1.4 Bars of varying section and compound bars
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Find the elongation of stepped bars and bars with several loads by summing PL/(AE) over segments with constant internal force.
- Derive and use the elongation of tapered circular and rectangular bars and of a bar hanging under its own weight.
- Analyse compound bars (two materials sharing load, such as an RCC column or a concrete-filled tube) and simple statically indeterminate bars using equilibrium and compatibility.
Theory
Real members are rarely uniform. A hanger may be thicker at the threaded end, a pile or pole may taper, and a bar may carry loads at several points so that its internal force changes along the length. The single formula δ = PL/(AE) still works, but only over a length where P, A and E are all constant. The member is split into such segments, the internal force in each is found by a free-body cut, and the segment elongations are added with their signs. Where the area changes continuously, the sum becomes an integral.
A bar of varying section does not have a single stress. The smallest section carries the highest stress and usually governs strength, while the overall elongation depends on every segment. Using an average diameter for a tapered bar gives the wrong elongation, because stiffness depends on the square of the diameter: a tapered circular bar stretches by 4PL/(πE d₁d₂), which is more than a uniform bar of the mean diameter would.
A compound bar is made of two or more materials joined so that they deform together, like steel bars cast in a concrete column, a steel tube filled with concrete, or a timber post with steel flitch plates. Equilibrium alone cannot say how the load divides; that needs a second condition, compatibility: because the materials are bonded and loaded through a common end plate, they shorten by the same amount and so have the same strain. Since stress equals E times strain, the stiffer material carries more stress in proportion to its modulus. In an RCC column the steel stress is m = Es/Ec times the concrete stress, and the column behaves as if it were all concrete with an equivalent area Ac + m As.
The same idea of equilibrium plus compatibility solves bars that are fixed at both ends, which are statically indeterminate: the reactions cannot be found from statics alone, but the total change of length is known to be zero. This is the first appearance of a method that runs through the whole of structural analysis. For compound columns it also explains a long-term effect: concrete creeps and shrinks while steel does not, so over months the load slowly shifts from the concrete to the steel, and steel stresses well above the short-term elastic value are normal in old columns.
Derivation
- Stepped bar: split into n segments with constant P_i, A_i, E_i over length L_i. Total δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i), with tension positive.
- Tapered circular bar, diameter varying linearly from d₁ to d₂ over L: d(x) = d₁ + (d₂ − d₁) x/L. The elongation of an element dx is P dx/(E π d(x)²/4); integrating gives δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂).
- Tapered flat bar of constant thickness t and width varying from b₁ to b₂: δ = ∫ P dx/(E t b(x)) = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)].
- Bar hanging under its own weight (density ρ, length L): the force at distance x from the free end is ρ g A x, so δ = ∫ ρ g x dx/E = ρ g L²/(2E) = W L/(2AE), half the elongation that the full weight W would cause if hung at the end.
- Compound bar of materials 1 and 2 under load P: equilibrium σ₁A₁ + σ₂A₂ = P; compatibility ε₁ = ε₂, so σ₁/E₁ = σ₂/E₂.
- Solving: P₁ = P A₁E₁/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂) and P₂ = P A₂E₂/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂); the common strain is P/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂).
- RCC column with m = Es/Ec: σ_s = m σ_c and P = σ_c(Ac + m As), where Ac is the net concrete area.
- Bar fixed at both ends with a load P at distance a from the left end (b from the right): reactions R_L + R_R = P and zero total elongation R_L a = R_R b give R_L = P b/L and R_R = P a/L.
Stepped bar δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i)Tapered circular bar δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂)Tapered flat bar δ = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)]Self-weight δ = ρ g L²/(2E) = WL/(2AE); maximum stress ρ g L at the supportCompound bar P₁ = P A₁E₁/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂); common strain ε = P/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂)RCC column (elastic, short term) σ_c = P/(Ac + m As), σ_s = m σ_c, m = Es/EcFixed-fixed bar R_L = Pb/L, R_R = Pa/LUnits: P in N, A in mm², E in N/mm², L in mm give δ in mm
- Linear elastic behaviour in every segment and material; the elastic load sharing in compound members does not hold after yielding or crushing.
- Perfect bond (or a rigid end plate) so the materials of a compound bar have equal strain.
- The taper is gentle, so stress is uniform over each cross-section; abrupt steps cause local stress concentrations that these formulas do not show.
- Self-weight and applied loads act along the axis; compression members are short enough not to buckle.
- Short-term moduli are used; creep and shrinkage of concrete change the load sharing with time.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs the elastic analysis of stepped, tapered and compound bars; it follows from equilibrium, compatibility and Hooke's law.
- The material constants used here follow IS 456:2000 cl. 6.2.3.1 (Ec = 5000 √fck) and cl. 5.6.3 (Es = 200 kN/mm²) for concrete and reinforcement, and IS 800:2007 cl. 2.2.4.1 (E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²) for structural steel.
- RCC columns are designed for strength by the limit state method of IS 456:2000 (RCC design subject), not by elastic load sharing; the elastic method here estimates service stresses and shortening. Side by side, EN 1992-1-1 and ACI 318-19 also design columns by strength methods; they are not ranked here.
Worked examples
Problem. A vertical steel bar is fixed at its top. The lower segment is 16 mm in diameter and 1.0 m long and carries a 20 kN load at its free end. The upper segment is 25 mm in diameter and 1.5 m long, and a further 30 kN acts downward at the step. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the stress in each segment and the total elongation.
- Internal forces by cuts: lower segment 20 kN; upper segment 20 + 30 = 50 kN (both tension).
- Areas: A₁ = π × 16²/4 = 201.06 mm²; A₂ = π × 25²/4 = 490.87 mm².
- Stresses: σ₁ = 20 000/201.06 = 99.47 N/mm²; σ₂ = 50 000/490.87 = 101.86 N/mm².
- δ₁ = 20 000 × 1000/(201.06 × 200 000) = 0.4974 mm; δ₂ = 50 000 × 1500/(490.87 × 200 000) = 0.7639 mm.
- Total δ = 0.4974 + 0.7639 = 1.261 mm.
Answer. σ = 99.5 and 101.9 N/mm²; total elongation 1.26 mm
Problem. A tapered round steel tie in a roof is 2 m long, with diameter varying from 40 mm to 20 mm, and carries 50 kN in tension. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find its elongation and compare with a uniform bar of the mean diameter, 30 mm.
- Tapered bar: δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂) = 4 × 50 000 × 2000 / (π × 200 000 × 40 × 20) = 0.796 mm.
- Uniform 30 mm bar: A = 706.86 mm²; δ = 50 000 × 2000/(706.86 × 200 000) = 0.707 mm.
- The mean-diameter estimate is about 11 % low, because the thin end is far more flexible than the thick end is stiff.
- Largest stress is at the 20 mm end: 50 000/314.16 = 159.2 N/mm².
Answer. δ = 0.80 mm (mean-diameter bar 0.71 mm, 11 % low)
Problem. A short RCC column 400 mm × 400 mm has 8 bars of 20 mm diameter in M25 concrete and carries a service axial load of 1500 kN. Using Ec = 5000 √fck and Es = 200 kN/mm² (short term), find the stresses in concrete and steel, the share of load taken by the steel and the elastic shortening of a 3 m storey height.
- As = 8 × π × 20²/4 = 2513.3 mm²; net Ac = 160 000 − 2513.3 = 157 486.7 mm².
- Ec = 5000 √25 = 25 000 N/mm²; m = 200 000/25 000 = 8.
- Equivalent area = Ac + m As = 157 486.7 + 8 × 2513.3 = 177 592.9 mm².
- σ_c = 1 500 000/177 592.9 = 8.45 N/mm²; σ_s = 8 × 8.45 = 67.6 N/mm².
- Steel share = 67.57 × 2513.3/1 500 000 = 11.3 % of the load (with only 1.57 % of the area).
- Shortening = (8.446/25 000) × 3000 = 1.01 mm. With creep, the steel stress and shortening rise over time.
Answer. σ_c = 8.45 N/mm²; σ_s = 67.6 N/mm²; steel carries 11.3 %; shortening 1.01 mm
Step-by-step procedure
- Draw the member with all loads and supports; if it is fixed at both ends, note that it is statically indeterminate.
- Cut the member in each segment and find the internal force by equilibrium (tension positive).
- For each segment with constant P, A and E compute P L/(A E); integrate where the area varies continuously.
- For compound members write equilibrium (sum of forces) and compatibility (equal strains or zero total elongation), then solve.
- Check the largest stress in each material against its limit, and the total deformation against what the structure can accept.
Site notes
- Column shortening in tall buildings is uneven: heavily reinforced columns and lightly reinforced walls shorten differently, so floor slabs are cambered or levelled in stages.
- Concrete-filled steel tubes use both materials well: the tube confines the concrete and the concrete stops the tube buckling inward.
- Threaded rods are weakest at the thread root; use the tensile stress area, not the nominal shank area, for stress, but the shank area for stretch over the plain length.
- Long hanging cables, drill rods and lift ropes stretch under their own weight; include it in level and length calculations.
- Using the total load in every segment instead of the internal force found by a cut.
- Using the mean diameter for a tapered bar's elongation.
- Splitting load between materials in proportion to area instead of to A × E.
- Using the gross area of concrete in a column without subtracting the steel area (small error at low steel ratios, larger at high).
- Forgetting that a bar fixed at both ends needs a compatibility equation; statics alone has too many unknowns.
In an RCC column at service load the steel stress is about m times the concrete stress; with 1 % steel and m = 8 the steel carries about 7.5 % of the load in the short term (m p/(1 − p + m p)). Creep raises this share over time.
Summary
- Stepped bars: δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i), using the internal force in each segment.
- Tapered round bar δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂); self-weight δ = ρ g L²/(2E).
- Compound bars: equilibrium plus equal strain; load shares in proportion to A E.
- Fixed-fixed bars: zero total elongation gives the extra equation.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A steel bar has two segments each 500 mm long, of 20 mm and 10 mm diameter, and carries 10 kN tension. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the total elongation.
δ = (10 000 × 500/200 000) × (1/314.16 + 1/78.54) = 0.398 mm.
2A steel rod (ρ = 7850 kg/m³, E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²) hangs 100 m down a shaft. Find its elongation under its own weight and the maximum stress.
δ = ρ g L²/(2E) = 7850 × 9.81 × 100²/(2 × 2 × 10¹¹) = 1.93 mm; maximum stress ρ g L = 7.70 N/mm² at the top.
3A short concrete-filled steel tube has As = 3000 mm² (Es = 200 GPa) and Ac = 30 000 mm² (Ec = 30 GPa) and carries 600 kN. Find the load and stress in each material.
Steel 600 × 600 000/1 500 000 = 240 kN, σ_s = 80 N/mm²; concrete 360 kN, σ_c = 12 N/mm².
4A uniform bar 3 m long is fixed at both ends and carries an axial load of 60 kN at 1 m from the left end. Find the reactions.
R_L = 60 × 2/3 = 40 kN; R_R = 60 × 1/3 = 20 kN (the nearer support takes more).
5A flat steel plate 10 mm thick tapers in width from 100 mm to 50 mm over 1 m and carries 50 kN. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find its elongation.
δ = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)] = 50 000 × 1000 × ln 2/(200 000 × 10 × 50) = 0.347 mm.
6Why does the steel stress in an RCC column increase over time under constant load?
Concrete creeps and shrinks but steel does not; to keep the strains equal, load transfers from concrete to steel.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.