Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 4 › Lesson 4.1

4.1 Deflection control

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 4: Limit state of serviceability Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain why a reinforced concrete member that is safe against collapse may still be unfit for use because it deflects too much, and state the two deflection limits of IS 456:2000 cl. 23.2.
  • Check deflection by the span to effective depth method of cl. 23.2.1: basic ratios 7, 20 and 26, the 10/span reduction for spans above 10 m, and the modification factors for tension and compression steel.
  • Calculate short-term, shrinkage and creep deflections by Annex C using the cracking moment, the cracked moment of inertia and the effective moment of inertia Ieff.

Theory

Chapters 2 and 3 made beams strong enough at the limit state of collapse. Strength alone does not make a usable floor. A slab that sags visibly, cracks the partition wall built on it, lets doors jam or ponds rainwater on a roof has failed its users even though it will never collapse. These are serviceability limit states, checked under service loads with partial safety factor 1.0 (lesson 1.2), and deflection is the first of them. Concrete members are also prone to it for two reasons: they crack, which lowers their stiffness, and concrete keeps deforming for years under sustained load (creep) and as it dries (shrinkage).

IS 456:2000 cl. 23.2 sets two limits. The final deflection due to all loads, including temperature, creep and shrinkage and measured from the as-cast level of the supports, should not normally exceed span/250 (cl. 23.2 (a)). The part of the deflection that occurs after partitions are built and finishes laid, again including creep and shrinkage, should not normally exceed span/350 or 20 mm, whichever is less (cl. 23.2 (b)). The first protects appearance and drainage; the second protects brittle walls and tiles that are attached to the member and cannot follow its movement.

Deflection: short-term + shrinkage + creepcracks in the middle thirdservice loadshort-term 9.4 mmshrinkage 1.4 mmcreep 2.5 mmlimit 24 mmIndiacon original, not to scale (Example 2 values)
Figure 4.1: Deflection of a simply supported reinforced concrete beam: cracking under service load lowers the stiffness, and the total deflection adds short-term, shrinkage and creep parts (values of Example 2) for comparison with span/250. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For most beams and slabs the code lets the designer avoid calculating deflection at all. Deflection of a beam of span l and depth d under a given stress level is proportional to l²/d multiplied by a curvature that depends on the steel stress, so limiting deflection to a fraction of the span is the same as limiting l/d. Cl. 23.2.1 gives basic span to effective depth ratios of 7 for cantilevers, 20 for simply supported members and 26 for continuous members, for spans up to 10 m. For longer spans these are multiplied by 10/span in metres, except for cantilevers, which must be checked by calculation. The basic value is then multiplied by a factor from Fig. 4, which depends on the percentage of tension steel and its service stress fs, and by a factor from Fig. 5 for compression steel; flanged beams use Fig. 6.

When the simple check fails, or for important members, deflection is calculated by Annex C. The short-term deflection uses the elastic formulas of Strength of Materials lesson 5.1 with the short-term modulus Ec = 5 000 √fck (cl. 6.2.3.1) and an effective moment of inertia Ieff between the cracked value Icr and the gross value Igr, because parts of the member between cracks still carry tension (tension stiffening). Long-term additions come from shrinkage, through a shrinkage curvature, and from creep, through an effective modulus Ece = Ec/(1 + θ) with the creep coefficient θ of cl. 6.2.5.1 (2.2, 1.6 and 1.1 for loading at 7 days, 28 days and 1 year). The total is the sum of the three (Annex C, C-1.1).

Derivation

  1. Why span/depth controls deflection: for a simply supported beam under uniform load, the midspan deflection is a = (5/48) M l²/(E I) and the curvature M/(E I) at midspan equals (εc + εs)/d, the sum of the concrete and steel strains divided by the effective depth. So a/l = (5/48)(εc + εs)(l/d). For a given strain level, keeping a/l below 1/250 means keeping l/d below a fixed number; higher steel stress means higher strains and a lower permitted l/d.
  2. Tension steel factor: the steel strain at service is fs/Es. IS 456 Fig. 4 expresses fs = 0.58 fy × (area of steel required)/(area of steel provided); 0.58 fy is roughly the service stress when the steel is exactly as required (0.87 fy divided by an average load factor of about 1.5). Providing more steel than required lowers fs and raises the factor. A curve fit to Fig. 4 used in Indian textbooks is kt = 1/[0.225 + 0.00322 fs − 0.625 log10(b d/(100 Ast))], not more than 2.0; it is used here only to reproduce the graph, and design offices read the figure itself.
  3. Cracking moment: the section stays uncracked until the extreme tension fibre reaches the flexural strength fcr = 0.7 √fck (cl. 6.2.2). With Igr the gross moment of inertia (steel ignored) and yt the distance from the centroid to the tension face, Mr = fcr Igr/yt (Annex C, C-2.1).
  4. Cracked section: with modular ratio m = Es/Ec, the neutral axis of a singly reinforced rectangle satisfies b x²/2 = m Ast (d − x), and Icr = b x³/3 + m Ast (d − x)², exactly as in the working stress lesson 1.1. The lever arm is z = d − x/3.
  5. Effective moment of inertia (Annex C, C-2.1): Ieff = Icr/[1.2 − (Mr/M)(z/d)(1 − x/d)(bw/b)], with Icr ≤ Ieff ≤ Igr, where M is the maximum service moment. When M is close to Mr the bracket is small and Ieff approaches Igr; when M is many times Mr, Ieff approaches Icr/1.2 limited to Icr.
  6. Shrinkage deflection (Annex C, C-3.1): acs = k3 ψcs l², with k3 = 0.5 for cantilevers, 0.125 for simply supported members, 0.086 for members continuous at one end and 0.063 for fully continuous members, and ψcs = k4 εcs/D. Here εcs is the ultimate shrinkage strain, 0.0003 in the absence of test data (cl. 6.2.4.1), and k4 = 0.72 (pt − pc)/√pt ≤ 1.0 for 0.25 ≤ pt − pc < 1.0, or 0.65 (pt − pc)/√pt ≤ 1.0 for pt − pc ≥ 1.0.
  7. Creep deflection (Annex C, C-4.1): compute the deflection under permanent load once with Ec and once with Ece = Ec/(1 + θ), each with its own Ieff; the creep part is acc = ai,cc(perm) − ai(perm).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Limits: final deflection ≤ span/250; after partitions and finishes ≤ span/350 or 20 mm, whichever is less (mm)
  • Allowable span/effective depth = basic ratio (7, 20 or 26) × 10/span for spans over 10 m × kt × kc (dimensionless)
  • Service steel stress for Fig. 4: fs = 0.58 fy × Ast,required/Ast,provided (N/mm²)
  • Cracking moment: Mr = fcr Igr/yt with fcr = 0.7 √fck (N mm; fcr and fck in N/mm²)
  • Cracked section: b x²/2 = m Ast (d − x); Icr = b x³/3 + m Ast (d − x)² (mm, mm⁴)
  • Effective inertia: Ieff = Icr/[1.2 − (Mr/M)(z/d)(1 − x/d)(bw/b)], Icr ≤ Ieff ≤ Igr (mm⁴)
  • Short-term deflection, simply supported uniform load: a = 5 w l⁴/(384 Ec Ieff) (mm; w in N/mm, l in mm)
  • Shrinkage: acs = k3 ψcs l², ψcs = k4 εcs/D (mm; ψcs in 1/mm)
  • Creep: Ece = Ec/(1 + θ); acc = ai,cc(perm) − ai(perm) (N/mm², mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • Service loads are taken with partial safety factor 1.0; the permanent part of the load (dead load plus any sustained live load) is what causes creep.
  • Concrete is linear elastic in compression at service stresses, steel is elastic, plane sections remain plane, and the cracked section carries no tension below the neutral axis (the effective inertia then adds back the stiffening between cracks).
  • The span/depth method is calibrated for ordinary beams and slabs with uniformly distributed load; it does not cover heavy concentrated loads, members supporting brittle partitions on long spans without further checks, or very slender members.
  • The textbook curve fit to Fig. 4 reproduces the graph only approximately; where the result is close to the limit, read the figure.
  • Limits: values of creep coefficient and shrinkage strain are code defaults for when test data are absent; for long-span or deflection-critical structures the code itself advises determining actual creep strains, and staged construction or early loading of slabs changes the answer.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 23.2 (a) final deflection ≤ span/250, (b) deflection after partitions and finishes ≤ span/350 or 20 mm, whichever is less; cl. 23.2.1 (a) basic span/effective depth ratios 7 (cantilever), 20 (simply supported), 26 (continuous) for spans up to 10 m, (b) × 10/span for longer spans except cantilevers, (c) Fig. 4 factor for tension steel with fs = 0.58 fy × area required/area provided, (d) Fig. 5 factor for compression steel, (e) Fig. 6 for flanged beams; Note: Annex C may be used to calculate deflections.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 6.2.2 (flexural strength 0.7 √fck), cl. 6.2.3.1 (Ec = 5 000 √fck), cl. 6.2.4.1 (total shrinkage strain 0.0003), cl. 6.2.5.1 (creep coefficient 2.2, 1.6 and 1.1 for loading at 7 days, 28 days and 1 year); Annex C, C-1.1 (total = short-term + shrinkage + creep), C-2.1 (Ieff and Mr), C-3.1 (k3 = 0.5, 0.125, 0.086, 0.063; k4 = 0.72 (pt − pc)/√pt or 0.65 (pt − pc)/√pt, not more than 1.0), C-4.1 (Ece = Ec/(1 + θ)).
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) offers both limiting span/depth expressions that depend on the reinforcement ratio and structural system, and a calculation method that interpolates between uncracked and fully cracked curvatures; the American code (ACI 318) gives minimum thickness tables for members not supporting partitions likely to be damaged, and an effective moment of inertia expression for calculated deflections, with a multiplier for long-term effects. The coefficients differ and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: span/depth check)

Problem. A simply supported beam of 6 m effective span is 230 mm wide with an effective depth of 410 mm, in M20 concrete with Fe 415 steel. Design for flexure needs 1 050 mm² of tension steel and three 22 mm bars are provided. Check deflection by cl. 23.2.1.

  1. Steel provided: 3 × 380.1 = 1 140 mm²; pt = 100 × 1 140/(230 × 410) = 1.21 per cent.
  2. Service stress for Fig. 4: fs = 0.58 × 415 × 1 050/1 140 = 221.6 N/mm².
  3. Fig. 4 at pt = 1.21 per cent and fs ≈ 222 N/mm² gives a factor close to 1.0 (the textbook curve fit gives 1.01).
  4. Allowable l/d = 20 × 1.01 = 20.2; actual l/d = 6 000/410 = 14.6, which is less, so deflection is acceptable without calculation.
  5. The smallest effective depth that would pass is 6 000/20.2 = 297 mm.

Answer. Actual l/d 14.6 ≤ allowable 20.2: deflection acceptable

Example 2 (design style: Annex C calculation)

Problem. A simply supported beam of 6 m span, 300 mm wide and 600 mm deep (d = 550 mm), M25 concrete, has four 20 mm Fe 415 bars at the bottom and no compression steel. Service loads are 20 kN/m permanent (including self-weight) and 10 kN/m live. Loading starts at 28 days. Find the short-term, shrinkage, creep and total deflections and compare them with cl. 23.2.

  1. Ec = 5 000 √25 = 25 000 N/mm²; m = 200 000/25 000 = 8; Ast = 1 257 mm²; Igr = 300 × 600³/12 = 5.4 × 10⁹ mm⁴; fcr = 0.7 √25 = 3.5 N/mm²; Mr = 3.5 × 5.4 × 10⁹/300 = 63.0 kN m.
  2. Cracked section: 150 x² = 8 × 1 257 (550 − x) gives x = 161.4 mm; Icr = 300 × 161.4³/3 + 8 × 1 257 × 388.6² = 1.939 × 10⁹ mm⁴; z = 550 − 161.4/3 = 496.2 mm.
  3. Total service moment M = 30 × 6²/8 = 135 kN m: bracket = 1.2 − (63.0/135)(496.2/550)(1 − 161.4/550) = 0.903; Ieff = 1.939 × 10⁹/0.903 = 2.148 × 10⁹ mm⁴; short-term deflection = 5 × 30 × 6 000⁴/(384 × 25 000 × 2.148 × 10⁹) = 9.43 mm.
  4. Permanent load alone (M = 90 kN m): Ieff = 2.572 × 10⁹ mm⁴ and ai(perm) = 5.25 mm.
  5. Shrinkage: pt = 0.76, k4 = 0.72 × 0.76/√0.76 = 0.628, ψcs = 0.628 × 0.0003/600 = 3.14 × 10⁻⁷ per mm; acs = 0.125 × 3.14 × 10⁻⁷ × 6 000² = 1.41 mm.
  6. Creep: θ = 1.6, Ece = 25 000/2.6 = 9 615 N/mm², m = 20.8; x = 234.5 mm, Icr = 3.891 × 10⁹ mm⁴, Ieff = 4.549 × 10⁹ mm⁴; ai,cc(perm) = 7.72 mm, so the creep deflection is 7.72 − 5.25 = 2.47 mm.
  7. Total = 9.43 + 1.41 + 2.47 = 13.3 mm ≤ 6 000/250 = 24 mm. Taking all shrinkage and creep plus the live-load part (9.43 − 5.25 = 4.18 mm) as occurring after the partitions gives 8.1 mm ≤ the lesser of 6 000/350 = 17.1 mm and 20 mm.

Answer. Total 13.3 mm ≤ 24 mm; after partitions about 8.1 mm ≤ 17.1 mm: both limits met

Example 3 (site style: a cantilever that only just passes)

Problem. A 2.4 m cantilever beam supporting a canopy is 230 mm wide with d = 300 mm, M20 and Fe 415. Design needs 520 mm² of top steel and the drawing shows three 16 mm bars. The site engineer asks whether deflection has been checked, and what happens if one more bar is added.

  1. Actual l/d = 2 400/300 = 8.0; basic ratio for a cantilever is 7.
  2. Three 16 mm bars: 603 mm², pt = 0.87 per cent, fs = 0.58 × 415 × 520/603 = 207.5 N/mm²; the Fig. 4 factor is about 1.17 (curve fit 1.167), so the allowable ratio is 7 × 1.17 = 8.17. It passes, but only by about 2 per cent.
  3. Four 16 mm bars: 804 mm², pt = 1.17 per cent, fs = 155.6 N/mm²; the factor rises to about 1.30, so the allowable ratio becomes 9.12, a comfortable margin.
  4. Because the span is below 10 m the 10/span reduction does not apply; for a cantilever longer than 10 m the code requires a deflection calculation instead.
  5. Recommendation: adopt four bars (or confirm by an Annex C calculation), because cantilever tips also rotate with their support and deflection complaints on canopies are common.

Answer. Three bars: 8.0 ≤ 8.17 (marginal); four bars: 8.0 ≤ 9.12 (comfortable)

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Choose the deflection criterion: span/250 for the final deflection and the lesser of span/350 and 20 mm after partitions and finishes (cl. 23.2).
  2. For routine members, apply the span/depth method: basic ratio 7, 20 or 26; × 10/span for spans above 10 m (not for cantilevers); × the Fig. 4 factor using fs = 0.58 fy × Ast,req/Ast,prov; × the Fig. 5 factor if compression steel is provided; Fig. 6 for flanged beams.
  3. If the actual ratio exceeds the allowable one, increase depth, add tension steel (lowering fs), add compression steel, or calculate deflection by Annex C.
  4. For an Annex C calculation, find Ec, m, Igr, Mr, x, Icr, z and Ieff under total service moment; compute the short-term deflection with elastic formulas.
  5. Add shrinkage deflection k3 ψcs l² and creep deflection from Ece = Ec/(1 + θ) under permanent load; compare the total and the post-partition part with the limits.
  6. Record the camber, propping and striking times assumed, because early loading of young concrete increases creep.

Site notes

  • Do not strike soffit formwork or remove props early on long spans: young concrete has a low modulus and a high creep coefficient (2.2 at 7 days against 1.6 at 28 days).
  • Stacking bricks, cement bags or steel on a freshly cast slab can load it beyond its design service load at the age when it is weakest in creep.
  • Partitions built immediately after de-propping pick up almost all of the long-term deflection; where possible build them late or leave a soft joint at the soffit.
  • Measure the as-built depth and cover; a slab cast 15 mm thinner than drawn can lose a large share of its stiffness.
  • Cracks in partition walls diagonal from the corners of openings are often a sign of excessive deflection of the floor below or above them.
Common mistakes
  • Using the basic ratio without the Fig. 4 modification factor, or computing fs with fy instead of 0.58 fy × Ast,req/Ast,prov.
  • Applying the 10/span reduction to a cantilever instead of calculating its deflection.
  • Using the gross moment of inertia of a cracked member for deflection, which can underestimate deflection by a factor of two or more.
  • Forgetting long-term deflection: shrinkage and creep can be as large as the short-term deflection itself.
  • Using the overall depth D in the span/effective depth ratio of cl. 23.2.1, which is defined with the effective depth d.
Quick check

For Fe 415 steel provided exactly as required (fs ≈ 241 N/mm²), the Fig. 4 factor is about 1.0 at 1 per cent steel and about 1.33 at 0.4 per cent; for Fe 500 it is about 0.86 at 1 per cent. So a simply supported Fe 415 beam with about 1 per cent steel needs l/d of about 20 or less. With θ = 1.6, creep makes the deflection under permanent load grow to between about 1.4 times (heavily cracked section, as in Example 2) and 2.6 times (uncracked section, 1 + θ) its short-term value.

Summary

  • Serviceability failures (sagging, cracked partitions, ponding) can occur in members that are perfectly safe against collapse, so deflection is checked under service loads.
  • IS 456 limits final deflection to span/250 and the deflection after partitions and finishes to span/350 or 20 mm, whichever is less.
  • The span/effective depth method uses basic ratios 7, 20 and 26, a 10/span reduction for spans above 10 m, and modification factors for tension steel (Fig. 4), compression steel (Fig. 5) and flanges (Fig. 6).
  • Annex C calculates deflection with an effective moment of inertia between Icr and Igr, a cracking moment from fcr = 0.7 √fck, and long-term additions for shrinkage and creep.
  • More steel lowers the service stress and raises the permitted ratio; more depth is the most effective cure of all.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the basic span/effective depth ratio for a 12 m simply supported beam before steel modification.

20 × 10/12 = 16.7.

2Find fs for Fig. 4 for Fe 500 steel where the steel provided is 1/0.9 times the steel required.

fs = 0.58 × 500 × 0.9 = 261 N/mm².

3Find the cracking moment of a 230 × 450 mm rectangular beam in M20 concrete.

fcr = 0.7 √20 = 3.13 N/mm²; Igr = 230 × 450³/12 = 1.747 × 10⁹ mm⁴; Mr = 3.13 × 1.747 × 10⁹/225 = 24.3 kN m.

4Find the shrinkage deflection of a 5 m simply supported beam with D = 500 mm, pt = 0.8 per cent and no compression steel.

k4 = 0.72 × 0.8/√0.8 = 0.644; ψcs = 0.644 × 0.0003/500 = 3.86 × 10⁻⁷ per mm; acs = 0.125 × 3.86 × 10⁻⁷ × 5 000² = 1.21 mm.

5Find the effective modulus for creep of M25 concrete loaded at 7 days.

Ece = 25 000/(1 + 2.2) = 7 813 N/mm².

6Why does providing extra tension steel improve the span/depth check?

The service stress fs = 0.58 fy × Ast,req/Ast,prov falls, so the steel strain and the curvature at service load fall, and Fig. 4 allows a higher span/depth ratio.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.