1.3 Working stress method concepts
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain the working stress method: elastic analysis at service loads with stresses kept below permissible values that are fractions of the yield stress.
- Use the permissible stresses of IS 800:2007 Section 11 for axial tension, bending of laterally supported beams and shear, and the 33 per cent increase of cl. 11.1.4 for load combinations with wind or earthquake.
- Compare a working stress design with a limit state design of the same member and explain where the two methods differ.
Theory
The working stress method, also called allowable stress design, is the older of the two design philosophies and is still used for some structures and in many existing calculations. The structure is analysed elastically under its service loads, the loads it is actually expected to carry, and the stress at every critical point is kept below a permissible stress. The permissible stress is the yield stress divided by a single factor of safety, so the whole margin sits on the stress side; the loads are taken at face value.
IS 800:2007 keeps the method in Section 11 as the alternative to limit state design where that cannot conveniently be adopted (cl. 3.1.2.2 and 5.1.4). Under cl. 11.1.2 elastic analysis is used, and under cl. 11.1.3 the working stresses are calculated with the partial load factors for service load. The permissible stresses follow. For axial tension, cl. 11.2.1 limits the actual stress on the gross area to 0.6 fy for yielding of the gross section, and also to 0.69 times the limit state rupture and block-shear strengths divided by the gross area. For axial compression, cl. 11.3.1 allows 0.60 fcd, where fcd is the limit state design compressive stress. For a laterally supported beam, cl. 11.4.1 allows 0.66 fy in bending for plastic and compact sections and 0.60 fy for semi-compact sections, and cl. 11.4.2 allows 0.40 fy in pure shear.
Wind and earthquake are rare, short events. Cl. 11.1.4 therefore lets the permissible stresses be increased by 33 per cent in load combinations involving wind or seismic loads, limited to 25 per cent for anchor bolts and construction loads, and not allowed at all when the wind or seismic load is the major load in the combination, such as when it acts with dead load alone.
The method is simple and gives a feel for the actual stresses in service, but it has clear weaknesses. One factor cannot reflect that dead load is known far more precisely than wind, or that rupture is more dangerous than yielding. Because it stops at the elastic limit, it ignores the reserve of strength from plastic redistribution and from the shape factor of compact sections, although the 0.66 fy bending stress gives part of that back. And it gives no direct picture of how the structure fails. Limit state design, with separate load and material factors and checks at both collapse and service, answers these points, which is why IS 800:2007 makes it the normal method.
Derivation
- Factor of safety on yield: a permissible stress of 0.6 fy means a factor of 1/0.6 = 1.67 between service stress and yield. The limit state margin for gross yielding of a tension member is γf × γm0 = 1.5 × 1.10 = 1.65, almost the same.
- Bending of compact sections: 0.66 fy corresponds to a factor of 1/0.66 = 1.52 on first yield. Since a compact I-section has a shape factor of about 1.12, the margin against the full plastic moment is about 1.52 × 1.12 = 1.70.
- Shear: the shear yield stress is fy/√3 = 0.577 fy, so a permissible 0.40 fy gives a factor of 0.577/0.40 = 1.44 on shear yield.
- Wind and earthquake combinations: increasing the permissible stress by 33 per cent reduces the factor of safety for that rare combination from 1.67 to 1.67/1.33 = 1.25 for tension.
- Working stress check of a beam: σ = M/Ze ≤ σ permissible, so the required elastic modulus is Ze ≥ M/σ permissible; for shear τ = V/(h tw) ≤ 0.40 fy.
Actual stresses at service load: ft = T/Ag; fbc = M/Zec; τ = V/Av (N/mm²; T, V in N; M in N mm; areas in mm²; Z in mm³)Tension (IS 800:2007 cl. 11.2.1): fat = 0.6 fy on the gross area, and not more than 0.69 Tdn/Ag or 0.69 Tdb/Ag from the limit state rupture and block shear strengthsCompression (cl. 11.3.1): fac = 0.60 fcdBending, laterally supported (cl. 11.4.1): 0.66 fy for plastic and compact sections; 0.60 fy for semi-compact sectionsShear (cl. 11.4.2): τ permissible = 0.40 fy in pure shearWind or earthquake combinations (cl. 11.1.4): permissible stresses × 1.33 (× 1.25 for anchor bolts and construction loads); no increase when wind or earthquake is the major load
- Elastic behaviour up to the permissible stress; no plastic redistribution is counted.
- Service loads are taken at face value; the single factor of safety is on the stress.
- The bending values assume a laterally supported beam; laterally unsupported beams use 0.60 times the limit state design bending strength divided by the elastic modulus (cl. 11.4.1 b), covered in the beams chapter.
- Section classification, detailing and slenderness rules of Section 3 still apply (cl. 11.1.1).
- The 33 per cent increase is for rare short-term loads in combination; it is not a general strength increase.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 3.1.2.2 and 5.1.4 (working stress design of Section 11 where the limit state method cannot conveniently be adopted), cl. 11.1.1 (Section 3 general design requirements apply), cl. 11.1.2 (elastic analysis), cl. 11.1.3 (working stresses with the partial load factors for service load), cl. 11.1.4 (33 per cent increase for wind or seismic combinations, 25 per cent for anchor bolts and construction loads, none when wind or seismic is the major load), cl. 11.2.1 (tension: 0.6 fy on the gross area; 0.69 times the rupture and block-shear strengths), cl. 11.3.1 (compression: 0.60 fcd), cl. 11.4.1 (bending: 0.66 fy plastic and compact, 0.60 fy semi-compact, laterally supported), cl. 11.4.2 (shear: 0.40 fy).
- IS 800 was first issued in 1956 and revised in 1962 and 1984; the foreword of the 2007 (third) revision records that it is based on the limit state method, and working stress design is kept as Section 11. Older steelwork in India was usually designed by the working stress rules of the earlier editions.
- AISC 360 keeps an allowable strength design route (ASD) in which the nominal strength is divided by a safety factor Ω and compared with service-level load combinations from ASCE 7; EN 1993-1-1 has no allowable stress route and uses limit states only. The approaches are listed side by side, not ranked.
Worked examples
Problem. Check the 8 m floor beam of lesson 1.2, Example 3 (service load 12 + 8 = 20 kN/m; plastic I-section with Ze = 1.111 × 10⁶ mm³, D = 400 mm, tw = 8 mm; E250, laterally supported) by the working stress method of IS 800:2007 Section 11.
- Service moment M = 20 × 8²/8 = 160 kN m; service shear V = 20 × 8/2 = 80 kN.
- Permissible bending stress (plastic section, cl. 11.4.1) = 0.66 × 250 = 165 N/mm².
- Actual bending stress = 160 × 10⁶/1.111 × 10⁶ = 144.0 N/mm² ≤ 165 N/mm²: safe. Required Ze = 160 × 10⁶/165 = 969 697 mm³ ≤ 1.111 × 10⁶ mm³.
- Shear: τ = 80 000/(400 × 8) = 25.0 N/mm² ≤ 0.40 × 250 = 100 N/mm².
- Utilisation in bending 144.0/165 = 0.87, close to the 0.85 of the limit state check: the two methods agree well for this simple beam.
Answer. Bending 144.0 ≤ 165 N/mm²; shear 25.0 ≤ 100 N/mm²; safe
Problem. For the 200 mm × 10 mm E250 plate with two 22 mm holes of lesson 1.2, Example 2 (Tdn = 460.5 kN), find the permissible service tension by IS 800:2007 cl. 11.2.1, and compare it with the service load allowed by the limit state design at γf = 1.5.
- Yielding of the gross section: 0.6 × 250 × 2 000 = 300 000 N = 300.0 kN.
- Rupture of the net section: 0.69 × Tdn = 0.69 × 460.5 = 317.7 kN.
- Permissible tension = 300.0 kN (yielding governs, as in limit state design).
- Limit state: Tdg/1.5 = 454.5/1.5 = 303.0 kN of service load. The two methods differ by 1 per cent, because 1/0.6 = 1.67 is close to 1.5 × 1.10 = 1.65.
Answer. Permissible 300.0 kN by working stress against 303.0 kN of service load by limit state
Problem. A tie of E250 steel (permissible tension 0.6 fy = 150 N/mm² on the gross area) has a service stress of 140 N/mm² under dead plus imposed load and 190 N/mm² under dead plus imposed plus wind load. A second tie has 70 N/mm² under dead load and 180 N/mm² under dead load plus wind. Check both by IS 800:2007 cl. 11.1.4.
- Tie 1, dead plus imposed: 140 ≤ 150 N/mm²: safe.
- Tie 1, with wind: permissible = 1.33 × 150 = 199.5 N/mm²; 190 ≤ 199.5: safe.
- Tie 2, dead plus wind: wind is the major load in this combination (it acts with dead load alone and gives most of the stress), so no increase is allowed; 180 > 150 N/mm²: not safe.
- Tie 2 needs at least 180/150 = 1.2 times its area.
Answer. Tie 1 safe (190 ≤ 199.5 N/mm²); tie 2 fails (180 > 150 N/mm², no increase when wind is the major load)
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the service loads and form the load combinations (wind and earthquake never together).
- Analyse the structure elastically for each combination.
- Classify the sections (Section 3 still applies) and pick the permissible stresses of Section 11 for tension, compression, bending and shear.
- Raise the permissible stresses by 33 per cent (25 per cent for anchor bolts and construction loads) for combinations with wind or earthquake, unless that load is the major one.
- Compute the actual stresses (T/A, M/Z, V/Av) and check each against its permissible value.
- Check deflection at service load as in limit state design.
Site notes
- Many older steel structures, such as sheds, foot-over bridges and towers, were designed by working stress; a check for a new loading or a modification has to start from the method and permissible stresses originally used.
- Working stress figures are close to the actual stresses in service, which makes them handy when comparing with strain-gauge readings in a load test.
- When an old drawing gives permissible stresses, the steel quality of the period should be confirmed by tests on coupons before new loads are added.
- For temporary works and lifting arrangements, contractors often use allowable stress checks; the factor of safety used must be stated on the calculation.
- Applying the 33 per cent increase to a dead plus wind combination where wind is the main load.
- Comparing a working stress (service) result directly with a factored limit state force.
- Using 0.66 fy for a semi-compact section; it is 0.60 fy.
- Using 0.4 fy on the whole cross-section area in shear instead of the web area h tw.
- Mixing permissible stresses from IS 800:1984 with loads or rules from IS 800:2007 in one calculation.
In E250 steel the working stress method allows about 150 N/mm² in axial tension, 165 N/mm² in bending of compact laterally supported beams and 100 N/mm² in shear. An actual service stress much above these values signals an error in the load or the section property; the figures apply to plates under 20 mm thick and laterally supported members.
Summary
- The working stress method keeps elastic service-load stresses below permissible stresses, with one factor of safety on the stress.
- IS 800:2007 keeps it in Section 11 as the alternative to limit state design.
- Permissible stresses: 0.6 fy tension (gross), 0.66 fy bending of plastic and compact sections, 0.60 fy semi-compact, 0.40 fy shear, 0.60 fcd compression.
- Permissible stresses rise by 33 per cent for combinations with wind or earthquake, except when that load is the major one.
- For simple members the two methods give similar sizes; limit state design handles different load types and failure modes more rationally.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the permissible bending stress for a laterally supported compact beam of E350 steel.
0.66 × 350 = 231 N/mm².
2A hot-rolled I-section has a 300 mm depth and a 7.5 mm web. Find its permissible shear force in E250 steel.
Av = 300 × 7.5 = 2 250 mm²; V = 0.40 × 250 × 2 250 = 225 000 N = 225 kN.
3Find the permissible tension on a 1 500 mm² E250 angle by gross-section yielding.
0.6 × 250 × 1 500 = 225 000 N = 225 kN.
4What is the permissible tensile stress for E250 steel in a dead plus imposed plus wind combination?
1.33 × 150 = 199.5 N/mm² (wind not the major load).
5Why is no 33 per cent increase allowed when wind acts with dead load alone?
Then wind is the major load, so the combination is not a rare addition to the normal loads; the full factor of safety is kept.
6What factor of safety on first yield does 0.66 fy imply, and how does it compare with limit state design?
1/0.66 = 1.52 on first yield; with the shape factor of about 1.12 it is about 1.70 on the plastic moment, against 1.5 × 1.10 = 1.65 in limit state design.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.