Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 8 › Lesson 8.1

8.1 Cantilever retaining walls

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 8: Special structures Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Find the active earth pressure on a cantilever retaining wall by Rankine theory, including a uniform surcharge, and locate its resultant.
  • Check a trial wall section for overturning, sliding and base pressure, using the stability rules of IS 456:2000 cl. 20.1 and 20.2 with earth pressure treated as an imposed load.
  • Design and detail the stem, heel and toe as cantilever slabs at the limit state of collapse, with minimum steel, shear, bar spacing and anchorage checks.

Theory

A retaining wall holds back soil that would otherwise slump to its natural slope: at a basement, a road cutting, a bridge approach or a terraced site. The soil pushes sideways on the wall, and the wall must neither tip over, slide forward nor press the ground under it harder than the ground can take. A cantilever retaining wall does this with an inverted T or L of reinforced concrete: a vertical stem fixed into a base slab. The part of the base in front of the stem is the toe; the part behind it, under the retained soil, is the heel.

The cleverness of the cantilever wall is that the soil standing on the heel becomes part of the structure. Its weight presses the heel down and supplies most of the moment that resists overturning, so the concrete itself can be quite thin. Each of the three parts is a cantilever slab fixed at the junction: the stem bends under the earth pressure with tension on the soil face, the heel is pushed down by the soil above it and bends with tension on top, and the toe is pushed up by the ground pressure and bends with tension underneath. The main steel therefore sits on the soil face of the stem, the top of the heel and the bottom of the toe.

Cantilever retaining wall: forcesPa at H/3retained soiltoeheelstembase pressure: higher under the toe
Figure 8.1: A cantilever retaining wall in section: stem, toe and heel, the retained soil standing on the heel, the triangular active pressure with its resultant at H/3, and the ground pressure under the base. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The sideways pressure of a dry, cohesionless backfill is usually found by Rankine theory. When the wall yields slightly away from the soil, the soil reaches its active state and the horizontal pressure at depth z is Ka γ z, where Ka = (1 − sin φ)/(1 + sin φ) for a level backfill and a smooth vertical back. The pressure grows linearly with depth, so its resultant Ka γ H²/2 acts at H/3 above the base. A uniform surcharge q on the backfill adds a constant pressure Ka q over the full height, whose resultant acts at H/2. Water behind the wall adds full hydrostatic pressure, which is why weep holes and a drainage layer are part of every design.

IS 456:2000 has no clause devoted to retaining walls, but its stability rules apply to the wall as a whole. Cl. 20.1 asks that the restoring moment, counting only 0.9 times the characteristic dead load, be at least 1.2 times the overturning moment from dead load plus 1.4 times that from imposed loads. Cl. 20.2 asks for a factor against sliding of at least 1.4 with only 0.9 times the dead load counted. Indian textbooks treat the earth pressure as an imposed load in these checks, so they reduce to 0.9 Mr ≥ 1.4 Mo and 0.9 μ W ≥ 1.4 Pa: in conventional terms, a factor of safety of 1.4/0.9 = 1.56 on both. The ground pressure under the base is checked separately against the safe bearing capacity with service loads, as for a footing (lesson 7.1).

Once the section is stable, the parts are designed as slabs at the limit state of collapse with the loads multiplied by 1.5 (cl. 36.4.1). The stem moment at the base grows with the cube of the height, so tall walls have stems tapering from a thick base to a thin top and alternate bars can be stopped part-way up, extended beyond the theoretical cut-off as cl. 26.2.3.1 requires. Shear is usually low enough for the concrete alone, and in slabs at least 300 mm thick the slab factor k of cl. 40.2.1.1 is 1.0. Minimum steel of 0.12 per cent for high strength deformed bars (cl. 26.5.2.1) often governs the base, and horizontal distribution steel in the stem controls shrinkage and temperature cracking along the length of the wall.

Derivation

  1. Rankine active coefficient: in the active state the larger principal stress is vertical, σv = γ z, and the smaller is horizontal, σh. For a cohesionless soil at failure, σh/σv = (1 − sin φ)/(1 + sin φ) = tan²(45° − φ/2) = Ka, so σh = Ka γ z.
  2. Resultant of the triangular pressure: Pa = ∫ Ka γ z dz from 0 to H = Ka γ H²/2, and its moment about the base is ∫ Ka γ z (H − z) dz = Ka γ H³/6, so the lever arm is (Ka γ H³/6)/(Ka γ H²/2) = H/3.
  3. Surcharge: a uniform q adds σh = Ka q at every depth, so Ps = Ka q H acting at H/2.
  4. Overturning about the toe: Mo = Pa H/3 (+ Ps H/2). Restoring moment Mr = Σ Wi xi, the weights of the stem, base and the soil on the heel times their lever arms from the toe. IS 456 cl. 20.1 with earth pressure as imposed load: 0.9 Mr ≥ 1.4 Mo.
  5. Sliding: the base friction available is μ W, with μ the coefficient of friction between base and soil. IS 456 cl. 20.2: 0.9 μ W ≥ 1.4 Pa (passive resistance in front of the toe is normally ignored because the soil there may be dug away).
  6. Base pressure: the resultant meets the base at x̄ = (Mr − Mo)/W from the toe, an eccentricity e = B/2 − x̄. With the linear pressure q = W/B ± 6 W e/B² the extreme values are q = (W/B)(1 ± 6e/B); there is no lift-off while e ≤ B/6.
  7. Stem design moment at its base, height h above the top of the base slab: Mu = 1.5 Ka γ h³/6 per metre run; the shear at a section y below the top is Vu = 1.5 Ka γ y²/2.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Ka = (1 − sin φ)/(1 + sin φ) (dimensionless; φ = angle of internal friction)
  • Pa = Ka γ H²/2 (kN/m; γ in kN/m³, H in m), acting at H/3 above the base
  • Surcharge: Ps = Ka q H (kN/m; q in kN/m²), acting at H/2
  • Overturning (IS 456 cl. 20.1, earth pressure as imposed load): 0.9 Mr ≥ 1.4 Mo (kN m per m)
  • Sliding (IS 456 cl. 20.2): 0.9 μ W ≥ 1.4 Pa (kN per m)
  • Base pressure: q max, min = (W/B)(1 ± 6e/B) (kN/m²), valid for e ≤ B/6; e = B/2 − (Mr − Mo)/W
  • Stem: Mu = 1.5 Ka γ h³/6 (kN m per m); Ast = 0.5 (fck/fy) [1 − √(1 − 4.6 Mu/(fck b d²))] b d (mm²)
  • Minimum steel in each slab part: 0.12 per cent of b D for high strength deformed bars (cl. 26.5.2.1)
Assumptions and limits
  • Rankine theory: level, dry, cohesionless backfill, vertical smooth back (the vertical plane through the heel end is used, with the soil on the heel counted as part of the wall), and enough wall movement to mobilise the active state. A wall that cannot yield, such as a propped basement wall, carries the higher at-rest pressure.
  • No water pressure behind the wall: this relies on working weep holes and a free-draining backfill. If drainage cannot be guaranteed, full water pressure must be added.
  • Soil on the toe and passive resistance in front of the toe are ignored in the stability checks; both may be removed by future excavation.
  • Earth pressure is treated as an imposed load in the IS 456 cl. 20.1 and 20.2 checks, as in standard Indian textbooks; the safe bearing capacity and the base friction coefficient come from the geotechnical report.
  • Linear ground pressure under a rigid base. The method is for walls up to about 6 to 7 m high; taller walls are usually counterfort walls, in which the stem spans between buttresses.
  • Structural design uses a load factor of 1.5 on all the soil, earth-pressure and self-weight loads, a common simplification for walls of this kind.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 20.1 (restoring moment with 0.9 times the dead load at least 1.2 times the dead-load overturning moment plus 1.4 times the imposed-load overturning moment) and cl. 20.2 (factor against sliding at least 1.4, with only 0.9 times the dead load counted).
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 36.4.1 with Table 18 (load factor 1.5 for the structural design), cl. 26.5.2.1 (minimum 0.12 per cent steel in slabs with high strength deformed bars), cl. 26.3.3 (main bars at not more than 3d or 300 mm; distribution bars at not more than 5d or 450 mm), cl. 40.2.1 with Table 19 and cl. 40.2.1.1 (shear strength of concrete in slabs, k = 1.0 for slabs 300 mm or more thick), cl. 26.2.1 (development length), cl. 26.2.3.1 (bars extend beyond the theoretical cut-off by d or 12 bar diameters, whichever is greater) and cl. 26.4.2.2 (50 mm minimum cover for footings, used here for the base slab). Bars to IS 1786.
  • EN 1997-1 (Eurocode 7) checks a retaining wall for overturning, sliding and bearing with partial factors on actions and on soil strength, and EN 1992-1-1 designs the concrete. ACI 318 designs the concrete members, with the stability checks usually done by allowable-stress factors of safety from geotechnical practice. The approaches are listed side by side, not ranked.

Worked examples

Example 1 (stability of a trial section, exam style)

Problem. A cantilever wall retains 4.5 m of level, dry backfill (γ = 18 kN/m³, φ = 30°) measured from the underside of the base. Trial section: base 3.0 m wide and 450 mm thick, toe 0.8 m, stem 400 mm thick at the base tapering on the front face to 200 mm at the top, heel 1.8 m. Concrete 25 kN/m³, coefficient of friction 0.5, safe bearing capacity 160 kN/m². Check overturning, sliding and base pressure.

  1. Ka = (1 − sin 30°)/(1 + sin 30°) = 1/3. Pa = (1/3) × 18 × 4.5²/2 = 60.75 kN/m, acting at 4.5/3 = 1.5 m; Mo = 91.13 kN m per m.
  2. Stem height above the base = 4.5 − 0.45 = 4.05 m. Weights and lever arms from the toe: stem rectangle 0.2 × 4.05 × 25 = 20.25 kN at 1.10 m (22.28 kN m); stem triangle 0.5 × 0.2 × 4.05 × 25 = 10.13 kN at 0.933 m (9.45 kN m); base 3.0 × 0.45 × 25 = 33.75 kN at 1.50 m (50.63 kN m); soil on the heel 1.8 × 4.05 × 18 = 131.22 kN at 2.10 m (275.56 kN m).
  3. W = 195.35 kN/m; Mr = 357.91 kN m per m.
  4. Overturning: 0.9 Mr = 322.1 kN m ≥ 1.4 Mo = 127.6 kN m. Safe by a wide margin (Mr/Mo = 3.93).
  5. Sliding: 0.9 μ W = 0.9 × 0.5 × 195.35 = 87.9 kN ≥ 1.4 Pa = 85.05 kN. Just safe (μ W/Pa = 1.61 against the 1.56 implied by the code factors). Sliding, not overturning, controls this wall.
  6. Base pressure: x̄ = (357.91 − 91.13)/195.35 = 1.366 m; e = 1.5 − 1.366 = 0.134 m ≤ B/6 = 0.5 m. q = (195.35/3.0)(1 ± 6 × 0.134/3.0) = 65.12 (1 ± 0.269): q max = 82.6 kN/m² under the toe, q min = 47.6 kN/m² at the heel end, both positive and within 160 kN/m².

Answer. Overturning 322.1 ≥ 127.6 kN m, sliding 87.9 ≥ 85.05 kN (just safe), base pressures 82.6 and 47.6 kN/m² with no lift-off: the trial section is acceptable.

Example 2 (stem design, site style)

Problem. Design the stem of the wall in Example 1 at its base. M25 concrete, Fe 415 bars, clear cover 40 mm on the soil face, 16 mm main bars.

  1. Stem height h = 4.05 m. Service moment Ka γ h³/6 = (1/3) × 18 × 4.05³/6 = 66.43 kN m per m; Mu = 1.5 × 66.43 = 99.65 kN m per m.
  2. d = 400 − 40 − 8 = 352 mm. Mu,lim = 0.138 × 25 × 1 000 × 352² = 427.5 kN m, far more than Mu: singly reinforced.
  3. Ast = 0.5 × (25/415) × [1 − √(1 − 4.6 × 99.65 × 10⁶/(25 × 1 000 × 352²))] × 1 000 × 352 = 816 mm² per m. Minimum 0.12 per cent of 1 000 × 400 = 480 mm². Provide 16 mm bars at 240 mm (838 mm²), spacing within 3d and 300 mm.
  4. Shear at d above the base: y = 4.05 − 0.352 = 3.698 m; Vu = 1.5 × (1/3) × 18 × 3.698²/2 = 61.5 kN; τv = 61.5 × 10³/(1 000 × 352) = 0.17 N/mm². With pt = 100 × 838/(1 000 × 352) = 0.238 per cent, τc = 0.35 N/mm² (Table 19, M25), and k = 1.0 because the stem is 400 mm thick. Safe without shear steel.
  5. Anchorage: Ld = 16 × 0.87 × 415/(4 × 1.4 × 1.6) = 645 mm. The base is 450 mm thick, so the stem bars are taken down to the bottom mesh and bent into the base slab to complete the anchorage.
  6. Distribution steel in the stem (horizontal): 0.12 per cent of the average thickness, 0.0012 × 1 000 × 300 = 360 mm² per m; provide 8 mm bars at 250 mm on each face (402 mm²), within 5d and 450 mm.

Answer. Mu = 99.65 kN m per m; 16 mm bars at 240 mm on the soil face (838 mm² ≥ 816 mm²); shear 0.17 ≤ 0.35 N/mm²; Ld = 645 mm achieved by bending into the base; 8 mm at 250 mm horizontal on each face.

Example 3 (heel and toe slabs)

Problem. Design the heel and the toe of the wall in Example 1, using the base pressures found there (82.6 kN/m² under the toe falling linearly to 47.6 kN/m² at the heel end), a load factor of 1.5, M25, Fe 415, 50 mm cover, 12 mm bars, d = 392 mm.

  1. Ground pressure along the base, x from the toe: q(x) = 82.6 − 11.66 x kN/m². At the front face of the stem (x = 0.8 m) q = 73.3 kN/m²; at the back face (x = 1.2 m) q = 68.6 kN/m². Base self-weight 0.45 × 25 = 11.25 kN/m².
  2. Toe: Mu = 1.5 ∫ (q − 11.25)(0.8 − x) dx from 0 to 0.8 = 32.8 kN m per m, needing only 234 mm²; the minimum 0.0012 × 1 000 × 450 = 540 mm² governs. Provide 12 mm at 200 mm at the bottom (565 mm²). Shear at d from the stem face: Vu = 1.5 ∫ (q − 11.25) dx from 0 to 0.408 = 42.2 kN; τv = 0.11 N/mm², well within τc.
  3. Heel: downward load = soil 4.05 × 18 = 72.9 plus self-weight 11.25 = 84.15 kN/m², against the upward ground pressure. Mu = 1.5 ∫ (84.15 − q)(x − 1.2) dx from 1.2 to 3.0 = 71.8 kN m per m, tension on top.
  4. Heel steel: Ast = 519 mm², less than the 540 mm² minimum; provide 12 mm at 200 mm at the top (565 mm²).
  5. Heel shear, taken conservatively at the face of the stem: Vu = 1.5 ∫ (84.15 − q) dx from 1.2 to 3.0 = 70.3 kN; τv = 70.3 × 10³/(1 000 × 392) = 0.18 N/mm² ≤ τc = 0.29 N/mm² (pt = 0.144 per cent, M25). Safe.
  6. Distribution steel at right angles in both slabs: 0.12 per cent, the same 12 mm at 200 mm or an equivalent.

Answer. Toe: Mu = 32.8 kN m per m, minimum steel 12 mm at 200 mm bottom. Heel: Mu = 71.8 kN m per m, 519 mm² needed, minimum 540 mm² governs, 12 mm at 200 mm top; shears 0.11 and 0.18 N/mm², no shear steel.

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Get the retained height, backfill properties (γ, φ), surcharge, groundwater and drainage arrangement, safe bearing capacity and base friction coefficient.
  2. Choose a trial section: base width about 0.5 to 0.7 times the height, toe about one third of the base, stem about one twelfth of the height at the base and 200 mm at the top, base about the same thickness as the stem base.
  3. Find Ka, Pa and any surcharge force, with their lever arms.
  4. List the weights of the stem, base and soil on the heel with their lever arms from the toe; find W and Mr.
  5. Check overturning (0.9 Mr ≥ 1.4 Mo) and sliding (0.9 μ W ≥ 1.4 Pa). If sliding fails, lengthen the heel or add a shear key below the base.
  6. Find x̄, e and the base pressures; check e ≤ B/6 and q max ≤ safe bearing capacity.
  7. Design the stem at its base for Mu = 1.5 Ka γ h³/6, check shear at d, and decide where alternate bars can stop (cl. 26.2.3.1).
  8. Design the heel (tension on top) and the toe (tension at the bottom) from the factored net pressures, with minimum steel and shear checks.
  9. Detail anchorage of the stem bars into the base, distribution steel, weep holes, drainage layer and movement joints.

Site notes

  • The backfill is placed only after the wall concrete has gained strength, in thin compacted layers; heavy rollers are kept back from the stem, because compaction close to the wall raises the pressure above the design value.
  • Weep holes, typically pipes about 100 mm in diameter at 1.5 m to 2 m centres, need a filter of graded aggregate or geotextile behind them, otherwise fines wash out and the holes block.
  • The stem bars are tied into the base mesh before the base is cast; a construction joint at the stem-base junction gets a key or roughened surface, and water bars if the wall must be watertight.
  • Vertical contraction joints are provided along long walls so that shrinkage cracks form at planned positions instead of at random.
  • The founding level is inspected before blinding. A soft spot under the toe raises the pressure there and makes the wall tilt forward.
Common mistakes
  • Putting the main stem steel on the exposed front face; the tension is on the soil face.
  • Forgetting that the heel bends with tension on top, so its main bars go in the top layer.
  • Checking only overturning; sliding usually controls a cantilever wall, as Example 1 shows.
  • Counting passive pressure in front of the toe or soil on the toe that may later be excavated.
  • Leaving out water pressure when the drainage is poor; saturated backfill can more than double the horizontal thrust.
Quick check

Base width about 0.6 H and stem base thickness about H/12 make a good first trial for a cantilever wall on medium soil. For the 4.5 m wall in Example 1, 0.6 × 4.5 = 2.7 m and 4 500/12 = 375 mm, close to the 3.0 m and 400 mm that passed all checks. The guide holds for level, drained backfill and heights up to about 6 m.

Summary

  • Rankine active pressure Ka γ z on a level, dry backfill gives Pa = Ka γ H²/2 at H/3; a surcharge adds Ka q H at H/2.
  • IS 456 cl. 20.1 and 20.2, with earth pressure as an imposed load, become 0.9 Mr ≥ 1.4 Mo and 0.9 μ W ≥ 1.4 Pa.
  • The base pressure must stay positive (e ≤ B/6) and within the safe bearing capacity.
  • The stem, heel and toe are cantilever slabs: tension on the soil face of the stem, the top of the heel and the bottom of the toe.
  • Minimum steel often governs the base, and sliding usually governs stability.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find Ka for a level, dry sand with φ = 36°.

Ka = (1 − sin 36°)/(1 + sin 36°) = (1 − 0.588)/(1 + 0.588) = 0.26.

2A wall retains 6 m of soil with γ = 18 kN/m³ and Ka = 1/3. Find the active thrust and its line of action.

Pa = (1/3) × 18 × 6²/2 = 108 kN/m, acting 2 m above the base.

3A uniform surcharge of 10 kN/m² acts on the backfill of a 5 m wall with Ka = 1/3. Find the extra thrust and where it acts.

Ps = (1/3) × 10 × 5 = 16.7 kN/m, acting at 2.5 m above the base.

4Why do Indian textbooks quote a factor of safety of about 1.55 against overturning and sliding for retaining walls?

IS 456 cl. 20.1 and 20.2 count only 0.9 of the dead load and ask for 1.4 times the imposed-load effect; with earth pressure as an imposed load the ratio is 1.4/0.9 = 1.56.

5A wall base 3 m wide carries W = 300 kN/m with e = 0.6 m. Is there lift-off, and what is the maximum pressure?

B/6 = 0.5 m < 0.6 m, so part of the base lifts off. With a triangular pressure, q max = 2W/(3(B/2 − e)) = 600/(3 × 0.9) = 222.2 kN/m².

6What does a shear key under the base do?

It pushes the sliding surface deeper into the ground and mobilises soil resistance in front of the key, raising the resistance to sliding when the base friction alone is not enough.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.