Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Steel Design › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.3

2.3 Eccentric connections

Steel Design Chapter 2: Connections Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain why a load that does not pass through the centroid of a bolt or weld group produces a moment, and how IS 800:2007 cl. 10.11 splits the effect into a direct share and a moment share.
  • Find the force on the most loaded bolt of a group loaded in its own plane (bolts in shear only) and of a group loaded out of its plane (bolts in shear and tension), and check it by cl. 10.3.
  • Find the size of a fillet weld group carrying an eccentric load out of its plane, using the equivalent stress check of cl. 10.5.10.1.1.

Theory

In lessons 2.1 and 2.2 the force passed through the centroid of the bolts or welds, so every bolt or every millimetre of weld took an equal share. Many real joints are not like that. A crane bracket on a column, a beam seat, a gusset that receives a member whose line of action misses the bolt group: in each case the load acts at a distance e, the eccentricity, from the centroid of the fasteners. Moving a force P to the centroid adds a couple P e, so the group must resist a direct force and a moment at the same time. IS 800:2007 cl. 10.8 asks that, where there is eccentricity at a joint, the members and components be designed for the moments that result.

There are two kinds of eccentric joint. If the load lies in the plane of the fasteners, as with a bracket plate bolted to the face of a column flange and loaded vertically in the plane of that plate, the moment twists the group in its own plane and every bolt is in shear. If the load lies in a plane at right angles to the fasteners, as with a bracket or a seat standing out from the flange, the moment tries to pull the top of the connection away from the column: the upper bolts go into tension, the lower part of the plate presses on the column, and all bolts still carry the vertical shear. Cl. 10.11.1, 10.11.2 and 10.11.3 deal with in-plane, out-of-plane and combined loading of bolt and weld groups.

Eccentric bolt group: direct and moment sharesrPeP/n: direct sharePe r/Σr²: momentshare, at rightangles to rbolt group (not to scale)
Figure 2.3: Eccentric bolt group: the load P at eccentricity e gives each bolt a direct share P/n and a moment share P e r/Σr² at right angles to the radius r; the farthest bolts govern. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For in-plane loading cl. 10.11.1.1 treats the connected plates as rigid, rotating relative to each other about an instantaneous centre. Under a pure couple that centre is the group centroid; under a force through the centroid it is at infinity and the force is shared equally. In other cases the code allows the two results to be superposed. Each bolt force is taken at right angles to the radius from the centre of rotation and proportional to that radius, so the corner bolts, farthest from the centroid, are the critical ones. The force in the most stressed bolt, or the highest force per unit length of weld, must then satisfy cl. 10.3, 10.4 or 10.5 as appropriate.

For out-of-plane loading cl. 10.11.2.1 shares the shear force equally between the bolts (or uniformly along the welds), and lets the force due to the moment vary linearly with distance from the neutral axis. In a bearing-type bolt group the plate on the compression side of the neutral axis and only the bolts on the tension side are counted when the neutral axis and the second moment of area are found; in a friction grip group only the bolts are counted; a fillet weld group is taken on its own, apart from the connected parts. Cl. 10.11.2.2 also allows the group to be treated as an extension of the connected member and the forces distributed by equilibrium. Bolts that carry shear and tension together are checked by the interaction rule of cl. 10.3.6, and where the connected plate or angle leg bends, cl. 10.4.7 asks for the prying force Q to be found and added to the bolt tension.

Superposition with an elastic, rigid-plate model is a safe and simple route. Tests show that bolt groups can carry somewhat more than the elastic analysis predicts, because the most loaded bolts yield and pass load to others; the instantaneous-centre method, which uses the measured load-deformation curve of a bolt, captures this and is the recognised method the clause also permits. For ordinary design the elastic method is used, and it is what is shown here.

Derivation

  1. In-plane moment share: let the group rotate through a small angle θ about its centroid. A bolt at radius r moves r θ, so its force is k r θ, at right angles to r. The moment of all bolt forces about the centroid is Σ k θ r² and equals P e. So k θ = P e/Σr², and the bolt force is Fm = P e r/Σr², largest at r max.
  2. Components: with the centroid at the origin and the bolt at (x, y), the moment share has a horizontal component P e y/Σr² and a vertical component P e x/Σr², where Σr² = Σx² + Σy². For a vertical load the direct share P/n is vertical, so the resultant is R = √[(P e y/Σr²)² + (P/n + P e x/Σr²)²] at the bolt where both shares add.
  3. Out-of-plane neutral axis: the bracket plate of width b bears on the column below the neutral axis at depth h from the bottom; the bolts above it, of area A each, stretch in proportion to their distance from it. Equal first moments of the compression block and the bolt areas give b h²/2 = Σ A (yi − h) for the bolts with yi > h; this quadratic gives h.
  4. Second moment of area about that axis: I = b h³/3 + Σ A (yi − h)². The stress in a bolt is M (yi − h)/I and its tension Tb = A M (yi − h)/I. Taking the neutral axis at the bottom bolt instead ignores the compression block and gives a larger, safe-side tension.
  5. Weld group out of its plane: two vertical fillet welds of effective length l and throat tt act like two thin rectangles. Their section modulus about the horizontal axis is 2 tt l²/6, so the normal stress is fa = M/(2 tt l²/6) = 3 M/(tt l²); the shear stress is q = P/(2 tt l). The throat sees both, so fe = √(fa² + 3 q²) is limited to fu/(√3 γmw).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Direct share (IS 800:2007 cl. 10.11.1.1): Fd = P/n (kN); moment share Fm = P e r/Σr² (kN), with Σr² = Σx² + Σy² (mm²) and e in mm
  • Resultant on the critical bolt: R = √[(P e y/Σr²)² + (P/n + P e x/Σr²)²] ≤ Vdb (cl. 10.3.2)
  • Out-of-plane (cl. 10.11.2.1): shear per bolt Vsb = P/n; neutral axis from b h²/2 = Σ A (yi − h); I = b h³/3 + Σ A (yi − h)²; tension Tb = A M (yi − h)/I
  • Shear with tension (cl. 10.3.6): (Vsb/Vdb)² + (Tb/Tdb)² ≤ 1.0; add the prying force Q where cl. 10.4.7 applies
  • Bolt values from lesson 2.1: M20 class 4.6, threads in the shear plane, Vdsb = 45.26 kN and Tdb = 68.5 kN; M20 class 8.8: Vdsb = 90.53 kN and Tdb = 141.1 kN (Anb = 245 mm², γmb = 1.25)
  • Weld group out of its plane: fa = M/(2 tt l²/6), q = P/(2 tt l), fe = √(fa² + 3 q²) ≤ fu/(√3 γmw) (cl. 10.5.10.1.1) (N/mm²)
Assumptions and limits
  • The connected plates are rigid and the bolts or welds behave elastically, so forces are proportional to distance from the centre of rotation (cl. 10.11.1.1).
  • All bolts in a group are of the same size and class and are in standard holes; bolt values come from cl. 10.3 with the reductions of lesson 2.1 where needed.
  • For out-of-plane loading the compression is carried by contact of the plate on the column; the bolts on the compression side carry shear only.
  • The column flange and the bracket are stiff enough not to bend between bolts; where they do bend, prying forces are added (cl. 10.4.7).
  • Static loading; under fatigue the eccentricities of cl. 10.8 that may otherwise be neglected must be considered.
  • The elastic method is a safe lower estimate; the instantaneous-centre method with bolt load-deformation curves gives higher capacities and is not used here.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 10.8 (members meeting at a joint arranged with centroidal axes meeting at a point where practicable; otherwise design for the moments due to eccentricity), cl. 10.10 (connection components such as cleats, gussets and brackets assessed by Sections 5 to 9), cl. 10.11.1.1 (in-plane loading: rigid plates, instantaneous centre, superposition, force at right angles to and proportional to the radius), cl. 10.11.2.1 and 10.11.2.2 (out-of-plane loading: shear shared equally, moment share linear with distance from the neutral axis, rules for which parts count; alternative equilibrium method), cl. 10.11.3.1 and 10.11.3.2 (combined in-plane and out-of-plane loading).
  • IS 800:2007 cl. 10.3.2 to 10.3.6 (bolt shear, bearing and tension values and the shear-tension interaction), cl. 10.4.7 (prying force added to the bolt tension), cl. 10.5.7.1.1 (fillet weld strength), cl. 10.5.9 (weld stress from a single force) and cl. 10.5.10.1.1 (equivalent stress in fillet welds under normal and shear stress), Table 5 (γmb = 1.25, γmw = 1.25 shop).
  • EN 1993-1-8 distributes forces in bolt and weld groups under in-plane moment in proportion to distance from the centre of rotation and gives the resistance of bolts in combined shear and tension, with its own rules for prying through the T-stub model. AISC 360 Chapter J, with the AISC Steel Construction Manual, uses either the elastic method or the instantaneous-centre-of-rotation method for eccentrically loaded bolt and weld groups. The approaches are listed side by side, not ranked; their factor values are not quoted here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (bracket bolted in its own plane, site style)

Problem. A bracket plate 12 mm thick (fu = 410 N/mm²) is bolted to a column flange by six M20 bolts in two vertical lines of three: gauge 100 mm (x = ±50 mm), pitch 80 mm (y = 0, ±80 mm), end distance 40 mm. It carries a factored vertical load of 150 kN at 200 mm from the centroid of the bolts. Threads lie in the single shear plane (Anb = 245 mm²). Find the force on the most loaded bolt and choose the bolt class.

  1. Moment about the centroid: M = P e = 150 × 200 = 30 000 kN mm.
  2. Σr² = Σx² + Σy² = 6 × 50² + 4 × 80² = 15 000 + 25 600 = 40 600 mm².
  3. Corner bolt (x = 50 mm, y = 80 mm, on the side towards the load): r = √(50² + 80²) = 94.34 mm, moment share 30 000 × 94.34/40 600 = 69.71 kN; horizontal 30 000 × 80/40 600 = 59.11 kN, vertical 30 000 × 50/40 600 = 36.95 kN.
  4. Direct share 150/6 = 25.0 kN, vertical. Resultant R = √(59.11² + (25.0 + 36.95)²) = 85.63 kN.
  5. An M20 class 4.6 bolt (Vdsb = 45.26 kN) is not enough. An M20 class 8.8 bolt: Vdsb = (800/√3) × 245/1.25 = 90.53 kN. Bearing on the 12 mm plate with kb = 40/66 = 0.606: 2.5 × 0.606 × 20 × 12 × 410/1.25 = 119.3 kN. Bolt value 90.53 kN ≥ 85.63 kN.

Answer. Most loaded bolt 85.63 kN; M20 class 8.8 bolts (90.53 kN each) are adequate, class 4.6 is not

Example 2 (bracket loaded out of its plane, exam style)

Problem. A bracket made from a plate 200 mm wide stands out from a column flange and is bolted to it by eight M20 bolts in two vertical lines of four, the rows at 40, 120, 200 and 280 mm above the bottom edge of the bracket. A factored vertical load of 250 kN acts 200 mm from the column face. Bearing-type bolts, threads in the shear plane, Anb = 245 mm² (two bolts per row: 490 mm²). Find the tension in the top bolts and check M20 class 4.6 and class 8.8 bolts.

  1. Shear per bolt Vsb = 250/8 = 31.25 kN. Moment M = 250 × 200 = 50 000 kN mm = 50 × 10⁶ N mm.
  2. Neutral axis: trying h < 40 mm gives h = 47.1 mm, above the bottom row, so the bottom row is in the compression zone and is left out. With the top three rows: 200 h²/2 = 490 [(120 − h) + (200 − h) + (280 − h)], that is 100 h² + 1 470 h − 294 000 = 0, so h = 47.37 mm.
  3. I = 200 × 47.37³/3 + 490 (72.63² + 152.63² + 232.63²) = 7.085 × 10⁶ + 40.52 × 10⁶ = 47.60 × 10⁶ mm⁴.
  4. Stress in the top bolts: 50 × 10⁶ × 232.63/47.60 × 10⁶ = 244.3 N/mm²; tension Tb = 244.3 × 245 = 59.86 kN.
  5. Class 4.6 (Vdb = 45.26 kN, Tdb = 68.5 kN): (31.25/45.26)² + (59.86/68.5)² = 0.477 + 0.763 = 1.24 > 1.0, fails.
  6. Class 8.8 (Vdb = 90.53 kN; Tdb = 0.90 × 800 × 245/1.25 = 141.1 kN, below the fyb Asb limit 640 × 314.2 × 1.25/1.10 = 228.5 kN): (31.25/90.53)² + (59.86/141.1)² = 0.119 + 0.180 = 0.30 ≤ 1.0, safe before any prying force (cl. 10.4.7). Taking the neutral axis at the bottom bolt instead gives a safe-side tension of 66.96 kN.

Answer. Top bolt tension 59.86 kN with 31.25 kN shear; class 4.6 fails (1.24), class 8.8 passes (0.30)

Example 3 (welded bracket loaded out of its plane, site style)

Problem. A bracket plate is welded to a column flange by two vertical shop fillet welds, one on each side of the plate, each 300 mm effective length. It carries a factored load of 200 kN at 120 mm from the weld plane. fu = 410 N/mm². Find the fillet size.

  1. M = 200 × 120 = 24 000 kN mm = 24 × 10⁶ N mm. fwd = 410/(√3 × 1.25) = 189.4 N/mm².
  2. Per millimetre of throat: fa = 24 × 10⁶/(2 × 300²/6) = 800/tt and q = 200 000/(2 × 300) = 333.3/tt (N/mm² with tt in mm).
  3. fe = √(800² + 3 × 333.3²)/tt = 986.6/tt ≤ 189.4, so tt ≥ 5.21 mm and s ≥ 5.21/0.7 = 7.44 mm.
  4. Provide 8 mm fillets (tt = 5.6 mm): fa = 142.9 N/mm², q = 59.5 N/mm², fe = √(142.9² + 3 × 59.5²) = 176.2 N/mm² ≤ 189.4 N/mm².
  5. Check the size limits of lesson 2.2 (Table 21 minimum for the thicker part, square-edge maximum) and add 2 s to each run for the length to be made.

Answer. 8 mm shop fillets each side, fe = 176.2 N/mm² ≤ 189.4 N/mm²

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the line of action of the load and the centroid of the bolt or weld group; the eccentricity e is the distance between them.
  2. Decide whether the moment P e acts in the plane of the group (bolts in shear only) or out of it (shear plus tension).
  3. In-plane: compute P/n and P e r/Σr² for the bolt where both add, combine as vectors, and compare with the bolt value of cl. 10.3.2.
  4. Out-of-plane: share the shear equally, locate the neutral axis (bearing type: plate in compression, bolts in tension), compute I and the tension in the top bolts, and apply the interaction rule of cl. 10.3.6, adding prying where cl. 10.4.7 applies.
  5. For welds, compute the stresses per unit throat, apply fe = √(fa² + 3 q²) and choose the size; check the detailing rules of cl. 10.5.
  6. Check the bracket plate itself for shear, bending and buckling as a connection component (cl. 10.10).

Site notes

  • Brackets for crane girders and pipe racks are often fixed late; the drawing must give the load position, because moving a load 50 mm further out can add more to the corner bolt than doubling the direct load would.
  • Bolts in tension are tightened so that the plates are in firm contact; a gap under the compression zone moves the neutral axis and raises bolt tensions.
  • Where a bracket plate is thin, it bends between bolts and prying adds to the bolt tension; a thicker plate or a stiffener is usually cheaper than larger bolts.
  • Weld runs on brackets are made full length and returned round the ends; a short weld at the top, where the bending stress is highest, is the usual defect found at inspection.
Common mistakes
  • Leaving out the moment P e and designing the bolts for P/n only.
  • Adding the direct and moment shares as numbers instead of as vectors, or choosing a corner bolt on the wrong side of the group.
  • Using Σr² = Σx² only (or Σy² only) for a group with more than one line of bolts.
  • In out-of-plane joints, counting the bolts in the compression zone when finding the neutral axis of a bearing-type group.
  • Forgetting the interaction rule: a bolt that is safe in shear and safe in tension separately may fail when both act.
  • Ignoring prying in thin end plates and angle legs.
Quick check

For a single vertical line of n bolts at pitch p under a vertical load with eccentricity e, the moment share on the end bolt is exactly 6 e/(n (n + 1) p) times P (from Σy² = p² n (n² − 1)/12); in Example 1 the critical bolt force is about 0.57 P (85.63/150). If the critical bolt force comes out below P/n, a sign or a vector addition has gone wrong.

Summary

  • An eccentric load P at distance e from the centroid is a direct force P plus a moment P e (cl. 10.8).
  • In-plane: P/n plus P e r/Σr² at right angles to r, added as vectors; the farthest bolts govern (cl. 10.11.1.1).
  • Out-of-plane: shear shared equally, tension from M (yi − h)/I about the neutral axis found with the compression plate and the tension bolts only (cl. 10.11.2.1).
  • Bolts in shear and tension satisfy (Vsb/Vdb)² + (Tb/Tdb)² ≤ 1.0 (cl. 10.3.6), with prying added where it occurs (cl. 10.4.7).
  • Weld groups out of plane: fe = √(fa² + 3 q²) ≤ fu/(√3 γmw) (cl. 10.5.10.1.1).

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Four bolts are at the corners of a 100 mm × 100 mm square. Find Σr² and the moment share on each bolt for P e = 10 000 kN mm.

r = 70.71 mm; Σr² = 4 × 5 000 = 20 000 mm²; Fm = 10 000 × 70.71/20 000 = 35.36 kN.

2In the same square group the load is 40 kN vertical. If the moment share at a bolt is at 45° to the vertical and adds to the direct share, find the resultant.

Direct share 10 kN; components 35.36 cos 45° = 25.0 kN each way; R = √(25.0² + (10 + 25.0)²) = 43.01 kN.

3A vertical line of five bolts at 75 mm pitch carries a vertical load of 60 kN at 250 mm from the line. Find the force on the end bolt.

Σy² = 2 (75² + 150²) = 56 250 mm²; moment share 60 × 250 × 150/56 250 = 40.0 kN horizontal; direct 12 kN; R = √(40.0² + 12²) = 41.76 kN.

4A bolt carries 40 kN shear and 50 kN tension. Is an M20 class 8.8 bolt (Vdb = 90.53 kN, Tdb = 141.1 kN) safe?

(40/90.53)² + (50/141.1)² = 0.195 + 0.126 = 0.32 ≤ 1.0: safe.

5Two vertical shop fillet welds, each 250 mm effective, carry a bracket load of 100 kN at 100 mm. Find fe for 6 mm welds (fu = 410 N/mm²).

tt = 4.2 mm; fa = 10 × 10⁶/(2 × 4.2 × 250²/6) = 114.3 N/mm²; q = 100 000/(2 × 4.2 × 250) = 47.6 N/mm²; fe = 140.9 N/mm² ≤ 189.4 N/mm².

6Why are only the bolts on the tension side counted when finding the neutral axis of a bearing-type group loaded out of its plane?

Below the neutral axis the plate presses on the column and carries the compression by contact; bolts there are not stretched, so they add nothing to the tension side (cl. 10.11.2.1).

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • N. Subramanian, Design of Steel Structures, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1st edition, 2008.
  • S. K. Duggal, Limit State Design of Steel Structures, McGraw Hill Education (India), 3rd edition, 2019.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.