Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 9 › Lesson 9.4

9.4 Direct and bending stresses and the kern of a section

Strength of Materials Chapter 9: Columns and combined stresses Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Combine direct and bending stresses, σ = P/A ± M y/I, for short members loaded eccentrically about one or both axes.
  • Derive the kern (core) of a section, the zone within which a compressive load causes no tension anywhere, and find it for rectangular, solid circular and hollow circular sections.
  • Apply the results to masonry piers, chimneys and hollow piers under wind, and footing or wall bases, including the pressure under a base when the load falls outside the kern.

Theory

A short member that is too stocky to buckle can still be loaded off its centroid. A beam bearing on one side of a brick pier, the wind on a chimney, earth pressure on a retaining wall and the column load on a footing all combine a direct force P with a bending moment M. Within the elastic range the two stress distributions add: a uniform P/A and a linear M y/I. The result is a linear distribution that is largest on one face and smallest on the other. Sign convention for this lesson: compression positive, because masonry, concrete and soil under these members are mainly in compression; a negative result means tension.

A compressive load P at eccentricity e from the centroid is the same as a central load P plus a moment M = P e. For a rectangle of width b and depth d with e along d, the extreme stresses are (P/(bd))(1 ± 6e/d). If e is less than d/6, both are compressive; at e = d/6 the stress on the far face is just zero; beyond d/6 the far face is in tension. This is the 'middle third' rule: the load must lie within the middle third of the depth.

b × d: d/6, b/6dbkern D/8e ≤ d/6outside kern3aIndiacon original
Figure 9.4: Kern of a rectangle (rhombus, d/6 and b/6) and of a solid circle (radius D/8), with base pressure for a load inside the kern and the triangular no-tension pressure for a load outside it. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The kern, or core, is the zone around the centroid within which a compressive load can be placed anywhere without causing tension on any fibre. For a rectangle it is a rhombus with half-diagonals d/6 and b/6 along the two axes; for a solid circle of diameter D it is a concentric circle of radius D/8; for a hollow circle of outer diameter D and inner diameter d its radius is (D² + d²)/(8D). In general, the kern boundary in any direction is at e = r²/c, where r is the radius of gyration and c the distance to the extreme fibre in that direction.

Many materials and supports cannot take tension: unreinforced masonry joints open, soil under a footing cannot pull it down, and a gravity dam or wall must not lift at its heel. When the resultant falls outside the kern, the part of the base in tension simply loses contact, and the pressure becomes triangular over a reduced length. For a rectangular base with the resultant at distance a from the more compressed edge, the contact length is 3a and the peak pressure is 2P/(3ab). Keeping resultants inside the kern is a basic check for piers, chimneys, retaining walls, dams and footings.

Derivation

  1. Superposition for a short member with load P at eccentricity e along the y-axis: σ = P/A + (P e) y/I, compression positive, y measured from the centroid towards the load.
  2. Rectangle b × d with e along d: A = bd, I = bd³/12, extreme fibres at y = ±d/2, so σ = P/(bd) ± P e (d/2)/(bd³/12) = (P/(bd))(1 ± 6e/d).
  3. No tension on the far face: 1 − 6e/d ≥ 0, so e ≤ d/6 (middle third). In general, σ = 0 at y = −c gives e = I/(A c) = r²/c, which is the kern limit in that direction.
  4. Two-way eccentricity e_x, e_y on a rectangle: σ = (P/A)(1 ± 6e_x/b ± 6e_y/d). The corner stays in compression when 6e_x/b + 6e_y/d ≤ 1, a straight line joining (b/6, 0) and (0, d/6), so the kern is a rhombus with diagonals b/3 and d/3.
  5. Solid circle diameter D: r² = D²/16, c = D/2, kern radius r²/c = D/8 (kern diameter D/4).
  6. Hollow circle D, d: r² = (D² + d²)/16, c = D/2, kern radius (D² + d²)/(8D).
  7. No-tension base with the resultant outside the kern: the pressure is triangular over a contact length x from the compressed edge; vertical equilibrium P = ½ q_max x b and moment balance place the resultant at x/3 from that edge, so x = 3a and q_max = 2P/(3ab), where a = d/2 − e.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • σ = P/A ± M y/I = P/A ± M/Z (compression positive), M = P e
  • Rectangle, one axis: σ = (P/(bd))(1 ± 6e/d); no tension if e ≤ d/6
  • Rectangle, two axes: σ = (P/A)(1 ± 6e_x/b ± 6e_y/d); kern rhombus with half-diagonals b/6 and d/6
  • Solid circle: Z = πD³/32, kern radius D/8
  • Hollow circle: Z = π(D⁴ − d⁴)/(32D), kern radius (D² + d²)/(8D)
  • General kern limit e = r²/c = Z/A
  • No-tension rectangular base: contact length 3a, q_max = 2P/(3ab), a = d/2 − e
  • Units: P in N or kN, stresses in N/mm² or kPa, dimensions in mm or m (consistent)
Assumptions and limits
  • Short member: no buckling or second-order amplification (otherwise use lesson 9.3).
  • Plane sections remain plane; linear elastic, homogeneous material; stresses well within the elastic range.
  • Loads act through, or are resolved to, the principal axes of the section.
  • For bases on soil, the base is rigid and the soil pressure varies linearly (a simplification of real soil behaviour).
  • Limits: the no-tension triangular distribution applies only where the material or interface truly cannot take tension; local bearing under concentrated loads, shear and sliding, and overturning stability are separate checks.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Combined direct and bending stress is mechanics; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Masonry walls and piers, chimneys, retaining walls, gravity dams and footings are designed in Indian, European and American practice to their own codes, which set permissible stresses, the permitted extent of tension or loss of contact and the factors of safety against overturning; those values are not reproduced here.
  • Side by side, not ranked: all three practices use the same linear stress distribution and the middle-third (kern) idea shown in this lesson.

Worked examples

Example 1 (brick pier with an eccentric beam bearing)

Problem. A brick pier 450 mm × 600 mm carries a beam reaction of 180 kN acting 80 mm from the centroid along the 600 mm side. Find the extreme stresses. Then find the peak stress if the bearing moves to 120 mm from the centroid and the joints cannot take tension.

  1. A = 450 × 600 = 270 000 mm²; P/A = 180 000/270 000 = 0.667 N/mm².
  2. 6e/d = 6 × 80/600 = 0.8; σ = 0.667 × 1.8 = 1.20 N/mm² and 0.667 × 0.2 = 0.133 N/mm², both compression (e = 80 mm < d/6 = 100 mm, inside the kern).
  3. At e = 120 mm the elastic formula would give 0.667(1 − 1.2) = −0.133 N/mm², tension, which the joints cannot carry.
  4. No-tension: a = 300 − 120 = 180 mm, contact length 3a = 540 mm; q_max = 2 × 180 000/(3 × 180 × 450) = 1.48 N/mm².
  5. Moving the bearing 40 mm outwards raised the peak stress by about a quarter and opened the far joint; a padstone or a central bearing keeps the load inside the kern.

Answer. e = 80 mm: 1.20 and 0.133 N/mm² compression; e = 120 mm: joint opens, contact 540 mm, peak 1.48 N/mm²

Example 2 (hollow circular pier or chimney shaft under wind)

Problem. At a section of a hollow circular RC shaft, outer diameter 3.0 m and inner diameter 2.4 m, the self-weight above is 4000 kN and the wind moment is 2500 kN m. Find the extreme stresses and check against the kern.

  1. A = π(3.0² − 2.4²)/4 = 2.545 m²; Z = π(3.0⁴ − 2.4⁴)/(32 × 3.0) = 1.565 m³.
  2. W/A = 4000/2.545 = 1572 kPa; M/Z = 2500/1.565 = 1597 kPa.
  3. σ = 1572 + 1597 = 3169 kPa (3.17 N/mm²) compression on the leeward face and 1572 − 1597 = −26 kPa, a small tension, on the windward face.
  4. Kern radius (D² + d²)/(8D) = (9.0 + 5.76)/24 = 0.615 m; eccentricity M/W = 0.625 m, just outside the kern, which is why a little tension appears.
  5. Vertical reinforcement carries this tension in an RC shaft; an unreinforced masonry chimney would need more weight or a wider base at this level.

Answer. σ = 3.17 N/mm² compression and 0.026 N/mm² tension; e = 0.625 m just outside the kern radius 0.615 m

Example 3 (base pressure under a retaining wall)

Problem. A retaining wall has a base 3.0 m wide. Per metre run the total vertical load is 300 kN and its resultant cuts the base 1.15 m from the toe. Find the base pressures. Then find the peak pressure if, under a higher backfill surcharge, the resultant moves to 0.90 m from the toe with the same vertical load.

  1. e = 1.5 − 1.15 = 0.35 m < B/6 = 0.50 m, inside the middle third.
  2. q = (300/3.0)(1 ± 6 × 0.35/3.0) = 100 × (1 ± 0.70) = 170 kPa at the toe and 30 kPa at the heel.
  3. Resultant at 0.90 m from the toe: e = 0.60 m > 0.50 m, so the heel lifts off and the pressure is triangular.
  4. Contact length 3a = 3 × 0.90 = 2.70 m; q_max = 2 × 300/(3 × 0.90 × 1.0) = 222.2 kPa at the toe.
  5. The peak pressure rose by 31 per cent and part of the base lost contact; check bearing capacity and overturning, and widen the base or shift the stem if needed.

Answer. Inside the kern: 170 kPa at the toe, 30 kPa at the heel; with the resultant at 0.90 m: contact 2.70 m, 222.2 kPa at the toe

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Resolve the loads into a vertical force P through the centroid and moments about the principal axes (or find the point where the resultant cuts the section).
  2. Compute A, I and Z about each axis (or r and c), and the kern limits r²/c.
  3. Compute σ = P/A ± M_x/Z_x ± M_y/Z_y at the corners or extreme fibres.
  4. If the material or interface can take the tension found, check the stresses; if not and the resultant is outside the kern, use the no-tension (cracked) distribution.
  5. Check the peak stress against the permissible value, and check stability (overturning, sliding) separately.

Site notes

  • Bearing plates and padstones on masonry should be set centrally; a beam end bearing on the outer edge of a pier loads it outside its kern.
  • Backfilling a retaining wall before the stem concrete has gained strength, or with heavy compactors close to it, raises the earth pressure and moves the base resultant towards the toe.
  • Chimneys and tall piers are often checked under construction, when wind acts on a shaft with less self-weight above the section.
  • Cracks along bed joints on one face of a masonry pier, or a gap under the heel of a wall, are signs that the resultant has moved outside the kern.
Common mistakes
  • Using the section modulus about the wrong axis for a moment in the other direction.
  • Applying the elastic formula and reporting a tensile stress at a soil-footing interface, which cannot take tension.
  • Measuring the eccentricity from the edge instead of from the centroid.
  • Taking the kern of a rectangle as d/3 each side of the centroid instead of d/6.
  • Forgetting that two-way eccentricity can put a corner in tension even when each eccentricity alone is inside the middle third.
Quick check

Keep the load inside the kern: d/6 each side for a rectangle, D/8 radius for a solid circle; then σ = (P/A)(1 ± 6e/d) stays compressive.

Summary

  • Direct and bending stresses add: σ = P/A ± M y/I, with M = P e.
  • Rectangle: (P/(bd))(1 ± 6e/d); no tension if e ≤ d/6 (middle third).
  • Kern: rhombus with half-diagonals b/6 and d/6 for a rectangle, radius D/8 for a solid circle, (D² + d²)/(8D) for a hollow circle.
  • Outside the kern, a no-tension base has triangular pressure over 3a with peak 2P/(3ab).
  • Short members only; slender members need the amplification of lesson 9.3.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the kern of a rectangular section 300 mm wide and 600 mm deep.

A rhombus centred on the centroid with half-diagonals 600/6 = 100 mm along the depth and 300/6 = 50 mm along the width (diagonals 200 mm and 100 mm).

2Find the kern radius of a solid circular pier of 1.2 m diameter.

D/8 = 0.15 m (kern diameter 0.30 m).

3A footing 2 m × 3 m carries 1200 kN with eccentricities of 0.2 m along the 3 m side and 0.1 m along the 2 m side. Find the largest and smallest corner pressures.

P/A = 200 kPa; 6 × 0.2/3 = 0.4 and 6 × 0.1/2 = 0.3; q = 200(1 ± 0.4 ± 0.3): maximum 340 kPa, minimum 60 kPa.

4A short column 400 mm × 400 mm carries 800 kN and a moment of 40 kN m about one axis. Find the extreme stresses.

e = 40/800 = 0.05 m; P/A = 5.0 N/mm²; 6e/d = 0.75; σ = 8.75 and 1.25 N/mm², both compression.

5Find the kern radius of a hollow circular section with D = 2.0 m and d = 1.6 m.

(D² + d²)/(8D) = (4.0 + 2.56)/16 = 0.41 m.

6Why must the resultant of a masonry gravity wall or dam stay within the middle third of its base?

So that the whole base stays in compression; outside it the heel would be in tension, which masonry joints and the foundation cannot carry, so a crack opens and the toe pressure rises.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.