6.4 Slender columns
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Decide whether a column is slender about each axis with IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2, and check the unsupported length limit of cl. 25.3.1.
- Compute the additional moments of cl. 39.7.1 and reduce them with the factor k of cl. 39.7.1.1 using Puz and the balanced load Pb.
- Combine additional moments with initial moments for braced and unbraced columns (cl. 39.7 notes) and design the section by lesson 6.2 or 6.3.
Theory
A long, thin column bends sideways under axial load. The lateral deflection moves the line of the load away from the column axis, so the axial load itself creates an extra moment, axial load times deflection. In a short column this second-order effect is negligible; in a slender one it can be large enough to reduce the load the column can carry well below its section strength, and in the limit it becomes the elastic buckling studied in strength of materials.
IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2 treats a column as short when both lex/D and ley/b are less than 12, where lex and ley are effective lengths about the major and minor axes. Effective length depends on the end restraint and on whether the frame is braced against sway; Table 28 and Annex E of the code give guidance and are named here, not reproduced. Cl. 25.3.1 also limits the unsupported length between end restraints to 60 times the least lateral dimension.
Cl. 39.7 asks that slender columns be designed for moments from an analysis that includes the effect of deflections; when the analysis does not include them, the additional moments of cl. 39.7.1 are added: Max = (Pu D/2000)(lex/D) squared about the major axis and May = (Pu b/2000)(ley/b) squared about the minor axis. The formula represents the extra moment at failure, when the section curvature is large, so it grows with the square of the slenderness ratio.
When the axial load is well above the balanced load, the column fails by crushing with little curvature and the additional moment is smaller. Cl. 39.7.1.1 therefore allows the additional moments to be multiplied by k = (Puz − Pu)/(Puz − Pb), not more than 1, where Pb is the axial load at which the concrete reaches 0.0035 compressive strain while the outermost tension steel reaches 0.002 tensile strain. For braced columns without transverse load, the code notes add the additional moment to an initial moment of 0.6 M2 + 0.4 M1 (M2 the larger end moment, M1 the smaller, negative in double curvature), not less than 0.4 M2, with the total not less than M2. For unbraced columns the additional moment is added to the end moments.
Derivation
- Assume the deflected shape of a pin-ended column is a sine curve, y = a sin(πx/le). Its curvature at mid-height is a(π/le) squared, so the mid-height deflection is a = (curvature) × le²/π², about le²/10 times the curvature.
- At failure the strains at the section are about 0.0035 on the compressed face and about 0.002 in the tension steel; with the lever between them close to the depth D, the curvature is about (0.0035 + 0.002)/D, roughly 1/(180 D). The code coefficient corresponds to rounding this to about 1/(200 D).
- Then a ≈ le²/(10 × 200 D) = D/2000 × (le/D)², and the additional moment Pu a = (Pu D/2000)(le/D)², which is the form of cl. 39.7.1.
- The reduction factor k is linear in Pu: it is 1 at the balanced load Pb, where the curvature at failure is greatest, and 0 at Puz, where the section crushes with uniform strain and no curvature; it is capped at 1 below Pb.
Short column (cl. 25.1.2): lex/D < 12 and ley/b < 12 (dimensionless)Unsupported length limit (cl. 25.3.1): l ≤ 60 × least lateral dimension (mm)Additional moments: Max = (Pu D/2000)(lex/D)², May = (Pu b/2000)(ley/b)² (kN m with Pu in kN, D and b in m)Reduction factor: k = (Puz − Pu)/(Puz − Pb) ≤ 1; Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc (dimensionless; kN)Balanced load Pb: neutral axis xu = 0.0035 d'/(0.0035 + 0.002), d' to the outermost tension bars (mm; Pb in kN)Braced column initial moment: Mi = 0.6 M2 + 0.4 M1 ≥ 0.4 M2; total Mi + k Ma ≥ M2 (kN m)
- The additional-moment method is an approximate second-order method; a frame analysis that includes deflection (P-delta) effects can be used instead, as cl. 39.7 permits.
- Effective lengths are taken as given in each example (from frame analysis or the code guidance named above); their values strongly affect the result.
- Section capacities use the lesson 6.2 assumptions: the IS 456 stress block when the neutral axis is within the section, steel idealised as linear up to 0.87 fy, Ac taken as the gross area minus the steel area.
- In the braced example the column has no transverse load between its ends, as the cl. 39.7 note on the initial moment requires.
- Limits: columns with slenderness well beyond the code range, long-term creep amplification beyond the code method, and IS 13920 ductile detailing are outside this lesson.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2 (short when lex/D and ley/b are both less than 12), cl. 25.2 with Table 28 and Annex E (effective length, named only), cl. 25.3.1 (unsupported length not more than 60 times the least lateral dimension), cl. 25.4 (minimum eccentricity l/500 + D/30, not less than 20 mm).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 39.7 (design for moments including the effect of deflections, or add the additional moments), cl. 39.7.1 (Max = Pu D/2000 × (lex/D)², May = Pu b/2000 × (ley/b)²; section designed by cl. 39.5 or 39.6), its notes (braced and unbraced columns; initial moment 0.4 M1 + 0.6 M2, not less than 0.4 M2, total not less than M2; unbraced additional moment added to end moments; average slenderness for columns of a storey constrained to sway together), cl. 39.7.1.1 (k = (Puz − Pu)/(Puz − Pb) ≤ 1, Pb at 0.0035 compressive strain in concrete and 0.002 tensile strain in the outermost tension steel).
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) uses slenderness limits that depend on the axial load and end moments, and second-order methods based on nominal stiffness or nominal curvature (the latter of the same family as the IS 456 additional moment); the American code (ACI 318) uses a moment magnifier based on the critical buckling load with separate treatment of non-sway and sway frames. Their limits and factors differ and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A braced column 300 mm × 450 mm, M25 and Fe 415, unsupported length 6.0 m, has 6 bars of 20 mm: 3 along each 300 mm face, centres 60 mm from the faces. From the frame analysis the effective lengths are lex = 6.0 m and ley = 4.2 m. It carries Pu = 1 100 kN, end moments about the major axis of 90 kN m and 50 kN m in single curvature, and no moment about the minor axis. Check it.
- Slenderness: lex/D = 6 000/450 = 13.3 and ley/b = 4 200/300 = 14.0, both 12 or more, so slender about both axes. Limit 60 × 300 = 18 m > 6.0 m.
- Additional moments: Max = 1 100 × 0.45/2 000 × 13.33² = 44.0 kN m; May = 1 100 × 0.30/2 000 × 14.0² = 32.3 kN m.
- Asc = 1 885 mm² (1.40 per cent); Puz = 0.45 × 25 × (135 000 − 1 885) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 885 = 2 084.2 kN. Pb about the major axis: xu = 0.0035 × 390/0.0055 = 248.2 mm, C = 670.1 kN, compression bars 329.7 kN, tension bars −340.3 kN, Pb = 659.6 kN, so kx = (2 084.2 − 1 100)/(2 084.2 − 659.6) = 0.691. About the minor axis xu = 152.7 mm, Pb = 618.9 kN, ky = 0.672.
- Major axis: Mi = 0.6 × 90 + 0.4 × 50 = 74 kN m (not less than 0.4 × 90 = 36); Mux = 74 + 0.691 × 44.0 = 104.4 kN m, more than M2 = 90 kN m. Minor axis: Muy = 0.672 × 32.3 = 21.7 kN m. The minimum eccentricity (27 mm, 29.7 kN m about x; 22 mm, 24.2 kN m about y) is met about one axis at a time; Mux already exceeds it.
- Biaxial check (lesson 6.3): Pu/Puz = 0.528, αn = 1.546. Mux1 = 151.3 kN m (xu = 329.8 mm) and Muy1 = 79.1 kN m (xu = 206.5 mm). (104.4/151.3)^1.546 + (21.7/79.1)^1.546 = 0.564 + 0.135 = 0.699 ≤ 1.0: safe.
Answer. Safe: 0.699 ≤ 1.0 (Mux 104.4 kN m, Muy 21.7 kN m)
Problem. An unbraced column 400 mm × 400 mm, M30 and Fe 415, unsupported length 4.0 m, effective length 7.2 m in the sway direction, carries Pu = 1 500 kN and a larger end moment of 120 kN m from the sway analysis. Bars: 8 bars, 3 on each face (corners and mid-faces), centres 60 mm from the faces. Check 8 bars of 20 mm, then 8 bars of 25 mm.
- Slenderness 7 200/400 = 18 ≥ 12: slender. Ma = 1 500 × 0.40/2 000 × 18² = 97.2 kN m. For an unbraced column it is added to the end moment.
- 8-20 (2 513 mm²): Puz = 2 908.3 kN, Pb = 953.2 kN (xu = 216.4 mm), k = (2 908.3 − 1 500)/(2 908.3 − 953.2) = 0.720; Mu = 120 + 0.720 × 97.2 = 190.0 kN m. Capacity at 1 500 kN: xu = 278.2 mm, Mu1 = 99.9 + 45.9 + 0 + 20.5 = 166.3 kN m < 190.0: not safe.
- 8-25 (3 927 mm², 2.45 per cent): Puz = 3 329.3 kN, Pb = 963.7 kN, k = (3 329.3 − 1 500)/(3 329.3 − 963.7) = 0.773; Mu = 120 + 0.773 × 97.2 = 195.2 kN m. Note that the extra steel raises Puz and so raises k slightly.
- Capacity at 1 500 kN: xu = 262.8 mm; C = 1 135.3 kN, compression face bars 511.9 kN, middle bars 155.5 kN, tension face bars −302.8 kN; Mu1 = 101.7 + 71.7 + 0 + 42.4 = 215.8 kN m ≥ 195.2: safe. Minimum eccentricity 4 000/500 + 400/30 = 21.3 mm gives only 32 kN m.
Answer. 8-20 fails (190.0 > 166.3 kN m); 8-25 is safe (195.2 ≤ 215.8 kN m)
Problem. A column 230 mm × 450 mm has an unsupported length of 4.0 m and effective length 4.0 m about both axes, and carries Pu = 600 kN. Classify it and find the additional moment before the k factor.
- lex/D = 4 000/450 = 8.9 < 12: short about the major axis. ley/b = 4 000/230 = 17.4 ≥ 12: slender about the minor axis.
- Unsupported length limit: 60 × 230 = 13 800 mm = 13.8 m ≥ 4.0 m, satisfied.
- May = 600 × 0.23/2 000 × 17.39² = 20.9 kN m (before reduction by k); no additional moment about the major axis.
- The thin direction governs: a 230 mm column wall often needs a check about its minor axis even when the major axis is comfortable.
Answer. Slender about the minor axis only; May = 20.9 kN m before k
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the unsupported and effective lengths about both axes; check cl. 25.3.1 and classify by cl. 25.1.2.
- For each slender direction compute the additional moment (cl. 39.7.1) and, if useful, the reduction factor k with a trial bar arrangement.
- Combine: braced columns use the initial moment 0.6 M2 + 0.4 M1 (not less than 0.4 M2, total not less than M2); unbraced columns add the additional moment to the end moments.
- Check the minimum eccentricity about one axis at a time.
- Design or check the section for Pu with the resulting moments by lesson 6.2 (one axis) or lesson 6.3 (both axes); iterate because k depends on the steel.
- Detail bars and ties (lesson 6.1); in sway frames under earthquake load apply IS 13920.
Site notes
- Do not remove props or bracing walls early from tall columns; until the frame is complete the effective length can be much greater than designed.
- Check verticality of tall column shutters: an initial out-of-plumb adds to the deflection the design allows for.
- Infill walls built later can change a frame from unbraced to braced, or create short-column effects; do not alter infill layouts without the designer.
- Keep column sizes as drawn; a 230 mm column cast at 210 mm raises ley/b and the additional moment with its square.
- Where a double-height column is created by omitting a slab or beam, refer it back for a slenderness check.
- Using the unsupported length instead of the effective length in lex/D and ley/b.
- Adding the braced-column initial moment rule to an unbraced (sway) column.
- Forgetting that k is capped at 1 when Pu is below Pb.
- Taking Pb from the 0.87 fy yield strain instead of the 0.002 tensile strain in the outermost tension steel that cl. 39.7.1.1 specifies.
- Checking only the major axis of a thin column that is slender about its minor axis.
The additional moment grows with the square of the slenderness ratio: going from le/D = 12 to 18 multiplies it by 2.25. For a quick estimate, Ma is about Pu D/14 at le/D = 12 and about Pu D/6 at le/D = 18 (from (le/D)²/2 000), before the reduction factor.
Summary
- A column is slender when lex/D or ley/b is 12 or more; the unsupported length is limited to 60 times the least lateral dimension.
- Lateral deflection adds a second-order moment; IS 456 represents it by Max = (Pu D/2000)(lex/D)² and May = (Pu b/2000)(ley/b)².
- These may be reduced by k = (Puz − Pu)/(Puz − Pb) ≤ 1, with Pb at 0.0035 concrete strain and 0.002 strain in the outermost tension steel.
- Braced columns add the additional moment to 0.6 M2 + 0.4 M1 (at least 0.4 M2, total at least M2); unbraced columns add it to the end moments.
- The section is then designed for Pu with these moments by lessons 6.2 and 6.3.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Is a 300 mm square column with effective length 3.3 m about both axes short or slender?
3 300/300 = 11 < 12: short.
2Find Max for Pu = 800 kN, D = 500 mm and lex = 7.5 m.
lex/D = 15; Max = 800 × 0.5/2 000 × 15² = 45 kN m.
3Find k when Puz = 3 000 kN, Pb = 900 kN and Pu = 1 500 kN.
k = (3 000 − 1 500)/(3 000 − 900) = 1 500/2 100 = 0.714.
4A braced column has end moments 100 kN m and 40 kN m in double curvature. Find the initial moment.
0.6 × 100 + 0.4 × (−40) = 44 kN m, which is more than 0.4 × 100 = 40 kN m, so 44 kN m.
5What is the largest unsupported length allowed for a column whose least lateral dimension is 250 mm?
60 × 250 = 15 000 mm = 15 m (cl. 25.3.1).
6What value does k take when Pu is less than Pb?
The expression exceeds 1, so k is taken as 1 (no reduction).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.