Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.1

2.1 Stress block and assumptions

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 2: Limit state of collapse: flexure Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State the assumptions of IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 for flexure at the limit state of collapse and explain the physical reason for each.
  • Derive the parabolic-rectangular stress block constants 0.36 fck xu (force) and 0.42 xu (position) from the design stress–strain curve of concrete.
  • Derive the limiting neutral-axis depths xu,max/d for Fe 250, Fe 415 and Fe 500 from strain compatibility, and use them to tell whether a section will fail by steel yielding or by concrete crushing.

Theory

Chapter 1 set out the limit state method: design loads are factored up and design strengths are factored down. To apply it to a beam we need a model of the section at the moment it fails in bending. A reinforced concrete beam loaded to collapse cracks on the tension side, the cracks rise towards the compression face, and failure comes when the concrete at the top crushes. In a well-designed beam the tension steel has already yielded and stretched a good deal by then, so the beam gives warning by wide cracks and large deflection. The limit state of collapse in flexure is the moment at which the top fibre reaches its crushing strain.

IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 lists the assumptions. Plane sections remain plane, so strain varies linearly with depth. The maximum compressive strain in concrete at the extreme fibre is 0.0035. The concrete stress follows a design curve that rises as a parabola to its peak at a strain of 0.002 and then stays constant up to 0.0035; the peak is 0.67 fck/γm = 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.447 fck, where 0.67 relates the cube strength to the strength of concrete in a real member. The tensile strength of concrete is ignored. The steel stress comes from the representative stress–strain curve of the bar (Fig. 23 of the code), divided by γm = 1.15. Finally, the strain in the tension steel at failure must be at least 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002, so that the steel has clearly yielded.

Limit state of collapse: the IS 456 stress blockNAbxu0.0035εsstrain3/7 xu0.447 fckC = 0.36 fck b xu0.42 xuT = 0.87 fy AststressIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 2.1: Section, strain and stress at the limit state of collapse in flexure: 0.0035 at the top fibre, linear strain to the steel, and the IS 456 parabolic-rectangular stress block whose resultant 0.36 fck b xu acts 0.42 xu below the top, balanced by the steel force 0.87 fy Ast. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Because the strain is linear and the concrete curve is fixed, the shape of the compressive stress diagram is the same for every section: the stress is uniform over the top 3/7 of the neutral-axis depth xu (where the strain exceeds 0.002) and parabolic over the lower 4/7. Its area and centroid can therefore be worked out once and for all. The resultant is 0.36 fck b xu and it acts 0.42 xu below the compression face (code Fig. 22). With these two numbers the whole flexural design of rectangular, doubly reinforced and flanged sections in this chapter follows from two equations: force equilibrium C = T and moment Mu = C × lever arm.

Strain compatibility ties the neutral axis to the steel. With 0.0035 at the top and xu known, the steel strain is 0.0035 (d − xu)/xu. Setting it equal to the minimum strain of cl. 38.1 gives the largest neutral-axis depth for which the steel still yields well: xu,max/d = 0.53 for Fe 250, 0.48 for Fe 415 and 0.46 for Fe 500 (Note below cl. 38.1). A section whose computed xu is below xu,max is under-reinforced and fails in a ductile way; one at xu,max is balanced in the code sense; one above it is over-reinforced, the steel does not yield before the concrete crushes, and the failure is sudden. IS 456 (Annex G, G-1.1) asks for an over-reinforced section to be redesigned.

Derivation

  1. Strain: with the top fibre at εcu = 0.0035 and the neutral axis at depth xu, the strain at depth y below the top is ε = 0.0035 (xu − y)/xu. The strain 0.002 occurs at a distance (0.002/0.0035) xu = (4/7) xu above the neutral axis, so the top (3/7) xu carries the uniform peak stress.
  2. Peak stress: fc,max = 0.67 fck/1.5 = 0.4467 fck (often written 0.446 fck). Uniform part: force C1 = 0.4467 fck × b × (3/7) xu = 0.1914 fck b xu, acting at (3/14) xu from the top.
  3. Parabolic part: over the lower (4/7) xu the stress rises from zero at the neutral axis as f = fc,max (2η − η²), where η is the distance from the neutral axis divided by (4/7) xu. Its area is (2/3) × fc,max × (4/7) xu, so C2 = 0.1702 fck b xu, and its centroid is (5/8) × (4/7) xu = (5/14) xu above the neutral axis, that is (9/14) xu below the top.
  4. Total compression: C = C1 + C2 = 0.4467 × (17/21) fck b xu = 0.3616 fck b xu, rounded to 0.36 fck b xu. Its position below the top: (C1 × 3/14 + C2 × 9/14)/C × xu = (99/238) xu = 0.416 xu, rounded to 0.42 xu.
  5. Limiting neutral axis: put the steel strain equal to the minimum of cl. 38.1, εs = 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002. From similar triangles xu,max/d = 0.0035/(0.0035 + εs). With Es = 200 000 N/mm²: Fe 250 gives 0.0035/0.006588 = 0.531; Fe 415 gives 0.0035/0.007305 = 0.479; Fe 500 gives 0.0035/0.007675 = 0.456, quoted as 0.53, 0.48 and 0.46.
  6. Limiting moment: with xu = xu,max, Mu,lim = 0.36 fck b xu,max (d − 0.42 xu,max) = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) fck b d². The coefficient is 0.148 for Fe 250, 0.138 for Fe 415 and 0.134 (often written 0.133) for Fe 500.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Design peak stress of concrete in flexure: fc,max = 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.447 fck (N/mm²)
  • Compression force: C = 0.36 fck b xu (N, with fck in N/mm² and b, xu in mm); acting 0.42 xu below the compression face (mm)
  • Strain at depth y: ε = 0.0035 (xu − y)/xu (dimensionless); steel strain εs = 0.0035 (d − xu)/xu
  • Minimum steel strain at collapse (cl. 38.1): εs ≥ 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002, with Es = 200 000 N/mm² (dimensionless)
  • Limiting neutral axis: xu,max/d = 0.0035/(0.0055 + 0.87 fy/Es) = 0.53 (Fe 250), 0.48 (Fe 415), 0.46 (Fe 500) (dimensionless)
  • Limiting moment of resistance: Mu,lim = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) fck b d² = 0.148, 0.138 and 0.133 fck b d² for Fe 250, 415 and 500 (N mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • Plane sections normal to the axis remain plane after bending, so strain is proportional to the distance from the neutral axis; bond between steel and concrete is perfect.
  • The maximum compressive strain in the extreme fibre is 0.0035 in bending, whatever the grade of concrete (IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1).
  • Concrete stress follows the design parabolic-rectangular curve with a peak of 0.67 fck/1.5 reached at a strain of 0.002; the tensile strength of concrete is ignored.
  • Steel stress follows the representative stress–strain curve of the bar with γm = 1.15, so the design yield stress is 0.87 fy; the elastic modulus is Es = 200 000 N/mm² (cl. 5.6.3).
  • Limits: the stress block is for flexure with the neutral axis inside the section; when the whole section is in compression (columns with small eccentricity) the strain limits of the compression clauses apply instead. The 0.0035 strain is a design value for ordinary concretes; very high-strength or confined concrete behaves differently, and the block does not describe service-load behaviour, cracking or deflection.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 (assumptions (a) to (f) for flexure at the limit state of collapse, with the design stress–strain curve of concrete in Fig. 21, the stress block parameters 0.36 fck xu and 0.42 xu in Fig. 22, and representative steel curves in Fig. 23); the Note below cl. 38.1 gives xu,max/d = 0.53, 0.48 and 0.46 for Fe 250, Fe 415 and Fe 500. Annex G, G-1.1 gives the moment of resistance of rectangular sections and requires an over-reinforced section to be redesigned.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 36.4.2.1 (γm = 1.5 for concrete and 1.15 for steel) and cl. 5.6.3 (Es = 200 kN/mm²); reinforcing bars to IS 1786.
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) also uses a parabola-rectangle curve with a limiting compressive strain and allows a simplified rectangular block; the American code (ACI 318) uses an equivalent rectangular stress block with a limiting compressive strain and classifies sections by the net tensile strain of the steel. The strain limits and block factors differ between codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: stress block constants and limiting depths)

Problem. Starting from the design stress–strain curve of IS 456, work out the force and position constants of the stress block, the limiting neutral-axis depth ratios for Fe 250, Fe 415 and Fe 500, and the corresponding coefficients of Mu,lim/(fck b d²).

  1. Peak design stress 0.67/1.5 = 0.4467 fck; the strain 0.002 lies at (4/7) xu above the neutral axis, so the uniform part is (3/7) xu deep.
  2. Force: 0.4467 × (3/7 + (2/3)(4/7)) = 0.4467 × 17/21 = 0.3616, so C = 0.36 fck b xu.
  3. Position: (3/7 × 3/14 + 8/21 × 9/14)/(17/21) = 0.416, so C acts at 0.42 xu.
  4. Fe 250: εs = 0.87 × 250/200 000 + 0.002 = 0.003088; xu,max/d = 0.0035/0.006588 = 0.531. Fe 415: εs = 0.003805; xu,max/d = 0.479. Fe 500: εs = 0.004175; xu,max/d = 0.456.
  5. Mu,lim/(fck b d²) = 0.36 k (1 − 0.42 k) = 0.148 (k = 0.53), 0.138 (k = 0.48) and 0.134 (k = 0.46).

Answer. C = 0.36 fck b xu at 0.42 xu; xu,max/d = 0.53, 0.48, 0.46; Mu,lim = 0.148, 0.138, 0.133 to 0.134 fck b d²

Example 2 (checking the block by parts)

Problem. A 300 mm wide section of M25 concrete has its neutral axis 200 mm below the top at collapse. Find the compressive force and its position by splitting the stress diagram into its uniform and parabolic parts, and compare with the 0.36 fck b xu and 0.42 xu rule.

  1. Peak stress 0.67 × 25/1.5 = 11.17 N/mm². Uniform depth (3/7) × 200 = 85.7 mm; parabolic depth 114.3 mm.
  2. Uniform part: 11.17 × 300 × 85.7 = 287.1 kN at 42.9 mm from the top.
  3. Parabolic part: (2/3) × 11.17 × 300 × 114.3 = 255.2 kN at (9/14) × 200 = 128.6 mm from the top.
  4. Total C = 542.4 kN at (287.1 × 42.9 + 255.2 × 128.6)/542.4 = 83.2 mm from the top.
  5. Rule: 0.36 × 25 × 300 × 200 = 540 kN at 0.42 × 200 = 84 mm, within 0.5 per cent and 1 mm of the exact values.

Answer. C = 542 kN at 83 mm by parts; the rule gives 540 kN at 84 mm

Example 3 (site style: will the steel yield?)

Problem. A design check on a beam reinforced with Fe 500 bars finds xu/d = 0.55 at collapse; a revised design gives xu/d = 0.40. For each, find the steel strain at failure, compare with the cl. 38.1 minimum, and read the steel stress from the Fe 500 design curve.

  1. Minimum strain for Fe 500: 0.87 × 500/200 000 + 0.002 = 0.004175 (the design curve reaches 0.87 fy = 434.8 N/mm² at a strain of 0.00417).
  2. xu/d = 0.55: εs = 0.0035 × (1 − 0.55)/0.55 = 0.00286, well below 0.00417.
  3. On the Fe 500 design curve this strain lies between the points 413.0 N/mm² at 0.00277 and 423.9 N/mm² at 0.00312, giving about 416 N/mm²: the bar has not reached 0.87 fy, and the section is over-reinforced (xu/d above 0.46), so it must be redesigned.
  4. xu/d = 0.40: εs = 0.0035 × 0.60/0.40 = 0.00525, above 0.00417, so the steel is at 434.8 N/mm² and the section is under-reinforced.

Answer. xu/d 0.55: εs = 0.0029, steel about 416 N/mm², over-reinforced, redesign; xu/d 0.40: εs = 0.0053, steel yields

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Fix the materials: fck from the concrete grade, fy from the steel grade; design stresses 0.447 fck (concrete peak) and 0.87 fy (steel).
  2. Draw the strain diagram with 0.0035 at the compression face and a trial neutral-axis depth xu.
  3. Replace the concrete compression by C = 0.36 fck b xu acting at 0.42 xu from the top.
  4. Find the steel strain from similar triangles and the steel stress from its design curve (0.87 fy once the strain exceeds the yield strain).
  5. Use force equilibrium C = T to fix xu, then compare xu/d with 0.53, 0.48 or 0.46 for the steel grade.
  6. Take moments of C about the steel (or T about C) to find Mu; redesign if xu exceeds xu,max.

Site notes

  • The stress block assumes the specified concrete grade is achieved in the compression zone; poor compaction at the top of a beam, where laitance collects, weakens exactly the concrete that the block relies on.
  • Substituting a higher steel grade for the one on the drawing (for example Fe 500 for Fe 415 with the same bar areas) increases the tension force and the neutral-axis depth and lowers xu,max; it can turn an under-reinforced beam into an over-reinforced one. Any substitution needs a design check.
  • Ductility comes from steel yielding before the concrete crushes; adding extra bars 'for safety' in a beam already near xu,max can reduce ductility rather than improve it.
  • Bar positions matter: d is measured to the centroid of the tension steel, so bars placed lower or higher than shown change d and therefore xu/d and the strength.
  • Cover blocks that are too thick reduce d; those that are too thin harm durability. Both change the flexural strength used in design.
Common mistakes
  • Using 0.67 fck or fck as the peak design stress instead of 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.447 fck.
  • Placing the compression force at xu/2 or xu/3 (rectangular or elastic triangle) instead of 0.42 xu.
  • Using 0.48 as xu,max/d for every steel grade; it is 0.53, 0.48 and 0.46 for Fe 250, 415 and 500.
  • Assuming the steel always yields; it yields only when xu/d is below the limiting value.
  • Forgetting that the concrete below the neutral axis carries no tension in this model.
Quick check

The stress block constants are 0.36 and 0.42; for any section C = 0.36 fck b xu acts 0.42 xu from the top. The limiting ratios fall as the steel grade rises (0.53, 0.48, 0.46), and Mu,lim is about 0.15, 0.14 and 0.13 fck b d². If a computed xu/d is above about 0.5 for Fe 415 or Fe 500, the section is over-reinforced and must be redesigned.

Summary

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 models a section at collapse: plane sections, 0.0035 crushing strain, parabolic-rectangular concrete stress with a 0.447 fck peak, no concrete tension, and steel at its design curve.
  • The stress block resultant is 0.36 fck b xu acting 0.42 xu below the compression face; both numbers come from integrating the design curve.
  • Strain compatibility gives the steel strain 0.0035 (d − xu)/xu; the minimum steel strain 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002 sets xu,max/d = 0.53, 0.48 and 0.46.
  • Sections with xu below xu,max are under-reinforced and ductile; sections above it are over-reinforced, fail suddenly and must be redesigned.
  • The limiting moment is Mu,lim = 0.36 (xu,max/d)(1 − 0.42 xu,max/d) fck b d², about 0.148, 0.138 and 0.133 fck b d² for the three steel grades.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1What is the peak design stress of M30 concrete in the flexural stress block?

0.67 × 30/1.5 = 13.4 N/mm² (0.447 fck).

2At what depth below the top does the concrete strain equal 0.002 if xu = 210 mm?

The strain 0.002 is at (4/7) × 210 = 120 mm above the neutral axis, that is 90 mm below the top (3/7 of xu).

3Find xu,max for a beam with d = 500 mm and Fe 415 steel.

0.48 × 500 = 240 mm.

4Find the compression force and its position for b = 250 mm, xu = 150 mm, M20.

C = 0.36 × 20 × 250 × 150 = 270 kN, acting 0.42 × 150 = 63 mm below the top.

5Find Mu,lim for b = 230 mm, d = 450 mm, M25 and Fe 500.

0.133 × 25 × 230 × 450² = 154.9 kN m (0.1336 gives 155.6 kN m).

6Why is xu,max/d smaller for Fe 500 than for Fe 415?

The higher grade needs a larger strain (0.00417 against 0.00380) before it yields fully, and a larger steel strain with the same 0.0035 at the top means a shallower neutral axis.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.