Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 3 › Lesson 3.1

3.1 Shear in beams and design of stirrups

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 3: Shear, bond and torsion Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain how a reinforced concrete beam fails in shear, why diagonal tension cracks form at about 45 degrees near supports, and how stirrups and the concrete share the shear force.
  • Compute the nominal shear stress τv = Vu/(b d), read the design shear strength τc of IS 456:2000 Table 19 for the tension steel provided, and check τv against τc,max of Table 20.
  • Design vertical stirrups from Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d/sv, apply the minimum shear steel and maximum spacing rules of cl. 26.5.1.5 and 26.5.1.6, and use the enhanced shear strength near supports of cl. 40.5.

Theory

Chapter 2 designed beams for bending. The same beam also carries a shear force, largest near the supports, and shear failures are sudden and give little warning. Near a support, bending and shear act together: the bending stress is small but the shear stress is large, so the principal tensile stress in the web is inclined at roughly 45 degrees to the axis (Strength of Materials lessons 4.1 and 7.2). Concrete is weak in tension, so once this principal tension exceeds the tensile strength, inclined cracks open in the web. Without reinforcement across them, a single crack can run from the tension steel up to the compression zone and split the beam.

Even after cracking, a beam without stirrups still carries shear in three ways: through the uncracked compression zone, through aggregate interlock across the rough crack faces, and through dowel action of the tension bars. Tests show that this combined capacity rises with concrete grade and, quite strongly, with the percentage of tension steel, because more steel keeps the crack narrow. IS 456:2000 gives the design shear strength of concrete τc in Table 19 as a function of pt = 100 As/(b d) and the grade, for beams without shear reinforcement (cl. 40.2.1); As is the tension steel that continues at least one effective depth beyond the section (Note to Table 19).

Shear: diagonal crack and stirrupstension barsdiagonal cracksvstirrups Asvcompression zoneloaddIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 3.1: Beam near a support: the diagonal tension crack at about 45 degrees is crossed by vertical stirrups at spacing sv; the concrete compression zone, aggregate interlock and dowel action carry Vc and the stirrups carry Vus. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Stirrups carry the rest. Picture a 45-degree crack crossing the beam: every stirrup leg that crosses it is stretched and, at collapse, yields. Over a horizontal distance d the crack crosses d/sv stirrups, so their combined force is 0.87 fy Asv d/sv. This is the truss analogy of Ritter and Mörsch: concrete struts at 45 degrees in compression, stirrups as vertical ties, and the tension and compression chords as the flanges of the truss. IS 456 adds the two contributions, Vu = τc b d + Vus, and asks for shear reinforcement to carry Vus = Vu − τc b d whenever τv exceeds τc (cl. 40.4). Bent-up bars may help, but they may not carry more than half of the shear reinforcement's share.

There is an upper limit. However much steel is provided, the concrete struts crush if the shear stress is too high, so τv may never exceed τc,max of Table 20 (cl. 40.2.3): 2.5, 2.8, 3.1, 3.5, 3.7 and 4.0 N/mm² for M15, M20, M25, M30, M35 and M40 and above. If it does, the section must be enlarged. At the other end, even a lightly stressed beam gets minimum stirrups (cl. 26.5.1.6) so that the first diagonal crack does not cause a sudden failure, and the spacing is capped at 0.75 d and 300 mm (cl. 26.5.1.5) so that every possible 45-degree crack is crossed by at least one stirrup. Near supports, a crack forced to be steeper than its natural angle needs more force, which is why cl. 40.5 allows an enhanced strength 2 d τc/av for sections closer than 2d to a support or concentrated load.

Derivation

  1. Nominal shear stress: τv = Vu/(b d), with b the web width for flanged beams (cl. 40.1). It is an average used for design, not the true peak stress, which in an uncracked rectangle would be 1.5 times the average (Strength of Materials lesson 4.2).
  2. Shear strength without stirrups: the concrete carries Vc = τc b d, where τc depends on pt and the grade (Table 19). The tabulated values follow a semi-empirical expression in textbooks, τc = 0.85 √(0.8 fck) (√(1 + 5β) − 1)/(6β) with β = 0.8 fck/(6.89 pt) and not less than 1; it reproduces the table to within 0.01 N/mm².
  3. Truss analogy for vertical stirrups: a crack at 45 degrees spans a horizontal length d. The number of stirrups it crosses is d/sv. Each stirrup of total leg area Asv yields at 0.87 fy, so Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d/sv (cl. 40.4 (a)).
  4. Inclined stirrups at angle α: the crack crosses more of them and each contributes a vertical component; the same count gives Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d (sin α + cos α)/sv (cl. 40.4 (b)). A single bent-up bar or group bent at one section gives Vus = 0.87 fy Asv sin α (cl. 40.4 (c)).
  5. Design: required Vus = Vu − τc b d; for chosen legs, sv = 0.87 fy Asv d/Vus. Minimum steel (cl. 26.5.1.6): Asv/(b sv) ≥ 0.4/(0.87 fy), that is sv ≤ 0.87 fy Asv/(0.4 b), with fy not taken greater than 415 N/mm² for stirrups. Maximum spacing (cl. 26.5.1.5): 0.75 d for vertical stirrups, d for 45-degree inclined stirrups, and never more than 300 mm.
  6. Enhanced strength near supports (cl. 40.5): for a section at av < 2d from the face of a support or concentrated load, τc may be raised to 2 d τc/av, provided τv at the support face stays below τc,max; the shear steel is then Asv = av b (τv − 2 d τc/av)/(0.87 fy) ≥ 0.4 av b/(0.87 fy), placed within the middle three-quarters of av (cl. 40.5.2). For beams carrying mainly uniform load, the shear may instead be checked at a distance d from the face of the support (cl. 40.5.3).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Nominal shear stress: τv = Vu/(b d) (N/mm²; Vu in N, b and d in mm)
  • Steel ratio for Table 19: pt = 100 As/(b d) (per cent; dimensionless)
  • Shear carried by concrete: Vc = τc b d (N; τc in N/mm², b and d in mm)
  • Vertical stirrups: Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d/sv (N; fy ≤ 415 N/mm², Asv in mm², d and sv in mm)
  • Inclined stirrups: Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d (sin α + cos α)/sv (N); single bent-up group: Vus = 0.87 fy Asv sin α (N; fy in N/mm², lengths in mm)
  • Minimum stirrups: Asv/(b sv) ≥ 0.4/(0.87 fy) (dimensionless, with fy in N/mm²); spacing ≤ 0.75 d and ≤ 300 mm
  • Enhanced strength near a support: τc,enh = 2 d τc/av for av < 2d (N/mm²)
Assumptions and limits
  • The beam is of uniform depth; for tapered beams cl. 40.1.1 adds a term for the inclination of the compression and tension chords.
  • Table 19 applies to beams without shear reinforcement and to the concrete share in beams with stirrups; pt counts only tension bars that continue at least d beyond the section (or are properly anchored at the support).
  • Stirrups are anchored as cl. 26.2.2.4 requires and enclose the tension bars, so the truss can develop; their characteristic strength is taken as not more than 415 N/mm² in the design formulas.
  • The 45-degree crack of the truss model is a design idealisation; real cracks are flatter in lightly reinforced webs and steeper near supports.
  • Limits: the method is for ordinary beams. Deep beams, corbels, slabs (cl. 40.2.1.1 gives a depth factor for solid slabs and cl. 40.2.3.1 halves τc,max), members with significant axial force (cl. 40.2.2) and punching in flat slabs (cl. 31.6) follow their own rules; torsion adds to the shear (lesson 3.3).

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 40.1 (nominal shear stress τv = Vu/(b d)), cl. 40.2.1 with Table 19 (design shear strength τc of concrete; for example 0.48, 0.62, 0.72 and 0.79 N/mm² for M20 at pt = 0.50, 1.00, 1.50 and 2.00, and 0.49, 0.64, 0.74 and 0.82 N/mm² for M25), cl. 40.2.3 with Table 20 (τc,max 2.5, 2.8, 3.1, 3.5, 3.7 and 4.0 N/mm² for M15 to M40 and above), cl. 40.3 (minimum shear reinforcement when τv < τc), cl. 40.4 (a) to (c) (Vus for vertical stirrups, inclined stirrups and bent-up bars; bent-up bars not more than half of the shear reinforcement; fy not taken greater than 415 N/mm²), cl. 40.5, 40.5.2 and 40.5.3 (enhanced shear strength near supports and the critical section at d for uniform loads).
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.5 (maximum spacing 0.75 d for vertical stirrups, d for inclined stirrups at 45 degrees, never more than 300 mm) and cl. 26.5.1.6 (minimum shear reinforcement Asv/(b sv) ≥ 0.4/(0.87 fy), need not be provided where the maximum shear stress calculated is less than half the permissible value, and in members of minor structural importance such as lintels); cl. 23.1.1 (b) (transverse slab steel at least 60 per cent of the slab midspan steel where the slab bars run parallel to a T-beam, which helps carry the shear between flange and web).
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) designs members needing shear reinforcement by a variable-angle strut-and-tie (truss) model in which the stirrups carry all the shear and the strut angle may be chosen within limits; the American code (ACI 318) adds a concrete contribution and a stirrup contribution in a way similar to IS 456, with its own strength reduction factor and limits. Coefficients and limits differ and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (design style: stirrups for a heavily loaded beam)

Problem. A simply supported beam of 5.0 m effective span rests on 300 mm wide supports and carries a factored load of 135 kN/m including self-weight. It is 300 mm wide with d = 600 mm (overall 650 mm), M30 concrete and Fe 415 steel, with four 28 mm bottom bars that all continue into the supports. Design two-legged 8 mm vertical stirrups.

  1. Flexure first: Mu = 135 × 5.0²/8 = 421.9 kN m; four 28 mm bars (2 463 mm²) give xu = 274.5 mm < 288 mm and Mu = 431.1 kN m, which is adequate.
  2. Support reaction 337.5 kN. The load is uniform, so shear may be checked at d from the face (cl. 40.5.3): 0.15 + 0.60 = 0.75 m from the support centre, Vu = 337.5 − 135 × 0.75 = 236.3 kN; τv = 236 250/(300 × 600) = 1.31 N/mm², below τc,max = 3.5 N/mm² (at the face τv = 1.76 N/mm², also below).
  3. pt = 100 × 2 463/(300 × 600) = 1.37 per cent; Table 19 (M30) gives 0.71 at 1.25 and 0.76 at 1.50, so τc = 0.734 N/mm² by interpolation; Vc = 0.734 × 300 × 600 = 132.1 kN.
  4. Vus = 236.3 − 132.1 = 104.2 kN. With Asv = 2 × 50.3 = 100.5 mm²: sv = 0.87 × 415 × 100.5 × 600/104 190 = 209 mm; adopt 200 mm.
  5. Elsewhere: minimum steel allows sv ≤ 0.87 × 415 × 100.5/(0.4 × 300) = 302 mm, and the maximum is the lesser of 0.75 × 600 = 450 mm and 300 mm, so 300 mm. Stirrups at 300 mm give Vu = 132.1 + 0.87 × 415 × 100.5 × 600/300 = 204.7 kN, which the shear diagram reaches 0.98 m from each support centre.
  6. Provide 8 mm two-legged stirrups at 200 mm for the first 1.0 m from each support and at 300 mm over the middle 3.0 m.

Answer. τv = 1.31 N/mm², τc = 0.73 N/mm²; 2L-8 at 200 mm for 1.0 m at each end, 2L-8 at 300 mm in the middle

Example 2 (exam style: shear capacity of a given section)

Problem. A beam 250 mm wide with d = 410 mm has four 16 mm bars (all continuing to the support) in M20 concrete and two-legged 8 mm Fe 415 stirrups at 150 mm. Find its design shear capacity and check the spacing rules.

  1. As = 804.2 mm²; pt = 100 × 804.2/(250 × 410) = 0.785 per cent. Table 19 (M20): 0.56 at 0.75 and 0.62 at 1.00, so τc = 0.568 N/mm²; Vc = 0.568 × 250 × 410 = 58.3 kN.
  2. Vus = 0.87 × 415 × 100.5 × 410/150 = 99.2 kN.
  3. Vu = 58.3 + 99.2 = 157.5 kN, which corresponds to τv = 1.54 N/mm², below τc,max = 2.8 N/mm² (the crushing limit would be 2.8 × 250 × 410 = 287 kN).
  4. Spacing: 150 mm is below 0.75 × 410 = 307.5 mm and 300 mm, and below the minimum-steel spacing 0.87 × 415 × 100.5/(0.4 × 250) = 363 mm, so all rules are met.

Answer. Design shear capacity 157 kN (concrete 58 kN + stirrups 99 kN); spacing rules satisfied

Example 3 (site style: a heavy load close to a support)

Problem. A 300 mm wide transfer beam with d = 550 mm, M25 concrete and pt = 1.50 per cent carries a factored column load of 400 kN applied 500 mm from the face of its support. Using the enhanced shear strength of cl. 40.5, find the shear steel within av, and compare with the stirrups needed without enhancement.

  1. τv = 400 000/(300 × 550) = 2.42 N/mm², below τc,max = 3.1 N/mm² for M25, so the section size is adequate.
  2. Table 19 (M25, pt 1.50): τc = 0.74 N/mm². Since av = 500 mm < 2d = 1 100 mm, τc,enh = 2 × 550 × 0.74/500 = 1.63 N/mm².
  3. Asv = av b (τv − 2 d τc/av)/(0.87 fy) = 500 × 300 × (2.42 − 1.63)/(0.87 × 415) = 328 mm², above the minimum 0.4 × 500 × 300/(0.87 × 415) = 166 mm².
  4. Place it within the middle three-quarters of av (375 mm): three two-legged 10 mm stirrups (471 mm²) at about 125 mm.
  5. Without enhancement: Vus = (2.42 − 0.74) × 300 × 550 = 277.9 kN, needing 2L-10 at 112 mm, about five stirrups over the same 500 mm. The enhancement recognises that a crack forced to run steeply from the load to the support needs more force.

Answer. Enhanced τc 1.63 N/mm²; 328 mm² needed, three 2L-10 stirrups within the middle 375 mm of av

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Draw the factored shear force diagram; for uniform loads note the shear at d from the face of the support, for concentrated loads near supports note av.
  2. Compute τv = Vu/(b d) and check it against τc,max of Table 20; if it is higher, enlarge the section.
  3. Find pt from the tension bars that continue past the section and read τc from Table 19 (interpolate between rows).
  4. If τv ≤ τc, provide minimum stirrups at the lesser of the cl. 26.5.1.6 spacing, 0.75 d and 300 mm (except where cl. 26.5.1.6 allows them to be omitted).
  5. If τv > τc, compute Vus = Vu − τc b d, choose bar size and legs, and find sv = 0.87 fy Asv d/Vus; round down and respect the maximum spacing.
  6. Find where the shear falls to the capacity of minimum stirrups and change the spacing there; detail stirrup hooks as cl. 26.2.2.4 requires.

Site notes

  • Check stirrup spacing at the support ends before concreting: the closely spaced zone is often shortened when bars are moved to clear a column cage.
  • Stirrups must wrap round the main bars and have 135-degree hooks or the anchorage shown on the drawing; open or short hooks cannot develop the truss tie.
  • Do not cut stirrups to pass service pipes; if an opening through a web is unavoidable, it needs a design check and trimming steel.
  • Use the correct bar grade for stirrups: substituting mild steel for the Fe 415 shown reduces the shear steel's strength by about 40 per cent.
  • Diagonal cracks near supports in an existing beam are a structural warning sign; report them rather than patching.
Common mistakes
  • Using the overall depth D instead of d, or the flange width instead of the web width, in τv = Vu/(b d).
  • Reading Table 19 with all bars when some are curtailed before the section, which overstates τc.
  • Forgetting the upper limit τc,max; no amount of stirrups can save a web that is too thin.
  • Spacing stirrups at more than 0.75 d or 300 mm because the calculation gave a larger value.
  • Counting the full yield strength of Fe 500 stirrups in Vus; the design formulas cap fy at 415 N/mm².
Quick check

In ordinary beams τc lies between about 0.3 and 1.0 N/mm²; if a computed τv is more than about 3 to 4 times τc, check it against τc,max before designing stirrups. Two-legged 8 mm Fe 415 stirrups at spacing sv provide Vus ≈ 36.3 d/sv kN with d in mm, about 73 kN for d = 600 mm at 300 mm. Stirrup spacing in critical zones rarely needs to fall below about 100 mm; if it does, use larger bars or more legs.

Summary

  • Shear causes inclined (diagonal tension) cracks near supports; failure is sudden, so shear design must never be the weak link.
  • τv = Vu/(b d) is compared with τc from Table 19 (depending on pt and grade) and with τc,max from Table 20.
  • Stirrups carry Vus = Vu − τc b d by truss action: Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d/sv for vertical stirrups, with fy capped at 415 N/mm².
  • Minimum stirrups Asv/(b sv) ≥ 0.4/(0.87 fy) and a maximum spacing of 0.75 d and 300 mm apply everywhere except where the code exempts them.
  • Near supports and concentrated loads within 2d, the enhanced strength 2 d τc/av may be used; for uniform loads the shear may be checked at d from the face.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find τv for Vu = 180 kN, b = 230 mm and d = 450 mm.

180 000/(230 × 450) = 1.74 N/mm².

2Read τc for M20 concrete with pt = 0.60 per cent.

Between 0.48 (0.50 per cent) and 0.56 (0.75 per cent): 0.48 + 0.08 × 0.10/0.25 = 0.512 N/mm².

3Find the spacing of 2L-10 Fe 415 stirrups for Vus = 120 kN with d = 500 mm.

sv = 0.87 × 415 × 157.1 × 500/120 000 = 236 mm; adopt 225 mm (below 0.75 d = 375 mm and 300 mm).

4What is the largest spacing of minimum 2L-8 Fe 415 stirrups in a 230 mm wide beam with d = 400 mm?

Minimum steel: 0.87 × 415 × 100.5/(0.4 × 230) = 394 mm; 0.75 d = 300 mm; 300 mm limit; so 300 mm.

5A beam has τv = 3.0 N/mm² in M25 concrete. What must the designer do?

τc,max for M25 is 3.1 N/mm², so the section is just adequate; with any increase in load the section must be enlarged, since stirrups cannot raise τc,max.

6Why does τc increase with the percentage of tension steel?

More tension steel keeps diagonal cracks narrower and the compression zone deeper, improving aggregate interlock, dowel action and the uncracked zone's share.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.