3.3 Design for torsion
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Distinguish equilibrium torsion, which must be designed for, from compatibility torsion, which IS 456:2000 cl. 41.1 allows to be released by neglecting torsional stiffness, and explain how torsion cracks a beam.
- Compute the equivalent shear Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b and the equivalent moment Me1 = Mu + Mt with Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7, and check τve against Tables 19 and 20.
- Design closed two-legged hoops by cl. 41.4.3 and longitudinal bars by cl. 41.4.2, apply the detailing rules of cl. 26.5.1.7, and relate the IS formula for hoops to the space-truss model of a cracked beam.
Theory
A beam is twisted when its loads act off its axis: a spandrel beam carrying a cantilever canopy, a beam supporting a slab on one side only, a curved beam in plan, or a lintel carrying a projecting sunshade. Strength of Materials lesson 6.1 showed how a circular shaft resists torque by shear stress that grows with distance from the centre. A rectangular concrete beam behaves similarly before cracking, with the largest shear stress at the middle of the long faces. Concrete is weak in tension, so the principal tension caused by this shear (at 45 degrees) cracks the beam in a spiral pattern round all four faces.
Two kinds of torsion are met in buildings. Equilibrium torsion is needed to keep the structure standing: the canopy would fall if the spandrel did not twist to carry it. It must be designed for. Compatibility torsion arises only because the beam is built monolithically with members that rotate; for example an edge beam twisted by the end rotation of a floor slab. If the torsional stiffness is neglected in the analysis, the slab simply redistributes its moments, and IS 456:2000 cl. 41.1 says that no specific design for torsion is then necessary, the shear reinforcement of cl. 40 being enough to control cracking.
After cracking, a twisted beam works like a hollow tube: the core contributes little, and the torque is carried by a circulating shear flow in a skin near the surface. That skin acts as a space truss. Concrete strips between the spiral cracks form inclined compression struts, the closed hoops are the transverse ties, and longitudinal bars in the corners are the chords. This is why torsion reinforcement must be closed hoops anchored round corner bars: an open U-stirrup cannot carry the circulating force, and without a bar in every corner the struts have nothing to push against.
IS 456 does not ask designers to analyse this truss directly. Instead (cl. 41, Note), torsional reinforcement is combined with bending and shear steel through two fictitious actions. An equivalent shear Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b is used to check the web and to decide whether torsion steel is needed; an equivalent bending moment Me1 = Mu + Mt with Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7 is used to size the longitudinal steel; and the hoops are sized from a formula that adds a torsion term Tu sv/(b1 d1 (0.87 fy)) to a reduced shear term. Remarkably, the torsion term is exactly what a 45-degree space truss with the hoop enclosing the area b1 d1 gives, which links the code to the mechanics.
Derivation
- Uncracked elastic behaviour: for a rectangle b × D (b the shorter side), the maximum torsional shear stress at the middle of the long face is τ = Tu/(α b² D), with α between about 0.21 and 0.33 depending on D/b (Strength of Materials, torsion of non-circular sections). Adding this to the direct shear explains why IS 456 adds a torsion term to the shear.
- Equivalent shear (cl. 41.3.1): Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b; equivalent nominal shear stress τve = Ve/(b d). It must not exceed τc,max of Table 20; if it does not exceed τc of Table 19, minimum shear reinforcement suffices (cl. 41.3.2); otherwise both longitudinal and transverse torsion steel are required (cl. 41.3.3).
- Longitudinal steel (cl. 41.4.2): Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7 and Me1 = Mu + Mt, designed as a bending moment for the flexural tension face. If Mt > Mu, steel is also needed on the flexural compression face for Me2 = Mt − Mu acting in the opposite sense (cl. 41.4.2.1).
- Space truss for the hoops: in a thin-walled tube the shear flow is q = Tu/(2 A0), with A0 the area enclosed by the shear flow path. A 45-degree crack on one face crosses hoop legs over a length equal to the face dimension; equating the yielding leg force At 0.87 fy per spacing s to q gives At/s = Tu/(2 A0 × 0.87 fy) for one leg.
- With A0 = b1 d1 (the area enclosed by the corner bars) and Asv = 2 At for a two-legged hoop: Asv/sv = Tu/(b1 d1 × 0.87 fy), which is the torsion term of cl. 41.4.3. The code adds the shear term Vu/(2.5 d1 × 0.87 fy) and requires the total to be at least (τve − τc) b/(0.87 fy) per unit spacing.
- Detailing (cl. 26.5.1.7): rectangular closed stirrups perpendicular to the axis at a spacing not exceeding the least of x1, (x1 + y1)/4 and 300 mm, where x1 and y1 are the short and long dimensions of the stirrup; at least one longitudinal bar in each corner of the ties; and, where a cross-sectional dimension exceeds 450 mm, additional longitudinal bars to meet the side-face rules of cl. 26.5.1.3.
Equivalent shear: Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b (kN, with Tu in kN m and b in m); τve = Ve/(b d) (N/mm²)Equivalent moment: Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7; Me1 = Mu + Mt (kN m); if Mt > Mu, Me2 = Mt − Mu on the compression face (kN m)Two-legged closed hoops: Asv = Tu sv/(b1 d1 (0.87 fy)) + Vu sv/(2.5 d1 (0.87 fy)) (mm²; Tu in N mm, Vu in N, b1, d1 and sv in mm)Minimum total hoop area: Asv ≥ (τve − τc) b sv/(0.87 fy) (mm²)Hoop spacing: sv ≤ least of x1, (x1 + y1)/4 and 300 mmThin-walled tube (space truss): shear flow q = Tu/(2 A0) (N/mm); one leg At/s = Tu/(2 A0 × 0.87 fy) (mm²/mm)
- The rules of cl. 41.3 and 41.4 are for solid rectangular sections; for flanged beams the web width bw may be used for b, which is generally conservative (cl. 41.1.1).
- Sections closer than d to the face of a support may be designed for the torsion at d (cl. 41.2).
- The hoops are closed, anchored round the corner bars with proper hooks, and the longitudinal bars are close to the corners, so the space truss can develop.
- Torsion, shear and bending are combined through the fictitious Ve and Me; the method gives the steel directly and does not report a strut angle or a separate torsional capacity.
- Limits: compatibility torsion need not be designed for if torsional stiffness is neglected in the analysis (cl. 41.1); box sections, thin-walled open sections and members with large axial force need specialist treatment; warping torsion of open steel-like sections is outside this method.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 41.1 (equilibrium torsion to be designed; compatibility torsion may be neglected if torsional stiffness is neglected in the analysis; shear reinforcement controls torsional cracking) and cl. 41.1.1 (rectangular sections; bw for flanged beams), cl. 41.2 (critical section at d from the face of the support), cl. 41.3.1 to 41.3.3 (Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b; τve not to exceed τc,max of Table 20; minimum shear steel when τve ≤ τc of Table 19), cl. 41.4.2 and 41.4.2.1 (Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7, Me1 = Mu + Mt, Me2 = Mt − Mu when Mt > Mu), cl. 41.4.3 (two-legged closed hoops and the minimum (τve − τc) b sv/(0.87 fy)).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.1.7 (closed rectangular stirrups at not more than the least of x1, (x1 + y1)/4 and 300 mm; a longitudinal bar in each corner; additional bars when a dimension exceeds 450 mm, with cl. 26.5.1.3), cl. 26.5.1.4 (transverse reinforcement taken round the outermost tension and compression bars), Table 19 and Table 20 as in lesson 3.1.
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) designs torsion directly on a thin-walled closed section (space truss) with a variable strut angle and an interaction check for combined shear and torsion; the American code (ACI 318) also uses the thin-walled tube and space-truss model with a threshold torque below which torsion may be neglected. Coefficients and limits differ and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. The spandrel beam of Strength of Materials lesson 6.3, Example 3, is 300 mm wide and 600 mm deep with d = 550 mm, M20 concrete and Fe 415 steel. At the critical section Vu = 80 kN, Tu = 25 kN m and Mu = 110 kN m. Corner bars are 50 mm from each face (b1 = 200 mm, d1 = 500 mm) and the 10 mm hoops are 230 mm × 530 mm centre to centre. Design the longitudinal steel and the hoops.
- Ve = 80 + 1.6 × 25/0.30 = 213.3 kN; τve = 213 333/(300 × 550) = 1.29 N/mm² < τc,max = 2.8 N/mm²: the section is adequate.
- Mt = 25 × (1 + 600/300)/1.7 = 44.1 kN m < Mu, so Me1 = 110 + 44.1 = 154.1 kN m and no Me2 is needed. Mu,lim = 0.138 × 20 × 300 × 550² = 250.5 kN m > 154.1, singly reinforced.
- Ast = 0.5 × (20/415) × [1 − √(1 − 4.6 × 154.1 × 10⁶/(20 × 300 × 550²))] × 300 × 550 = 872 mm²: provide three 20 mm bars (942 mm²) at the bottom, two 12 mm bars at the top corners and one 12 mm bar on each side face at mid-depth (D > 450 mm).
- pt = 100 × 942/(300 × 550) = 0.57 per cent; τc = 0.503 N/mm² (Table 19, M20, interpolated). Since τve > τc, torsion steel is required.
- Hoops: Asv/sv = 25 × 10⁶/(200 × 500 × 361.05) + 80 000/(2.5 × 500 × 361.05) = 0.692 + 0.177 = 0.870 mm²/mm; minimum (1.29 − 0.503) × 300/361.05 = 0.657 mm²/mm, so 0.870 governs. For 2L-10 (157.1 mm²): sv = 157.1/0.870 = 181 mm.
- Spacing limits: x1 = 230 mm, (230 + 530)/4 = 190 mm, 300 mm. Adopt closed 10 mm hoops at 175 mm with 135-degree hooks.
Answer. Ve = 213 kN (τve 1.29 N/mm²); Me1 = 154 kN m, 3-20 bottom; 10 mm closed hoops at 175 mm
Problem. An edge beam 250 mm × 500 mm (d = 450 mm, corner bars 50 mm from each face) in M25 concrete with Fe 415 steel carries Vu = 60 kN, Tu = 30 kN m and Mu = 40 kN m. Find Ve, Me1 and Me2, the longitudinal steel and the hoops.
- Ve = 60 + 1.6 × 30/0.25 = 252 kN; τve = 252 000/(250 × 450) = 2.24 N/mm² < 3.1 N/mm² (M25): adequate.
- Mt = 30 × (1 + 500/250)/1.7 = 52.9 kN m > Mu = 40 kN m, so Me1 = 92.9 kN m (bottom) and Me2 = 52.9 − 40 = 12.9 kN m acting the other way (top).
- Bottom: Ast = 631 mm², provide four 16 mm bars (804 mm²). Top: Me2 needs only 81 mm², but the minimum tension steel 0.85 × 250 × 450/415 = 230 mm² governs; provide two 16 mm bars (402 mm²).
- pt = 0.71 per cent, τc = 0.559 N/mm² (M25, interpolated). b1 = 150 mm, d1 = 400 mm: Asv/sv = 30 × 10⁶/(150 × 400 × 361.05) + 60 000/(2.5 × 400 × 361.05) = 1.385 + 0.166 = 1.551 mm²/mm, above the minimum (2.24 − 0.559) × 250/361.05 = 1.164.
- 2L-10: sv = 157.1/1.551 = 101 mm; limits x1 = 180 mm, (180 + 430)/4 = 152 mm, 300 mm. Adopt closed 10 mm hoops at 100 mm.
Answer. Ve = 252 kN; Me1 = 92.9 kN m (4-16 bottom), Me2 = 12.9 kN m (2-16 top); 10 mm hoops at 100 mm
Problem. A 1.5 m cantilever canopy is cast monolithically with a 300 mm × 600 mm spandrel beam (d = 550 mm) spanning 6.0 m between 400 mm columns that restrain it against twisting. The canopy's factored load is 12 kN/m² and the beam's own factored load (self-weight and wall) is 20 kN/m. Find Tu and Vu at the critical section and the equivalent shear stress, and decide whether torsion must be designed for.
- Torque per metre about the beam axis: 12 × 1.5 × (1.5/2 + 0.15) = 16.2 kN m/m; vertical load per metre 12 × 1.5 + 20 = 38 kN/m.
- The beam is restrained against twist at both columns, so the torque is shared equally: the twisting moment at midspan is zero and grows linearly to the supports. The critical section is at d from the column face: 0.2 + 0.55 = 0.75 m from the column centre.
- Tu = 16.2 × (3.0 − 0.75) = 36.45 kN m; Vu = 38 × (3.0 − 0.75) = 85.5 kN.
- Ve = 85.5 + 1.6 × 36.45/0.30 = 279.9 kN; τve = 279 900/(300 × 550) = 1.70 N/mm², below τc,max for M20 (2.8) and M25 (3.1).
- This is equilibrium torsion: without the beam's twisting resistance the canopy would collapse. It cannot be released (cl. 41.1), so the beam is designed for torsion as in Example 1, and the columns must be able to take the torque as moments.
Answer. Tu = 36.5 kN m, Vu = 85.5 kN, τve = 1.70 N/mm²; equilibrium torsion, so design for it
Step-by-step procedure
- Decide whether the torsion is equilibrium torsion (design for it) or compatibility torsion (may be released by neglecting torsional stiffness, cl. 41.1).
- Find Vu, Tu and Mu at the critical section (at d from the support face).
- Compute Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b and τve = Ve/(b d); check against τc,max (Table 20).
- Compute Mt = Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7, design the tension face for Me1 = Mu + Mt, and the compression face for Me2 = Mt − Mu if Mt > Mu.
- Read τc for the steel provided; if τve > τc, size two-legged closed hoops by cl. 41.4.3, check the minimum, and apply the spacing limits x1, (x1 + y1)/4 and 300 mm.
- Detail: closed hoops with 135-degree hooks, a bar in every corner, side bars when D or b exceeds 450 mm, and anchorage of longitudinal bars into the supports.
Site notes
- Torsion hoops must be closed; U-stirrups with a separate top cap bar are not acceptable unless the drawing shows a lapped closed detail.
- Check that hook ends of hoops are bent to 135 degrees into the core; 90-degree hooks open under torsion when the cover spalls.
- Every corner of a hoop needs a longitudinal bar; missing top corner bars in spandrel beams are a common defect.
- Canopy and balcony bars must be anchored into the beam far enough to develop their force; their torque reaches the columns only through the beam.
- Do not remove the props of a cantilever canopy until the spandrel beam and columns have gained strength; early striking twists the beam before it can resist.
- Designing a beam that carries a canopy as if the torsion were compatibility torsion and releasing it.
- Using the overall depth for d, or the flange width for b, in Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b.
- Forgetting Me2 on the compression face when Mt exceeds Mu.
- Spacing torsion hoops at 0.75 d as for shear, ignoring x1 and (x1 + y1)/4.
- Taking b1 and d1 as the overall section dimensions instead of the distances between corner bars.
Each kN m of torque adds 1.6/b kN of equivalent shear: 5.3 kN for b = 300 mm and 6.4 kN for b = 250 mm. For D/b = 2, Mt is about 1.76 Tu. The hoop torsion term equals two legs of a 45-degree space truss enclosing b1 d1, so a quick hoop estimate is Asv/sv ≈ Tu/(0.87 fy b1 d1). Torsion hoop spacing in beams of ordinary size usually ends up between about 75 and 200 mm.
Summary
- Equilibrium torsion must be designed for; compatibility torsion may be released if torsional stiffness is neglected in the analysis (cl. 41.1).
- Torsion cracks a beam spirally; after cracking it acts as a tube or space truss with concrete struts, closed hoops and corner bars.
- IS 456 combines torsion with shear by Ve = Vu + 1.6 Tu/b and with bending by Me1 = Mu + Tu (1 + D/b)/1.7 (and Me2 when Mt > Mu).
- Two-legged closed hoops: Asv = Tu sv/(b1 d1 (0.87 fy)) + Vu sv/(2.5 d1 (0.87 fy)), not less than (τve − τc) b sv/(0.87 fy); the torsion term is the 45-degree space-truss result.
- Hoop spacing must not exceed x1, (x1 + y1)/4 or 300 mm, with a bar in every corner and side bars when a dimension exceeds 450 mm (cl. 26.5.1.7).
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find Ve for Vu = 50 kN, Tu = 15 kN m and b = 250 mm.
Ve = 50 + 1.6 × 15/0.25 = 146 kN.
2Find Mt for Tu = 20 kN m, D = 500 mm and b = 250 mm.
Mt = 20 × (1 + 2)/1.7 = 35.3 kN m.
3Find the maximum hoop spacing for x1 = 200 mm and y1 = 450 mm.
Least of 200, (200 + 450)/4 = 162.5 and 300 mm: 162.5 mm, say 160 mm.
4Find τve for Ve = 146 kN, b = 250 mm and d = 450 mm, and compare with τc,max for M20.
146 000/(250 × 450) = 1.30 N/mm², below 2.8 N/mm².
5An edge beam supports one side of a floor slab. Must it be designed for torsion?
Usually not: it is compatibility torsion, which may be ignored if the beam's torsional stiffness is neglected in the slab analysis (cl. 41.1); the shear stirrups control cracking.
6Why must torsion stirrups be closed and anchored round corner bars?
The torque is carried by a shear flow circulating round all four faces; the hoop must carry tension continuously round the section, and the corner bars anchor the inclined concrete struts.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.