Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 7 › Lesson 7.2

7.2 Combined footings

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 7: Footings Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Decide when two columns need a combined footing, and size a rectangular or trapezoidal footing so that its centroid lies under the resultant of the column loads.
  • Draw the shear force and bending moment diagrams of a combined footing treated as an inverted beam, and place top and bottom steel accordingly.
  • Check one-way shear, punching at interior and edge columns, and transverse bending in bands under the columns.

Theory

When two columns are close together, their isolated footings overlap; when a column stands on a property line, its footing cannot project beyond it and an isolated footing would be loaded eccentrically. In both cases one footing is made for both columns. The aim is a uniform soil pressure, which is reached when the centroid of the footing area lies directly under the resultant of the column loads.

For a rectangular footing the centroid is at mid-length, so the footing is made twice as long as the distance from its end to the resultant. If the length is restricted at both ends, for example by property lines, a trapezoidal plan moves the centroid towards the heavier column: its centroid is at (L/3)(B1 + 2B2)/(B1 + B2) from the wide end, which works as long as the resultant lies between L/3 and L/2 from the wide end. A strap footing, two pads joined by a stiff beam, is the other answer for a boundary column.

Combined footing: loads and momentsP1P2hoggingsaggingbending moment, tension face changes at two points
Figure 7.2: A rectangular combined footing under two columns with uniform upward soil pressure, and the bending moment along it: hogging between the columns and sagging at and beyond them. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Structurally, a combined footing behaves like an upside-down continuous beam: the soil pressure pushes up along its whole length, and the two columns hold it down. Between the columns the footing bends upwards, so the moment there is hogging, with tension at the top; beyond each column the overhangs act as cantilevers with tension at the bottom. The largest hogging moment is where the shear force is zero. Main steel therefore runs along the footing at the top between the columns and at the bottom under and beyond them.

Across the footing, each column load spreads out sideways like the cantilever of an isolated footing. The transverse steel is usually concentrated in a band under each column, a common textbook choice being the column width plus d/2 on each side (or on the one free side of a boundary column), with nominal steel elsewhere. Shear is checked as for isolated footings: one-way shear across the full width at d from the column faces, and punching around each column, with a three-sided perimeter at a column on the edge (cl. 31.6.1.1).

Derivation

  1. Resultant: for loads P1 and P2 at spacing s, the resultant is at x̄ = P2 s/(P1 + P2) from P1.
  2. Rectangular footing with its end at a distance e1 outside the centre of P1: uniform pressure requires the centroid at the resultant, so L/2 = e1 + x̄ and L = 2 (e1 + x̄). Width B = required area / L.
  3. Line load from the soil: w = (Pu1 + Pu2)/L in kN/m. Shear just left of P1: w e1; just right: w e1 − Pu1. The shear is zero at x0 = Pu1/w from the end.
  4. Moment (sagging positive) at x between the columns: M(x) = w x²/2 − Pu1 (x − e1); at x0 this is the largest hogging moment. The moment returns to zero at the free end, as equilibrium requires.
  5. Trapezoid of length L with end widths B1 and B2: area A = L (B1 + B2)/2 and centroid from the B1 end x = (L/3)(B1 + 2B2)/(B1 + B2). Setting A and x to the required values gives two linear equations for B1 and B2.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Resultant position from P1: x̄ = P2 s/(P1 + P2) (m)
  • Rectangular footing length for uniform pressure: L = 2 (e1 + x̄) (m), with e1 = distance from the footing end to the centre of P1
  • Soil line load: w = (Pu1 + Pu2)/L (kN/m); area pressure qu = (Pu1 + Pu2)/(L B) (kN/m²)
  • Zero shear: x0 = Pu1/w; Mmax = w x0²/2 − Pu1 (x0 − e1) (kN m)
  • Trapezoid: A = L (B1 + B2)/2; x from wide end = (L/3)(B1 + 2B2)/(B1 + B2), valid for L/3 ≤ x < L/2
  • Punching at an interior column: b0 = 4 (c + d); at an edge column flush with the end: b0 = 2 (c + d/2) + (c + d) (mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • The footing is rigid and the soil pressure uniform (or linear), as in lesson 7.1. A long or flexible combined footing should be analysed as a beam on an elastic foundation.
  • Column loads are treated as point loads at the column centres for the moment diagram; shears for design are taken at d from the faces.
  • The service and factored load ratios are the same for both columns, so the footing sized for uniform service pressure also has uniform factored pressure.
  • The transverse band width is a textbook convention, not a code value; it is used here for the first design.
  • Limits: moment transfer from columns into the footing, strap footings and footings for more than two columns are not worked here.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 34.1 (uniform settlement as far as possible and the safe bearing capacity not exceeded; it points to IS 1904), cl. 34.1.2 (edge thickness), cl. 34.2.3.1 (moment from all pressure on one side of a section across the footing), cl. 34.2.4.1 (one-way shear at d from the face for footings on soils, as amended, and two-way shear by cl. 31.6), cl. 34.2.4.3 (development length at bending sections).
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 31.6.1 and 31.6.1.1 (punching perimeter at d/2, and the critical section at a column near a free edge), cl. 31.6.2.1 and 31.6.3.1 (τv = V/(b0 d) against ks 0.25 √fck), cl. 34.3 (steel to resist the moment at every section), cl. 34.4 and 34.4.3 (load transfer and dowels), cl. 34.5.1 (minimum steel as for slabs), cl. 26.4.2.2 (50 mm cover), cl. 26.2.1 (development length), cl. 36.4.1 (load factors), Table 19 (cl. 40.2.1); IS 1904; IS 1786.
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) treats a combined footing as a beam or slab for bending and checks punching on its own control perimeters, with soil pressures from EN 1997-1; in American practice ACI 318 gives the strength rules and the committee report ACI 336.2R discusses analysis of combined footings and mats. Factors are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (rectangular combined footing: size, shear force and bending moment)

Problem. Column A, 400 mm square, carries 800 kN at service and stands with its outer face on a property line. Column B, 450 mm square, carries 1 200 kN at service, 4.0 m centre to centre from A. Safe bearing capacity 200 kN/m², M25, Fe 415, footing 800 mm thick with d = 740 mm. Size the footing and draw the factored shear and moment diagrams.

  1. Resultant from A: x̄ = 1 200 × 4.0/2 000 = 2.4 m, which is 2.6 m from the property line (A centre is 0.2 m inside it). L = 2 × 2.6 = 5.2 m, leaving a 1.0 m overhang beyond B.
  2. Area = 1.1 × 2 000/200 = 11.0 m², B = 11.0/5.2 = 2.12 m; adopt 2.2 m.
  3. Factored loads 1 200 and 1 800 kN; w = 3 000/5.2 = 576.9 kN/m (262.2 kN/m² over the 2.2 m width).
  4. Shear: at A, 115.4 kN on the left and 115.4 − 1 200 = −1 084.6 kN on the right; at B, 576.9 × 4.2 − 1 200 = 1 223.1 kN on the left and −576.9 kN on the right, falling to zero at the free end.
  5. Zero shear at x0 = 1 200/576.9 = 2.08 m from the property line. Mmax = 576.9 × 2.08²/2 − 1 200 × (2.08 − 0.2) = 1 248.0 − 2 256.0 = −1 008.0 kN m (hogging, tension at the top). At A the moment is 11.5 kN m and at B it is 576.9 × 1.0²/2 = 288.5 kN m, both sagging. The moment changes sign at 0.21 m and 3.95 m from the property line.
  6. Top steel for 1 008.0 kN m on b = 2 200 mm: Ast = 3 932 mm².
  7. One-way shear at d from the inner face of B (x = 4.2 − 0.225 − 0.74 = 3.235 m): Vu = 576.9 × 3.235 − 1 200 = 666.3 kN, τv = 666 300/(2 200 × 740) = 0.41 N/mm². With 12 bars of 25 mm at the top (5 890 mm², pt = 0.362 per cent) τc = 0.42 N/mm²: safe, so 12 bars of 25 mm are provided rather than the 9 that bending alone needs. At d from the inner face of A, Vu = 542.3 kN and τv = 0.33 N/mm².
  8. Bottom steel under B for 288.5 kN m: Ast = 1 092 mm², below the minimum 0.0012 × 2 200 × 800 = 2 112 mm², so 11 bars of 16 mm (2 212 mm²).

Answer. 5.2 m × 2.2 m × 800 mm; Mmax −1 008.0 kN m at 2.08 m; top 12 bars of 25 mm (governed by shear), bottom 11 bars of 16 mm

Example 2 (punching and transverse bands for Example 1)

Problem. For the footing of Example 1 (qu = 262.2 kN/m², d = 740 mm), check punching at both columns and design the transverse steel in a band under each column, using an effective depth of 720 mm for the transverse layer.

  1. Column B (interior): perimeter side 450 + 740 = 1 190 mm, b0 = 4 760 mm. Vu = 1 800 − 262.2 × 1.19² = 1 428.6 kN; τv = 1 428 600/(4 760 × 740) = 0.41 N/mm² against ks τc = 1.0 × 0.25 × √25 = 1.25 N/mm²: safe.
  2. Column A (on the edge): three-sided perimeter, 400 + 370 = 770 mm along the footing on two sides and 400 + 740 = 1 140 mm across, b0 = 2 × 770 + 1 140 = 2 680 mm. Vu = 1 200 − 262.2 × 0.770 × 1.140 = 969.8 kN; τv = 969 800/(2 680 × 740) = 0.49 N/mm²: safe.
  3. Transverse band under B, width 450 + 740 = 1 190 mm: each side cantilevers (2.2 − 0.45)/2 = 0.875 m, and the column load per metre of footing width is 1 800/2.2 = 818.2 kN/m, so Mu = 818.2 × 0.875²/2 = 313.2 kN m. Ast = 1 235 mm² on b = 1 190 mm: 7 bars of 16 mm (1 407 mm²).
  4. Transverse band under A, width 400 + 370 = 770 mm: cantilever 0.9 m, Mu = (1 200/2.2) × 0.9²/2 = 220.9 kN m, Ast = 873 mm²: 5 bars of 16 mm (1 005 mm²).
  5. Between the bands, nominal transverse steel 0.0012 × 1 000 × 800 = 960 mm² per metre: 12 mm bars at 110 mm (1 028 mm² per metre).

Answer. Punching τv 0.41 (B) and 0.49 (A) ≤ 1.25 N/mm²; bands of 7 bars of 16 mm under B and 5 bars of 16 mm under A; 12 mm at 110 mm elsewhere

Example 3 (trapezoidal combined footing)

Problem. Two columns 4.5 m apart carry 1 500 kN (left) and 1 000 kN (right) at service. Property lines leave only 0.25 m beyond each column centre, so L = 5.0 m. Safe bearing capacity 250 kN/m². Find the end widths of a trapezoidal footing for uniform pressure.

  1. Resultant from the left column: 1 000 × 4.5/2 500 = 1.8 m, so 2.05 m from the left (wide) end. L/3 = 1.667 m < 2.05 m < L/2 = 2.5 m: a trapezoid works.
  2. Area = 1.1 × 2 500/250 = 11.0 m², so B1 + B2 = 2 × 11.0/5.0 = 4.4 m.
  3. Centroid: (5.0/3)(B1 + 2B2)/4.4 = 2.05, so B1 + 2B2 = 5.412 m and B2 = 5.412 − 4.4 = 1.012 m, B1 = 3.388 m.
  4. Adopt B1 = 3.40 m and B2 = 1.02 m; the centroid moves by about 1 mm, which is negligible.

Answer. B1 = 3.388 m at the heavier column and B2 = 1.012 m, adopted as 3.40 m and 1.02 m

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the resultant of the service column loads and its position.
  2. Fix the footing length so that its centroid lies under the resultant (rectangle, trapezoid or strap footing), then the width from the area.
  3. Compute the factored line load and draw the shear force and bending moment diagrams along the footing.
  4. Choose the depth for punching at each column (three-sided at an edge column) and for one-way shear at d from the faces.
  5. Design top steel for the hogging moment between columns and bottom steel under and beyond the columns; check minimum steel and development lengths.
  6. Design transverse steel in a band under each column and nominal steel between them; detail with 50 mm cover.

Site notes

  • Set out both column centres from the same reference; a combined footing is sized for one exact spacing.
  • Top bars between the columns need stout chairs; a mat of 25 mm bars walked on during the pour sinks if poorly supported.
  • Check the property line on site before excavating; the reason for the combined footing is usually that boundary.
  • Place concrete continuously from one end to the other so that no cold joint forms across the high-moment zone.
  • Inspect the founding level under both columns; a soft patch under one end causes tilting.
Common mistakes
  • Putting all the main steel at the bottom, as in an isolated footing; between the columns the tension is at the top.
  • Making the footing symmetric about the two columns instead of about the resultant.
  • Using a trapezoid when the resultant lies outside L/3 to L/2.
  • Checking punching at a boundary column with a four-sided perimeter.
  • Leaving out transverse steel under the columns.
Quick check

For two columns on a rectangular combined footing, the largest hogging moment sits where the soil force from the free end equals the first column load: at x0 = Pu1/w. If x0 falls beyond the second column, the moment between them never turns hogging.

Summary

  • A combined footing carries two or more columns when isolated footings would overlap or a column stands on a boundary.
  • For uniform pressure the footing centroid lies under the load resultant; a trapezoid helps when both ends are fixed.
  • The footing acts as an inverted beam: hogging with top steel between columns, sagging with bottom steel under and beyond them.
  • Punching is checked at each column, with a three-sided perimeter at an edge column; one-way shear at d from the faces.
  • Transverse steel goes in bands under the columns, with nominal steel elsewhere.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Two columns carry 600 kN and 900 kN at 3.0 m spacing. Where is the resultant from the lighter column?

900 × 3.0/1 500 = 1.8 m.

2For Question 1, the footing ends 0.3 m outside the lighter column. Find L for a rectangular footing.

L = 2 × (0.3 + 1.8) = 4.2 m.

3With w = 500 kN/m and Pu1 = 1 000 kN applied 0.2 m from the end, where is the zero shear and what is the moment there?

x0 = 2.0 m; M = 500 × 2²/2 − 1 000 × 1.8 = −800 kN m (hogging).

4A trapezoid has L = 6 m, B1 = 3 m and B2 = 1.5 m. Find its area and the centroid from the wide end.

A = 13.5 m²; x = 2 × (3 + 3)/4.5 = 2.67 m.

5Why is the steel between the columns at the top of a combined footing?

The soil pushes the footing up between the columns that hold it down, so it bends upward and the top face is in tension.

6Find the critical perimeter at d/2 for a 400 mm column flush with the end of a footing, with d = 600 mm.

b0 = 2 × (400 + 300) + (400 + 600) = 2 400 mm.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.