4.2 Built-up columns with lacing and battens
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why built-up compression members need lacings or battens and state the IS 800:2007 shear-deformation factors 1.05 (laced) and 1.10 (battened) on the overall (KL/r)_0.
- Check component spacing a1/r1 against the twin limits 50 and 0.7 times the most unfavourable overall slenderness, and size flat lacings for width, thickness, inclination and KL/r ≤ 145.
- Design battens for Vt = 2.5% of axial force using Vb = Vt·C/(N·S) and M = Vt·C/(2N), and apply the depth and thickness rules of cl. 7.7.2.3.
Theory
A single rolled section is often too weak or too slender about one axis for a heavy column. Two (or more) main components placed a clear distance apart raise the radius of gyration about the open axis, but they act as one member only if they are tied so that they cannot buckle separately and so that they share shear. IS 800:2007 Section 7 allows two classical ties for that job: a system of lacings (inclined bars or flats) or a system of battens (horizontal plates). Both systems are designed for a notional transverse shear of at least 2.5 percent of the factored axial force, and both increase the effective overall slenderness slightly to allow for shear deformation of the open web.
Cl. 7.6 covers laced columns. Where practicable the radius of gyration about the axis perpendicular to the plane of lacing should be at least that about the axis parallel to the plane of lacing (cl. 7.6.1.1), so the open axis is not the weaker one after the chords are spaced. The lacing should be uniform along the length (cl. 7.6.1.2). Mixing a single-laced system on one face with a double-laced system on the other, or combining lacings with battens as perpendicular ties, is avoided unless the forces are calculated; a single-laced system with bars all sloping the same way on opposite faces is preferred so that the shear deformation of the two planes matches (cl. 7.6.1.3–7.6.1.4). The design effective slenderness is (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0, where (KL/r)_0 is the actual maximum overall slenderness of the built-up member (cl. 7.6.1.5). That amplified value is the one taken into the buckling curves of lesson 4.1.
Flat lacings have a minimum width of three times the nominal diameter of the end bolt or rivet (cl. 7.6.2). Thickness must be at least one-fortieth of the effective length for single lacings and one-sixtieth for double lacings (cl. 7.6.3); rolled sections or tubes of equivalent strength may replace flats. Inclination to the axis of the built-up member must lie between 40° and 70° (cl. 7.6.4). Spacing of connections along each main component must keep a1/r1 ≤ 50 and also ≤ 0.7 times the most unfavourable overall slenderness of the member as a whole (cl. 7.6.5), where a1 is the unsupported length between lacing points and r1 is the minimum radius of gyration of the individual component.
Lacings are proportioned for a transverse shear Vt equal to at least 2.5 percent of the axial force in the member, shared equally among the parallel planes of lacing (cl. 7.6.6). When eccentricity, end moments or lateral loads produce a calculated shear, that actual shear is used if it is larger. Each lacing bar then carries a force equal to the plane shear divided by sin θ, with θ the inclination to the member axis. The slenderness of a lacing bar must not exceed 145 (cl. 7.6.6.3). For bolted or riveted construction the effective length is the length between the inner end fasteners for single lacings, and 0.7 of that length for double lacings that are effectively connected at their intersections; for welded single lacings the effective length is 0.7 times the distance between the inner ends of the welds. Attachments must transmit the bar force; welded overlap along either edge is at least four times the thinner part (cl. 7.6.7). End tie plates, detailed as for battens in cl. 7.7, close the lacing system at the ends and wherever it is interrupted (cl. 7.6.8).
Cl. 7.7 covers battened columns. The main components should preferably be of the same cross-section and placed symmetrically (cl. 7.7.1.1); again ry about the axis perpendicular to the battens should, where practicable, be at least ry about the axis parallel to them. A battened member needs at least three bays (cl. 7.7.1.2–7.7.1.3). The design effective slenderness is (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0 (cl. 7.7.1.4) — a slightly larger shear-deformation penalty than for lacings. Battens are designed for Vt = 2.5 percent of the total axial force, divided equally between the parallel planes of battens (cl. 7.7.2.1). At each connection the shear in one batten is Vb = Vt·C/(N·S) and the moment is M = Vt·C/(2N), where C is the centre-to-centre distance of the main components, N is the number of parallel planes of battens, and S is the spacing of battens centre-to-centre of end fastenings. Tie plates at the ends are designed by the same method and must not be weaker than the battens (cl. 7.7.2.2).
Plate battens have size rules in cl. 7.7.2.3: the effective longitudinal depth of an end batten (and of battens at stay points) is at least the perpendicular distance between the centroids of the main members; an intermediate batten is at least three-quarters of that distance; and no batten may be shallower than twice the width of one main member in the plane of the battens. Thickness is at least C'/50, where C' is the distance between the innermost lines of bolts, rivets or welds measured perpendicular to the main member. Spacing of battens must keep the component slenderness over that distance ≤ 50 and ≤ 0.7 times the overall slenderness about the z–z axis (the axis parallel to the battens) (cl. 7.7.3). Welded attachment follows the lap and weld rules of cl. 7.7.4.
EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 also give built-up member rules (shear factors, stitch spacing, and connecting-element forces). They are named here for comparison only; they are not ranked, and their numerical factor tables are not quoted. Background commentary matching the IS approach is in N. Subramanian (OUP, 2008) and S. K. Duggal (3rd ed., 2019).
Derivation
- Shear-deformation amplification (cl. 7.6.1.5, cl. 7.7.1.4): (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0 for laced columns; (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0 for battened columns. Use (KL/r)_e in the buckling curves of lesson 4.1.
- Component spacing (cl. 7.6.5, cl. 7.7.3): a1/r1 ≤ 50 and a1/r1 ≤ 0.7 × (overall slenderness of the built-up member on the governing axis).
- Notional shear: Vt ≥ 0.025 P (kN), shared equally among N parallel planes. Force in one inclined lacing bar: F = (Vt/N) / sin θ (kN), with θ the angle between the bar and the member axis.
- Flat lacing geometry (cl. 7.6.2–7.6.4, cl. 7.6.6.3): width ≥ 3 d_bolt; t ≥ L_eff/40 (single) or L_eff/60 (double); 40° ≤ θ ≤ 70°; KL/r ≤ 145. For a flat of thickness t, r_min = t/√12 about the weak axis.
- Batten forces (cl. 7.7.2.1): Vb = Vt·C/(N·S) (kN); M = Vt·C/(2N) (with C, S in consistent length units → kN·mm or kNm). Depth and t from cl. 7.7.2.3.
Laced: (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0 (dimensionless)Battened: (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0 (dimensionless)Component check: a1/r1 ≤ min(50, 0.7 × overall KL/r)Vt ≥ 0.025 P (kN); F_bar = (Vt/N)/sin θ (kN)Flat lacings: b ≥ 3 d; t ≥ L_eff/40 (single) or L_eff/60 (double); 40° ≤ θ ≤ 70°; KL/r ≤ 145; r_min = t/√12 (mm)Battens: Vb = Vt·C/(N·S) (kN); M = Vt·C/(2N); end depth ≥ C; intermediate depth ≥ (3/4)C; depth ≥ 2 × member width; t ≥ C′/50
- Static axial compression; fatigue and seismic ductile detailing of the built-up member are outside this lesson.
- E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm² and γm0 = 1.10 as in IS 800 for ordinary structural steel (Table 5).
- Steel grade E250 (fy = 250 N/mm²) unless stated; changing the grade changes fy in the strut check of a lacing only.
- Section areas and radii of gyration of the main components and of the built-up section are given design data (handbook values), not re-derived from plate dimensions.
- Examples take the notional shear Vt = 2.5% P with no extra calculated shear from eccentricity or lateral load; when such shear exists, use the larger of the two.
- Lacing compressive checks use a stated buckling class (α) as given design data for the flat about its weak axis; local plate classification of the main components is taken as already satisfied.
- Welded double-lacing intersection connections and second-order frame K-factors are not worked here.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 7.6 (Laced Columns): cl. 7.6.1–7.6.1.5 (general and (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0), cl. 7.6.2 (min width 3 × bolt diameter), cl. 7.6.3 (thickness L_eff/40 or /60), cl. 7.6.4 (inclination 40°–70°), cl. 7.6.5 (spacing a1/r1), cl. 7.6.6–7.6.6.3 (Vt = 2.5% P; KL/r ≤ 145; effective lengths), cl. 7.6.7 (attachment), cl. 7.6.8 (end tie plates per 7.7).
- IS 800:2007 cl. 7.7 (Battened Columns): cl. 7.7.1–7.7.1.4 (general and (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0), cl. 7.7.2.1 (Vt, Vb, M), cl. 7.7.2.2 (tie plates), cl. 7.7.2.3 (depths and t ≥ C′/50), cl. 7.7.3 (spacing), cl. 7.7.4 (weld attachment). Table 5 (γm0 = 1.10). Buckling curves as in cl. 7.1.2.1 (lesson 4.1).
- Background: N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, 2008; S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
- EN 1993-1-1 built-up member rules and AISC 360 built-up member rules are named for comparison only; they are not ranked and their factor tables are not quoted.
Worked examples
Problem. A laced built-up column of E250 steel has an actual maximum overall slenderness (KL/r)_0 = 80 (given). Each main component has a minimum radius of gyration r1 = 25.0 mm (given). Lacing connections are spaced so that the unsupported length of a component between consecutive connections is a1 = 600 mm. Check the design effective slenderness for flexural buckling and the component spacing limit of cl. 7.6.5.
- Design effective slenderness (cl. 7.6.1.5): (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × 80 = 84.0. Use 84.0 (not 80) when computing λ and χ in lesson 4.1.
- Component slenderness: a1/r1 = 600/25.0 = 24.0.
- Limits: 50 and 0.7 × (KL/r)_0 = 0.7 × 80 = 56.0; governing limit = min(50, 56) = 50.
- 24.0 ≤ 50, so the spacing satisfies cl. 7.6.5. (If a1 were raised to 1 300 mm, a1/r1 would be 52 > 50 and would fail even though 52 < 56.)
- Also confirm ry about the axis perpendicular to the lacings is not less than ry about the parallel axis where practicable (cl. 7.6.1.1), and that end tie plates are provided (cl. 7.6.8).
Answer. (KL/r)_e = 84.0; a1/r1 = 24.0 ≤ 50 — OK
Problem. A laced column carries a factored axial force P = 1 600 kN. Two parallel planes of single flat lacings are used, inclined at θ = 45° to the member axis. Bolted end connections use M20 bolts. The effective length of each lacing bar between inner end fasteners is L_eff = 450 mm (given). Check and size a flat lacing: width, thickness, KL/r, and compressive capacity. Take E250, γm0 = 1.10, E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm², and buckling class c (α = 0.49) about the weak axis of the flat as given for this check.
- Notional shear: Vt = 0.025 × 1 600 = 40.0 kN. With N = 2 planes, shear per plane = 20.0 kN.
- Force in one bar: F = 20.0 / sin 45° = 20.0 / 0.7071 = 28.28 kN.
- Min width (cl. 7.6.2): b ≥ 3 × 20 = 60 mm. Adopt b = 60 mm.
- Min thickness for single lacing (cl. 7.6.3): t ≥ L_eff/40 = 450/40 = 11.25 mm. Adopt t = 12 mm.
- Inclination 45° lies in 40°–70° (cl. 7.6.4). Area Ag = 60 × 12 = 720 mm².
- Weak-axis r_min = t/√12 = 12/√12 = 3.464 mm. For bolted single lacing, KL = L_eff = 450 mm, so KL/r = 450/3.464 = 129.9 ≤ 145 (cl. 7.6.6.3) — OK.
- λ = (129.9)/π × √(250/2.0×10⁵) = 1.4619; φ = 0.5[1 + 0.49(1.4619 − 0.2) + 1.4619²] = 1.8778; χ = 0.3272; fcd = 0.3272 × 250/1.10 = 74.36 N/mm².
- Pd = 720 × 74.36 / 1 000 = 53.54 kN ≥ 28.28 kN — OK. Provide end fasteners that can transmit 28.28 kN, and end tie plates per cl. 7.6.8 / 7.7.
Answer. 60 × 12 flat OK; KL/r = 129.9 ≤ 145; Pd = 53.54 kN ≥ 28.28 kN
Problem. A battened column of two identical main components carries P = 1 600 kN. The centre-to-centre distance of the components is C = 400 mm (given). There are N = 2 parallel planes of battens spaced S = 600 mm centre-to-centre of end fastenings. Each main member is 100 mm wide in the plane of the battens. The distance between the innermost bolt lines, measured perpendicular to the main member, is C′ = 350 mm (given). Find Vt, Vb and M, and check the end-batten depth and thickness rules of cl. 7.7.2.3. Also state the design effective slenderness factor.
- Vt = 0.025 × 1 600 = 40.0 kN (cl. 7.7.2.1).
- Vb = Vt·C/(N·S) = 40.0 × 400 / (2 × 600) = 13.33 kN.
- M = Vt·C/(2N) = 40.0 × 400 / (2 × 2) = 4 000 kN·mm = 4.00 kNm at each connection.
- End (and stay-point) batten effective depth ≥ C = 400 mm. Intermediate battens ≥ (3/4)×400 = 300 mm. Also depth ≥ 2 × 100 = 200 mm, so the centroid-distance rule governs for the end batten.
- Thickness t ≥ C′/50 = 350/50 = 7.0 mm; adopt t = 8 mm.
- Design effective slenderness (cl. 7.7.1.4): (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0. Spacing must also keep a1/r1 ≤ 50 and ≤ 0.7 × overall about z–z (cl. 7.7.3). Provide at least three bays.
Answer. Vb = 13.33 kN; M = 4.00 kNm; end depth ≥ 400 mm; t ≥ 7 mm (use 8 mm)
Step-by-step procedure
- Decide laced or battened (or a combination only when forces are calculated). Space the main components so that, where practicable, ry_perp ≥ ry_parallel.
- Compute the actual overall (KL/r)_0 about both axes; form (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0 (laced) or 1.10 × (KL/r)_0 (battened); design the member for flexural buckling with that amplified slenderness (lesson 4.1).
- Set connection spacing so that a1/r1 ≤ min(50, 0.7 × overall KL/r). For battens also keep ≥3 bays and check the z–z rule of cl. 7.7.3.
- Take Vt = max(0.025 P, calculated shear). For lacings: pick θ in 40°–70°, size flats for b ≥ 3d and t ≥ L_eff/40 (or /60), check KL/r ≤ 145 and bar strength. For battens: compute Vb and M, then depth and t from cl. 7.7.2.3.
- Detail end tie plates (laced) or end battens (battened) to the same forces; check welds/bolts for the bar or batten forces; attach per cl. 7.6.7 or cl. 7.7.4.
Site notes
- Shop drawings should state whether the column is laced or battened, the assumed (KL/r)_e factor (1.05 or 1.10), and the bracing that delivers the overall K.
- Single lacings on opposite faces should slope the same way; opposing slopes make the two planes deform differently under shear.
- Missing an end tie plate is a common fabrication miss — the lacing system must be closed at both ends and at any interruption.
- Batten bolts in single shear often govern before the plate thickness; check the fasteners for Vb and M, not only t ≥ C′/50.
- On site, do not replace specified lacings with battens (or the reverse) without a redesign — the shear-deformation factor and the force paths both change.
- Using (KL/r)_0 in the buckling curves without the 1.05 (laced) or 1.10 (battened) shear-deformation factor.
- Checking a1/r1 against 50 only and forgetting the 0.7 × overall-slenderness cap (or the other way round).
- Sizing lacings for axial force P instead of for Vt = 2.5% P (or the larger calculated shear).
- Using θ outside 40°–70°, or a flat thinner than L_eff/40 for single lacings.
- Taking KL/r of a lacing above 145, or using the wrong effective length (full length vs 0.7 L for double/welded cases).
- For battens: computing Vb with S as clear gap instead of centre-to-centre of end fastenings, or omitting the end-depth ≥ C rule.
- Providing fewer than three bays in a battened member, or omitting end tie plates on a laced member.
Quick laced check: (KL/r)_e ≈ 1.05 × (KL/r)_0, and a1 ≤ 50 r1. Quick shear: Vt = P/40. At 45° with two planes, each bar takes about 0.707 × (Vt/2) ≈ 0.0088 P. Quick batten check: (KL/r)_e ≈ 1.10 × (KL/r)_0; Vb ≈ Vt·C/(N·S); end depth ≈ C; t ≈ C′/50.
Summary
- Built-up columns use lacings or battens so separate chords act as one member and share shear.
- Laced: (KL/r)_e = 1.05 × (KL/r)_0; flat width ≥ 3d; t ≥ L_eff/40 (single) or /60 (double); θ in 40°–70°; a1/r1 and KL/r ≤ 145 rules apply.
- Battened: (KL/r)_e = 1.10 × (KL/r)_0; Vb = Vt·C/(N·S); M = Vt·C/(2N); depth and t from cl. 7.7.2.3; ≥3 bays.
- Both systems take Vt ≥ 2.5% of axial force (or the larger calculated shear), shared among parallel planes.
- EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 have related built-up rules — named here, not ranked.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A laced column has (KL/r)_0 = 100. What (KL/r)_e does cl. 7.6.1.5 require?
(KL/r)_e = 1.05 × 100 = 105.
2A battened column has (KL/r)_0 = 90. What (KL/r)_e does cl. 7.7.1.4 require?
(KL/r)_e = 1.10 × 90 = 99.
3P = 2 000 kN. What notional Vt does IS 800 require for lacings or battens?
Vt = 0.025 × 2 000 = 50 kN.
4a1 = 450 mm, r1 = 20 mm, overall (KL/r)_0 = 70. Does a1/r1 satisfy cl. 7.6.5?
a1/r1 = 22.5; limits min(50, 0.7×70 = 49) = 49; 22.5 ≤ 49 — OK.
5A double flat lacing has L_eff = 600 mm. What minimum thickness does cl. 7.6.3 require?
t ≥ 600/60 = 10 mm.
6Vt = 50 kN, C = 450 mm, N = 2, S = 750 mm. Find Vb and M.
Vb = 50×450/(2×750) = 15.0 kN; M = 50×450/(2×2) = 5 625 kN·mm = 5.625 kNm.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
- S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.