2.4 Beam-column connections
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Classify beam-to-column connections as simple (flexible), rigid or semi-rigid by IS 800:2007 cl. 10.6.1 and Annex F, and say what each must transfer.
- Design a double web-cleat simple connection and an unstiffened seated connection for shear, including the minimum design action of cl. 10.7 and the web bearing check of cl. 8.7.4.
- Check an extended end-plate moment connection: flange force, bolt tension, shear-tension interaction and welds.
Theory
Where a beam meets a column the connection decides how the frame behaves. A connection that lets the beam end rotate freely, carrying only the end shear, makes the beam simply supported and the frame must be braced against sway. A connection that holds the angle between beam and column nearly unchanged makes the frame continuous, so it carries moment and can resist sway on its own. IS 800:2007 cl. 10.6.1 classifies connections as rigid, semi-rigid or flexible following Annex F. It names flush and extended end-plate connections as examples of rigid connections; single and double web angle connections and header plate connections as flexible (pinned); and top and seat angle connections, with or without web angles, as semi-rigid. A connection that cannot be shown to be rigid or flexible is assumed semi-rigid.
Annex F explains the choice. Simple connections (F-4.1) transfer shear at a nominal eccentricity and are typically used in frames up to about five storeys, where strength rather than stiffness governs; the web-angle and seat connections of its Fig. 32 (A) to (D) need be checked only for the transfer of shear from beam to column. Rigid connections (F-4.2), needed in high-rise and slender structures and in sway frames, transfer significant moment with negligible joint deformation; end plates with or without column stiffeners and T-stubs are checked for both shear and moment, and fully welded connections can also be taken as rigid. Semi-rigid connections (F-4.3) lie between: their moment-rotation curve comes from tests or from published models such as the Frye-Morris polynomial, and the classification proposed by Bjorhovde, based on a non-dimensional moment and rotation, is suggested.
Every connection is designed so that the forces sent to its parts are in equilibrium with the actions on the joint, its parts can deform as needed and stay stable, and each part is strong enough (cl. 10.6). Design may use any rational method backed by test evidence (cl. 10.6.2). Cl. 10.7 sets a floor on the design actions: a connection to a beam in simple construction is designed for at least 0.15 times the member design shear capacity or 40 kN, whichever is less; a connection in rigid construction for a moment of at least 0.5 times the member design moment capacity. Beam and column splices follow F-2 and F-3 (cl. 10.6.3).
In a moment connection the beam moment is carried mostly by its flanges as a couple: the tension flange pulls on the bolts near it, and the compression flange pushes the end plate against the column. The flange force is close to M divided by the distance between flange centroids. The bolts near the tension flange are checked in tension and, with their share of the shear, by the interaction rule of cl. 10.3.6, and prying from the bending of the end plate is added by cl. 10.4.7. The column must take these flange forces too: its web may need stiffeners opposite the beam flanges, as in the end plate with column stiffeners of Fig. 32 (F).
In a seated connection the beam end rests on an angle bolted or welded to the column. The beam web just above the seat must carry the reaction without crippling; cl. 8.7.4 gives the local capacity of the web at its junction with the flange as Fw = (b1 + n2) tw fyw/γm0, where b1 is the stiff bearing length and n2 the length found by dispersion at a slope of 1:2.5 through the flange to the web junction. If the reaction exceeds Fw a longer seat or a bearing stiffener is needed. A small top cleat holds the top flange in line; the seat angle leg is then checked in bending and shear as a connection component (cl. 10.10).
Derivation
- Flange couple: if the web carries little of the moment, the flanges form a couple with lever arm z = h − tf (distance between flange centroids), so the flange force is Ff = M/(h − tf).
- Bolt tension: with nt bolts grouped round the tension flange and sharing equally, each carries Ff/nt before prying; the vertical shear is shared by all bolts.
- Plastic moment of an I-section: Zp = bf tf (h − tf) + tw (h − 2 tf)²/4 (flanges as two areas at the lever arm, plus the web rectangle), and Md = Zp fy/γm0 for a plastic or compact section (cl. 8.2.1.2), not more than 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 for a simply supported beam.
- Web bearing at a beam end: the reaction spreads through the flange and root at 1:2.5, but at the end of the beam it can spread only one way, so n2 = 2.5 (tf + r) (textbook practice for an end reaction) and the bearing length needed is b1 = R γm0/(tw fyw) − n2.
- Seat angle leg: taking the reaction at the middle of the needed bearing length b1, measured from a clearance gap g at the beam end, and the critical section at the face of the vertical leg of thickness t (a simple model on the safe side), the bending moment in the outstanding leg is M = R (g + b1/2 − t); the leg of width w and thickness t has Ze = w t²/6 and Zp = w t²/4.
Minimum design action (IS 800:2007 cl. 10.7): simple construction V ≥ the lesser of 0.15 Vd and 40 kN; rigid construction M ≥ 0.5 MdShear capacity of a web or plate (cl. 8.4.1): Vd = Av fy/(√3 γm0) (N; Av in mm², fy in N/mm²); γm0 = 1.10Design moment of a plastic or compact beam (cl. 8.2.1.2): Md = Zp fy/γm0 ≤ 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 (N mm)Flange force Ff = M/(h − tf) (N, with M in N mm and lengths in mm); bolt tension Tb = Ff/nt + Q (prying, cl. 10.4.7)Shear with tension (cl. 10.3.6): (Vsb/Vdb)² + (Tb/Tdb)² ≤ 1.0Web bearing (cl. 8.7.4): Fw = (b1 + n2) tw fyw/γm0; at a beam end n2 = 2.5 (tf + r) (textbook practice)Bolt values (lesson 2.1): M20 class 4.6 single shear 45.26 kN; M24 class 8.8: An = 353 mm², Vdsb = 130.4 kN, Tdb = 203.3 kN
- Simple connections carry the end shear only; the small moment from the nominal eccentricity is ignored in the beam design (F-4.1).
- In moment connections the flanges carry the moment as a couple and the web carries the shear; this is a common, slightly safe-side simplification.
- Bolt groups around the tension flange share the flange force equally; prying is added where the end plate bends (cl. 10.4.7).
- The column is checked separately for the flange forces it receives; stiffeners are provided where its web or flange is not strong enough.
- Static loading. Under earthquake combinations connections must also provide the ductility of Section 12, and the actions of cl. 10.7 may need to be raised.
- Semi-rigid behaviour needs a moment-rotation curve from tests or a published model (F-4.3); it is not used in the examples.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 10.6 (design of connections: equilibrium, deformation capacity, strength and stability of every part), cl. 10.6.1 (rigid, semi-rigid and flexible connections per Annex F, with examples of each), cl. 10.6.2 (rational methods supported by tests; residual stresses; fatigue to Section 13; earthquake actions to Section 12), cl. 10.6.3 (beam and column splices per F-2 and F-3), cl. 10.7 (minimum design actions), cl. 10.9 (choice of fasteners), cl. 10.10 (connection components).
- IS 800:2007 Annex F: F-4.1 (simple connections: shear at nominal eccentricity, frames up to about five storeys, Fig. 32 (A) to (D)), F-4.2 (rigid connections: Fig. 32 (E) to (G), fully welded connections), F-4.3, F-4.3.1 and F-4.3.2 (semi-rigid connections, Bjorhovde classification, Frye-Morris model). Also cl. 8.2.1.2 (design bending strength), cl. 8.4.1 (shear strength), cl. 8.7.4 (bearing stiffeners and the local web capacity Fw), cl. 10.3.2 to 10.3.6 (bolt values and interaction), cl. 10.4.7 (prying), cl. 10.5.2.3 with Table 21 (minimum fillet size), cl. 10.5.7.1.1 and 10.5.7.1.2 (fillet weld strength; butt welds as parent metal).
- EN 1993-1-8 classifies joints by stiffness as nominally pinned, rigid or semi-rigid and by strength, and designs end-plate joints by the component method with equivalent T-stubs. AISC 360 Chapter B and Chapter J, with the AISC Steel Construction Manual and AISC 358 for prequalified seismic moment connections, separate simple shear connections, fully restrained and partially restrained moment connections. The approaches are listed side by side, not ranked; their factor values are not quoted here.
Worked examples
Problem. A beam with a web 380 mm deep and 8 mm thick (E250, fy = 250, fu = 410 N/mm²) is connected to a column flange by two cleat angles 10 mm thick, one on each side of the web. The factored end reaction is 180 kN. Use M20 class 4.6 bolts in 22 mm holes, end distance 40 mm, pitch 80 mm, threads in the shear planes. Find the bolts in the beam web and in the column flange.
- Minimum design action (cl. 10.7): web shear capacity Vd = 380 × 8 × 250/(√3 × 1.10) = 398.9 kN; 0.15 × 398.9 = 59.8 kN, so the lesser value is 40 kN. The reaction of 180 kN governs.
- Beam web bolts are in double shear: 2 × 45.26 = 90.53 kN. Bearing on the 8 mm web with kb = 40/66 = 0.606: 2.5 × 0.606 × 20 × 8 × 410/1.25 = 79.5 kN. Bolt value 79.5 kN (bearing governs); 180/79.5 = 2.26, provide 3 bolts (238.5 kN).
- Column flange bolts are in single shear through one angle each: 45.26 kN (bearing on the 10 mm angle 99.4 kN). 180/45.26 = 3.98; provide 3 bolts in each angle, 6 in all (271.6 kN), matching the web rows.
- Cleat length 40 + 2 × 80 + 40 = 240 mm; shear capacity of the two angle legs 2 × 240 × 10 × 250/(√3 × 1.10) = 629.8 kN ≥ 180 kN.
- The small eccentricity of the bolt lines is ignored for a simple connection (F-4.1); the beam is designed as simply supported.
Answer. 3 bolts in double shear in the web (bearing 79.5 kN each) and 6 bolts in single shear in the column flange; cleats 240 mm long
Problem. A welded beam 400 mm deep with flanges 140 × 16 mm and an 8 mm web (E250, plastic section) is connected to a column by an extended end plate with full-penetration flange welds. Factored actions: M = 150 kN m, V = 120 kN. Four M24 class 8.8 bolts are grouped round the tension flange, with four more near the compression flange; threads in the shear plane. Check the minimum design action, the bolts and the web welds.
- Zp = 140 × 16 × 384 + 8 × 368²/4 = 860 160 + 270 848 = 1 131 008 mm³; Md = 1 131 008 × 250/1.10 = 257.0 kN m (≤ 1.2 Ze fy/γm0 = 270.6 kN m with Ze = 0.992 × 10⁶ mm³). Outstand 66/16 = 4.1 and web 368/8 = 46 are well inside the Table 2 plastic limits.
- Rigid construction (cl. 10.7): at least 0.5 × 257.0 = 128.5 kN m. The applied 150 kN m governs.
- Flange force Ff = 150 × 10⁶/(400 − 16) = 390.6 kN, within the flange capacity 140 × 16 × 250/1.10 = 509.1 kN; the full-penetration butt welds are treated as parent metal (cl. 10.5.7.1.2).
- M24 class 8.8: An = (π/4)(24 − 0.9382 × 3)² = 352.5, taken as 353 mm²; Tnb = 0.90 × 800 × 353 = 254.2 kN (below 640 × 452.4 × 1.25/1.10 = 329.0 kN), Tdb = 203.3 kN; Vdsb = (800/√3) × 353/1.25 = 130.4 kN.
- Tension per bolt 390.6/4 = 97.7 kN; shear per bolt 120/8 = 15.0 kN. Interaction (15.0/130.4)² + (97.7/203.3)² = 0.013 + 0.231 = 0.24 ≤ 1.0. The reserve of 203.3 − 97.7 = 105.6 kN per bolt is available for the prying force of cl. 10.4.7, which is found from the end-plate thickness and bolt geometry before the bolts are accepted.
- Web to end plate: two fillet welds about 300 mm long carry 120 kN, 200 N/mm, needing a throat of only 200/189.4 = 1.06 mm; the Table 21 minimum for a 25 mm end plate (6 mm) governs, giving 600 × 4.2 × 189.4 = 477.2 kN.
Answer. Design moment 150 kN m (minimum 128.5); flange force 390.6 kN; bolt tension 97.7 kN, interaction 0.24 before prying; 6 mm web fillets
Problem. A beam with a 7.0 mm web, 12 mm flanges and a 12 mm root radius (fyw = 250 N/mm²) rests on a seat angle 16 mm thick and 150 mm wide bolted to a column flange, with a 10 mm clearance between the beam end and the column. The factored reaction is 150 kN. Find the bearing length needed, check the seat leg in bending and shear, and choose the bolts (M20 class 4.6).
- Dispersion at the beam end: n2 = 2.5 × (12 + 12) = 60 mm.
- Web bearing (cl. 8.7.4): 150 000 ≤ (b1 + 60) × 7.0 × 250/1.10, so b1 + 60 ≥ 94.29 mm and b1 ≥ 34.3 mm. An outstanding leg of 90 mm gives 80 mm of seat beyond the gap, ample.
- Lever arm to the face of the vertical leg: 10 + 34.29/2 − 16 = 11.14 mm; M = 150 × 11.14 = 1 671 kN mm = 1.67 kN m.
- Leg 150 × 16: Ze = 150 × 16²/6 = 6 400 mm³, Zp = 9 600 mm³; Md = smaller of 9 600 × 250/1.10 = 2.18 kN m and 1.2 × 6 400 × 250/1.10 = 1.75 kN m, so 1.75 kN m ≥ 1.67 kN m. Shear 150 × 16 × 250/(√3 × 1.10) = 314.9 kN ≥ 150 kN.
- Bolts through the vertical leg in single shear: 150/45.26 = 3.31, provide 4 bolts (181.1 kN); bearing on 16 mm with kb = 0.606 is 159.0 kN per bolt, not critical.
- Add a light top cleat to hold the top flange; the seat and cleat together make a top and seat angle connection, which cl. 10.6.1 counts as semi-rigid but which is designed here as simple, for shear only (F-4.1).
Answer. Bearing length 34.3 mm; seat leg 1.67 ≤ 1.75 kN m; 4 bolts M20 class 4.6
Step-by-step procedure
- Decide the frame type: braced frame with simple connections, or sway or continuous frame with rigid connections; semi-rigid only with a known moment-rotation curve.
- Find the end shear and, for rigid connections, the end moment from the analysis; raise them to the minimum design actions of cl. 10.7.
- Simple connection: choose web cleats, header plate or seat; design bolts or welds for the shear, check bearing on the web and the cleat or seat as a component, and check web bearing (cl. 8.7.4) for seats.
- Rigid connection: find the flange force M/(h − tf); design the flange welds; group bolts round the tension flange; check tension, shear and interaction; add prying (cl. 10.4.7).
- Check the column for the flange forces (web bearing and buckling, flange bending) and add stiffeners where needed.
- Detail for erection: clearance at the beam end, accessible bolts, and seats or erection cleats to carry the beam while it is bolted up.
Site notes
- Seats and erection cleats let a beam be landed and held while the main bolts go in; they also keep the beam at the right level.
- End plates are cut square and welded with a planned sequence, because a plate that dishes from welding heat will not bear fully on the column and the bolts will see prying.
- Bolts in tension in moment connections are usually friction grip bolts tightened to the specified preload and checked; snug-tight bolts are not used there.
- Column stiffeners opposite beam flanges are fitted to bear or are welded as drawn; leaving them out changes a rigid connection into a much more flexible one.
- A connection shown on drawings as pinned should be built as pinned: adding top and bottom plates "for safety" makes it attract moment it was never designed for.
- Designing a beam as simply supported but building a rigid connection, or the reverse, so the frame behaves differently from the analysis.
- Forgetting the minimum design actions of cl. 10.7, especially the 0.5 Md moment for rigid construction.
- Taking the flange force as M/h instead of M/(h − tf), or ignoring the shear on the tension bolts.
- Leaving out prying in end-plate connections with thin plates.
- Not checking web bearing (cl. 8.7.4) at a seat, or measuring n2 both ways at a beam end.
- Treating double-shear web bolts as single shear, or forgetting that bearing on a thin web often governs.
For an I-beam the flange force in a moment connection is close to M divided by 0.95 to 0.97 of the beam depth (in Example 2, 150/0.384 = 390.6 kN); bolts grouped round a tension flange usually need a tension capacity of at least a quarter of that each when four bolts are used, plus prying. A simple connection designed for the full end reaction automatically exceeds the 40 kN floor of cl. 10.7 for most floor beams.
Summary
- IS 800:2007 cl. 10.6.1 and Annex F classify connections as flexible (web angles, header plates), rigid (end plates, T-stubs, fully welded) or semi-rigid (top and seat angles).
- Simple connections carry shear only and suit braced frames up to about five storeys (F-4.1); rigid connections carry moment and shear (F-4.2).
- Minimum design actions (cl. 10.7): shear the lesser of 0.15 Vd and 40 kN in simple construction; moment 0.5 Md in rigid construction.
- Moment connections: flange force M/(h − tf), bolts in tension and shear with the cl. 10.3.6 interaction and prying of cl. 10.4.7.
- Seats: web bearing Fw = (b1 + n2) tw fyw/γm0 (cl. 8.7.4), and the seat leg checked in bending and shear.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Name the IS 800 class of (a) a double web-angle connection, (b) an extended end-plate connection, (c) a top and seat angle connection.
(a) flexible (pinned), (b) rigid, (c) semi-rigid (cl. 10.6.1).
2A beam has a design shear capacity of 200 kN. What is the minimum design shear for its simple end connection?
0.15 × 200 = 30 kN, less than 40 kN, so 30 kN (cl. 10.7).
3A beam in rigid construction has Md = 300 kN m and an analysed end moment of 120 kN m. What moment is the connection designed for?
At least 0.5 × 300 = 150 kN m, which exceeds 120 kN m, so 150 kN m.
4Find the flange force for M = 200 kN m in a beam 450 mm deep with 17.4 mm flanges.
200 × 10⁶/(450 − 17.4) = 462.3 kN.
5A beam end with a 6 mm web, tf + r = 20 mm and fyw = 250 N/mm² carries a reaction of 100 kN on a seat. Find the stiff bearing length needed.
n2 = 2.5 × 20 = 50 mm; b1 + 50 ≥ 100 000 × 1.10/(6 × 250) = 73.33 mm, so b1 ≥ 23.3 mm.
6Why do frames with simple connections need bracing?
Pinned beam-to-column joints give no sway stiffness, so lateral loads must be carried by braces, cores or shear walls (F-4.1).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.