8.2 Water tanks
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Find the ring (hoop) tension in the wall of a circular tank and the cantilever moment in the wall of a rectangular tank from the water pressure.
- Design tank walls by the limit state route of IS 3370 (Part 2):2009, checking collapse to IS 456 and crack control through the service steel stress limit of cl. 4.4.3.1, with the minimum steel and bar spacing of cl. 8.1.1.
- Apply the material, exposure, flotation and water-tightness test requirements of IS 3370 (Part 1):2009 to a tank on site.
Theory
A water tank is a structure whose first job is not to leak. Strength still matters, but a tank that is strong enough and cracks freely will seep, stain, corrode its steel and fail its test. That is why liquid-retaining structures have their own code, IS 3370, used together with IS 456: Part 1 sets the general requirements (materials, exposure, joints, flotation, testing) and Part 2 the design of reinforced concrete tanks. Part 2 lets the designer use either limit state design or working stress design (cl. 4.3), but not a mixture.
Water pressure grows linearly with depth, γw z, exactly like a fluid version of earth pressure. In a circular tank whose wall is free to slide at the base, this outward pressure is carried by ring tension: cut the tank along a diameter and the pressure on the half-ring, p D per unit height, is held by two wall forces T, so T = p D/2 = γw z D/2, largest at the bottom. This is the thin-cylinder result from strength of materials, and it is carried entirely by horizontal steel, because concrete is not trusted in tension for strength.
Real circular walls are usually cast monolithically with the floor, so the base is restrained. Near the base the ring tension falls and a vertical bending moment appears instead. IS 3370 (Part 2) cl. 6.4 advises assuming the wall fully fixed at the base unless the degree of fixity is established by analysis, and IS 3370 (Part 4) gives coefficients for ring tension and moment for common cases. In rectangular tanks the walls are plates loaded by a triangular pressure and restrained along their edges (cl. 6.3); a long wall of a shallow tank behaves mainly as a vertical cantilever from its base, with moment γw H³/6 at the base, while short walls and corners also bend horizontally and carry direct tension from the adjoining walls.
Cracking is controlled in two ways. In the limit state route the surface crack width under service loads must not exceed 0.2 mm (cl. 4.4), and cl. 4.4.3.1 allows this to be taken as satisfied if the steel stress under service conditions does not exceed 130 N/mm² for high strength deformed bars (115 N/mm² for plain bars). That is far below the 0.87 fy = 361 N/mm² used at collapse for Fe 415, so the service check usually governs the steel. In the working stress route the whole concrete section is checked to stay below a permissible tensile stress, which leads to thicker walls. Either way the steel must not fall below the minimum of cl. 8.1.1: 0.35 per cent of the surface zone for high strength deformed bars in each direction, reducible to 0.24 per cent for tanks with no dimension over 15 m, with bar spacing not more than 300 mm or the wall thickness.
Part 1 makes the rest of the design durable. Faces in contact with the liquid are treated as severe exposure (cl. 4), which under IS 456 means at least 45 mm nominal cover. Reinforced concrete must be at least M30, with a water-cement ratio of not more than 0.45 and at least 320 kg/m³ of cement (cl. 5 and its Table 1; M25 is allowed for small tanks up to 50 m³ where M30 is hard to produce, except in coastal areas). A tank built in waterlogged ground must not float when empty: cl. 7.2 (b) asks for a factor of safety of 1.2 against uplift. Finally, every tank is tested by filling it and watching the level for seven days (cl. 12.1.1).
Derivation
- Pressure at depth z below the water surface: p = γw z, with γw = 9.81 kN/m³.
- Ring tension in a cylindrical wall of diameter D: cut a ring of unit height along a diameter. The resultant outward pressure on the half-ring is p D, balanced by the tension T in the two cut ends: 2T = p D, so T = γw z D/2 (kN per m height).
- Steel for ring tension at service: As = T/σs with σs ≤ 130 N/mm² (cl. 4.4.3.1); at collapse As ≥ 1.5 T/(0.87 fy). The larger governs, usually the service value.
- Cantilever wall of height H fixed at the base: the triangular load has resultant γw H²/2 at H/3 above the base, so the base moment is M = γw H³/6 and the base shear V = γw H²/2 (per m run).
- Service steel stress in a cracked section (elastic theory of IS 456 Annex B): the neutral axis depth x satisfies b x²/2 = m As (d − x), the lever arm is z = d − x/3, and fs = M/(As z), with m = 280/(3 σcbc).
- Flotation: an empty tank with its base at depth hw below the water table is pushed up by U = γw hw A, where A is the base area. Stability needs the permanent weight W ≥ 1.2 U (IS 3370 (Part 1) cl. 7.2 (b)).
p = γw z (kN/m²; γw = 9.81 kN/m³, z in m)Ring tension: T = γw H D/2 at the base of a free-sliding wall (kN per m height; D in m)Ring steel at service: As = T/130 (mm² per m; T in N per m, 130 N/mm² for high strength deformed bars)Cantilever wall: M = γw H³/6 (kN m per m), V = γw H²/2 (kN per m)Cracked section: b x²/2 = m As (d − x); z = d − x/3; fs = M/(As z) ≤ 130 N/mm²; m = 280/(3 σcbc)Minimum steel each way in each surface zone: 0.35 per cent (0.24 per cent for tanks up to 15 m) of the surface zone; surface zone = half the thickness for walls under 500 mm thick, 250 mm for thicker wallsFlotation: W ≥ 1.2 γw hw A (kN)
- Water at 9.81 kN/m³ and at ambient temperature; IS 3370 does not cover hot liquids or light oils.
- Ring tension alone assumes a wall free to slide at its base. A monolithic base restrains the wall; IS 3370 (Part 2) cl. 6.4 advises assuming full fixity unless analysis shows otherwise, and the ring tension and moment then come from plate or shell coefficients such as those of IS 3370 (Part 4).
- Treating a long rectangular wall as a vertical cantilever is a simplification for walls much longer than they are high; corners and short walls need two-way plate analysis and must carry the direct tension from the end walls together with bending (cl. 6.3).
- The 130 N/mm² service stress limit stands in for a crack width calculation; designs that need cracks narrower than 0.2 mm, or that cannot meet the stress limit, use the crack width methods of Annex B of Part 2.
- Temperature and shrinkage stresses are not calculated separately where the minimum steel of cl. 8.1.1 and the movement joints of Part 1 are provided and the tank is used for water near ambient temperature (Part 2 cl. 4.5.4).
- Earth pressure on the outside of buried walls is not counted as relieving the water pressure when the tank is full (Part 1 cl. 7.2 (a)); the empty-tank case with earth pressure alone is checked separately.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 3370 (Part 1):2009 cl. 4 (faces retaining liquid treated as severe exposure under IS 456), cl. 5 with Table 1 (reinforced concrete at least M30, water-cement ratio not more than 0.45, minimum cement content; M25 permitted for tanks up to 50 m³ where M30 is difficult, not in coastal areas), cl. 6.2.1 (cover as per IS 456 for the exposure), cl. 7.2 (a) (no relief from soil pressure on the walls with the tank full) and cl. 7.2 (b) (factor of safety 1.2 against uplift), cl. 12.1.1 (water-tightness test: fill, wait seven days, then record the level for seven more days; a covered underground tank is deemed watertight if the total drop in seven days does not exceed 20 mm).
- IS 3370 (Part 2):2009 cl. 4.3 (limit state design or working stress design, one or the other), cl. 4.4 (limit state design: collapse to IS 456, deflection to IS 456, calculated surface crack width not more than 0.2 mm), cl. 4.4.3.1 (crack widths deemed satisfactory if the service steel stress does not exceed 115 N/mm² for plain bars and 130 N/mm² for high strength deformed bars), cl. 4.5 (working stress design with resistance to cracking), cl. 4.5.4 (no separate temperature and moisture stress calculation under stated conditions), cl. 6.3 (rectangular and polygonal tank walls as plates), cl. 6.4 (cylindrical tank walls, base fixity), cl. 8.1.1 (minimum steel and bar spacing). IS 3370 (Part 4) for design coefficients, named by number only.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 26.4.2 with Table 16 (45 mm nominal cover for severe exposure), cl. 36.4.1 (load factor 1.5 at collapse), Annex B cl. B-1.3 (elastic theory, modular ratio m = 280/(3 σcbc)) with Table 21 (σcbc = 10 N/mm² for M30), cl. 40.2.1 with Table 19 (shear strength of concrete). Bars to IS 1786.
- EN 1992-3 (Eurocode 2, Part 3: liquid retaining and containment structures) classifies tanks by tightness class and limits crack widths accordingly; ACI 350 (Code requirements for environmental engineering concrete structures) raises the durability factor on loads and limits service steel stresses. Listed side by side, not ranked.
Worked examples
Problem. A circular water tank of 10 m internal diameter holds water 4 m deep. The wall rests on the floor through a sliding joint. M30 concrete, Fe 415 bars, wall 200 mm thick, limit state route of IS 3370 (Part 2). Design the ring steel at the base and at 2 m depth, and the vertical steel.
- Ring tension at the base: T = 9.81 × 4 × 10/2 = 196.2 kN per m height.
- Service check (cl. 4.4.3.1): As = 196 200/130 = 1 509 mm² per m, that is 755 mm² on each face.
- Collapse check: Tu = 1.5 × 196.2 = 294.3 kN; As = 294 300/(0.87 × 415) = 815 mm². The service check governs.
- Provide 12 mm rings at 140 mm on each face: 2 × 808 = 1 616 mm² per m; service steel stress = 196 200/1 616 = 121.4 N/mm² ≤ 130.
- At 2 m depth: T = 9.81 × 2 × 10/2 = 98.1 kN; As = 98 100/130 = 755 mm², 377 mm² per face; 10 mm at 200 mm on each face (393 mm²).
- Vertical steel: the tank is 10 m across, under 15 m, so the minimum is 0.24 per cent of the surface zone. Wall under 500 mm thick, surface zone 100 mm per face: 0.0024 × 100 × 1 000 = 240 mm² per face; 8 mm at 200 mm (251 mm²) each face. Spacing 200 mm is within the 300 mm and wall-thickness limits.
Answer. Base: 12 mm rings at 140 mm each face (service stress 121.4 N/mm²); at 2 m depth 10 mm at 200 mm each face; vertical 8 mm at 200 mm each face (minimum steel).
Problem. The long wall of a rectangular tank 20 m × 6 m in plan holds 3 m of water and is treated as a vertical cantilever fixed at the base. Wall 300 mm thick, M30, Fe 415, 45 mm cover (severe exposure), 16 mm vertical bars on the water face. Design the vertical steel by the limit state route.
- Service moment M = 9.81 × 3³/6 = 44.15 kN m per m; Mu = 1.5 × 44.15 = 66.22 kN m.
- d = 300 − 45 − 8 = 247 mm. Collapse steel: Ast = 0.5 × (30/415) × [1 − √(1 − 4.6 × 66.22 × 10⁶/(30 × 1 000 × 247²))] × 1 000 × 247 = 777 mm².
- Service stress check: m = 280/(3 × 10) = 9.33. Try 16 mm at 200 mm (1 005 mm²): x from 1 000 x²/2 = 9.33 × 1 005 (247 − x) gives x = 59.3 mm; z = 247 − 19.8 = 227.2 mm; fs = 44.15 × 10⁶/(1 005 × 227.2) = 193 N/mm², more than 130: not acceptable.
- Try 16 mm at 130 mm (1 547 mm²): x = 71.2 mm, z = 223.3 mm, fs = 127.8 N/mm² ≤ 130; concrete stress 2M/(b x z) = 5.55 N/mm² ≤ σcbc = 10. Accept.
- Shear at the base: Vu = 1.5 × 9.81 × 3²/2 = 66.2 kN; τv = 0.27 N/mm² against τc = 0.55 N/mm² (pt = 0.626 per cent, M30). Safe.
- Minimum steel: the tank is 20 m long, over 15 m, so 0.35 per cent of the 150 mm surface zone = 525 mm² per m per face. Provide 12 mm at 200 mm (565 mm²) vertically on the outer face and horizontally on both faces.
Answer. 16 mm at 130 mm on the water face (service stress 127.8 N/mm², about twice the 777 mm² needed for collapse); 12 mm at 200 mm elsewhere as minimum steel.
Problem. An underground tank, 8.0 m × 6.0 m outside, is 4.0 m deep overall: base 400 mm, walls 300 mm thick and 3.4 m high, roof slab 200 mm, with 0.5 m of earth cover (18 kN/m³) above the roof. In the wet season the water table can rise to the top of the roof slab. Check flotation of the empty tank and suggest a fix.
- Uplift: U = 9.81 × 4.0 × (8.0 × 6.0) = 1 883.5 kN.
- Weights: base 48 × 0.4 × 25 = 480 kN; roof 48 × 0.2 × 25 = 240 kN; walls on the centre-line perimeter 2 × (7.7 + 5.7) = 26.8 m, so 26.8 × 0.3 × 3.4 × 25 = 683.4 kN; earth cover 48 × 0.5 × 18 = 432 kN. W = 1 835.4 kN.
- Factor of safety W/U = 1 835.4/1 883.5 = 0.97, less than 1.0, let alone the 1.2 asked by IS 3370 (Part 1) cl. 7.2 (b). The empty tank would float.
- Weight needed: 1.2 × 1 883.5 = 2 260.2 kN. Raising the earth cover to 1.0 m adds 432 kN: W = 2 267.4 kN and W/U = 1.20. Acceptable, provided the cover is permanent and cannot be removed while the tank is empty.
- Alternatives: extend the base slab beyond the walls so that the soil above the projection holds it down, thicken the base, or lower the water table with drainage. The base and roof slabs must also be designed for the uplift pressure as a load.
Answer. With 0.5 m cover W/U = 0.97 (floats); with 1.0 m cover W = 2 267.4 kN ≥ 2 260.2 kN and W/U = 1.20, meeting the 1.2 factor.
Step-by-step procedure
- Fix the capacity, shape, depth and support condition (on ground, underground or elevated), and decide the base joint: sliding or monolithic.
- Set the materials and cover from IS 3370 (Part 1): M30 or better, water-cement ratio not more than 0.45, severe exposure, 45 mm cover.
- Choose the design route (limit state or working stress) and keep to it for the whole tank.
- Find the forces: ring tension for circular walls, cantilever or plate moments for rectangular walls, with direct tension from adjoining walls added.
- Design the steel for collapse and check the service steel stress (130 N/mm² for high strength deformed bars), or calculate the crack width; the larger steel governs.
- Check the minimum steel in each surface zone (0.35 or 0.24 per cent) and the bar spacing limit.
- Check flotation for the empty tank with the highest water table and design the slabs for uplift.
- Detail movement joints, water bars, corner haunches and laps, then specify the water-tightness test.
Site notes
- Cast walls in as tall a lift as practical and keep vertical joints continuous over the full height; every joint is a possible leak path and needs a water bar.
- Form-tie bolts that pass right through a liquid-retaining wall are not used unless a proper water-tight detail is adopted.
- Cure the walls and floor continuously; early drying causes the shrinkage cracks that the minimum steel is trying to control.
- Fill the tank slowly the first time; IS 3370 (Part 1) notes that slow first filling helps control cracking.
- Run the water-tightness test before any lining, plaster or backfill hides the faces, so that damp patches can be seen and repaired.
- Designing the steel only for collapse; the service stress or crack width check usually needs about twice as much steel.
- Assuming a sliding base and pure ring tension when the wall is cast monolithically with the floor; the base moment is then missed.
- Counting earth pressure outside a buried wall as relieving the water pressure in the full condition.
- Forgetting flotation of an empty underground tank in the wet season.
- Using the minimum steel of IS 456 slabs (0.12 per cent) instead of the higher IS 3370 minimum.
For high strength deformed bars, the steel needed for crack control in direct tension is T/130 against 1.5 T/361 at collapse, a ratio of 361/(1.5 × 130) = 1.85. So in tank walls expect the serviceability steel to be close to double the strength steel, as in Examples 1 and 2. The guide applies to the limit state route with the 130 N/mm² deemed-to-satisfy limit.
Summary
- IS 3370 (Part 1) sets materials (M30, w/c 0.45), severe exposure, flotation (factor 1.2) and the seven-day water-tightness test; Part 2 sets the design.
- Ring tension T = γw H D/2 in a circular wall free at the base; a monolithic base is assumed fixed unless shown otherwise (Part 2 cl. 6.4).
- A long rectangular wall acts roughly as a cantilever with M = γw H³/6 at the base.
- Crack width 0.2 mm, deemed satisfied when the service steel stress is at most 130 N/mm² for deformed bars (cl. 4.4.3.1).
- Minimum steel 0.35 per cent of each surface zone (0.24 per cent for tanks up to 15 m), spacing not more than 300 mm or the thickness (cl. 8.1.1).
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the ring tension at the base of a 12 m diameter tank holding 5 m of water, and the service steel needed with deformed bars.
T = 9.81 × 5 × 12/2 = 294.3 kN per m; As = 294 300/130 = 2 264 mm² per m (about 1 132 mm² per face).
2What minimum steel is needed per face in a 250 mm wall of a tank 20 m long?
Surface zone = 125 mm; 0.35 per cent × 125 × 1 000 = 437.5 mm² per m per face, in each direction.
3What is the largest bar spacing allowed in a 180 mm tank wall, and where may the steel go?
Not more than 300 mm or the thickness, so 180 mm; in walls under 200 mm thick the calculated steel may all be placed in one face.
4A covered underground tank loses 18 mm of level over the seven-day test. Does it pass?
Yes. IS 3370 (Part 1) cl. 12.1.1 deems such a tank watertight if the drop in seven days does not exceed 20 mm.
5Why is the service steel stress limited to 130 N/mm² when Fe 415 can be used at 361 N/mm² at collapse?
Lower steel stress means smaller steel strain and narrower cracks; the limit is the deemed-to-satisfy route to the 0.2 mm crack width.
6What concrete grade and water-cement ratio does IS 3370 (Part 1) require for a reinforced concrete tank?
At least M30 with a water-cement ratio of not more than 0.45 (M25 allowed for small tanks up to 50 m³ where M30 is difficult, except in coastal areas).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.