6.1 Short axially loaded columns
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Classify a compression member as a column, and as short or slender, using IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.1 and cl. 25.1.2, and find its minimum eccentricity from cl. 25.4.
- Design and check short tied columns with the axial load formula of cl. 39.3, Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc, and know when it may be used.
- Detail longitudinal bars and lateral ties to cl. 26.5.3, and design a helically reinforced column with the 1.05 enhancement of cl. 39.4.
Theory
A column carries the floors above it down to the foundation, mainly in compression. IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.1 calls a compression member a column when its effective length exceeds three times its least lateral dimension. If both slenderness ratios, effective length over depth about each axis, are less than 12 the column is short (cl. 25.1.2): it fails by crushing of concrete and yielding of steel, and buckling is not a concern. Slender columns, with larger ratios, carry extra moments from their own deflection and are treated in lesson 6.4.
No real column is loaded exactly through its centroid. Construction tolerances, out-of-plumb formwork and unequal spans put the load slightly off centre, so cl. 25.4 asks every column to be designed for a minimum eccentricity equal to the unsupported length divided by 500 plus the lateral dimension divided by 30, but not less than 20 mm. When this minimum eccentricity does not exceed 0.05 times the lateral dimension, cl. 39.3 allows the simple axial formula Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc, which has the allowance for that small eccentricity built in.
The formula comes from adding the strengths of the two materials at the strain limit of axial compression, 0.002 (cl. 39.1 (a)). At that strain concrete has reached its design strength 0.67 fck/1.5 = 0.447 fck, and the steel stress is set at 0.67 fy, below the design yield stress 0.87 fy, because high strength bars are not fully yielded at 0.002 strain; both terms are reduced by about 10 per cent for the minimum eccentricity, giving 0.4 fck. Longitudinal steel adds strength, ductility and resistance to unintended bending and creep, so cl. 26.5.3.1 asks for at least 0.8 per cent and not more than 6 per cent of the gross area (with a note recommending lower values, about 4 per cent where bars are lapped), at least four bars in rectangular and six in circular columns, 12 mm minimum diameter and a peripheral spacing of not more than 300 mm.
Lateral ties hold the longitudinal bars in place and stop them buckling outwards once the cover spalls. Cl. 26.5.3.2 (c) limits the tie pitch to the least of the least lateral dimension, 16 times the smallest longitudinal bar diameter and 300 mm, and the tie diameter to at least a quarter of the largest longitudinal bar and not less than 6 mm (Amendment No. 1; the original print read 16 mm). A closely spaced helix confines the core concrete much more effectively; cl. 39.4 allows a helically reinforced column satisfying cl. 39.4.1 to carry 1.05 times the load of a similar tied column.
Derivation
- Strain compatibility under axial load: concrete and bonded steel shorten together, so both are at the same strain; at the axial limit strain 0.002 (cl. 39.1 (a)) the concrete stress is the design value 0.67 fck/γm = 0.67 fck/1.5 = 0.447 fck.
- Axial strength without eccentricity: Puo = 0.447 fck Ac + fsc Asc, where fsc is the steel stress at strain 0.002 and Ac = Ag − Asc is the net concrete area.
- Allowance for the minimum eccentricity of 0.05 D: reducing the concrete term by about 10 per cent gives 0.4 fck (0.4/0.447 = 0.89), and the steel term is taken as 0.67 fy, giving Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc (cl. 39.3).
- Design for a given load: substituting Ac = Ag − Asc, Pu = 0.4 fck Ag + (0.67 fy − 0.4 fck) Asc, so Asc = (Pu − 0.4 fck Ag)/(0.67 fy − 0.4 fck).
- Minimum eccentricity (cl. 25.4): emin = l/500 + D/30 ≥ 20 mm; the formula may be used only if emin ≤ 0.05 D. Since emin is at least 20 mm, this can hold only for D of at least 400 mm; smaller dimensions are checked for Pu with Mu = Pu emin by the method of lesson 6.2.
- Helical columns (cl. 39.4.1): the volume of helix per unit volume of core must be at least 0.36 (Ag/Ak − 1) fck/fy, where Ak is the core area measured to the outside of the helix and fy is not taken above 415 N/mm²; for a helix of bar area Asp, core diameter dk and pitch s this ratio is π (dk − φ) Asp/(Ak s).
Axial strength of a short column: Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc, Ac = Ag − Asc (N; stresses in N/mm², areas in mm²)Steel required: Asc = (Pu − 0.4 fck Ag)/(0.67 fy − 0.4 fck) (mm²)Minimum eccentricity: emin = l/500 + D/30 ≥ 20 mm; formula valid when emin ≤ 0.05 D (mm)Short column: lex/D < 12 and ley/b < 12 (dimensionless)Longitudinal steel: 0.8 to 6 per cent of Ag; at least 4 bars (rectangular) or 6 (circular); φ ≥ 12 mm; peripheral spacing ≤ 300 mm (mm)Ties: pitch ≤ least of b, 16 φmin and 300 mm; diameter ≥ φmax/4 and ≥ 6 mm (mm)Helical columns: strength 1.05 × tied; helix ratio π (dk − φ) Asp/(Ak s) ≥ 0.36 (Ag/Ak − 1) fck/fy (dimensionless; fy ≤ 415 N/mm²)
- The column is short (both slenderness ratios below 12) and braced, and is loaded essentially axially, with only the minimum eccentricity of cl. 25.4.
- Plane sections remain plane and steel and concrete are perfectly bonded; the maximum compressive strain in axial compression is 0.002 (cl. 39.1 (a)).
- The partial safety factors are 1.5 for concrete and 1.15 for steel, built into the coefficients 0.4 and 0.67; loads are factored by 1.5 for dead plus imposed load.
- Effective lengths are taken from the end restraints of the column (cl. 25.2 and Table 28); this lesson uses given effective lengths.
- Limits: the formula is not valid when the minimum or calculated eccentricity exceeds 0.05 D (use lesson 6.2), for slender columns (lesson 6.4), for biaxial bending (lesson 6.3) or for columns in ductile earthquake-resisting frames, which also follow IS 13920.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.1 (column: effective length more than three times the least lateral dimension), cl. 25.1.2 (short when both slenderness ratios are less than 12), cl. 25.2 and Table 28 (effective length from end restraint), cl. 25.4 (minimum eccentricity l/500 + D/30, not less than 20 mm), cl. 39.1 (a) (axial strain limit 0.002), cl. 39.2 (minimum eccentricity applies; calculated eccentricity governs if larger), cl. 39.3 (Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc when emin does not exceed 0.05 times the lateral dimension), cl. 39.4 and cl. 39.4.1 (helical reinforcement: 1.05 times; ratio 0.36 (Ag/Ak − 1) fck/fy, fy not above 415 N/mm²).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 26.5.3.1 (0.8 to 6 per cent with a note recommending lower values and about 4 per cent where bars are lapped; minimum four bars in rectangular and six in circular columns; bars not less than 12 mm; peripheral spacing not more than 300 mm), cl. 26.5.3.2 (c) (tie pitch: least lateral dimension, 16 times the smallest longitudinal bar, 300 mm; tie diameter at least one-quarter of the largest bar and not less than 6 mm as amended by Amendment No. 1), cl. 26.5.3.2 (d) (helix pitch not more than 75 mm or one-sixth of the core diameter and not less than 25 mm or three times the helix bar diameter), cl. 26.4.2.1 (column cover not less than 40 mm or the bar diameter, 25 mm for small columns with bars up to 12 mm); IS 1786 deformed bars; IS 13920 for ductile detailing.
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) designs columns from the section's strain-based resistance with its own minimum eccentricity (imperfection) allowance, minimum and maximum steel and transverse reinforcement rules; the American code (ACI 318) limits the axial strength of tied and spiral columns by a reduction for accidental eccentricity and a strength reduction factor, with its own steel limits, tie and spiral rules. The values differ and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. Design a short square column 400 mm × 400 mm with an unsupported and effective length of 3.0 m for a factored axial load Pu = 2 000 kN, M25 concrete, Fe 415 bars.
- Slenderness: 3 000/400 = 7.5 < 12, so short. emin = 3 000/500 + 400/30 = 6 + 13.3 = 19.3 mm, so 20 mm; 0.05 × 400 = 20 mm: emin does not exceed 0.05 D and cl. 39.3 applies.
- Asc = (2 000 000 − 0.4 × 25 × 160 000)/(0.67 × 415 − 0.4 × 25) = 400 000/268.05 = 1 492 mm².
- Minimum 0.8 per cent × 160 000 = 1 280 mm², so 1 492 mm² governs. Provide 8 bars of 16 mm (1 608 mm², 1.01 per cent): four at the corners and one at the middle of each face, spacing well under 300 mm.
- Check: Pu = 0.4 × 25 × (160 000 − 1 608) + 0.67 × 415 × 1 608 = 1 583.9 + 447.2 = 2 031 kN ≥ 2 000 kN.
- Ties: diameter at least 16/4 = 4 mm and not less than 6 mm, so 8 mm ties are a common choice; pitch not more than the least of 400 mm, 16 × 16 = 256 mm and 300 mm: 8 mm ties at 250 mm. Cover 40 mm (cl. 26.4.2.1).
Answer. 8 bars of 16 mm (1 608 mm²) with 8 mm ties at 250 mm; capacity 2 031 kN
Problem. A short column 300 mm × 450 mm has 6 bars of 16 mm, M20 concrete and Fe 415 bars, unsupported length 3.2 m. Find its axial load capacity by cl. 39.3 and comment on the minimum eccentricity.
- Asc = 6 × 201.1 = 1 206 mm² (0.89 per cent of 135 000 mm²); Ac = 135 000 − 1 206 = 133 794 mm².
- Pu = 0.4 × 20 × 133 794 + 0.67 × 415 × 1 206 = 1 070.4 + 335.4 = 1 405.8 kN.
- Slenderness 3 200/300 = 10.7 < 12: short. Major axis: emin = 3 200/500 + 450/30 = 21.4 mm ≤ 0.05 × 450 = 22.5 mm.
- Minor axis: emin = 6.4 + 10 = 16.4 mm, so 20 mm, which exceeds 0.05 × 300 = 15 mm; strictly, cl. 39.3 is not valid about the minor axis and the column should be checked for Pu with Mu = 0.02 Pu about that axis (done in lesson 6.2, Example 3).
Answer. 1 405.8 kN by cl. 39.3, but the minor-axis minimum eccentricity needs the lesson 6.2 check
Problem. A circular column of 450 mm diameter has 8 bars of 20 mm, M25 concrete and Fe 415 bars, with 40 mm cover to the helix (core diameter 370 mm to the outside of the helix). Find the helix pitch for 8 mm bars that earns the 1.05 enhancement, and the column's capacity.
- Ag = π × 450²/4 = 159 043 mm²; Ak = π × 370²/4 = 107 521 mm²; Ag/Ak = 1.479.
- Required ratio 0.36 × (1.479 − 1) × 25/415 = 0.01039.
- Helix volume per turn: π × (370 − 8) × 50.27 = 57 165 mm³; pitch s ≤ 57 165/(107 521 × 0.01039) = 51.2 mm; use 50 mm (ratio provided 0.01063). Limits of cl. 26.5.3.2 (d): not more than 75 mm or 370/6 = 61.7 mm, and not less than 25 mm or 3 × 8 = 24 mm: 50 mm is acceptable.
- Tied strength: Asc = 2 513 mm² (1.58 per cent); Pu = 0.4 × 25 × (159 043 − 2 513) + 0.67 × 415 × 2 513 = 1 565.3 + 698.8 = 2 264 kN; with the helix 1.05 × 2 264 = 2 377 kN.
- On site the helix must be continuous with one and a half extra turns at each end, and its pitch held with spacer bars; a helix opened up to ease concreting loses the enhancement.
Answer. 8 mm helix at 50 mm pitch; capacity 2 377 kN (2 264 kN as a tied column)
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the effective lengths about both axes from the end restraints and check that the column is short (both ratios below 12).
- Compute emin = l/500 + D/30 (at least 20 mm) about each axis and confirm emin ≤ 0.05 D; otherwise design for Pu with Mu = Pu emin (lesson 6.2).
- Choose the concrete grade and section size (axial stress Pu/Ag of about 10 to 14 N/mm² for M25 is a common starting point) and compute Asc from the cl. 39.3 formula.
- Provide at least 0.8 per cent and the minimum number of bars of at least 12 mm, spaced at not more than 300 mm round the periphery; keep the steel well below 4 per cent where bars are lapped.
- Design ties (pitch and diameter by cl. 26.5.3.2 (c)) or a helix (cl. 39.4.1 and cl. 26.5.3.2 (d)), and check cover.
- Detail laps and splices, the joint with beams and the transfer of load to the footing, and add IS 13920 confinement in earthquake-resisting frames.
Site notes
- Ties must be closed with 135 degree hooks into the core; 90 degree hooks open up when the cover spalls and the bars buckle.
- Check vertical alignment and cover blocks before closing column shutters; out-of-plumb columns increase the eccentricity the design allowed for.
- Pour columns in lifts or with a tremie so that concrete does not segregate when dropped from height; honeycombing at the column base is a common defect.
- Lap longitudinal bars in the middle half of the column height where possible and stagger them; congestion at beam-column joints must be resolved on the drawings, not on site.
- Record cube results for column concrete separately: columns are the members where a low-strength batch is most dangerous.
- Using the gross area Ag instead of Ac = Ag − Asc in the concrete term.
- Applying Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc without checking that emin ≤ 0.05 D.
- Spacing ties at 300 mm in a column with 12 mm bars, where 16 × 12 = 192 mm governs.
- Providing less than 0.8 per cent steel, or only two bars on a face longer than 300 mm between them.
- Forgetting that the 1.05 enhancement for helical columns needs the full cl. 39.4.1 ratio and the pitch limits.
For short tied columns, each 1 per cent of Fe 415 steel adds about 0.67 × 415 × 0.01 = 2.8 N/mm² on the gross area, while M25 concrete gives about 0.4 × 25 = 10 N/mm². So a 1 per cent column carries roughly Pu ≈ 12.7 N/mm² × Ag; 400 mm × 400 mm then takes about 2 000 kN. Columns with any side less than 400 mm cannot satisfy emin ≤ 0.05 D and need the lesson 6.2 check.
Summary
- A compression member is a column when its effective length exceeds three times its least lateral dimension; it is short when both slenderness ratios are below 12.
- Every column is designed for a minimum eccentricity l/500 + D/30, not less than 20 mm; if this is not more than 0.05 D, Pu = 0.4 fck Ac + 0.67 fy Asc may be used.
- Longitudinal steel lies between 0.8 and 6 per cent (lower values recommended), with at least four bars (six in circular columns) of at least 12 mm, spaced not more than 300 mm.
- Ties: pitch not more than the least lateral dimension, 16 bar diameters or 300 mm; diameter at least a quarter of the largest bar and not less than 6 mm.
- A helix meeting cl. 39.4.1 raises the strength by 5 per cent and greatly improves ductility.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A 300 mm × 300 mm column has an effective length of 3.3 m. Is it short?
3 300/300 = 11 < 12: short.
2Find emin for a 500 mm deep column with unsupported length 4.0 m.
4 000/500 + 500/30 = 8 + 16.7 = 24.7 mm.
3Find Pu for a 450 mm square column, M30, Fe 500, 1 per cent steel.
Asc = 2 025 mm²; Pu = 0.4 × 30 × 200 475 + 0.67 × 500 × 2 025 = 2 405.7 + 678.4 = 3 084 kN.
4What tie pitch is needed for a 350 mm square column with 20 mm bars?
Least of 350, 16 × 20 = 320 and 300 mm: 300 mm.
5What is the minimum tie diameter for 25 mm longitudinal bars?
25/4 = 6.25 mm, so 8 mm ties.
6Why is the steel stress in the axial formula 0.67 fy, not 0.87 fy?
Because at the axial strain limit 0.002 high strength bars have not fully reached their design yield stress, and the term also carries the allowance for the minimum eccentricity.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.