6.3 Columns with biaxial bending
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why corner and edge columns carry moments about both principal axes, and why the neutral axis is then inclined.
- Check a rectangular column for axial load and biaxial bending with the load-contour equation of IS 456:2000 cl. 39.6, using the exponent that depends on Pu/Puz.
- Find the uniaxial capacities Mux1 and Muy1 at the design axial load by strain compatibility, and know when the exponent of 1 is a safe shortcut.
Theory
Columns at the corners of a building, and many edge columns, receive beams from two directions. Each beam bends the column about a different axis, so the column carries an axial load Pu together with moments Mux and Muy at the same time. The resultant moment acts about an inclined axis, the neutral axis is no longer parallel to a face, and the compression zone becomes a triangle or a trapezium in one corner of the section.
An exact check would place the inclined neutral axis by trial until both the force and the two moments balance, as cl. 39.6 permits on the assumptions of cl. 39.1 and 39.2. For every axial load the capacities then form a closed curve in the Mux-Muy plane, called the load contour; stacked for all axial loads they form a three-dimensional failure surface. That calculation is lengthy by hand, so cl. 39.6 also offers an alternative: (Mux/Mux1) raised to the power αn plus (Muy/Muy1) raised to the power αn shall not exceed 1.
Here Mux1 and Muy1 are the uniaxial moment capacities about each axis at the same axial load Pu, found exactly as in lesson 6.2. The exponent αn sets the shape of the contour. It depends on Pu/Puz, where Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc is the crushing load of the section: αn is 1.0 when Pu/Puz is 0.2 or less, 2.0 when it is 0.8 or more, and varies linearly between. An exponent of 1 is the straight line joining the two uniaxial capacities, which always lies inside the true contour; higher axial loads make the contour fuller and closer to an ellipse, so a larger exponent can be used.
The equation, first proposed by Bresler for this kind of check, separates a two-dimensional problem into two one-dimensional ones. Its accuracy depends on the uniaxial capacities being right, so bars must be placed as assumed, cover must be kept, and both capacities must be worked out at the actual design axial load, not at zero load. The minimum eccentricity of cl. 25.4 need only be met about one axis at a time when biaxial bending is considered.
Derivation
- For a given Pu, the exact load contour is the set of moment pairs (Mux, Muy) that bring the section to the strain limits of cl. 39.1 with an inclined neutral axis. At its two ends the contour passes through (Mux1, 0) and (0, Muy1).
- Divide each moment by its uniaxial capacity: the contour then runs from (1, 0) to (0, 1) in the plane of the ratios. A family of curves through these two points is x to the power α plus y to the power α equal to 1; α = 1 gives the straight line and α = 2 a quarter circle.
- Tests and exact strain-compatibility solutions show the contour is near the straight line at low axial load, where the tension steel governs, and fuller at high axial load, where the concrete governs. IS 456 links the exponent to Pu/Puz: αn = 1.0 for Pu/Puz ≤ 0.2, αn = 1.0 + (Pu/Puz − 0.2)/0.6 for 0.2 < Pu/Puz < 0.8, and αn = 2.0 for Pu/Puz ≥ 0.8.
- Because each ratio Mu/Mu1 is less than 1, raising it to a power above 1 makes it smaller. The check with the code exponent therefore always gives a sum less than or equal to the check with exponent 1, which is why using αn = 1 is a conservative shortcut.
Biaxial check: (Mux/Mux1)^αn + (Muy/Muy1)^αn ≤ 1.0 (dimensionless; moments in kN m)Crushing load: Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc (N; N/mm², mm²)Exponent: αn = 1.0 for Pu/Puz ≤ 0.2; αn = 1.0 + (Pu/Puz − 0.2)/0.6 for 0.2 to 0.8; αn = 2.0 for Pu/Puz ≥ 0.8 (dimensionless)Uniaxial capacities Mux1, Muy1 at the design Pu by strain compatibility (lesson 6.2): C = 0.36 fck b xu at 0.42 xu from the compressed face when xu ≤ D (N, mm)Minimum eccentricity: emin = l/500 + D/30 ≥ 20 mm, checked about one axis at a time (mm)
- All the assumptions of lesson 6.2 (plane sections, perfect bond, no concrete tension, the cl. 39.1 strain limits, steel idealised as linear up to 0.87 fy) apply to each uniaxial capacity.
- In the worked examples Ac is taken as the gross area minus the steel area, and the steel stress is limited to 0.87 fy, as in lesson 6.2; design charts built on the gradual Fig. 23 curve give slightly different capacities.
- The column is short and braced; for slender columns the additional moments of lesson 6.4 are added first.
- The load-contour equation is an approximation to the exact inclined-neutral-axis solution; it is used here because cl. 39.6 permits it, not because it is exact.
- Limits: circular columns (where any diameter is a principal axis and biaxial moments are combined as a vector), shear, and the ductile detailing of IS 13920 are outside this lesson.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 39.6 (resistance under axial force and biaxial bending on the assumptions of cl. 39.1 and 39.2, with the neutral axis chosen to satisfy equilibrium about two axes; alternatively the load-contour equation with Mux1, Muy1 the maximum uniaxial capacities at Pu, Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc, and αn from 1.0 at Pu/Puz = 0.2 to 2.0 at 0.8, varying linearly).
- IS 456:2000 cl. 39.1 and 39.2 (strain assumptions and minimum eccentricity, as in lesson 6.2), cl. 25.4 (emin = l/500 + D/30, not less than 20 mm; with biaxial bending it is sufficient that the eccentricity exceeds the minimum about one axis at a time), cl. 26.5.3.1 and cl. 26.5.3.2 (bars and ties, as in lesson 6.1); IS 1786 deformed bars; IS 13920 for columns of earthquake-resisting frames.
- Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) also allows a simplified biaxial criterion of the same power form with its own exponent linked to the axial load ratio, as well as a full strain-compatibility check; the American code (ACI 318) designs biaxial columns from the strain-compatibility interaction surface, and textbooks based on it present Bresler's reciprocal-load method as an approximation. Their exponents and factors differ and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A short braced corner column 400 mm × 600 mm, M25 and Fe 415, has 8 bars of 25 mm: 3 along each 400 mm face and 1 at the middle of each 600 mm face, with all bar centres 60 mm from the faces. It carries Pu = 1 800 kN, Mux = 220 kN m about the major axis and Muy = 110 kN m about the minor axis. Unsupported and effective lengths are 3.6 m. Is it safe?
- Slenderness: 3 600/600 = 6 and 3 600/400 = 9, both below 12, so the column is short. Minimum eccentricity: emin,x = 3 600/500 + 600/30 = 27.2 mm (Pu emin = 49.0 kN m) and emin,y = 3 600/500 + 400/30 = 20.5 mm (36.9 kN m); both are below the applied moments.
- Steel: Asc = 8 × 490.9 = 3 927 mm² (1.64 per cent). Puz = 0.45 × 25 × (240 000 − 3 927) + 0.75 × 415 × 3 927 = 2 655.8 + 1 222.3 = 3 878.1 kN. Pu/Puz = 1 800/3 878.1 = 0.464, so αn = 1.0 + (0.464 − 0.2)/0.6 = 1.440.
- Mux1 (bending about the major axis, D = 600 mm): by strain compatibility xu = 405.0 mm. C = 0.36 × 25 × 400 × 405.0 = 1 458.0 kN at 0.42 xu; the top 3 bars (1 473 mm², strain 0.00298) give 515.2 kN net of displaced concrete, the 2 middle bars (strain 0.00091) 170.5 kN, and the bottom 3 bars (strain −0.00117) −343.7 kN, totalling 1 800 kN. Moments about the centroid add to 395.5 kN m (concrete 189.4, top bars 123.7, middle bars 0, bottom bars 82.5 kN m).
- Muy1 (bending about the minor axis, depth 400 mm, width 600 mm): xu = 263.7 mm; C = 1 424.1 kN; the 3 bars on the compressed face give 515.2 kN, the 2 middle bars 158.7 kN and the 3 far bars −298.1 kN. Moments add to 241.0 kN m (concrete 127.1, near bars 72.1, middle bars 0, far bars 41.7 kN m).
- Check: (220/395.5)^1.440 + (110/241.0)^1.440 = 0.430 + 0.323 = 0.753 ≤ 1.0, safe. With the shortcut αn = 1 the sum would be 0.556 + 0.457 = 1.013, just above 1, so the code exponent matters here.
Answer. Safe: 0.753 ≤ 1.0 (αn = 1.440; Mux1 395.5 kN m, Muy1 241.0 kN m)
Problem. A square corner column 300 mm × 300 mm, M20 and Fe 415, length 3.0 m, carries Pu = 300 kN with Mux = Muy = 40 kN m. Bars are at the four corners, centres 50 mm from each face. Check 4 bars of 20 mm, and 4 bars of 25 mm if needed.
- Minimum eccentricity: 3 000/500 + 300/30 = 16 mm, so 20 mm governs; Pu emin = 6 kN m, well below 40 kN m. By symmetry Mux1 = Muy1.
- With 4-20 (1 257 mm²): Puz = 0.45 × 20 × (90 000 − 1 257) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 257 = 798.7 + 391.1 = 1 189.8 kN; Pu/Puz = 0.252, αn = 1.0 + 0.052/0.6 = 1.087. Strain compatibility gives xu = 141.5 mm, C = 305.6 kN, compression bars 221.2 kN, tension bars −226.9 kN; Mu1 = 27.7 + 22.1 + 22.7 = 72.5 kN m.
- Check: 2 × (40/72.5)^1.087 = 2 × 0.524 = 1.048 > 1.0: not safe.
- With 4-25 (1 963 mm², 2.18 per cent): Puz = 0.45 × 20 × (90 000 − 1 963) + 0.75 × 415 × 1 963 = 792.3 + 611.1 = 1 403.5 kN; Pu/Puz = 0.214, αn = 1.023. xu = 143.0 mm, C = 308.8 kN, compression bars 345.7 kN, tension bars −354.5 kN; Mu1 = 27.8 + 34.6 + 35.4 = 97.8 kN m.
- Check: 2 × (40/97.8)^1.023 = 2 × 0.401 = 0.801 ≤ 1.0, safe. At this low axial load the exponent is almost 1, so the biaxial check is nearly the straight-line rule.
Answer. 4-20 fails (1.048); 4-25 is safe (0.801)
Problem. For the column of Example 1, find αn when Pu is 600 kN, 1 800 kN and 3 300 kN, and say which rule applies.
- Puz = 3 878.1 kN from Example 1.
- Pu = 600 kN: Pu/Puz = 0.155 ≤ 0.2, so αn = 1.0, the straight-line rule.
- Pu = 1 800 kN: Pu/Puz = 0.464, αn = 1.440, as used in Example 1.
- Pu = 3 300 kN: Pu/Puz = 0.851 ≥ 0.8, so αn = 2.0, the quarter-circle rule. Mux1 and Muy1 must still be found at 3 300 kN, and they are much smaller than at 1 800 kN because the column is then deep in the compression-failure region of lesson 6.2.
Answer. αn = 1.0, 1.440 and 2.0
Step-by-step procedure
- Collect Pu, Mux and Muy from the analysis, and check the minimum eccentricity about one axis at a time (cl. 25.4).
- Check slenderness about both axes (lesson 6.1); if either ratio is 12 or more, add the additional moments of lesson 6.4 first.
- Choose a section and a bar arrangement, often with more bars along the face that resists the larger moment; compute Asc and Puz.
- Compute Pu/Puz and the exponent αn.
- Find Mux1 and Muy1 at the design Pu by strain compatibility or from interaction charts.
- Evaluate (Mux/Mux1)^αn + (Muy/Muy1)^αn; if it exceeds 1, add steel or enlarge the section and repeat, then detail bars and ties (lesson 6.1).
Site notes
- Corner columns are the ones most often under-reinforced on site through substituted bar sizes; check bar diameters at the corners before closing the shutter.
- The biaxial capacity relies on the corner bars: keep them truly at the corners, tied with closed ties with proper hooks.
- Keep column cover equal on all four faces; a column shifted in its formwork loses lever arm about one axis.
- When columns are made longer than drawn (for example a raised plinth), the slenderness and moments change: refer it back to the designer.
- Do not core or chase corner columns for services without the designer's approval.
- Checking each axis separately and ignoring the interaction between the two moments.
- Using the uniaxial capacities at zero axial load instead of at the design Pu.
- Taking αn = 2 at every axial load; at low Pu/Puz the contour is close to a straight line.
- Applying the minimum eccentricity about both axes at once, which cl. 25.4 does not require.
- Forgetting to add slenderness moments before the biaxial check.
For a quick first estimate, take αn = 1: if (Mux/Mux1) + (Muy/Muy1) ≤ 1 the column is certainly safe. A sum up to about 1.1 at medium axial load (Pu/Puz near 0.5) usually passes with the code exponent, as Example 1 shows (1.013 by the straight line, 0.753 with αn = 1.440).
Summary
- Corner and edge columns carry axial load with moments about both axes; the neutral axis is inclined.
- IS 456 cl. 39.6 allows an exact strain-compatibility solution or the load-contour check (Mux/Mux1)^αn + (Muy/Muy1)^αn ≤ 1.
- Mux1 and Muy1 are the uniaxial capacities at the same Pu, found as in lesson 6.2.
- αn rises from 1.0 at Pu/Puz ≤ 0.2 to 2.0 at Pu/Puz ≥ 0.8, with Puz = 0.45 fck Ac + 0.75 fy Asc.
- αn = 1 is always conservative; the minimum eccentricity is checked about one axis at a time.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find αn when Pu/Puz = 0.35.
αn = 1.0 + (0.35 − 0.2)/0.6 = 1.25.
2What is αn when Pu/Puz is 0.15, and when it is 0.9?
1.0 and 2.0.
3Find Puz for a 450 mm square column, M30, Fe 500, 8 bars of 20 mm.
Asc = 2 513 mm²; Puz = 0.45 × 30 × (202 500 − 2 513) + 0.75 × 500 × 2 513 = 2 699.8 + 942.5 = 3 642.3 kN.
4With αn = 1.5, Mux/Mux1 = 0.6 and Muy/Muy1 = 0.5, is the column safe?
0.6^1.5 + 0.5^1.5 = 0.465 + 0.354 = 0.818 ≤ 1.0: safe.
5Why is αn = 1 always on the safe side?
Each ratio is below 1, so raising it to a power above 1 makes it smaller; the straight line lies inside the code contour.
6In a biaxially bent column, about how many axes must the minimum eccentricity be met at the same time?
One axis at a time (cl. 25.4).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
- P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
- J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
- R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.