Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 5 › Lesson 5.2

5.2 Two-way slabs

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 5: Slabs and stairs Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain how a slab supported on four edges shares its load between the short and long spans, and why the short span carries most of it.
  • Find design moments from the coefficients of IS 456:2000 Annex D: Table 27 for simply supported slabs whose corners can lift, Table 26 for restrained slabs with corner torsion steel, applied to the middle strips.
  • Detail a two-way slab: bars in both directions with the correct effective depths, curtailment, edge strips and the corner torsion reinforcement of D-1.8 to D-1.10.

Theory

When a slab is supported on all four edges and its long side is not much longer than its short side, it bends in both directions like a shallow dish. Load reaches all four supports, and the slab is called two-way. The deflection at the centre must be the same whichever direction you follow, and because deflection grows with the fourth power of span, the stiffer short direction attracts the larger share of the load. The ratio ly/lx therefore controls the behaviour: at 1.0 the load is shared equally, and by 2.0 the short span carries about 94 per cent of it, which is why Annex D (D-1.11) treats slabs with ly/lx above 2 as one-way (lesson 5.1).

A simply supported slab whose corners are free to lift curls up at the corners as it bends. If the corners are held down by walls above or by anchorage into edge beams, the slab twists near the corners, the twisting moments relieve the midspan moments, and the slab is stiffer and stronger. This needs reinforcement for the twisting moments at the corners. IS 456:2000 handles the two cases separately: Table 27 (D-2) gives coefficients for simply supported slabs without adequate provision against corner lifting, and Table 26 (D-1) gives coefficients for slabs whose corners are held down, for nine combinations of continuous and discontinuous edges.

Two-way slab: strips and corner steelshort span lxlong span lymiddle strip 3/4edge strip1/8 eachcorner matslx/5 squareIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 5.2: A two-way slab panel: middle strips three-quarters of the width carry the Annex D moments, edge strips one-eighth each, and corner mats of torsion steel extend one-fifth of the short span where the corners are held down. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Annex D gives the moments per unit width as Mx = αx w lx² and My = αy w lx², both using the short span lx (D-1.1, D-2.1). For restrained slabs the moments apply to the middle strip, three-quarters of the width in each direction; the two edge strips, each one-eighth of the width, get only the minimum steel plus the corner torsion steel (D-1.2, D-1.3, D-1.7). Torsion reinforcement is placed at corners where both edges are discontinuous: top and bottom mats in two directions extending one-fifth of the short span, each layer three-quarters of the midspan steel (D-1.8); half of that where one edge is continuous (D-1.9) and none where both are continuous (D-1.10).

The steel in the short direction goes in the outer layer because it carries the larger moment; the long-direction bars sit on top of them with an effective depth smaller by one bar diameter. The same minimum steel, maximum diameter and spacing rules as for one-way slabs apply (lesson 5.1), and deflection is checked on the shorter span (a note to cl. 24.1). Moments in adjacent panels with different coefficients may be balanced at common supports, and the loads on the supporting beams follow cl. 24.5; those topics belong with continuous slab systems.

Derivation

  1. Strip method of Rankine and Grashoff: take two crossing strips of unit width through the centre, spans lx and ly, carrying shares wx and wy of the load w = wx + wy. Simply supported strips deflect 5 wx lx⁴/(384 E I) and 5 wy ly⁴/(384 E I).
  2. Equal deflection at the crossing point gives wx lx⁴ = wy ly⁴, so with r = ly/lx, wx = w r⁴/(1 + r⁴) and wy = w/(1 + r⁴).
  3. Moments: Mx = wx lx²/8 = [r⁴/(8 (1 + r⁴))] w lx² and My = wy ly²/8 = [r²/(8 (1 + r⁴))] w lx². These are the coefficients αx and αy of a simply supported slab whose corners are free to lift; at r = 1 both are 1/16 = 0.0625, at r = 1.5 they are 0.104 and 0.046, and at r = 2 αx = 0.118 — the values of Table 27 (0.062, 0.104 and 0.046, and 0.118).
  4. Load share in the short direction r⁴/(1 + r⁴): 50 per cent at r = 1, 83.5 per cent at r = 1.5 and 94.1 per cent at r = 2; the one-way limit of D-1.11 follows.
  5. Restrained slabs: holding the corners down adds twisting moments that reduce the midspan moments; Table 26 coefficients come from plate analyses that include the corner restraint and the continuity of the edges. For an interior panel at ly/lx = 1.0 they are 0.032 (negative, at continuous edges) and 0.024 (positive, at midspan); for four discontinuous edges with corners held down at ly/lx = 1.5 the short-span positive coefficient is 0.089 instead of 0.104 in Table 27.
  6. Design of the strip: with Mx and My per metre, use the Chapter 2 formula Ast = 0.5 (fck/fy)[1 − √(1 − 4.6 Mu/(fck b d²))] b d with b = 1 000 mm, d = dx for the short span and dy = dx − φ for the long span.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Moments per metre (Annex D): Mx = αx w lx², My = αy w lx² (kN m per metre; w in kN/m², lx in m)
  • Rankine–Grashoff (corners free): αx = r⁴/[8 (1 + r⁴)], αy = r²/[8 (1 + r⁴)], r = ly/lx (dimensionless)
  • Load share in the short direction: r⁴/(1 + r⁴) (dimensionless)
  • Middle strip = 3/4 of the width; edge strips = 1/8 each (D-1.2) (widths in m; fractions dimensionless)
  • Corner torsion steel: four layers, each 0.75 × Ast (midspan) over lx/5 from the edges (D-1.8); half at one continuous edge (mm² per metre)
  • Effective depths: dy = dx − φ (mm); deflection on the shorter span (cl. 24.1)
Assumptions and limits
  • The slab is rectangular, supported on four edges by walls or stiff beams, and carries a uniformly distributed load.
  • Table 27 applies where corners can lift (no anchorage against lifting and no torsion steel); Table 26 applies only when corners are held down and the torsion steel of D-1.8 to D-1.10 is provided.
  • Moments from Table 26 apply to the middle strips without redistribution (D-1.3); edge strips carry minimum steel and corner torsion steel.
  • Partial safety factor 1.5 on loads; steel yields (under-reinforced slab).
  • Limits: Annex D covers uniformly loaded rectangular panels; concentrated loads, openings, non-rectangular panels, flat slabs without beams (lesson 5.3) and panels with ly/lx > 2 (designed one way) need other methods.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 24.4 (two-way slabs carrying uniformly distributed load designed by any acceptable theory or by the coefficients of Annex D), cl. 24.1 and its notes (the shorter span used for span to effective depth ratios), cl. 24.5 (loads on supporting beams), cl. 26.5.2.1, cl. 26.5.2.2 and cl. 26.3.3 (b) as in lesson 5.1.
  • IS 456:2000 Annex D: D-1.1 (Mx = αx w lx², My = αy w lx², Table 26), D-1.2 (middle strip three-quarters, edge strips one-eighth), D-1.3 (moments apply to middle strips, no redistribution), D-1.4 (bottom steel to within 0.25 l of a continuous edge or 0.15 l of a discontinuous edge), D-1.5 (top steel 0.15 l, at least 50 per cent to 0.3 l), D-1.6 (50 per cent of midspan steel over 0.1 l at discontinuous edges), D-1.8 to D-1.10 (torsion steel: lx/5, three-quarters, half, none), D-1.11 (ly/lx > 2 designed one way), D-2.1 (Table 27 for simply supported slabs without corner restraint: αx 0.062, 0.104, 0.118 and αy 0.062, 0.046, 0.029 at ly/lx 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0), D-2.1.1 (at least 50 per cent of midspan steel to the supports).
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) allows two-way slabs to be analysed by elastic, plastic (yield-line or strip) or tabulated methods and gives its own detailing for corner and edge reinforcement; the American code (ACI 318) designs two-way systems by the direct design or equivalent frame methods with column and middle strips. Their coefficients differ and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (design style: simply supported, corners free)

Problem. A roof slab 4 m × 6 m (effective spans) rests on masonry walls on all four sides with nothing holding the corners down. It is 150 mm thick, M20, Fe 415, 20 mm clear cover, finish 1.0 kN/m², imposed 3.0 kN/m². Design the reinforcement.

  1. w = 3.75 + 1.0 + 3.0 = 7.75 kN/m²; wu = 11.625 kN/m²; ly/lx = 1.5; Table 27: αx = 0.104, αy = 0.046 (Rankine–Grashoff gives 0.1044 and 0.0464).
  2. Mx = 0.104 × 11.625 × 4² = 19.34 kN m/m; My = 0.046 × 11.625 × 4² = 8.56 kN m/m.
  3. dx = 150 − 20 − 5 = 125 mm: Ast,x = 465 mm²/m. dy = 125 − 10 = 115 mm: Ast,y = 214 mm²/m → 8 mm at 200 mm (251 mm²/m), above the 180 mm²/m minimum.
  4. Deflection on the short span: 10 mm at 150 mm (524 mm²/m) gives fs = 213.6 N/mm², pt = 0.42 per cent, factor about 1.48, allowable 29.6 < actual 4 000/125 = 32: fails. 10 mm at 120 mm (654 mm²/m) gives fs = 171.0 N/mm², pt = 0.52 per cent, factor about 1.67, allowable 33.3 ≥ 32: passes.
  5. Detailing (D-2.1.1): at least half the midspan bars run into the supports; the rest may stop within 0.1 lx = 0.4 m (short bars) or 0.1 ly = 0.6 m (long bars) of the supports.

Answer. Short span 10 mm at 120 mm (deflection governs), long span 8 mm at 200 mm

Example 2 (exam style: interior panel of a floor)

Problem. An interior panel 4.5 m × 4.5 m of a continuous floor is 150 mm thick, M20, Fe 415, finish 1.5 kN/m², imposed 4.0 kN/m², corners held by the continuity of the floor. Find the moments and steel, the strip widths and the extent of top steel.

  1. w = 3.75 + 1.5 + 4.0 = 9.25 kN/m²; wu = 13.875 kN/m²; ly/lx = 1.0, Table 26 case 1 (interior panel): 0.032 negative, 0.024 positive, the same in both directions.
  2. Negative moment = 0.032 × 13.875 × 4.5² = 8.99 kN m/m → 206 mm²/m (d = 125 mm): 8 mm at 200 mm top (251 mm²/m). Positive moment = 0.024 × 13.875 × 4.5² = 6.74 kN m/m → 153 mm²/m (d = 125) and 168 mm²/m (d = 115): minimum 180 mm²/m governs, 8 mm at 250 mm (201 mm²/m) bottom both ways.
  3. Middle strip = 0.75 × 4.5 = 3.375 m; edge strips = 4.5/8 = 0.5625 m each, with minimum steel. All edges are continuous, so no corner torsion steel is required (D-1.10).
  4. Top steel over the supports extends 0.15 × 4.5 = 0.675 m into the span, with at least half of it continued to 0.3 × 4.5 = 1.35 m (D-1.5).
  5. Deflection: continuous, basic 26; with fs = 183.7 N/mm² and pt = 0.16 per cent the factor is at its 2.0 cap, so allowable l/d = 52 ≥ 4 500/125 = 36.

Answer. Mneg 8.99 and Mpos 6.74 kN m/m; 8 mm at 200 mm top, 8 mm at 250 mm bottom; top bars to 0.675 m and 1.35 m

Example 3 (site style: is it worth holding the corners down?)

Problem. For the slab of Example 1, the contractor proposes concrete edge beams that hold the corners down, so that the slab can be designed by Table 26 case 9 (four edges discontinuous). Compare the short-span moment and give the corner steel.

  1. Table 26 case 9 at ly/lx = 1.5: short-span coefficient 0.089 instead of 0.104: Mx = 0.089 × 11.625 × 4² = 16.55 kN m/m, about 14 per cent less.
  2. Ast,x = 393 mm²/m instead of 465 mm²/m (deflection must still be checked as in Example 1).
  3. Corner torsion steel (D-1.8): at all four corners (both edges discontinuous), top and bottom mats in both directions, each layer 0.75 × 393 = 294 mm²/m, extending lx/5 = 0.8 m from each edge: 8 mm at 170 mm (296 mm²/m) in four layers.
  4. The saving in midspan steel is partly used up by the corner mats, but the slab no longer curls at the corners, which is what cracks the plaster and the parapet at roof corners.

Answer. Mx falls from 19.34 to 16.55 kN m/m; corner mats of 8 mm at 170 mm in four layers over 0.8 m × 0.8 m

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Check ly/lx: if it exceeds 2, design one-way (lesson 5.1); otherwise two-way.
  2. Decide whether the corners are held down and torsion steel will be provided (Table 26, case by edge conditions) or not (Table 27).
  3. Choose a trial depth from deflection on the shorter span; compute w and wu per square metre.
  4. Read αx and αy for ly/lx (interpolating between columns), compute Mx and My (negative and positive) per metre width.
  5. Design steel for the middle strips: short span in the outer layer at dx, long span at dy = dx − φ; satisfy minimum steel, D/8, 3d and 300 mm; check deflection and shear.
  6. Detail edge strips with minimum steel, curtail bars per D-1.4 to D-1.6 or D-2.1.1, and add corner torsion mats per D-1.8 to D-1.10.

Site notes

  • Short-span bars go underneath; check this at every panel, because the long and short directions swap between panels of different shape.
  • Corner torsion mats are often forgotten at roof corners and re-entrant corners; their absence shows up as diagonal cracks across the slab corners.
  • Use enough chairs for the top mats of continuous floors so that top steel stays at the top under foot traffic.
  • Do not let walls above be built on a slab designed as having free corners without checking: they may hold the corners down and change the load path.
  • Record which edges are continuous on the bar bending schedule, since the coefficients and curtailment depend on them.
Common mistakes
  • Using ly instead of lx in My = αy w lx².
  • Placing long-span bars under short-span bars, which reduces the effective depth for the larger moment.
  • Using Table 26 coefficients while omitting the corner torsion reinforcement they assume.
  • Designing edge strips for the full middle-strip moment, or giving them no steel at all.
  • Treating a panel with ly/lx = 2.5 as two-way.
Quick check

For a simply supported square slab with free corners αx = 0.062, about half the one-way value 0.125, so two-way action roughly halves the short-span moment; by ly/lx = 2 αx = 0.118 is within about 6 per cent of the one-way value, which is why such panels are designed one way. Holding the corners down cuts the short-span moment by about 14 per cent at ly/lx = 1.5.

Summary

  • A slab supported on four edges with ly/lx ≤ 2 spans two ways; the short span carries the larger share because deflection grows with the fourth power of span.
  • Annex D gives Mx = αx w lx² and My = αy w lx²: Table 27 for simply supported slabs whose corners can lift, Table 26 for slabs whose corners are held down.
  • Table 26 moments apply to the middle strips (three-quarters of the width); edge strips (one-eighth each) get minimum steel and corner torsion steel.
  • Corner torsion mats extend lx/5, with each of four layers three-quarters of the midspan steel at corners with two discontinuous edges, half at corners with one, none at fully continuous corners.
  • Short-span bars go in the outer layer; deflection is checked on the shorter span, and curtailment follows D-1.4 to D-1.6 or D-2.1.1.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A simply supported square slab with free corners has lx = 4 m and wu = 10 kN/m². Find Mx from Table 27.

0.062 × 10 × 4² = 9.92 kN m/m.

2Find αx by Rankine–Grashoff for ly/lx = 2 and compare with Table 27.

16/(8 × 17) = 0.118, the same as Table 27.

3Find the middle and edge strip widths of a 5 m wide panel.

Middle 3.75 m; edge strips 0.625 m each.

4A corner has one continuous edge and one discontinuous edge. What torsion steel is needed?

Half of the D-1.8 amount: each layer 3/8 of the midspan steel, over lx/5.

5A panel is 3 m × 6.6 m on four supports. How is it designed?

ly/lx = 2.2 > 2: as a one-way slab spanning 3 m.

6Which span is used for the span/effective depth check of a two-way slab?

The shorter span (a note to cl. 24.1).

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.