag fy/γm0, with γm0 = 1.10 (Table 5).

Three ways a tension member failsT1 gross section yields (Tdg)2 net section ruptures (Tdn)3 block tears out at the bolted end (Tdb)Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 3.1: A plate in tension and its three failure paths: the gross section yielding along the member, the net section rupturing through the bolt holes, and a block tearing out at the bolted end. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Rupture of the net section (cl. 6.3). At a bolt hole the area is smaller and the stress is higher; the material can tear there before the rest yields. The code uses the ultimate stress with a factor of 0.9 on the net area and the higher safety factor γm1 = 1.25 (Table 5), because rupture is sudden: Tdn = 0.9 An fu/γm1. A threaded rod uses the same expression with An as the net root area at the thread (cl. 6.3.2).

Angles and other sections connected by only some of their elements (cl. 6.3.3 and 6.3.4). When an angle is bolted through one leg, the outstanding leg picks up load only gradually, so the stress is not uniform; this is called shear lag. The code splits the strength into the net connected leg at ultimate stress and a reduced share of the outstanding leg at yield stress, using a factor β that depends on the leg width, the shear lag width bs and the length of the connection Lc (the distance between the outermost bolts, or the weld length). Longer connections have a smaller bs/Lc and so a larger β, which means less reduction. For preliminary sizing the code also allows a quick rule: Tdn = α An fu/γm1, with α = 0.6 for one or two bolts, 0.7 for three, and 0.8 for four or more bolts in the end connection.

Block shear (cl. 6.4). At an end connection, a block of material along the bolts can tear out: it shears along the line of bolts and pulls in tension across to the end or edge. Two possible mechanisms are checked and the smaller strength is used. In one, the shear plane yields while the tension plane ruptures; in the other, the shear plane ruptures while the tension plane yields. Gross and net areas are used in the way their names suggest, with the shear terms divided by √3.

Slenderness (cl. 3.8 and Table 3). Even a tension member should not be so slim that it sags, rattles or is bent in handling. The code limits the effective slenderness ratio KL/r: 400 for a member always in tension (not pre-tensioned), 180 for a tension member in which stress reversal occurs from loads other than wind or earthquake, and 350 for a roof-truss or bracing tie that could reverse only under wind or earthquake. A footnote exempts tension members, such as bracing, that are pre-tensioned to avoid sag.

Derivation

  1. Yielding limit: the member as a whole extends by ε L with ε = fy/E at yield, so the load at which the whole length yields is fy Ag; dividing by γm0 gives the design value Tdg = Ag fy/γm0 (N, with Ag in mm² and fy in N/mm²).
  2. Net area of a plate with bolt holes in a line across the width: An = (b − n d0) t, where b is the plate width, n the number of holes in the section, d0 the hole diameter and t the thickness. A bolt hole is taken as the bolt diameter plus the clearance (2 mm more than the bolt for M16 to M24); if holes are punched directly, the code adds 2 mm more to d0.
  3. Staggered holes: a tear path can run diagonally from one hole to the next. Along the diagonal the section carries shear as well as tension, and the code allows for this by adding back p²/(4g) for each stagger, where p is the staggered pitch and g the gauge between the two lines of holes: An = [b − n d0 + Σ p²/(4g)] t. Every possible chain is tried and the smallest An is used.
  4. Which of yielding and rupture governs for a plate: rupture governs when 0.9 An fu/γm1 < Ag fy/γm0, that is when An/Ag < (fy/γm0)/(0.9 fu/γm1) = fy γm1/(0.9 fu γm0). For E250 steel with fy = 250 and fu = 410 N/mm² this ratio is 312.5/405.9 = 0.77, so a plate whose net area falls below about 77% of its gross area is governed by rupture.
  5. Shear lag factor for an angle (cl. 6.3.3): β = 1.4 − 0.076 (w/t)(fy/fu)(bs/Lc), kept between 0.7 and an upper limit of 0.9 fu γm0/(fy γm1) (cl. 6.3.3 as amended by Amendment No. 1, 2012; the original 2007 print had no 0.9), about 1.30 for E250 steel. Here w is the outstand leg width, t the leg thickness, and bs = w + w1 − t for a bolted connection (w1 is the distance from the heel to the bolt line, Fig. 6) or bs = w for a welded one.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Yielding of gross section (IS 800:2007 cl. 6.2): Tdg = Ag fy/γm0 (N), γm0 = 1.10
  • Rupture of net section, plates (cl. 6.3.1): Tdn = 0.9 An fu/γm1 (N), γm1 = 1.25; threaded rods (cl. 6.3.2) with An the net root area
  • Net area with staggered holes: An = [b − n d0 + Σ p²/(4g)] t (mm²), the smallest chain governs
  • Angle connected through one leg (cl. 6.3.3): Tdn = 0.9 Anc fu/γm1 + β Ago fy/γm0; β = 1.4 − 0.076 (w/t)(fy/fu)(bs/Lc) with 0.7 ≤ β ≤ 0.9 fu γm0/(fy γm1); preliminary Tdn = α An fu/γm1 with α = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8
  • Block shear (cl. 6.4.1): Tdb = smaller of [Avg fy/(√3 γm0) + 0.9 Atn fu/γm1] and [0.9 Avn fu/(√3 γm1) + Atg fy/γm0]
  • Design strength: Td = lowest of Tdg, Tdn and Tdb; check T ≤ Td
  • Slenderness (cl. 3.8, Table 3): KL/r ≤ 400 (always in tension), 180 (reversal from loads other than wind or earthquake), 350 (truss or bracing tie, reversal only from wind or earthquake)
Assumptions and limits
  • Static loading. Members under repeated loading need a fatigue check (IS 800 Section 13), which is not covered here.
  • The load is applied through the connection and shared as the code expressions assume; eccentric connections add bending that must be checked separately.
  • Bolt holes are drilled or punched to the standard clearance; the effect of the hole on yielding is ignored because the gross section governs the yielding check.
  • Steel is E250 (fy = 250, fu = 410 N/mm²) in the examples; other grades change fy and fu only.
  • Areas of the connected and outstanding legs of an angle are taken as the leg width less half the thickness (Anc also less the hole), the usual textbook convention.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 6.1 (design strength is the lowest of three values), cl. 6.2 (yielding of gross section), cl. 6.3.1 (plates, with net area and Fig. 5), cl. 6.3.2 (threaded rods), cl. 6.3.3 (single angles, shear lag, Fig. 6), cl. 6.3.4 (other sections), cl. 6.4.1 (block shear, Fig. 7), cl. 3.8 with Table 3 (maximum effective slenderness ratios), cl. 5.4.1 with Table 5 (partial safety factors 1.10 and 1.25).
  • Background: NPTEL course Design of Steel Structures (IIT Kharagpur, Module 5, Lecture 21, design strength of tension members); N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, 2008; S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
  • EN 1993-1-1 and EN 1993-1-8 (Eurocode 3) and AISC 360 treat tension members with the same three failure modes and different reduction factors. They are named here for comparison, not ranked, and their factor values are not quoted.

Worked examples

Example 1 (plate with two bolt holes, exam style)

Problem. A flat plate 180 mm wide and 10 mm thick, E250 (fy = 250, fu = 410 N/mm²), has two M20 bolts side by side across its width (holes 22 mm). Find the design tensile strength, ignoring block shear.

  1. Gross yielding: Ag = 180 × 10 = 1 800 mm²; Tdg = 1 800 × 250/1.10 = 409.1 kN.
  2. Net area: An = (180 − 2 × 22) × 10 = 1 360 mm²; Tdn = 0.9 × 1 360 × 410/1.25 = 401.5 kN.
  3. Check: An/Ag = 0.756, below 0.77, so rupture governs, as the numbers show.

Answer. Td = 401.5 kN, rupture of the net section governs

Example 2 (angle tie, site design)

Problem. A truss tie ISA 75 × 75 × 8 (Ag = 1 138 mm²), E250, is bolted through one leg with three M16 bolts in a line (holes 18 mm), pitch 40 mm, end distance 30 mm, bolt line 40 mm from the heel. Find the design tensile strength.

  1. Yielding: Tdg = 1 138 × 250/1.10 = 258.6 kN.
  2. Shear lag: w = 75, t = 8, w1 = 40, so bs = 75 + 40 − 8 = 107 mm; Lc = 2 × 40 = 80 mm. Anc = (75 − 18 − 4) × 8 = 424 mm²; Ago = (75 − 4) × 8 = 568 mm². β = 1.4 − 0.076 × (75/8) × (250/410) × (107/80) = 0.819, which lies between 0.7 and the upper limit 0.9 × 410 × 1.10/(250 × 1.25) = 1.30.
  3. Rupture: Tdn = 0.9 × 424 × 410/1.25 + 0.819 × 568 × 250/1.10 = 125.2 + 105.7 = 230.9 kN.
  4. Block shear: shear length 30 + 2 × 40 = 110 mm, so Avg = 880 and Avn = (110 − 2.5 × 18) × 8 = 520 mm²; tension width from the bolt line to the toe 75 − 40 = 35 mm, so Atg = 280 and Atn = (35 − 9) × 8 = 208 mm².
  5. Tdb1 = 880 × 250/(√3 × 1.10) + 0.9 × 208 × 410/1.25 = 115.5 + 61.4 = 176.9 kN; Tdb2 = 0.9 × 520 × 410/(√3 × 1.25) + 280 × 250/1.10 = 88.6 + 63.6 = 152.3 kN. The smaller, 152.3 kN, is the block shear strength.

Answer. Td = 152.3 kN, block shear governs (yielding 258.6 kN, rupture 230.9 kN)

Example 3 (slenderness check, exam style)

Problem. A bracing member 3.6 m long between connections (effective length 3.6 m) has a least radius of gyration of 15 mm. Check it if it is (a) always in tension and not pre-tensioned, and (b) a tension member in which stress reversal occurs from loads other than wind or earthquake. If (b) fails, find the least radius of gyration needed.

  1. KL/r = 3 600/15 = 240.
  2. (a) 240 ≤ 400: satisfied.
  3. (b) 240 > 180: not satisfied; r ≥ 3 600/180 = 20 mm is needed, so a larger section is chosen.

Answer. Passes as an always-tension member; fails if reversal from other loads, which needs r ≥ 20 mm

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the factored tension T from the load combinations of IS 800 Table 4.
  2. Pick a trial section and compute Tdg from its gross area.
  3. Compute the net area at the holes (all chains if staggered); for an angle or channel connected by one element, use cl. 6.3.3 or 6.3.4 with shear lag; compute Tdn.
  4. Compute block shear Tdb at the end connection, both mechanisms, and keep the smaller.
  5. Td is the lowest of the three; require T ≤ Td, and change the section or the connection if it fails.
  6. Check KL/r against Table 3 for the member type and its load reversal, then check the connection itself (bolts or welds) under lesson 2.1 or 2.2 methods.

Site notes

  • Holes drilled in a tie reduce its strength; an extra hole drilled on site for a pipe or cable, away from the drawing, can make the net section the weak point.
  • Short connections with few bolts waste the section: a long outstanding leg and a short bolt group give a large shear-lag loss and often block shear governs, so adding a bolt or lengthening the gusset can pay for itself.
  • Hangers and ties that sag during erection are straightened by tightening or by pre-tensioning; pre-tensioned bracing is exempt from the slenderness limit in the Table 3 footnote.
  • Welded end connections avoid hole deductions, but the shear-lag reduction still applies to angles welded through one leg.
  • Rods threaded for turnbuckles are checked at the thread root, not at the shank.
Common mistakes
  • Using the gross area in the rupture check or the net area in the yielding check.
  • Using γm0 = 1.10 in the rupture expression instead of γm1 = 1.25, or leaving out the 0.9.
  • Counting only one hole in a staggered chain, or forgetting that each diagonal adds back p²/(4g).
  • Treating an angle bolted through one leg as if the whole section were effective, with no shear lag.
  • Ignoring block shear at a short end connection, where it often governs.
  • Applying a single slenderness limit to every tension member instead of choosing the Table 3 row by load reversal.
Quick check

For E250 steel, a plate whose net area is below about 77% of its gross area is governed by rupture rather than yielding (Ag fy/γm0 against 0.9 An fu/γm1). In Example 1 the ratio is 0.756, so the net section governs. For short connections with three or fewer bolts, check block shear before anything else.

Summary

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 6.1: design tension strength is the lowest of yielding of gross section, rupture of net section and block shear.
  • Yielding: Tdg = Ag fy/γm0 with γm0 = 1.10; rupture: Tdn = 0.9 An fu/γm1 with γm1 = 1.25.
  • Angles connected through one leg lose strength to shear lag (cl. 6.3.3, factor β); use the smaller block shear mechanism at an end connection (cl. 6.4.1).
  • Net area with staggered holes: An = [b − n d0 + Σ p²/(4g)] t, using the smallest chain.
  • Table 3 slenderness limits: 400 always in tension, 180 for reversal from other loads, 350 for wind or earthquake reversal in a tie.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Name the three failure modes that fix the design tension strength of a bolted plate, and the clause of IS 800:2007 for each.

Yielding of gross section (cl. 6.2), rupture of net section (cl. 6.3) and block shear (cl. 6.4).

2A plate 150 mm × 10 mm, E250, has one 20 mm hole across its width. Find Td, ignoring block shear.

Tdg = 1 500 × 250/1.10 = 340.9 kN; An = (150 − 20) × 10 = 1 300 mm², Tdn = 0.9 × 1 300 × 410/1.25 = 383.8 kN; Td = 340.9 kN (yielding governs; An/Ag = 0.867).

3A plate 180 mm wide and 10 mm thick has holes of 22 mm in three positions on one chain, with two staggers of pitch 40 mm and gauge 50 mm. Find An.

Each stagger adds 40²/(4 × 50) = 8 mm; An = (180 − 3 × 22 + 2 × 8) × 10 = 1 300 mm².

4A threaded rod has a net root area of 225 mm² and E250 steel. Find its rupture strength.

Tdn = 0.9 × 225 × 410/1.25 = 66.4 kN (cl. 6.3.2, with An the net root area).

5A roof-truss tie that reverses stress only under wind is 3.0 m long and has r = 9 mm. Does it meet Table 3? And if the reversal came from dead and imposed loads?

KL/r = 3 000/9 = 333, within 350: satisfied. For reversal from dead and imposed loads the limit is 180: not satisfied.

6A member with no holes carries a factored tension of 300 kN. What gross area of E250 steel is needed for yielding only?

Ag ≥ 300 000 × 1.10/250 = 1 320 mm².

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
  • S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.