2.3 Doubly reinforced beams
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain when and why compression reinforcement is used, and split the moment into the limiting moment of the concrete section and the extra moment carried by a steel couple.
- Find the stress in compression steel from strain compatibility and the design stress–strain curve of the bar, and design a doubly reinforced beam for a moment above Mu,lim.
- Analyse a given doubly reinforced section by iterating on the neutral-axis depth, and apply the IS 456 limits on compression steel.
Theory
A singly reinforced beam cannot resist more than Mu,lim without becoming over-reinforced (lesson 2.2). When the depth is fixed by headroom or architecture and the moment is larger, the designer adds steel on the compression side as well as extra tension steel. The added pair of bars forms a steel couple of lever arm d − d′, where d′ is the depth of the compression steel from the top. The concrete section is still used only up to its limiting neutral-axis depth, so the beam stays under-reinforced and ductile.
The design moment is therefore split into two parts. Mu,lim is carried by the concrete block and the tension steel Ast1 of the limiting singly reinforced section. The rest, Mu2 = Mu − Mu,lim, is carried by compression steel Asc working at stress fsc against extra tension steel Ast2 at 0.87 fy. This is exactly the approach of IS 456:2000 Annex G, G-1.2, which gives Mu − Mu,lim = fsc Asc (d − d′), and the total tension steel Ast = Ast1 + Ast2 with Ast2 fixed by the force balance of the steel couple.
The compression steel does not automatically reach its design yield stress. Its strain comes from the strain diagram: with the top at 0.0035 and the neutral axis at xu,max, εsc = 0.0035 (xu,max − d′)/xu,max. For mild steel (Fe 250) this is normally enough to yield, but for Fe 415 and Fe 500 the strain usually lies on the curved part of the design stress–strain curve, so fsc is read from the curve (Fig. 23A of the code, defined by the inelastic-strain points tabulated in Indian textbooks and design aids). A precise calculation also allows for the concrete displaced by the compression bars, using fsc − 0.446 fck as their net stress.
Compression steel brings other benefits: it reduces long-term deflection because creep of the concrete transfers load into it, it improves ductility by keeping the neutral axis shallow, it carries stress reversal under wind or earthquake, and it holds the stirrups in place. IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.2 limits compression steel to 0.04 b D and requires it to be enclosed by stirrups so that the bars cannot buckle outwards when they carry high compression.
Derivation
- Split the moment: Mu = Mu,lim + Mu2, with Mu,lim = 0.36 fck b xu,max (d − 0.42 xu,max) carried by the concrete and Ast1 = 0.36 fck b xu,max/(0.87 fy).
- Strain in the compression steel (neutral axis at xu,max): εsc = 0.0035 (xu,max − d′)/xu,max; read fsc from the design curve of the bar (elastic, fsc = Es εsc, up to 0.8 × 0.87 fy for Fe 415 and Fe 500, then the curved part, then 0.87 fy).
- Steel couple: Mu2 = Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′), so Asc = Mu2/((fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′)); the code form of G-1.2 omits the 0.446 fck term, which gives a slightly smaller Asc.
- Force balance of the couple: 0.87 fy Ast2 = Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck), so Ast2 = Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)/(0.87 fy) and Ast = Ast1 + Ast2.
- Analysis of a given section: force equilibrium 0.36 fck b xu + Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck) = Ast fst, with εsc = 0.0035 (xu − d′)/xu and εst = 0.0035 (d − xu)/xu. Start by assuming both steels yield, solve for xu, recompute the strains and stresses, and iterate until the forces balance.
- Moment about the tension steel: Mu = 0.36 fck b xu (d − 0.42 xu) + Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′), valid while xu does not exceed xu,max.
Compression steel strain: εsc = 0.0035 (xu − d′)/xu (dimensionless); fsc from the design curve of the bar (N/mm²)Moment split: Mu2 = Mu − Mu,lim (kN m)Compression steel: Asc = Mu2/((fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′)) (mm²); code form Asc = Mu2/(fsc (d − d′))Tension steel: Ast = Ast1 + Ast2, Ast1 = 0.36 fck b xu,max/(0.87 fy), Ast2 = Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)/(0.87 fy) (mm²)Analysis: 0.36 fck b xu + Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck) = Ast fst; Mu = 0.36 fck b xu (d − 0.42 xu) + Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′) (N, N mm)Limit (cl. 26.5.1.2): Asc ≤ 0.04 b D (mm²)
- All the assumptions of IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 hold; the compression steel is bonded and restrained by stirrups so that it strains with the concrete.
- Design keeps the neutral axis at xu,max for the concrete part, so the tension steel reaches at least 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002.
- Fe 415 and Fe 500 bars follow the cold-worked design curve; the inelastic-strain points used here (for Fe 415: 288.7, 306.7, 324.8, 342.8, 351.8 and 360.9 N/mm² at strains 0.00144, 0.00163, 0.00192, 0.00241, 0.00276 and 0.00380) follow from stress/Es plus inelastic strains of 0, 0.0001, 0.0003, 0.0007, 0.001 and 0.002 at 0.80 to 1.0 of 0.87 fy, with straight lines between the points.
- The 0.446 fck correction for displaced concrete is small (about 2.5 per cent of the compression-steel force for M20 with Fe 415) and is often included in textbook designs; the code form without it is also accepted.
- Limits: compression steel placed deep in the section (d′/d above about 0.2) works at low stress and is uneconomical; if Mu is much larger than Mu,lim, increasing the depth or the concrete grade is usually more economical than adding large amounts of compression steel. Doubly reinforced design does not remove the need for shear, deflection and detailing checks.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 Annex G, G-1.2 (section with compression reinforcement: Mu − Mu,lim = fsc Asc (d − d′), fsc at a strain of 0.0035 (xu,max − d′)/xu,max, total tension steel Ast = Ast1 + Ast2 with Ast2 = fsc Asc/(0.87 fy)); cl. 38.1 and its Note (xu,max/d); Fig. 23 (representative stress–strain curves of reinforcement).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.2 (compression steel not more than 0.04 b D, enclosed by stirrups for lateral restraint) and cl. 26.5.1.1 (limits on tension steel); bars to IS 1786.
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European code (EN 1992-1-1) and the American code (ACI 318) also design doubly reinforced sections by strain compatibility and equilibrium, checking whether the compression steel yields and limiting the neutral-axis depth or the net tensile strain for ductility; both require ties or links around compression bars. Their numerical limits are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A beam 300 mm wide with d = 550 mm and d′ = 50 mm must resist a factored moment of 350 kN m. Use M20 concrete and Fe 415 steel. Design the reinforcement.
- xu,max = 0.48 × 550 = 264 mm; Mu,lim = 0.36 × 20 × 300 × 264 × (550 − 0.42 × 264) = 250.4 kN m < 350 kN m, so compression steel is needed.
- Ast1 = 0.36 × 20 × 300 × 264/(0.87 × 415) = 1 579 mm²; Mu2 = 350 − 250.4 = 99.6 kN m.
- εsc = 0.0035 × (264 − 50)/264 = 0.00284; on the Fe 415 curve between 351.8 N/mm² at 0.00276 and 360.9 N/mm² at 0.00380, fsc = 352.5 N/mm².
- Asc = 99.6 × 10⁶/((352.5 − 0.446 × 20) × 500) = 99.6 × 10⁶/(343.6 × 500) = 580 mm² (the code form 99.6 × 10⁶/(352.5 × 500) gives 565 mm²).
- Ast2 = 580 × 343.6/(0.87 × 415) = 552 mm²; Ast = 1 579 + 552 = 2 131 mm².
- Provide four 25 mm and one 16 mm bar in tension (2 165 mm²) and two 20 mm bars in compression (628 mm²). Check by strain compatibility: xu = 261.7 mm < 264 mm and Mu = 356.7 kN m ≥ 350 kN m. Because the tension steel was rounded up, the compression steel was also rounded up; with three 16 mm bars (603 mm²) xu would be 265.3 mm, just over the limit.
Answer. Ast = 2 131 mm² (4-25 + 1-16 provided), Asc = 580 mm² (2-20 provided); check Mu = 357 kN m with xu = 262 mm
Problem. A beam 250 mm wide, d = 450 mm, d′ = 50 mm, M25 concrete and Fe 500 steel, has four 20 mm tension bars and two 16 mm compression bars. Find the neutral-axis depth and the moment of resistance.
- Ast = 1 256.6 mm², Asc = 402.1 mm², xu,max = 0.46 × 450 = 207 mm.
- Trial 1, both steels yielding: 0.36 × 25 × 250 xu + 402.1 × (435 − 11.15) = 435 × 1 256.6, giving xu = 167.2 mm. Then εsc = 0.0035 × 117.2/167.2 = 0.00245, below 0.00417, so the compression steel has not yielded.
- Iterate with fsc from the Fe 500 curve: xu = 173.2 mm gives εsc = 0.00249, fsc = 401.1 N/mm² (between 391.3 at 0.00226 and 413.0 at 0.00277), and εst = 0.0056 > 0.00417, so fst = 434.8 N/mm². Forces: Cc = 389.6 kN, Cs = 402.1 × (401.1 − 11.15) = 156.8 kN, total 546.4 kN = T = 1 256.6 × 434.8 = 546.4 kN.
- xu = 173.2 mm < xu,max = 207 mm: under-reinforced.
- Mu = 389.6 × (450 − 0.42 × 173.2) + 156.8 × (450 − 50) = 147.0 + 62.7 = 209.7 kN m (kN mm divided by 1 000).
- For comparison, the same section without compression steel would be limited to Mu,lim = 0.1336 × 25 × 250 × 450² = 169.1 kN m.
Answer. xu = 173 mm; fsc = 401 N/mm² (compression steel not yielded); Mu = 209.7 kN m
Problem. A beam carrying a floor has its overall depth limited to 460 mm by a services duct; b = 230 mm, d = 400 mm (to the centroid of two layers), d′ = 45 mm, M25 and Fe 415. The factored moment is 180 kN m. Design the steel and check the bar limits.
- xu,max = 0.48 × 400 = 192 mm; Mu,lim = 0.36 × 25 × 230 × 192 × (400 − 0.42 × 192) = 126.9 kN m < 180 kN m: doubly reinforced.
- Ast1 = 0.36 × 25 × 230 × 192/(0.87 × 415) = 1 101 mm²; Mu2 = 53.1 kN m.
- εsc = 0.0035 × 147/192 = 0.00268, so fsc = 349.7 N/mm² (between 342.8 at 0.00241 and 351.8 at 0.00276); net stress 349.7 − 11.15 = 338.6 N/mm².
- Asc = 53.1 × 10⁶/(338.6 × 355) = 442 mm²; Ast2 = 442 × 338.6/361.05 = 414 mm²; Ast = 1 515 mm².
- Provide five 20 mm bars in two layers (1 571 mm²) and two 20 mm compression bars (628 mm²); strain-compatibility check: xu = 171.8 mm < 192 mm and Mu = 191.6 kN m ≥ 180 kN m.
- Limits: 0.04 b D = 0.04 × 230 × 460 = 4 232 mm² for each of Ast and Asc, comfortably met; enclose the top bars in closed stirrups.
Answer. Ast = 1 515 mm² (5-20 in two layers), Asc = 442 mm² (2-20); xu = 172 mm, Mu = 191.6 kN m
Step-by-step procedure
- Compute Mu,lim for the chosen b and d; if Mu ≤ Mu,lim, design as singly reinforced (lesson 2.2).
- Otherwise find Ast1 for the limiting section and Mu2 = Mu − Mu,lim.
- Find εsc at xu,max from strain compatibility and read fsc from the design curve of the bar.
- Compute Asc = Mu2/((fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′)) and Ast2 = Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)/(0.87 fy); Ast = Ast1 + Ast2.
- Choose bars; if the tension bars are rounded up noticeably, round the compression bars up as well, and confirm xu ≤ xu,max by a strain-compatibility check of the bars provided.
- Check Asc and Ast against 0.04 b D, detail closed stirrups around the compression bars, then check shear, anchorage and deflection.
Site notes
- Compression bars only work if they stay in position: tie them into closed stirrups at the spacing shown, especially near supports where they may also carry reversal.
- Top bars in beams are often displaced downwards by workers walking on the cage before the pour; a larger d′ lowers the strain and the stress of the compression steel.
- Do not lap compression bars in the zone of maximum moment unless the drawing shows it; laps there should be designed.
- Check the clear distance between bars in two-layer arrangements so that concrete can flow around them; congestion leaves voids exactly where the steel needs bond.
- Where a beam was made doubly reinforced only because of a depth limit, confirm on site that the overall depth was not reduced further by finishes or services.
- Assuming the compression steel reaches 0.87 fy for Fe 415 or Fe 500 without checking its strain.
- Using d instead of d − d′ as the lever arm of the steel couple.
- Forgetting Ast2: adding compression steel without the matching extra tension steel.
- Rounding the tension steel up but not the compression steel, which can push xu above xu,max.
- Leaving compression bars without closed stirrups, so they can buckle and spall the cover.
With d′/d between 0.10 and 0.20, the compression-steel stress at the limiting section is about 352 to 329 N/mm² for Fe 415 and about 412 to 372 N/mm² for Fe 500, so in Fe 500 it is usually well below 0.87 fy = 435 N/mm². As a first estimate, every extra 10 kN m above Mu,lim needs roughly 10 × 10⁶/(330 × (d − d′)) mm² of compression steel for Fe 415.
Summary
- When Mu exceeds Mu,lim and the depth cannot change, add compression steel and matching extra tension steel.
- Split Mu = Mu,lim + Mu2: the concrete section carries Mu,lim and a steel couple of lever arm d − d′ carries Mu2.
- The compression steel stress comes from εsc = 0.0035 (xu,max − d′)/xu,max and the design curve; for Fe 415 and Fe 500 it is usually below 0.87 fy.
- Asc = Mu2/((fsc − 0.446 fck)(d − d′)) and Ast = Ast1 + Asc (fsc − 0.446 fck)/(0.87 fy); the code form omits the 0.446 fck term.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.2 limits Asc to 0.04 b D and requires stirrups around compression bars.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find fsc for Fe 415 at a strain of 0.0030.
Between 351.8 N/mm² at 0.00276 and 360.9 N/mm² at 0.00380: 351.8 + 9.1 × (0.00024/0.00104) = 353.9 N/mm².
2Find εsc for xu = 240 mm and d′ = 50 mm.
0.0035 × 190/240 = 0.00277.
3For b = 250 mm, d = 450 mm, d′ = 50 mm, M20, Fe 415 and Mu = 200 kN m, find Mu2 and Asc using the code form with fsc = 352 N/mm².
Mu,lim = 0.138 × 20 × 250 × 450² = 139.7 kN m, so Mu2 = 60.3 kN m and Asc = 60.3 × 10⁶/(352 × 400) = 428 mm².
4What is the maximum compression steel in a 300 × 600 mm beam?
0.04 × 300 × 600 = 7 200 mm².
5Why must compression bars be enclosed by stirrups?
Without lateral restraint the bars can buckle outwards under compression and push off the cover, so they cannot carry their design stress (cl. 26.5.1.2).
6Give two benefits of compression steel apart from strength.
It reduces long-term deflection due to creep and shrinkage, and it improves ductility by keeping the neutral axis shallow; it also resists moment reversal and supports the stirrups.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.