Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 9 › Lesson 9.1

9.1 Euler's theory and effective length

Strength of Materials Chapter 9: Columns and combined stresses Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Derive Euler's critical load for an ideal pin-ended column from the differential equation of the bent axis, and extend it to fixed-free, fixed-fixed and fixed-pinned columns.
  • Use effective length and slenderness ratio to find the buckling load and the axis about which a column buckles, including the effect of intermediate bracing.
  • State the limits of Euler's theory, and relate the theoretical effective lengths to the design effective lengths and short-column limit used in Indian practice.

Theory

A short, stocky column fails when the material crushes or yields under direct stress P/A. A long, slender column fails at a much lower load by bowing sideways, called buckling. Buckling is a loss of stability, not of strength: up to a certain load the straight column springs back if pushed sideways, and at that load it no longer does. The load is the critical or Euler load, and it depends on stiffness EI and length, not on the strength of the material. Sign convention for this chapter: P is the magnitude of the compressive load (a positive number), x runs along the column from one end, and y is the sideways deflection of the axis.

For an ideal column, perfectly straight, centrally loaded, of uniform elastic material and pinned at both ends, the bent shape under P satisfies EI y″ = −P y. Its non-zero solution is a half sine wave, and that is only possible when P = π²EI/L². Below this load the only equilibrium shape is straight; at it, a bent shape of any small amplitude is also in equilibrium, which is the meaning of neutral stability. Higher modes (two, three half-waves) need four, nine times the load and occur only if the column is braced at the right points.

PLe = LLe = 2LLe = 0.5LLe ≈ 0.7LIndiacon original
Figure 9.1: Buckled shapes of ideal columns with different end conditions and their effective lengths (pinned-pinned, fixed-free, fixed-fixed, fixed-pinned). Indiacon original, not to scale.

End conditions change the buckled shape. A cantilever column, fixed at the base and free at the top, bends into a quarter wave, as if it were half of a pin-ended column of length 2L, so its critical load is a quarter of the pin-ended value. A column fixed at both ends bends into a full wave with points of contraflexure at L/4 from each end, so the length between them, L/2, acts like a pin-ended column and the load is four times as large. A column fixed at one end and pinned at the other has an effective length of about 0.7L. Writing every case as P_cr = π²EI/L_e² with an effective length L_e = KL keeps one formula for all.

Dividing P_cr by the area gives the critical stress σ_cr = π²E/λ², where λ = L_e/r is the slenderness ratio and r = √(I/A) is the radius of gyration. A column buckles about the axis with the larger slenderness ratio, which is usually the axis with the smaller I unless that axis is braced at closer intervals. Because the derivation assumes elastic behaviour, Euler's load is only valid while σ_cr stays below the proportional limit. For structural steel with E = 200 000 N/mm² and a proportional limit taken as about the yield stress of 250 N/mm², this means λ above about 89. Stockier columns fail by inelastic buckling or yielding at loads below Euler's value, which is why design uses buckling curves; lesson 9.2 gives the Rankine-Gordon blend and lesson 9.3 the effect of eccentric load.

Derivation

  1. Pin-ended column of length L: the bending moment at a section is M = −P y, so EI y″ + P y = 0. With k² = P/(EI) the general solution is y = A sin kx + B cos kx.
  2. Boundary conditions y(0) = 0 gives B = 0; y(L) = 0 gives A sin kL = 0. For a bent shape A ≠ 0, so sin kL = 0 and kL = nπ. The smallest load (n = 1) is P_cr = π²EI/L², with the half-sine shape y = A sin(πx/L); the amplitude A stays undetermined (neutral equilibrium).
  3. General form: differentiating twice gives the fourth-order equation EI y⁗ + P y″ = 0, with solution y = C₁ sin kx + C₂ cos kx + C₃ x + C₄. Each end gives two conditions: pinned y = 0 and y″ = 0; fixed y = 0 and y′ = 0; free y″ = 0 and y‴ + k² y′ = 0 (no shear at the free end). Setting the determinant of the four equations to zero gives the critical load.
  4. Fixed base, free top: the determinant gives cos kL = 0, so kL = π/2 and P_cr = π²EI/(4L²); effective length 2L.
  5. Fixed at both ends: the determinant gives kL sin kL − 2(1 − cos kL) = 0, whose first non-trivial root for the symmetric mode is kL = 2π, so P_cr = 4π²EI/L²; effective length 0.5L.
  6. Fixed at one end and pinned at the other: the determinant gives tan kL = kL, whose first root is kL = 4.4934, so P_cr = 20.19EI/L² = π²EI/(0.699L)²; effective length about 0.7L.
  7. Critical stress: σ_cr = P_cr/A = π²E I/(A L_e²) = π²E/(L_e/r)² = π²E/λ². Elastic limit of validity: σ_cr ≤ σ_p, that is λ ≥ π√(E/σ_p); for E = 200 000 and σ_p = 250 N/mm², λ ≥ 88.9.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • P_cr = π²EI/L_e²; L_e = K L (theoretical K: pinned-pinned 1.0, fixed-free 2.0, fixed-fixed 0.5, fixed-pinned 0.699)
  • Radius of gyration r = √(I/A); slenderness ratio λ = L_e/r (use the least r unless the axes are braced differently)
  • Critical stress σ_cr = π²E/λ²
  • Limit of validity λ ≥ π√(E/σ_p) (about 88.9 for E = 200 000 N/mm² and σ_p = 250 N/mm²)
  • Bracing at mid-height about one axis halves L_e about that axis and multiplies P_cr about it by 4
  • Units: P in N, E and σ in N/mm², I in mm⁴, A in mm², L and r in mm
Assumptions and limits
  • The column is initially perfectly straight and the load acts exactly along its centroidal axis.
  • The material is homogeneous, isotropic and linear elastic, and the stress stays below the proportional limit (σ_cr ≤ σ_p).
  • Deflections are small, so the curvature is taken as y″; the column is long compared with its cross-section, so shortening and shear deformation are neglected.
  • End conditions are ideal (perfect pins, perfectly rigid fixity, or completely free), and the cross-section is uniform.
  • Limits: real columns have initial crookedness, eccentric loads and residual stresses, so they deflect from the start and fail below the Euler load; stocky columns (λ below about 89 for mild steel) fail inelastically; thin-walled sections may buckle locally or by twisting before the Euler load, which needs separate checks.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 7.2.2 with Table 11 sets the design effective length of prismatic steel compression members from the end restraint: 0.65L with both ends restrained in translation and rotation, 0.8L with one end fixed and the other pinned, 1.0L with both ends pinned, 1.2L with one end fixed and the other restrained in rotation but free to sway, and 2.0L with one end fixed and the other free. The fixed-end values are larger than the theoretical 0.5L and 0.7L because real connections never give perfect fixity.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2 treats a reinforced concrete compression member as short when both slenderness ratios, effective length about the major axis divided by the depth and effective length about the minor axis divided by the width, are less than 12; otherwise it is slender and additional moments from deflection must be considered.
  • European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, also start from the Euler load and an effective length factor based on end restraint, and use buckling curves or moment magnification for real columns; their factors and limits are set in their own steel and concrete codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (scaffold tube used as a prop)

Problem. A steel scaffold tube of outside diameter 48.3 mm and wall thickness 4.0 mm is used as a 2.5 m long prop, taken as pinned at both ends. E = 200 000 N/mm². Find the Euler load and the slenderness ratio, and check whether Euler's theory applies. What would the load be if the same tube were fixed at the base and free at the top?

  1. Inside diameter 40.3 mm. A = π(48.3² − 40.3²)/4 = 556.7 mm²; I = π(48.3⁴ − 40.3⁴)/64 = 137 676 mm⁴.
  2. r = √(137 676/556.7) = 15.73 mm; λ = 2500/15.73 = 159.0, above 88.9, so the column is in the elastic range and Euler's theory applies.
  3. P_cr = π² × 200 000 × 137 676/2500² = 43 480 N = 43.5 kN; σ_cr = 43 480/556.7 = 78.1 N/mm², well below yield.
  4. Fixed base, free top: L_e = 2 × 2500 = 5000 mm, P_cr = 43.5/4 = 10.9 kN.
  5. This is the elastic upper bound for a perfectly straight tube; a real prop with crookedness and an off-centre load carries less (lessons 9.2 and 9.3), so props are used well below this value as their supplier's tables allow.

Answer. P_cr = 43.5 kN (λ = 159, elastic); as a free-standing cantilever only 10.9 kN

Example 2 (weak-axis bracing of a wind-bracing strut)

Problem. A steel strut in the wind bracing of a shed is 7 m long and pinned at both ends about both axes. A = 3000 mm², I_xx = 2.4 × 10⁷ mm⁴, I_yy = 3.0 × 10⁶ mm⁴, E = 200 000 N/mm², proportional limit about 250 N/mm². Find the buckling load, then the effect of a brace that holds the strut at mid-height against movement about the weak (y) axis only.

  1. r_x = √(2.4 × 10⁷/3000) = 89.4 mm, r_y = √(3.0 × 10⁶/3000) = 31.6 mm; λ_x = 7000/89.4 = 78.3, λ_y = 7000/31.6 = 221.4.
  2. Without the brace, buckling is about y: P_cr = π² × 200 000 × 3.0 × 10⁶/7000² = 120 900 N = 120.9 kN.
  3. With the mid-height brace, L_e about y = 3500 mm: λ_y = 110.7 (> 88.9, still elastic) and P_cr,y = 120.9 × 4 = 483.4 kN, σ_cr = 161.1 N/mm².
  4. About x the Euler formula would give 966.8 kN, but λ_x = 78.3 is below 88.9 and σ = 322 N/mm² exceeds the proportional limit, so Euler does not apply about x; the squash load A × 250 = 750 kN caps it in any case.
  5. The weak axis still governs, now at 483.4 kN: one brace multiplied the strut's buckling load by four.

Answer. 120.9 kN unbraced (weak axis); 483.4 kN with the mid-height weak-axis brace, which still governs

Example 3 (is an RC column short or slender?)

Problem. A reinforced concrete column of a building frame is 300 mm wide and 450 mm deep. The designer has assessed the effective lengths as 3.0 m about the major axis (bending in the 450 mm direction) and 3.6 m about the minor axis. Classify it, and find the elastic Euler load of the uncracked concrete section about the minor axis with E = 25 000 N/mm² to see why RC columns are not designed by Euler's formula.

  1. Major axis: l_ex/D = 3000/450 = 6.67, less than 12.
  2. Minor axis: l_ey/b = 3600/300 = 12.0, which is not less than 12, so by IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2 the column is slender about the minor axis.
  3. Minor-axis I = 450 × 300³/12 = 1.0125 × 10⁹ mm⁴; P_cr = π² × 25 000 × 1.0125 × 10⁹/3600² = 19.28 × 10⁶ N = 19 280 kN.
  4. Average stress at that load = 19.28 × 10⁶/(300 × 450) = 142.8 N/mm², several times the crushing strength of ordinary concrete.
  5. So the column will never buckle elastically; slenderness instead adds a second-order moment from its own deflection, and the design follows the concrete code's slender-column provisions. Increasing b to 325 mm would bring l_ey/b to 11.1 and make the column short.

Answer. Slender about the minor axis (3600/300 = 12.0, not below 12); elastic Euler load 19 280 kN would need 142.8 N/mm², so crushing and second-order bending govern, not elastic buckling

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Identify the end restraint about each principal axis and the points where bracing holds the column, and choose the effective length about each axis (theoretical K for an ideal column, or the code value for design).
  2. Find A, the principal second moments of area and r about each axis.
  3. Compute λ = L_e/r about each axis; the larger λ governs.
  4. Check that λ ≥ π√(E/σ_p); if so, P_cr = π²EI/L_e² about the governing axis. If not, Euler does not apply: use Rankine-Gordon (lesson 9.2) or the code buckling curve.
  5. Apply a suitable factor of safety, or for design use the code compressive strength, and remember that real columns carry less than the ideal Euler load.

Site notes

  • Temporary props and scaffold standards buckle if their bracing, ledgers or ties are removed early; removing one tie can double the effective length and cut the buckling load to a quarter.
  • Check the plumb and straightness of steel columns and props before loading; initial crookedness reduces the load they carry.
  • A column assumed fixed at the base needs a base plate, bolts and foundation that really prevent rotation; a lightly bolted base behaves closer to a pin.
  • For RC columns, holding the dimensions and cover on site matters: casting a 300 mm column at 280 mm raises its slenderness ratio and its second-order moment.
Common mistakes
  • Using the larger moment of inertia instead of the least one, or forgetting to check both axes when bracing differs.
  • Using Euler's formula for stocky columns (λ below about 89 for mild steel), where it overestimates the strength.
  • Taking the theoretical effective length 0.5L for a 'fixed' column in design, when real connections are never fully fixed.
  • Mixing units: I in mm⁴ with L in metres, giving loads wrong by a factor of 10⁶.
  • Thinking a higher-strength steel raises the Euler load; the elastic buckling load depends on E, I and L_e only.
Quick check

P_cr = π²EI/L_e²: halve the effective length and the buckling load goes up four times; Euler applies to steel only above λ ≈ 89.

Summary

  • Buckling is a stability failure governed by EI and length, not strength.
  • Pin-ended P_cr = π²EI/L²; other ends via L_e = KL (2L, 0.5L, about 0.7L for ideal fixed-free, fixed-fixed, fixed-pinned).
  • σ_cr = π²E/λ² with λ = L_e/r; the axis with the larger λ governs.
  • Euler is valid only in the elastic range (λ ≥ π√(E/σ_p)); real columns carry less.
  • IS 800:2007 Table 11 gives design effective lengths; IS 456:2000 cl. 25.1.2 sets the short-column limit of 12 for RC.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A pin-ended steel strut 3 m long has I_min = 1.0 × 10⁶ mm⁴ and E = 200 000 N/mm². Find the Euler load.

P_cr = π² × 200 000 × 1.0 × 10⁶/3000² = 219 300 N = 219.3 kN.

2By what factor does the Euler load of a pin-ended column change if it is made fixed-free, fixed-fixed or fixed-pinned (ideal ends)?

Fixed-free: L_e = 2L, factor 1/4. Fixed-fixed: L_e = 0.5L, factor 4. Fixed-pinned: L_e = 0.699L, factor 1/0.699² = 2.05.

3Find the slenderness ratio above which Euler's theory is valid for a steel with E = 200 000 N/mm² and proportional limit 250 N/mm².

λ = π√(200 000/250) = π√800 = 88.9.

4A steel strut is fixed at one end and pinned at the other. Compare the Euler load using the theoretical effective length with that using the IS 800:2007 Table 11 value of 0.8L.

Ratio = (0.699/0.8)² = 0.764, so the design effective length gives about 76 per cent of the theoretical load.

5Does using a steel of higher yield strength raise the Euler load of a slender column?

No. P_cr = π²EI/L_e² contains E, I and L_e but not the yield strength; all structural steels have about the same E.

6A solid steel rod of 40 mm diameter is 2 m long and pin-ended. E = 200 000 N/mm². Find I, the slenderness ratio, P_cr and σ_cr.

I = π × 40⁴/64 = 125 664 mm⁴; r = 10 mm, λ = 200; P_cr = π² × 200 000 × 125 664/2000² = 62.0 kN; σ_cr = π² × 200 000/200² = 49.3 N/mm².

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.