Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.2

2.2 Singly reinforced rectangular beams

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 2: Limit state of collapse: flexure Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Find the neutral-axis depth and the moment of resistance of a singly reinforced rectangular beam at the limit state of collapse.
  • Design a singly reinforced beam for a given factored moment: choose b and d from Mu,lim and find the tension steel from the quadratic of Annex G.
  • Recognise under-reinforced, balanced and over-reinforced sections, analyse an over-reinforced section by strain compatibility, and apply the minimum and maximum steel limits of IS 456.

Theory

A singly reinforced rectangular beam has tension steel only. At collapse the compression is carried by the concrete stress block, C = 0.36 fck b xu acting 0.42 xu below the top (lesson 2.1), and the tension by the steel. When the steel yields, T = 0.87 fy Ast. Equilibrium C = T fixes the neutral axis, and the moment of the couple fixes the strength: Mu = 0.87 fy Ast (d − 0.42 xu). Everything else in this lesson is a consequence of these two lines.

The neutral-axis depth grows in proportion to the steel area. With a little steel, xu is small, the lever arm is long and the steel strain at collapse is large: the beam is under-reinforced and fails in a ductile way. As steel is added, xu rises until it reaches xu,max, the deepest neutral axis at which the steel still reaches the strain 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002. That section is the limiting (balanced) section and its strength is Mu,lim. More steel than that makes the section over-reinforced: the concrete crushes before the steel yields, the failure is sudden, and the extra steel adds little strength.

Under-reinforced, balanced and over-reinforcedsteel levelzero strain axis0.0035underbalancedoverminimum steel strain 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002NA (under)xu,maxNA (over)Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 2.2: Strain diagrams at collapse, all with 0.0035 at the top: the under-reinforced section has a shallow neutral axis and a large steel strain, the limiting (balanced) section reaches exactly 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002 at xu,max, and the over-reinforced section has a deep neutral axis and a steel strain short of yield. Indiacon original, not to scale.

IS 456:2000 Annex G, G-1.1 turns this into design rules. For xu/d below the limit the moment of resistance is Mu = 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)), which is the same couple with xu written in terms of Ast. At the limit, Mu,lim = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) b d² fck. If xu/d exceeds the limit the section should be redesigned. In design the usual route is to choose b, find the least effective depth from Mu = Mu,lim, adopt a slightly larger d so the section is under-reinforced, and solve the quadratic for Ast.

Two code limits bracket the steel. The minimum tension steel of cl. 26.5.1.1 is As/(b d) = 0.85/fy, so that the beam does not fail suddenly when the concrete first cracks; the maximum is 0.04 b D, to allow proper placing and compaction of concrete around the bars. Between these limits, keeping the section under-reinforced is what gives ductility. When an existing beam is found to be over-reinforced, its strength can be estimated by strain compatibility, but for design the code's answer is redesign, not a larger moment.

Derivation

  1. Equilibrium of forces (steel yielding): 0.36 fck b xu = 0.87 fy Ast, so xu = 0.87 fy Ast/(0.36 fck b) and xu/d = 2.417 (fy/fck)(Ast/(b d)).
  2. Moment about the compression resultant: Mu = 0.87 fy Ast (d − 0.42 xu). Substituting xu: d − 0.42 xu = d (1 − 0.42 × 0.87/0.36 × Ast fy/(b d fck)) = d (1 − 1.015 Ast fy/(b d fck)), which the code rounds to Mu = 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)).
  3. Moment about the steel: Mu = 0.36 fck b xu (d − 0.42 xu); both forms give the same answer once xu satisfies equilibrium.
  4. Limiting section: at xu = xu,max, Mu,lim = 0.36 fck b xu,max (d − 0.42 xu,max) and the limiting steel ratio is pt,lim = 100 × 0.36 fck xu,max/(0.87 fy d) per cent (0.96 per cent for M20 with Fe 415).
  5. Design depth: from Mu = Mu,lim, d = √(Mu/(Q b)), with Q = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) fck. Steel for a chosen d > dmin: the quadratic (0.87 fy²/(b d fck)) Ast² − 0.87 fy d Ast + Mu = 0, taking the smaller root.
  6. Over-reinforced section (xu > xu,max): the steel strain 0.0035 (d − xu)/xu is below the yield strain, so the steel stress fs comes from its design curve and xu is found from 0.36 fck b xu = Ast fs(εs) by trial or iteration; then Mu = 0.36 fck b xu (d − 0.42 xu).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Neutral axis (steel yields): xu = 0.87 fy Ast/(0.36 fck b) (mm; fy, fck in N/mm², Ast in mm², b in mm)
  • Moment of resistance (xu < xu,max): Mu = 0.87 fy Ast (d − 0.42 xu) = 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)) (N mm)
  • Limiting moment: Mu,lim = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) fck b d² (N mm)
  • Limiting steel: pt,lim = 100 × 0.36 fck (xu,max/d)/(0.87 fy) (per cent of b d; dimensionless)
  • Minimum depth: d = √(Mu/(Q b)), Q = Mu,lim/(b d²) in N/mm² (mm)
  • Steel area for Mu: Ast = (0.5 fck/fy)[1 − √(1 − 4.6 Mu/(fck b d²))] b d (mm²)
  • Steel limits (cl. 26.5.1.1): As,min = 0.85 b d/fy; As,max = 0.04 b D (mm²)
Assumptions and limits
  • All the assumptions of lesson 2.1 and IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 hold; the beam is rectangular over its compression zone and the steel is in one layer, or d is taken to the centroid of the layers.
  • The tension steel yields (xu below xu,max) for the closed-form expressions; otherwise strain compatibility is used.
  • Shear, bond, anchorage and deflection are checked separately (later chapters); flexural strength alone does not make a beam adequate.
  • The 4.6 in the steel formula is 4/0.87 = 4.598, which appears when the Annex G quadratic is solved for Ast.
  • Limits: these equations do not apply to sections with significant axial force, to flanged sections with the neutral axis in the web (lesson 2.4) or to sections with compression steel (lesson 2.3); for moments above Mu,lim a singly reinforced section cannot be used without increasing its size or adding compression steel.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 Annex G, G-1.1 (a) to (d): neutral axis, moment of resistance for xu/d below the limit, Mu,lim at the limit, and redesign when xu/d exceeds the limit; the limiting values xu,max/d are in the Note below cl. 38.1.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.1 (minimum tension steel As/(b d) = 0.85/fy and maximum 0.04 b D); cl. 38.1 (assumptions); cl. 36.4.2.1 (γm).
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European code (EN 1992-1-1) designs rectangular sections from the same equilibrium and strain-compatibility ideas with its own stress block and ductility limits on the neutral-axis depth; the American code (ACI 318) uses an equivalent rectangular block and a strength reduction factor that depends on the net tensile strain of the steel, which plays a role similar to the xu,max limit. Their coefficients are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: moment of resistance)

Problem. A beam 230 mm wide with an effective depth of 410 mm has three 16 mm bars of Fe 415 in M20 concrete. Find the neutral-axis depth, check that the steel yields, and find the moment of resistance. Compare with the limiting moment of the section.

  1. Ast = 3 × π × 16²/4 = 603.2 mm²; T = 0.87 × 415 × 603.2 = 217.8 kN.
  2. xu = 217 780/(0.36 × 20 × 230) = 131.5 mm; xu/d = 0.321 < 0.48, so the section is under-reinforced.
  3. Steel strain = 0.0035 × (410 − 131.5)/131.5 = 0.0074, above 0.0038: the steel yields.
  4. Mu = 217.8 × (410 − 0.42 × 131.5)/1 000 = 77.3 kN m (the Annex G form 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)) gives 77.4 kN m).
  5. Mu,lim = 0.138 × 20 × 230 × 410² = 106.7 kN m; the beam uses about 72 per cent of its limiting capacity. Minimum steel 0.85 × 230 × 410/415 = 193 mm² is met.

Answer. xu = 131.5 mm (under-reinforced); Mu = 77.3 kN m; Mu,lim = 106.7 kN m

Example 2 (design style: simply supported floor beam)

Problem. A simply supported beam of 6.0 m effective span, 300 mm wide, carries a characteristic dead load of 22 kN/m (including self-weight) and an imposed load of 12 kN/m. Using M25 concrete and Fe 500 steel, find the minimum effective depth for a singly reinforced section, adopt a depth, and design the tension steel.

  1. Design load 1.5 × (22 + 12) = 51 kN/m; Mu = 51 × 6.0²/8 = 229.5 kN m.
  2. Q = 0.36 × 0.46 × (1 − 0.42 × 0.46) × 25 = 0.1336 × 25 = 3.34 N/mm²; dmin = √(229.5 × 10⁶/(3.34 × 300)) = 478.6 mm.
  3. Adopt d = 500 mm (overall depth 550 mm) so that the section is under-reinforced.
  4. Ast from 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)) = Mu: 217 500 Ast (1 − Ast/7 500) = 229.5 × 10⁶, giving Ast = 1 270 mm².
  5. Provide two 25 mm and one 20 mm bar, 1 296 mm². Check: xu = 0.87 × 500 × 1 296/(0.36 × 25 × 300) = 208.8 mm, xu/d = 0.418 < 0.46; Mu = 563.7 kN × (500 − 0.42 × 208.8) mm = 232.4 kN m ≥ 229.5 kN m.
  6. Limits: As,min = 0.85 × 300 × 500/500 = 255 mm² and As,max = 0.04 × 300 × 550 = 6 600 mm²; 1 296 mm² lies between them.

Answer. 300 × 550 mm beam, d = 500 mm, Ast = 1 270 mm² required, 2-25 + 1-20 (1 296 mm²) provided; Mu = 232 kN m

Example 3 (site style: an over-reinforced existing beam)

Problem. An existing beam 250 mm wide with d = 450 mm in M20 concrete was built with four 20 mm Fe 415 bars. Check whether it is under- or over-reinforced, estimate its flexural strength by strain compatibility, and state the value a designer should use.

  1. Ast = 4 × π × 20²/4 = 1 256.6 mm². If the steel yielded, xu = 0.87 × 415 × 1 256.6/(0.36 × 20 × 250) = 252.1 mm, xu/d = 0.560 > 0.48: over-reinforced, so the steel does not reach 0.87 fy.
  2. Strain compatibility: find xu so that 0.36 × 20 × 250 × xu = 1 256.6 × fs, with εs = 0.0035 (450 − xu)/xu and fs from the Fe 415 design curve. Trial xu = 246.4 mm gives εs = 0.00289, fs = 353.0 N/mm² (between 351.8 at 0.00276 and 360.9 at 0.00380), and C = 443.5 kN = T.
  3. Mu = 0.36 × 20 × 250 × 246.4 × (450 − 0.42 × 246.4) = 153.7 kN m.
  4. Mu,lim = 0.138 × 20 × 250 × 450² = 139.7 kN m. The extra 10 per cent comes with a brittle failure mode, so the code approach (Annex G, G-1.1 (d)) is not to count it: for assessment use about Mu,lim = 139.7 kN m, and for new work redesign the section.

Answer. Over-reinforced (xu/d about 0.55); strain-compatibility strength 153.7 kN m; use Mu,lim = 139.7 kN m

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Compute the factored moment Mu from the design loads (lesson 1.2).
  2. Choose b (often the wall or column width) and find Q = Mu,lim/(b d²) for the grades; compute dmin = √(Mu/(Q b)).
  3. Adopt d larger than dmin and fix the overall depth from cover, link and bar size.
  4. Solve the Annex G quadratic for Ast (or use the 4.6 formula) and choose bars.
  5. Check xu = 0.87 fy Ast/(0.36 fck b) is below xu,max and that Mu for the bars provided is at least the design moment.
  6. Check minimum and maximum steel, bar spacing, and then shear, anchorage and deflection.

Site notes

  • Check bar sizes and counts at the pour inspection: replacing three 16 mm bars by three 20 mm bars raises the steel area by over 50 per cent and can push a beam towards xu,max.
  • Bars bunched in the top layer of a two-layer arrangement reduce the effective depth; measure d to the centroid of the steel actually fixed.
  • Never cut a hole or chase through the compression zone of a beam near midspan; it removes the concrete the stress block depends on.
  • For deep beams of over 750 mm web depth, side-face reinforcement is a separate code requirement; it does not count in the flexural design.
  • Cube results below the grade reduce both the block force and xu,max margins; check the strength of critical beams if the pour fails acceptance.
Common mistakes
  • Forgetting the 1.5 load factor and designing for the service moment.
  • Using b d² with the overall depth D instead of the effective depth d.
  • Adopting d exactly equal to dmin and then providing more steel than required, which makes the section over-reinforced.
  • Taking the larger root of the steel quadratic, which corresponds to an impossible over-reinforced section.
  • Ignoring the minimum steel 0.85 b d/fy in lightly loaded beams and lintels.
Quick check

For Fe 415 the limiting steel ratio is about 0.96 per cent in M20 and 1.2 per cent in M25; for Fe 500 about 0.76 and 0.95 per cent. Economical beams usually sit at 60 to 85 per cent of these values, and for an under-reinforced Fe 415 or Fe 500 beam the lever arm z = d − 0.42 xu lies between about 0.80d (at the limit) and 0.95d (near minimum steel). A quick steel estimate is Ast ≈ Mu/(0.87 fy × 0.9 d).

Summary

  • For a singly reinforced rectangular beam, 0.36 fck b xu = 0.87 fy Ast gives the neutral axis and Mu = 0.87 fy Ast (d − 0.42 xu) the strength.
  • The Annex G form Mu = 0.87 fy Ast d (1 − Ast fy/(b d fck)) is the same couple with xu eliminated.
  • Mu,lim = 0.148, 0.138 and 0.133 fck b d² for Fe 250, 415 and 500; it fixes the minimum depth of a singly reinforced section.
  • Under-reinforced sections are ductile; over-reinforced sections fail suddenly and IS 456 requires them to be redesigned.
  • Tension steel must lie between 0.85 b d/fy and 0.04 b D (cl. 26.5.1.1).

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find xu for b = 300 mm, Ast = 942 mm² (three 20 mm bars), M25, Fe 415.

xu = 0.87 × 415 × 942/(0.36 × 25 × 300) = 126.0 mm.

2Find Mu for the beam of question 1 with d = 450 mm.

Mu = 0.87 × 415 × 942 × (450 − 0.42 × 126.0) = 135.1 kN m.

3What is the minimum tension steel for a 230 × 450 mm beam (d = 410 mm) with Fe 500?

0.85 × 230 × 410/500 = 160 mm².

4Find the limiting steel ratio for M20 and Fe 415.

100 × 0.36 × 20 × 0.48/(0.87 × 415) = 0.96 per cent.

5Find dmin for Mu = 150 kN m, b = 250 mm, M20, Fe 415.

Q = 0.138 × 20 = 2.76 N/mm²; d = √(150 × 10⁶/(2.76 × 250)) = 466 mm.

6Why is an over-reinforced section undesirable even though its strength is a little higher?

The concrete crushes before the steel yields, so the beam fails suddenly with little cracking or deflection to give warning.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.