6.2 Columns with uniaxial bending
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why every column carries some bending, and how axial load and moment interact through the strain distribution of IS 456:2000 cl. 39.1.
- Check a rectangular column for a given axial load and uniaxial moment by strain compatibility, with the neutral axis inside or outside the section, and design for the minimum eccentricity moment of cl. 25.4 and cl. 39.2.
- Construct and read an interaction diagram (pure axial point, balanced point, pure bending point) and use it to judge compression and tension failure.
Theory
Columns in frames carry moments as well as axial loads: beams frame into them with unequal spans and loads, wind and earthquake push the frame sideways, and even an axially loaded column must be designed for the minimum eccentricity of cl. 25.4. When a column carries an axial load Pu and a moment Mu about one axis, the combination is equivalent to Pu acting at an eccentricity e = Mu/Pu, and cl. 39.5 requires such members to be designed on the basis of the assumptions of cl. 39.1, and cl. 39.2 applies the minimum eccentricity to all compression members.
The assumptions are those of flexure (lesson 2.1) plus two strain rules. When the neutral axis lies within the section, the maximum compressive strain is 0.0035, as in a beam. When the whole section is in compression (neutral axis outside), cl. 39.1 (b) limits the strain at the highly compressed face to 0.0035 minus 0.75 times the strain at the least compressed face; this is the same as saying that every limiting strain profile passes through a strain of 0.002 at three-sevenths of the depth from the highly compressed face, and it reduces to the 0.002 axial limit of cl. 39.1 (a) when the strain is uniform.
For each position of the neutral axis there is one limiting strain profile, and integrating the concrete stresses and the steel forces gives one pair of capacities (Pu, Mu). Plotting all such pairs gives the interaction diagram. At the top is the pure axial point, Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc (the cl. 39.6 value). As the neutral axis rises the load falls and the moment grows until the balanced point, where the tension steel just reaches its design yield strain as the concrete crushes; below it the moment capacity falls again to the pure bending point. Above the balanced point failure is by crushing of concrete (compression failure) and more axial load reduces the moment capacity; below it failure starts with yielding of the tension steel and, interestingly, some axial load increases the moment capacity.
Because the calculation is repetitive, designers use interaction charts published as design aids for IS 456, or software, and the IS 456 note to cl. 39.5 says so. A design point (Pu, Mu) inside the curve for the chosen section and steel is safe. Columns are normally reinforced symmetrically, because moments in frames reverse under lateral loads and because symmetric bars are harder to place wrongly on site.
Derivation
- Strain profile with the neutral axis at depth xu ≤ D: εc = 0.0035 at the compressed face and ε(y) = 0.0035 (xu − y)/xu at depth y; the steel strain at depth di is εsi = 0.0035 (xu − di)/xu.
- Concrete force for xu ≤ D: integrating the parabolic-rectangular design curve (peak 0.447 fck reached at strain 0.002) gives the stress block C = 0.36 fck b xu acting at 0.42 xu from the compressed face (lesson 2.1).
- Neutral axis outside (xu > D): the profile pivots about a strain of 0.002 at 3D/7 from the highly compressed face, so ε(y) = 0.002 (xu − y)/(xu − 3D/7); this satisfies εtop = 0.0035 − 0.75 εbottom exactly, and the concrete force is found by integrating the stress curve over the full depth.
- Steel forces: fsi from the design stress-strain curve (here idealised as Es εsi up to 0.87 fy); bars in the compression zone carry (fsi − fci) Asi to allow for the concrete they displace.
- Equilibrium: Pu = C + Σ (fsi − fci) Asi, with tension forces negative; moment about the centroid: Mu = C (D/2 − x̄) + Σ (fsi − fci) Asi (D/2 − di).
- Balanced point: the tension steel strain equals 0.87 fy/Es + 0.002 when εc = 0.0035, so xu,b/d = 0.0035/(0.0055 + 0.87 fy/Es), which is 0.48 for Fe 415, the same limit as for beams in lesson 2.1.
Strain at depth y (xu ≤ D): ε = 0.0035 (xu − y)/xu (dimensionless; y, xu in mm)Strain at depth y (xu > D): ε = 0.002 (xu − y)/(xu − 3D/7); εtop = 0.0035 − 0.75 εbottom (dimensionless; mm)Concrete force (xu ≤ D): C = 0.36 fck b xu at 0.42 xu from the compressed face (N, mm)Axial capacity: Pu = C + Σ (fsi − fci) Asi; moment capacity Mu = C (D/2 − x̄) + Σ (fsi − fci) Asi (D/2 − di) (N, N mm)Pure axial point: Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc (N; N/mm², mm²)Balanced neutral axis: xu,b = 0.0035 d/(0.0055 + 0.87 fy/Es) (mm)Minimum eccentricity moment: Mu ≥ Pu emin, emin = l/500 + D/30 ≥ 20 mm (kN m, mm)
- Plane sections remain plane; steel and concrete are perfectly bonded; the tensile strength of concrete is ignored (lesson 2.1).
- Concrete follows the parabolic-rectangular design curve with peak 0.447 fck at a strain of 0.002; the limiting strains are those of cl. 39.1.
- For hand calculation the steel design curve is idealised as linear up to 0.87 fy and flat beyond (Es = 200 kN/mm²); the design curve of IS 456 for cold-worked bars (Fig. 23) bends gradually near yield, so design charts give slightly different values.
- The column is short and braced; the moment is about one principal axis only and includes at least the minimum eccentricity moment.
- Limits: biaxial bending (lesson 6.3), slender columns with additional moments (lesson 6.4), shear in columns and the ductile detailing of IS 13920 are outside this lesson.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 39.1 (assumptions: (a) axial strain limit 0.002; (b) strain at the highly compressed face 0.0035 minus 0.75 times the strain at the least compressed face when there is no tension), cl. 38.1 (flexure assumptions, as in lesson 2.1), cl. 39.2 (minimum eccentricity of cl. 25.4; calculated eccentricity governs if larger), cl. 25.4 (l/500 + D/30, not less than 20 mm), cl. 39.5 (combined axial load and uniaxial bending designed on the basis of the cl. 39.1 assumptions; its note observes that the trial-and-error calculation is lengthy and points to published design aids).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 39.6 (the pure axial capacity Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc, used there for biaxial bending), cl. 26.5.3.1 and cl. 26.5.3.2 (longitudinal steel and ties, as in lesson 6.1), Fig. 23 (design stress-strain curves for reinforcement, named only); IS 1786 deformed bars; IS 13920 for columns of earthquake-resisting frames.
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) checks column sections by the same plane-section strain compatibility with its own concrete and steel design curves, minimum moment from imperfections and detailing rules; the American code (ACI 318) also builds the axial load and moment interaction from strain compatibility, with its own strength reduction factors that depend on the tension steel strain and a cap on axial strength. Their values differ and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A short braced column 300 mm × 500 mm, effective length 3.0 m, M25 and Fe 415, has 3 bars of 20 mm near each 300 mm face (centres 60 mm from the faces, so d = 440 mm). It carries Pu = 1 200 kN and Mu = 150 kN m about the major axis. Is it safe?
- Minimum eccentricity: emin = 3 000/500 + 500/30 = 22.7 mm, Pu emin = 27.2 kN m < 150 kN m, so Mu = 150 kN m governs. Each face has 3 × 314.2 = 942.5 mm².
- Find xu for Pu = 1 200 kN with xu ≤ D: try xu = 369.2 mm. Compression steel strain 0.0035 × (369.2 − 60)/369.2 = 0.00293, beyond yield (0.87 × 415/200 000 = 0.0018), so 361.0 N/mm², or 349.9 N/mm² net of the displaced concrete 0.447 × 25 = 11.2 N/mm².
- Tension steel strain 0.0035 × (440 − 369.2)/369.2 = 0.00067, stress 134.3 N/mm². Forces: C = 0.36 × 25 × 300 × 369.2 = 996.8 kN; Cs = 942.5 × 349.9 = 329.7 kN; T = 942.5 × 134.3 = 126.5 kN; C + Cs − T = 1 200.0 kN, as required.
- Moment about the centroid: 996.8 kN × (250 − 0.42 × 369.2) mm + 329.7 kN × 190 mm + 126.5 kN × 190 mm = 94.6 + 62.7 + 24.0 = 181.3 kN m.
- Mu,cap = 181.3 kN m ≥ 150 kN m: safe, with the capacity about 21 per cent above the demand. Steel 1 885 mm² = 1.26 per cent, within 0.8 to 4 per cent; ties as in lesson 6.1.
Answer. Safe: capacity 181.3 kN m at Pu = 1 200 kN (demand 150 kN m)
Problem. For the column of Example 1, find the pure axial capacity Puz, the balanced point (Pb, Mb) and the pure bending capacity Mu0, and sketch the diagram.
- Puz = 0.45 × 25 × (150 000 − 1 885) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 885 = 1 666.3 + 586.7 = 2 253 kN.
- Balanced point: xu,b = 0.0035 × 440/(0.0035 + 0.0018 + 0.002) = 210.8 mm (0.479 d). C = 0.36 × 25 × 300 × 210.8 = 569.2 kN; compression steel strain 0.0025, so 349.9 N/mm² net, Cs = 329.7 kN; tension steel at 361.0 N/mm², T = 340.3 kN. Pb = 569.2 + 329.7 − 340.3 = 558.6 kN.
- Mb = 569.2 × (250 − 0.42 × 210.8) + (329.7 + 340.3) × 190 = 91.9 + 127.3 = 219.2 kN m.
- Pure bending (Pu = 0): xu = 76.7 mm; compression steel strain 0.00076, stress 152.5 N/mm²; C = 207.1 kN, Cs = 133.2 kN, T = 340.3 kN; Mu0 = 45.1 + 25.3 + 64.7 = 135.1 kN m.
- The curve runs from (0, 2 253) through (219.2, 558.6) to (135.1, 0). The Example 1 point (150, 1 200) lies above the balanced load, in the compression-failure region, and inside the curve.
Answer. Puz 2 253 kN; balanced 558.6 kN with 219.2 kN m; pure bending 135.1 kN m
Problem. Lesson 6.1, Example 2 gave 1 405.8 kN by cl. 39.3 for a 300 mm × 450 mm column with 6 bars of 16 mm (three on each 450 mm face), M20 and Fe 415, unsupported length 3.2 m, but the minor-axis minimum eccentricity (20 mm) exceeded 0.05 × 300 = 15 mm. Check it for Pu = 1 400 kN with Mu = 1 400 × 0.020 = 28 kN m about the minor axis.
- About the minor axis the section is 450 mm wide and 300 mm deep, with 3 × 201.1 = 603 mm² at 56 mm from each face. Puz = 0.45 × 20 × (135 000 − 1 206) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 206 = 1 204.1 + 375.5 = 1 579.6 kN, so the load is high and the neutral axis will lie outside the section.
- Strain compatibility with the profile pivoting at 0.002 at 3D/7 = 128.6 mm: for Pu = 1 400 kN the neutral axis is at about xu = 354 mm (outside the 300 mm depth); the strains are 0.00314 at the top and 0.00048 at the bottom, and 0.0035 − 0.75 × 0.00048 = 0.00314 confirms cl. 39.1 (b).
- Integrating the parabolic-rectangular stress block over the section (spreadsheet or program) and adding the bar forces gives a moment capacity of about 23.5 kN m at Pu = 1 400 kN, less than the 28 kN m required.
- Repeating for lower loads, the column satisfies Mu,cap ≥ 0.02 Pu up to about Pu = 1 364 kN, roughly 3 per cent below the 1 405.8 kN of the simple formula.
- Site decision: limit the factored load to about 1 360 kN, or increase the steel or concrete grade (or the 300 mm side to 350 mm); do not rely on the axial formula for columns with a side under 400 mm.
Answer. Not adequate at 1 400 kN (about 23.5 < 28 kN m); safe up to about 1 364 kN
Step-by-step procedure
- Obtain Pu and Mu about the axis from analysis; add the minimum eccentricity moment Pu emin if it is larger (cl. 39.2), about each axis in turn.
- Choose a section and a symmetric bar arrangement (about 1 to 3 per cent steel), with cover and tie sizes from lesson 6.1.
- Locate the neutral axis that gives the required Pu by strain compatibility (or read the interaction chart for Pu/(fck b D) and the steel ratio).
- Compute the moment capacity at that axial load and compare it with Mu; adjust steel or section until Mu ≤ Mu,cap.
- Check the detailing rules (0.8 to 6 per cent, bar numbers, spacing, ties) and the shear in the column.
- For biaxial moments or slender columns continue with lessons 6.3 and 6.4; for earthquake frames apply IS 13920.
Site notes
- Symmetric column bars are easier to place; when the design is unsymmetric, mark the heavier face clearly on the drawing and check it before shuttering.
- Keep the specified cover on all faces: in bending-dominated columns the outer bars' lever arm is what provides the moment capacity.
- Laps in bending columns should be in the middle half of the storey height, where moments are lower, and staggered.
- Inspect ties at beam-column joints; they are often left out to ease concreting, yet joints carry high shear in sway frames.
- Check that column dimensions on site match the drawing: a 300 mm column built as 280 mm loses capacity in both axial load and moment.
- Ignoring the minimum eccentricity moment because the analysis shows zero moment.
- Using the beam stress block when the neutral axis lies outside the section, instead of the cl. 39.1 (b) strain rule.
- Forgetting to deduct the concrete displaced by compression bars, or taking all bars at 0.87 fy without checking their strains.
- Assuming that more axial load always reduces the moment capacity; below the balanced point it increases it.
- Designing about the major axis only and forgetting the minor axis minimum eccentricity.
For symmetrically reinforced rectangular columns with Fe 415 bars the compression and tension steel forces nearly cancel at the balanced point, so Pb is close to 0.36 × 0.48 × (d/D) fck b D, about 0.15 fck b D (here 558.6/(25 × 300 × 500) = 0.149); loads above it mean compression failure, where the moment capacity falls as the load rises. When Pu/(fck b D) exceeds roughly 0.45 to 0.5 for 1 to 2 per cent steel, expect the neutral axis outside the section and use the cl. 39.1 (b) strain rule.
Summary
- Every column carries at least the minimum eccentricity moment; an axial load with a moment is equivalent to an eccentric load.
- Capacity follows from strain compatibility with the cl. 39.1 limits: 0.0035 at the compressed face when the neutral axis is within the section, and 0.0035 − 0.75 times the least strain (pivot at 3D/7) when it is outside.
- Each neutral axis position gives one (Pu, Mu) pair; together they form the interaction diagram from Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc through the balanced point to pure bending.
- Above the balanced point failure is by concrete crushing and more load reduces moment capacity; below it the tension steel yields first and some axial load helps.
- Charts or software do the repetitive work, but the method behind them is the same strain compatibility shown here.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the eccentricity of Pu = 1 500 kN with Mu = 90 kN m.
e = 90/1 500 = 0.06 m = 60 mm.
2Check cl. 39.1 (b) for a bottom strain of 0.0008.
Top strain = 0.0035 − 0.75 × 0.0008 = 0.0029.
3Find xu,b for d = 540 mm with Fe 500 bars (Es = 200 kN/mm²).
0.0035 × 540/(0.0055 + 0.87 × 500/200 000) = 0.0035 × 540/0.007675 = 246.3 mm (0.456 d).
4Find Puz for a 400 mm square column, M25, Fe 415, 8 bars of 16 mm.
0.45 × 25 × (160 000 − 1 608) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 608 = 1 781.9 + 500.6 = 2 283 kN.
5Where does a column fail if the design point lies above the balanced point?
By crushing of the concrete before the tension steel yields (compression failure).
6Why is the pivot of the limiting strain profile at 3D/7?
Because a line through 0.0035 at the face and zero at D, and the uniform 0.002 profile, intersect at y = 3D/7: 0.0035 (1 − 3/7) = 0.002.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.