3.2 Section modulus and beam selection
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Define the elastic section modulus Z = I/y_max and use σ = M/Z to find the moment a section can carry at a given stress.
- Derive Z for rectangular, circular, hollow and I-sections, and the plastic modulus Z_p and shape factor for a rectangle and an I-section.
- Select a beam section from a required section modulus, and explain how IS 800:2007 uses the elastic and plastic moduli for laterally supported steel beams.
Theory
Lesson 3.1 showed that the largest bending stress in a section is σ = M y_max/I. The two section quantities in that expression can be combined into one, the elastic section modulus Z = I/y_max, so that σ_max = M/Z. Z depends only on the shape and size of the section, and it measures bending strength directly: at a given permissible stress, the moment a section can carry is proportional to Z. Choosing a beam therefore comes down to finding a section with enough Z.
For a rectangle Z = b d²/6, so doubling the depth gives four times the bending strength while doubling the width only doubles it. A plank with sides in the ratio 2:1 is therefore twice as strong on edge as laid flat, for the same area of timber. Shapes that place area far from the neutral axis, such as I-sections and box sections, give much more Z for the same weight than a solid rectangle or a round bar. That is why rolled steel beams have thick flanges joined by a thin web: the flanges carry most of the moment and the web holds them apart and carries the shear.
When a section is not symmetric about its neutral axis, as with a T- or channel section bent about its horizontal axis, the distances to the top and bottom fibres differ, so there are two moduli, Z_top = I/y_top and Z_bottom = I/y_bottom. The smaller one controls if the same stress limit applies on both sides. Materials with different limits in tension and compression, such as cast iron or plain concrete, are often used in T-shapes for this reason, with the larger area on the weaker side.
Steel is ductile, so a laterally supported steel beam does not fail when its outer fibres first yield. Yielding spreads inward until the whole section is at the yield stress, half in tension and half in compression, and the moment reaches the plastic moment M_p = Z_p f_y. Z_p, the plastic section modulus, is the sum of the first moments of the two half-areas about the axis that divides the section into equal areas. The ratio Z_p/Z, the shape factor, is 1.5 for a rectangle and only about 1.1 to 1.15 for rolled I-sections, because their flanges already work near yield in the elastic state. Steel codes use Z_p for sections whose plates are stocky enough to reach the plastic moment, and Z for sections that would buckle locally first.
Derivation
- Elastic modulus: from σ = M y/I, the largest stress is at y_max, so σ_max = M/Z with Z = I/y_max.
- Rectangle b × d: Z = (b d³/12)/(d/2) = b d²/6.
- Solid circle of diameter d: Z = (π d⁴/64)/(d/2) = π d³/32.
- Hollow circle, outer D and inner d: Z = π(D⁴ − d⁴)/(32 D).
- Symmetric I-section, flanges B × t_f, web t_w, overall depth D: I = [B D³ − (B − t_w)(D − 2t_f)³]/12 and Z = 2I/D (outer rectangle minus the two side voids).
- Plastic modulus of a rectangle: each half (area b d/2) has its centroid at d/4 from the axis, so Z_p = 2 × (b d/2)(d/4) = b d²/4, and the shape factor Z_p/Z = (b d²/4)/(b d²/6) = 1.5.
- Plastic modulus of a symmetric I-section: Z_p = 2[B t_f (D − t_f)/2] + 2[t_w h_w/2 × h_w/4], with h_w = D − 2t_f, that is the flange areas times their lever arm plus the web halves times theirs.
- Design: the required elastic modulus for a moment M and a limiting stress σ is Z_req = M/σ; with the IS 800:2007 approach for a laterally supported beam, Z_p,req = M_u γ_m0/f_y when the section is plastic or compact.
Z = I/y_max (elastic section modulus, mm³)σ_max = M/Z (N/mm²)Rectangle: Z = b d²/6; Z_p = b d²/4; shape factor 1.5Solid circle: Z = π d³/32Hollow circle: Z = π(D⁴ − d⁴)/(32 D)Unsymmetric section: Z_top = I/y_top, Z_bottom = I/y_bottomPlastic moment: M_p = Z_p f_y (N·mm)Required modulus: Z_req = M/σ_allow; IS 800 laterally supported beam: M_d = β_b Z_p f_y/γ_m0 with β_b = 1.0 (plastic, compact) or Z_e/Z_p (semi-compact)Units: Z in mm³ (1 cm³ = 10³ mm³), M in N·mm, f_y in N/mm²
- The elastic modulus assumes linear elastic behaviour (lesson 3.1 assumptions) up to the extreme fibre stress.
- The plastic modulus assumes an elastic-perfectly plastic material that can sustain yield over the whole depth, which needs a ductile material and plates stocky enough not to buckle locally.
- The compression flange is restrained against lateral-torsional buckling; an unrestrained beam carries less, and that check is part of steel design.
- Bending is about a principal axis of a section with an axis of symmetry in the plane of loading.
- Shear is low enough not to reduce the bending capacity; heavy shear needs a combined check.
- Section modulus selects for strength only: deflection, shear, bearing and vibration must be checked separately and can govern long or lightly loaded beams.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.1.2: for a laterally supported beam with low shear (factored shear not above 0.6 V_d), the design bending strength is M_d = β_b Z_p f_y/γ_m0, with β_b = 1.0 for plastic and compact sections and β_b = Z_e/Z_p for semi-compact sections, so a semi-compact section is limited to Z_e f_y/γ_m0. The same clause limits M_d to 1.2 Z_e f_y/γ_m0 for simply supported beams, so that the beam does not yield under service loads.
- IS 800:2007 uses the partial safety factor γ_m0 = 1.10 for resistance governed by yielding, and classifies sections as plastic, compact, semi-compact or slender from the width-to-thickness ratios of their plates before β_b is chosen.
- Rolled I-section properties (Z_e and Z_p for ISMB and other series) are taken from steel tables based on IS 808. Values used in this lesson: ISMB 250, Z_e = 410.5 cm³ and Z_p about 465 cm³; ISMB 300, Z_e = 573.6 cm³.
- Side by side, not ranked: EN 1993-1-1 uses W_pl f_y/γ_M0 for Class 1 and 2 sections and W_el f_y/γ_M0 for Class 3; AISC 360 uses the plastic moment F_y Z_x with a resistance factor φ for compact laterally braced members. The ideas are the same; the symbols, factors and class limits differ.
Worked examples
Problem. Three timber sections each have an area of 20 000 mm²: (a) 100 mm wide × 200 mm deep, (b) the same plank laid flat, 200 mm wide × 100 mm deep, (c) a square of side 141.4 mm. Compare their elastic section moduli and hence their bending strengths at the same permissible stress.
- (a) Z = 100 × 200²/6 = 6.667 × 10⁵ mm³.
- (b) Z = 200 × 100²/6 = 3.333 × 10⁵ mm³.
- (c) Z = 141.4³/6 = 4.714 × 10⁵ mm³.
- At the same stress, moment capacity is in proportion to Z: 2.00 : 1.00 : 1.41 for (a) : (b) : (c).
Answer. On edge, the plank is twice as strong as laid flat and 1.41 times as strong as the square of the same area
Problem. A welded I-section has two flanges 200 mm × 20 mm and a web 360 mm × 10 mm, overall depth 400 mm. Find I, Z, the moment it can carry if the bending stress is limited to 150 N/mm², its plastic modulus and shape factor, and compare Z with a solid rectangle of the same area and depth.
- I = [200 × 400³ − 190 × 360³]/12 = (1.28 × 10¹⁰ − 8.865 × 10⁹)/12 = 3.279 × 10⁸ mm⁴.
- Z = I/200 = 1.640 × 10⁶ mm³.
- M = σ Z = 150 × 1.640 × 10⁶ = 2.460 × 10⁸ N·mm = 246.0 kN·m.
- Z_p = 2 × (200 × 20 × 190) + 2 × (10 × 180 × 90) = 1.520 × 10⁶ + 0.324 × 10⁶ = 1.844 × 10⁶ mm³; shape factor = 1.844/1.640 = 1.12.
- Area = 2 × 4000 + 3600 = 11 600 mm²; a rectangle 29 mm × 400 mm has the same area and Z = 29 × 400²/6 = 7.733 × 10⁵ mm³, so the I-section has 2.12 times the bending strength for the same steel.
Answer. I = 3.279 × 10⁸ mm⁴, Z = 1.640 × 10⁶ mm³, M = 246.0 kN·m; Z_p = 1.844 × 10⁶ mm³, shape factor 1.12; 2.12 times a rectangle of the same area
Problem. A laterally restrained, simply supported steel floor beam spans 5 m and carries a factored uniform load of 30 kN/m including its own weight. The steel has f_y = 250 N/mm²; take γ_m0 = 1.10. Choose between ISMB 250 and ISMB 300 for bending, first with the elastic modulus only and then with the IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.1.2 approach for a plastic or compact section (shear assumed low).
- M_u = wL²/8 = 30 × 5²/8 = 93.75 kN·m.
- Elastic check: Z_e,req = M_u γ_m0/f_y = 93.75 × 10⁶ × 1.10/250 = 4.125 × 10⁵ mm³ = 412.5 cm³. ISMB 250 has Z_e = 410.5 cm³ (just short; M = 410.5 × 10³ × 250/1.10 = 93.30 kN·m); ISMB 300 has 573.6 cm³ (130.4 kN·m), so the elastic route picks ISMB 300.
- Plastic route: if ISMB 250 classifies as plastic or compact, M_d = Z_p f_y/γ_m0 = 465 × 10³ × 250/1.10 = 105.7 kN·m.
- Upper limit 1.2 Z_e f_y/γ_m0 = 1.2 × 410.5 × 10³ × 250/1.10 = 112.0 kN·m, which does not govern, so M_d = 105.7 kN·m ≥ 93.75 kN·m.
- ISMB 250 is adequate in bending on the plastic route; shear, deflection and the section classification itself must still be checked before it is adopted.
Answer. Elastic route: ISMB 300 (ISMB 250 short by 0.5 %); plastic route under IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.1.2: ISMB 250 with M_d = 105.7 kN·m ≥ 93.75 kN·m
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the design bending moment from the bending moment diagram, using factored loads for limit state design.
- Choose the design basis: elastic (Z with a permissible or design stress) or plastic (Z_p with the yield stress and partial factor, only for plastic or compact steel sections with lateral restraint).
- Compute the required modulus: Z_req = M/σ or Z_p,req = M_u γ_m0/f_y.
- Pick the lightest section from the table whose modulus is at least the required value; for unsymmetric sections use the smaller of Z_top and Z_bottom, or check each face against its own limit.
- Confirm section class, then check shear, deflection, bearing and lateral-torsional buckling.
- Add self-weight if it was estimated, and repeat the check if it changes the moment.
Site notes
- When a site substitutes one rolled section for another because of stock, compare Z (and I for deflection), not just depth or weight per metre; sections of the same depth from different series have different moduli.
- A beam turned on its side during erection, or a timber joist laid flat, loses most of its bending strength; check that sections are placed with the strong axis vertical as drawn.
- Holes cut in flanges for services reduce Z sharply; holes in the web near the neutral axis at mid-depth, away from supports, cost much less, and still need approval.
- Deflection often governs long, lightly loaded beams; a section chosen by Z alone may sag visibly or cause cracked finishes, so check the span-to-depth and deflection limits as well.
- Using I instead of Z, or Z in cm³ with M in N·mm without converting (1 cm³ = 1000 mm³).
- Using the plastic modulus for a semi-compact or slender section, or for a beam whose compression flange is not restrained.
- Taking the larger modulus of a T- or channel section when the smaller one controls.
- Choosing the deepest section rather than the lightest adequate one, or the lightest one without checking deflection and shear.
- Forgetting to include the beam's own weight in the design moment.
Bending strength grows with the square of depth but only linearly with width: for rectangles, Z = b d²/6. For rolled I-sections bent about the major axis, Z_p is about 1.1 to 1.15 times Z_e; a much larger ratio suggests a wrong table value or axis.
Summary
- Z = I/y_max, and σ_max = M/Z; the moment a section can carry at a given stress is proportional to Z.
- Rectangle Z = b d²/6, circle π d³/32; I-sections give much more Z per kilogram.
- Unsymmetric sections have two moduli; the smaller usually controls.
- Z_p = b d²/4 for a rectangle; shape factor 1.5 for a rectangle, about 1.1 to 1.15 for I-sections.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.1.2: M_d = β_b Z_p f_y/γ_m0 with an upper limit of 1.2 Z_e f_y/γ_m0 for simply supported beams.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the elastic section modulus of a 230 mm × 450 mm rectangular section bent about its major axis, and the moment it carries at a bending stress of 8 N/mm².
Z = 230 × 450²/6 = 7.763 × 10⁶ mm³; M = 8 × 7.763 × 10⁶ = 6.21 × 10⁷ N·mm = 62.1 kN·m.
2Find the section modulus of a solid circular section of 150 mm diameter.
Z = π × 150³/32 = 3.313 × 10⁵ mm³.
3Find the section modulus of a steel tube with outer diameter 100 mm and inner diameter 80 mm.
I = π(100⁴ − 80⁴)/64 = 2.898 × 10⁶ mm⁴; Z = I/50 = 5.796 × 10⁴ mm³.
4For the T-section of lesson 3.1, Example 3 (I = 2.618 × 10⁷ mm⁴, neutral axis 64.55 mm below the top and 135.45 mm above the bottom), find Z_top and Z_bottom and say which controls if the stress limit is the same on both faces.
Z_top = 2.618 × 10⁷/64.55 = 4.057 × 10⁵ mm³; Z_bottom = 2.618 × 10⁷/135.45 = 1.933 × 10⁵ mm³. Z_bottom is smaller, so the bottom (tension) fibre controls.
5A laterally restrained steel beam of 6 m span carries a factored uniform load of 25 kN/m. With f_y = 250 N/mm² and γ_m0 = 1.10, find the required elastic modulus and say whether ISMB 250 (Z_e = 410.5 cm³) or ISMB 300 (Z_e = 573.6 cm³) satisfies it.
M_u = 25 × 36/8 = 112.5 kN·m; Z_e,req = 112.5 × 10⁶ × 1.10/250 = 4.95 × 10⁵ mm³ = 495 cm³. ISMB 300 satisfies it; ISMB 250 does not.
6Why is the shape factor of a rectangle (1.5) larger than that of an I-section (about 1.12)?
In the elastic state the rectangle has much of its area near the neutral axis working at low stress, so it gains a lot when yield spreads inward. In an I-section most of the area is in the flanges, already near the yield stress at first yield, so little reserve is left.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.