8.3 Introduction to ductile detailing
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why reinforced concrete frames in seismic zones are designed to yield in a controlled, ductile way, and what the strong column, weak beam principle achieves.
- Apply the beam and column detailing rules of IS 13920:2016: geometry, minimum and maximum steel, link spacing in hinge zones, lap locations and special confining reinforcement.
- Calculate the capacity-design shear in a beam and a column from the moments of resistance at their ends, and the confining link area of cl. 7.6 (numbered 8.1 in the unamended 2016 text).
Theory
Correction, 10 Nov 2026: earlier versions of this lesson used the pre-amendment beam hoop-spacing limit of 8 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter and the original 2016 hook extension of 6 diameters and 65 mm. IS 13920:2016 Amendment No. 1 (September 2017) sets end-zone spacing as the least of d/4, 6 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter, and 100 mm, and hook extensions as 8 bar diameters but not less than 75 mm. Special confining reinforcement is in cl. 7.6 after that amendment (cl. 8.1 in the 2016 print).
A building in a strong earthquake is shaken by forces far larger than those it is designed for. Codes accept this on purpose: the design forces of IS 1893 (Part 1) are reduced by a response reduction factor on the understanding that the structure will crack and yield, absorb energy, and keep carrying its gravity load. The property that makes this possible is ductility, the ability to deform well beyond first yield without losing strength. IS 13920:2016 is the code of practice for ductile design and detailing of reinforced concrete structures subjected to seismic forces; it works alongside IS 456, which still governs everything it does not modify (cl. 5.1).
Ductility does not come from the concrete, which crushes at small strains, but from steel that yields and keeps stretching while the concrete around it is held together. So IS 13920 asks for steel with a real yield plateau and reserve strength: since Amendment No. 2 (November 2020), only grades with a minimum 0.2 per cent proof stress of 415, 500 or 550 MPa, with elongation of at least 14.5 per cent and a ratio of ultimate to proof stress between 1.15 and 1.25 (cl. 5.3.1 as substituted; the old cl. 5.3.3 was deleted); and the actual proof stress not more than 20 per cent above the characteristic value (cl. 5.3.2). The concrete must be at least M20, and M25 for buildings over 15 m tall in Zones III, IV and V (cl. 5.2).
Where yielding happens matters as much as whether it happens. If the columns of one storey yield first, that storey sways sideways as a mechanism and the floors above can collapse onto it. If the beams yield first, at their ends next to the columns, many hinges share the energy and the columns stay intact to carry the building down. This is the strong column, weak beam principle: IS 13920 cl. 7.2.1 asks that at each joint the sum of the column moment capacities be at least 1.4 times the sum of the beam moment capacities in the same plane.
The places expected to yield are then detailed to survive many cycles of reversing load. Beam ends get closely spaced links over a length 2d from the column face (cl. 6.3.5), to stop the compression bars buckling, hold the cracked concrete together and add shear strength. Column ends get special confining reinforcement over a length lo (cl. 7.6, numbered 8.1 in the unamended 2016 text), which raises the strength and, more importantly, the crushing strain of the core concrete. Laps are kept out of these zones, links have 135° hooks that stay anchored in the core when the cover spalls, and both faces of a beam carry continuous bars because the moment reverses.
Finally, the brittle modes are made stronger than the ductile ones. A member that fails in shear fails suddenly, so beams and columns are designed for the shear that exists when the plastic hinges have formed at their ends: capacity design. In a beam that is the gravity shear (with a factor of 1.2 on dead and live load) plus 1.4 times the sum of the end moment capacities divided by the clear span (cl. 6.3.3); in a column, 1.4 times the sum of the beam moment capacities at the joint divided by the storey height (cl. 7.5). In this calculation the concrete contribution to beam shear strength is ignored (cl. 6.3.4), because the concrete in a hinge zone is cracked through after a few cycles.
Derivation
- Minimum beam steel: IS 13920 cl. 6.2.1 asks for ρmin = 0.24 √fck/fy on any face at any section, at least two 12 mm bars top and bottom, and cl. 6.2.2 caps ρmax at 0.025. The minimum ensures the cracking moment does not exceed the yield moment, so the beam yields gradually instead of snapping when it first cracks.
- Moment reversal: cl. 6.2.3 asks for bottom steel at the column face at least half the top steel there, and cl. 6.2.4 for at least a quarter of the larger top steel at the column faces on both faces at every section, because earthquake moments reverse sign at the beam ends.
- Beam capacity shear (cl. 6.3.3): for sway to the right, Vu,a = Vu,a(D+L) − 1.4 (MuAs + MuBh)/LAB and Vu,b = Vu,b(D+L) + 1.4 (MuAs + MuBh)/LAB; for sway to the left, Vu,a = Vu,a(D+L) + 1.4 (MuAh + MuBs)/LAB and Vu,b = Vu,b(D+L) − 1.4 (MuAh + MuBs)/LAB. The gravity shears use a factor of 1.2 with the beam simply supported; the design shear at each end is the larger value. The term 1.4 ΣMu/LAB is the shear that keeps a beam of clear span LAB in equilibrium with hinges at both ends.
- Links for that shear with the concrete ignored (cl. 6.3.4): from IS 456 cl. 40.4 (a), Vus = 0.87 fy Asv d/sv, so sv = 0.87 fy Asv d/Vu.
- Column capacity shear (cl. 7.5): Vu = 1.4 (MuAs + MuBh)/hst for one sway direction and 1.4 (MuAh + MuBs)/hst for the other, with the beam moments of resistance at the joint and hst the storey height.
- Confining links in rectangular columns (cl. 7.6 (c), originally 8.1 (c)): Ash ≥ 0.18 sv h (fck/fy)(Ag/Ak − 1) and Ash ≥ 0.05 sv h fck/fy, where h is the longer dimension of the link (not more than 300 mm, reducible with cross-ties), Ag the gross area and Ak the core area to the outside of the links. The first term replaces the strength lost when the cover spalls; the second sets a floor for heavily confined sections.
ρmin = 0.24 √fck/fy on any face; ρmax = 0.025 (beams, cl. 6.2.1 and 6.2.2)Beam link spacing over 2d at each end: not more than d/4, 6 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter, and 100 mm; first link within 50 mm of the joint face; elsewhere not more than d/2 (cl. 6.3.5 as amended 2017)Beam design shear: Vu = Vu(D+L) ± 1.4 (Mu,hog + Mu,sag)/LAB (kN; Mu in kN m, LAB in m), gravity factor 1.2Column design shear: Vu = 1.4 (MuA + MuB)/hst (kN)Strong column, weak beam: ΣMc ≥ 1.4 ΣMb at each joint (cl. 7.2.1)Confining zone: lo ≥ larger lateral dimension, 1/6 of the clear span, 450 mm; spacing ≤ 1/4 of the minimum member dimension, 6 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter, 100 mm (cl. 7.6, numbered 8.1 in the 2016 text before Amendment No. 1)Ash = area of the bar forming the link or spiral ≥ max[0.18 sv h (fck/fy)(Ag/Ak − 1), 0.05 sv h fck/fy] (mm²; sv, h in mm)
- The building is a regular moment-resisting frame with the plan and vertical irregularities listed in IS 1893 (Part 1) avoided (IS 13920 cl. 5.5); irregular buildings need more than detailing.
- The frame members are designed for the reduced seismic forces of IS 1893 (Part 1) and combined loads to IS 456 first; this lesson covers only the extra rules for ductility.
- Beam rules apply where the factored axial compressive stress does not exceed 0.08 fck (cl. 6.1); members with more axial load follow the column rules of cl. 7.
- The moments of resistance used in capacity design come from the actual reinforcement provided (cl. 6.3.3 and 7.2.1.1), not from the analysis moments.
- Shear walls, beam-column joint shear checks and gravity columns have further rules in IS 13920 cl. 9 to 11, outside this introduction.
- The h used for Ash with one cross-tie each way is taken as half the core width, the usual textbook reading of the code note that cross-ties reduce h.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 13920:2016 cl. 5.1 (IS 456 governs except as modified), cl. 5.2 (M20 minimum, M25 for buildings over 15 m in Zones III to V), cl. 5.3.1 and 5.3.2 as amended by Amendment No. 2, 2020 (grades 415, 500 and 550 MPa only, elongation at least 14.5 per cent, ultimate-to-proof ratio 1.15 to 1.25, actual proof stress not more than 20 per cent above characteristic; cl. 5.3.3 deleted), cl. 5.5 (regular planar frames).
- IS 13920:2016 beams: cl. 6.1 (axial stress up to 0.08 fck), cl. 6.1.1 (width-to-depth ratio preferably more than 0.3), cl. 6.1.2 (width at least 200 mm), cl. 6.1.3 (depth not more than a quarter of the clear span), cl. 6.2.1 (two 12 mm bars each face and ρmin = 0.24 √fck/fy), cl. 6.2.2 (ρmax = 0.025), cl. 6.2.3 (bottom steel at the column face at least half the top steel), cl. 6.2.4 (any section at least a quarter of the top steel at the column face), cl. 6.2.6.1 (laps with links at not more than 150 mm, not within a joint, within 2d of the column face or near hinges; not more than 50 per cent of bars lapped at a section), cl. 6.3.2 (links at least 8 mm), cl. 6.3.3 (capacity-design shear with 1.4 and gravity factor 1.2), cl. 6.3.4 (bent-up bars, inclined links and concrete not counted), cl. 6.3.5, 6.3.5.1 and 6.3.5.2 (link spacing).
- IS 13920:2016 columns: cl. 7.1.1 (minimum dimension at least 20 times the largest beam bar diameter and 300 mm), cl. 7.1.2 (aspect ratio at least 0.45), cl. 7.2.1 (column capacities at least 1.4 times beam capacities at each joint), cl. 7.3.2.1 (laps only in the central half of the clear height, links at not more than 100 mm), cl. 7.4.1 (closed links with 135° hooks extended 8 diameters, at least 75 mm, Amendment No. 1), cl. 7.4.2 (link diameter, legs at not more than 300 mm, cross-ties), cl. 7.5 (capacity-design column shear), cl. 7.6 (special confining reinforcement: length lo, spacing and Ash; numbered 8.1 in the unamended 2016 text), cl. 7.6.2 / original 8.2 (confinement extends at least 300 mm into the footing).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 40.4 (shear reinforcement design). IS 1893 (Part 1) for seismic forces and IS 1786 for bars, named by number only.
- EN 1998-1 (Eurocode 8) sets ductility classes DCM and DCH with capacity design and confinement rules for each; ACI 318 Chapter 18 sets rules for special moment frames, including a strong column, weak beam ratio and confinement over a length lo. Listed side by side, not ranked.
Worked examples
Problem. A frame beam 300 mm × 600 mm (d = 550 mm), clear span 6.0 m, M25 concrete, Fe 500 longitudinal bars, carries 4 bars of 20 mm at the top at the column face and 16 mm bars elsewhere. Check the geometry and find the steel limits and link spacing required by IS 13920:2016.
- Geometry: b/D = 300/600 = 0.5 > 0.3 (cl. 6.1.1); b = 300 ≥ 200 mm (cl. 6.1.2); D = 600 ≤ 6 000/4 = 1 500 mm (cl. 6.1.3). All satisfied.
- ρmin = 0.24 √25/500 = 0.0024; As,min = 0.0024 × 300 × 550 = 396 mm² on each face, more than two 12 mm bars (226 mm²).
- ρmax = 0.025: As,max = 0.025 × 300 × 550 = 4 125 mm² on any face.
- Top steel at the face 4-20 = 1 257 mm², so bottom steel at that face ≥ 628 mm² (cl. 6.2.3): for example 2-16 plus 1-20, or 4-16 (804 mm²). At every section both faces need ≥ 1 257/4 = 314 mm² (cl. 6.2.4), so the 396 mm² minimum governs there.
- Links over 2d = 1 100 mm from each column face: spacing ≤ min(d/4 = 137.5, 6 × 16 = 96, 100) = 96 mm (Amendment No. 1; the pre-2017 8 × 16 = 128 mm limit would have left 100 mm governing), first link within 50 mm of the face (cl. 6.3.5, 6.3.5.1). Elsewhere spacing ≤ d/2 = 275 mm. Links at least 8 mm (cl. 6.3.2).
Answer. Geometry passes; 396 mm² minimum and 4 125 mm² maximum per face; bottom steel at the face at least 628 mm²; links at 96 mm over 1 100 mm at each end, not more than 275 mm elsewhere.
Problem. The beam of Example 1 has moments of resistance (from the steel provided) of 280 kN m hogging and 180 kN m sagging at each end. Dead load 25 kN/m and live load 15 kN/m. Links Fe 415. Find the design shear and the links.
- Gravity shear with the factor 1.2 and the beam simply supported: w = 1.2 × (25 + 15) = 48 kN/m; Vu(D+L) = 48 × 6.0/2 = 144 kN at each end.
- Sway to the right: 1.4 (MuAs + MuBh)/LAB = 1.4 × (180 + 280)/6.0 = 107.3 kN. Vu,a = 144 − 107.3 = 36.7 kN; Vu,b = 144 + 107.3 = 251.3 kN.
- Sway to the left gives the mirror image: Vu,a = 144 + 1.4 × (280 + 180)/6.0 = 251.3 kN. Design shear = 251.3 kN at both ends.
- Concrete ignored (cl. 6.3.4). Two-legged 8 mm links (101 mm²) would need sv = 0.87 × 415 × 101 × 550/251 300 = 79 mm. Two-legged 10 mm links (157 mm²): sv = 0.87 × 415 × 157 × 550/251 300 = 124 mm; the end-zone limit from Example 1 is 96 mm (6 × 16 mm, Amendment No. 1), so use 10 mm at 90 mm over 2d (capacity 0.87 × 415 × 157 × 550/90 = 346.4 kN).
- Beyond 2d from the face: Vu = 251.3 − 48 × 1.1 = 198.5 kN; sv = 0.87 × 415 × 157 × 550/198 500 = 157 mm. Use 10 mm at 150 mm, within d/2 = 275 mm.
Answer. Design shear 251.3 kN; two-legged 10 mm links at 90 mm over 1.1 m at each end and at 150 mm in the middle.
Problem. An interior column 450 mm × 450 mm, M25, 20 mm longitudinal bars, Fe 415 links, 40 mm clear cover to the links, clear height 3.0 m, storey height 3.3 m. At a joint the beam capacities are 260 kN m (hogging, one side) and 170 kN m (sagging, other side); the column capacities above and below, at the critical axial load, are 310 and 320 kN m. Check cl. 7.2.1 and find the column design shear, lo, link spacing and Ash.
- Strong column, weak beam: 1.4 ΣMb = 1.4 × (260 + 170) = 602 kN m; ΣMc = 310 + 320 = 630 kN m ≥ 602. Satisfied (only just: a 20 kN m shortfall would make the column a gravity column only).
- Capacity shear: Vu = 1.4 × (170 + 260)/3.3 = 182.4 kN (cl. 7.5), compared with the analysis shear and the larger used.
- Confining length: lo ≥ max(450, 3 000/6 = 500, 450) = 500 mm at each end (cl. 7.6).
- Spacing: ≤ min(450/4 = 112.5, 6 × 20 = 120, 100) = 100 mm.
- Core to the outside of the links = 450 − 2 × 40 = 370 mm, so Ak = 370² = 136 900 mm², Ag = 202 500 mm², Ag/Ak = 1.479. The link side 370 mm exceeds 300 mm, so cross-ties are needed (cl. 7.4.2); with one each way, h = 185 mm.
- Ash in IS 13920 is the area of the bar that forms the link, not the total of all legs. Required Ash = max[0.18 × 100 × 185 × (25/415) × 0.479, 0.05 × 100 × 185 × 25/415] = max(96.1, 55.7) = 96.1 mm². A 12 mm bar (113 mm²) at 100 mm works; a 10 mm bar (78.5 mm²) would need the spacing dropped to 80 mm.
Answer. ΣMc = 630 ≥ 602 kN m; Vu = 182.4 kN; lo = 500 mm; spacing 100 mm; Ash = 96.1 mm², so 12 mm links with cross-ties at 100 mm (or 10 mm at 80 mm) over 500 mm at each end.
Step-by-step procedure
- Confirm the materials (cl. 5.2, 5.3) and that the frame is regular (cl. 5.5).
- Analyse the frame for the IS 1893 (Part 1) load combinations and design members to IS 456.
- Check beam geometry (cl. 6.1.1 to 6.1.3) and longitudinal steel limits (cl. 6.2.1 to 6.2.4), and place laps away from joints and hinge zones (cl. 6.2.6.1).
- Compute the beam moments of resistance from the steel provided, then the capacity-design shear (cl. 6.3.3) with the concrete ignored (cl. 6.3.4), and space links within the cl. 6.3.5 limits.
- Check column geometry (cl. 7.1.1, 7.1.2) and strong column, weak beam at each joint (cl. 7.2.1).
- Find the column capacity shear (cl. 7.5) and design the column links.
- Provide special confining reinforcement over lo at each column end (cl. 7.6), extended at least 300 mm into the footing (cl. 7.6.2 / original 8.2).
- Draw the joint details: 135° hooks, cross-ties, lap positions and bar anchorage at exterior joints (cl. 6.2.5).
Site notes
- Check every link hook on site: 135° bends with a straight extension of 8 diameters, but not less than 75 mm, into the core (Amendment No. 1, 2017; the original 2016 text said 6 diameters and 65 mm). 90° hooks open out when the cover spalls.
- Joints are congested. Agree the bar sequence before fixing, and use smaller aggregate or self-compacting concrete if needed; a honeycombed joint undoes all the detailing.
- Do not lap column bars just above the floor, the most convenient place on site and the place where a hinge forms; laps go in the central half of the clear height.
- Keep the confining links going through the beam-column joint; they are often left out because they are hard to place.
- Test certificates for the bars must show elongation, the proof strength and the ultimate-to-proof ratio required by cl. 5.3.
- Lapping column bars at floor level, inside the hinge zone.
- Using 90° hooks on links or omitting cross-ties in columns wider than about 300 mm of link side.
- Designing beam shear from the analysis shear only, instead of the larger capacity-design shear.
- Counting the concrete shear strength in capacity-design shear.
- Making beams stronger than the columns, for example with deep upstand beams, which reverses the hinge pattern.
In a typical frame beam the capacity-design shear is about 1.5 to 2 times the gravity shear; in Example 2 it is 251.3/144 = 1.75. If the calculated design shear comes out barely above the gravity shear, check that the moments of resistance used are those of the steel actually provided. The guide applies to beams in Zones III to V with spans of about 4 to 8 m.
Summary
- Ductility, the capacity to deform well beyond yield, is what lets a frame survive forces larger than its design forces; IS 13920 provides it through materials, proportions and detailing.
- Steel: grades 415, 500 or 550 MPa with elongation at least 14.5 per cent, controlled over-strength and an ultimate-to-proof ratio of 1.15 to 1.25 (Amendment No. 2).
- Beams: ρmin 0.24 √fck/fy, ρmax 0.025, bottom steel at the face at least half the top, links at d/4, 6 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter or 100 mm over 2d (Amendment No. 1).
- Columns: strong column, weak beam with a factor of 1.4; confinement over lo with Ash from cl. 7.6 (original 8.1).
- Shear is designed for the plastic hinge moments (capacity design), so the ductile flexural mode comes before the brittle shear mode.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find ρmin for a beam of M20 concrete with Fe 415 bars under IS 13920.
ρmin = 0.24 √20/415 = 0.0026, that is 0.26 per cent of b d on each face.
2A beam has d = 450 mm and 12 mm smallest longitudinal bars. What link spacing is needed in the end zones, and over what length?
min(450/4 = 112.5, 6 × 12 = 72, 100) = 72 mm, over 2d = 900 mm from each column face.
3A 400 mm square column has a clear height of 2.8 m and 16 mm bars. Find lo and the confining link spacing.
lo = max(400, 2 800/6 = 467, 450) = 467 mm, say 470 mm; spacing ≤ min(100, 6 × 16 = 96, 100) = 96 mm.
4Why is the concrete contribution ignored in beam capacity-design shear?
Under reversed cyclic loading the hinge zone cracks through in both directions and the concrete shear strength degrades, so the links must carry the whole shear.
5Is a 230 mm × 450 mm beam acceptable under IS 13920 for width and proportions?
Yes: width 230 ≥ 200 mm and b/D = 0.51 > 0.3.
6What happens to a column at a joint that fails the strong column, weak beam check?
IS 13920 cl. 7.2.1 says it is to be treated as a gravity column only, not part of the lateral load resisting system.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Correction note. Corrected 10 November 2026: earlier versions used the pre-amendment beam hoop-spacing limit of 8 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter (which made 100 mm govern in Example 1) and the original 2016 hook extension of 6 diameters and 65 mm. IS 13920:2016 Amendment No. 1 (September 2017) sets end-zone spacing as the least of d/4, 6 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter, and 100 mm, and hook extensions as 8 bar diameters but not less than 75 mm. Special confining reinforcement is in cl. 7.6 after that amendment (cl. 8.1 in the 2016 print). See our corrections policy.