Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.4

1.4 Bars of varying section and compound bars

Strength of Materials Chapter 1: Simple stress and strain Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Find the elongation of stepped bars and bars with several loads by summing PL/(AE) over segments with constant internal force.
  • Derive and use the elongation of tapered circular and rectangular bars and of a bar hanging under its own weight.
  • Analyse compound bars (two materials sharing load, such as an RCC column or a concrete-filled tube) and simple statically indeterminate bars using equilibrium and compatibility.

Theory

Real members are rarely uniform. A hanger may be thicker at the threaded end, a pile or pole may taper, and a bar may carry loads at several points so that its internal force changes along the length. The single formula δ = PL/(AE) still works, but only over a length where P, A and E are all constant. The member is split into such segments, the internal force in each is found by a free-body cut, and the segment elongations are added with their signs. Where the area changes continuously, the sum becomes an integral.

A bar of varying section does not have a single stress. The smallest section carries the highest stress and usually governs strength, while the overall elongation depends on every segment. Using an average diameter for a tapered bar gives the wrong elongation, because stiffness depends on the square of the diameter: a tapered circular bar stretches by 4PL/(πE d₁d₂), which is more than a uniform bar of the mean diameter would.

P₁P₂A₂, L₂A₁, L₁δ = Σ PᵢLᵢ / (AᵢEᵢ)σs = m σc, ε equalP = σc (Ac + m As)Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.4: A stepped bar and a compound RCC column section sharing load. Indiacon original, not to scale.

A compound bar is made of two or more materials joined so that they deform together, like steel bars cast in a concrete column, a steel tube filled with concrete, or a timber post with steel flitch plates. Equilibrium alone cannot say how the load divides; that needs a second condition, compatibility: because the materials are bonded and loaded through a common end plate, they shorten by the same amount and so have the same strain. Since stress equals E times strain, the stiffer material carries more stress in proportion to its modulus. In an RCC column the steel stress is m = Es/Ec times the concrete stress, and the column behaves as if it were all concrete with an equivalent area Ac + m As.

The same idea of equilibrium plus compatibility solves bars that are fixed at both ends, which are statically indeterminate: the reactions cannot be found from statics alone, but the total change of length is known to be zero. This is the first appearance of a method that runs through the whole of structural analysis. For compound columns it also explains a long-term effect: concrete creeps and shrinks while steel does not, so over months the load slowly shifts from the concrete to the steel, and steel stresses well above the short-term elastic value are normal in old columns.

Derivation

  1. Stepped bar: split into n segments with constant P_i, A_i, E_i over length L_i. Total δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i), with tension positive.
  2. Tapered circular bar, diameter varying linearly from d₁ to d₂ over L: d(x) = d₁ + (d₂ − d₁) x/L. The elongation of an element dx is P dx/(E π d(x)²/4); integrating gives δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂).
  3. Tapered flat bar of constant thickness t and width varying from b₁ to b₂: δ = ∫ P dx/(E t b(x)) = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)].
  4. Bar hanging under its own weight (density ρ, length L): the force at distance x from the free end is ρ g A x, so δ = ∫ ρ g x dx/E = ρ g L²/(2E) = W L/(2AE), half the elongation that the full weight W would cause if hung at the end.
  5. Compound bar of materials 1 and 2 under load P: equilibrium σ₁A₁ + σ₂A₂ = P; compatibility ε₁ = ε₂, so σ₁/E₁ = σ₂/E₂.
  6. Solving: P₁ = P A₁E₁/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂) and P₂ = P A₂E₂/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂); the common strain is P/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂).
  7. RCC column with m = Es/Ec: σ_s = m σ_c and P = σ_c(Ac + m As), where Ac is the net concrete area.
  8. Bar fixed at both ends with a load P at distance a from the left end (b from the right): reactions R_L + R_R = P and zero total elongation R_L a = R_R b give R_L = P b/L and R_R = P a/L.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Stepped bar δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i)
  • Tapered circular bar δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂)
  • Tapered flat bar δ = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)]
  • Self-weight δ = ρ g L²/(2E) = WL/(2AE); maximum stress ρ g L at the support
  • Compound bar P₁ = P A₁E₁/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂); common strain ε = P/(A₁E₁ + A₂E₂)
  • RCC column (elastic, short term) σ_c = P/(Ac + m As), σ_s = m σ_c, m = Es/Ec
  • Fixed-fixed bar R_L = Pb/L, R_R = Pa/L
  • Units: P in N, A in mm², E in N/mm², L in mm give δ in mm
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic behaviour in every segment and material; the elastic load sharing in compound members does not hold after yielding or crushing.
  • Perfect bond (or a rigid end plate) so the materials of a compound bar have equal strain.
  • The taper is gentle, so stress is uniform over each cross-section; abrupt steps cause local stress concentrations that these formulas do not show.
  • Self-weight and applied loads act along the axis; compression members are short enough not to buckle.
  • Short-term moduli are used; creep and shrinkage of concrete change the load sharing with time.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • No design code governs the elastic analysis of stepped, tapered and compound bars; it follows from equilibrium, compatibility and Hooke's law.
  • The material constants used here follow IS 456:2000 cl. 6.2.3.1 (Ec = 5000 √fck) and cl. 5.6.3 (Es = 200 kN/mm²) for concrete and reinforcement, and IS 800:2007 cl. 2.2.4.1 (E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²) for structural steel.
  • RCC columns are designed for strength by the limit state method of IS 456:2000 (RCC design subject), not by elastic load sharing; the elastic method here estimates service stresses and shortening. Side by side, EN 1992-1-1 and ACI 318-19 also design columns by strength methods; they are not ranked here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style)

Problem. A vertical steel bar is fixed at its top. The lower segment is 16 mm in diameter and 1.0 m long and carries a 20 kN load at its free end. The upper segment is 25 mm in diameter and 1.5 m long, and a further 30 kN acts downward at the step. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the stress in each segment and the total elongation.

  1. Internal forces by cuts: lower segment 20 kN; upper segment 20 + 30 = 50 kN (both tension).
  2. Areas: A₁ = π × 16²/4 = 201.06 mm²; A₂ = π × 25²/4 = 490.87 mm².
  3. Stresses: σ₁ = 20 000/201.06 = 99.47 N/mm²; σ₂ = 50 000/490.87 = 101.86 N/mm².
  4. δ₁ = 20 000 × 1000/(201.06 × 200 000) = 0.4974 mm; δ₂ = 50 000 × 1500/(490.87 × 200 000) = 0.7639 mm.
  5. Total δ = 0.4974 + 0.7639 = 1.261 mm.

Answer. σ = 99.5 and 101.9 N/mm²; total elongation 1.26 mm

Example 2 (site style)

Problem. A tapered round steel tie in a roof is 2 m long, with diameter varying from 40 mm to 20 mm, and carries 50 kN in tension. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find its elongation and compare with a uniform bar of the mean diameter, 30 mm.

  1. Tapered bar: δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂) = 4 × 50 000 × 2000 / (π × 200 000 × 40 × 20) = 0.796 mm.
  2. Uniform 30 mm bar: A = 706.86 mm²; δ = 50 000 × 2000/(706.86 × 200 000) = 0.707 mm.
  3. The mean-diameter estimate is about 11 % low, because the thin end is far more flexible than the thick end is stiff.
  4. Largest stress is at the 20 mm end: 50 000/314.16 = 159.2 N/mm².

Answer. δ = 0.80 mm (mean-diameter bar 0.71 mm, 11 % low)

Example 3 (site style)

Problem. A short RCC column 400 mm × 400 mm has 8 bars of 20 mm diameter in M25 concrete and carries a service axial load of 1500 kN. Using Ec = 5000 √fck and Es = 200 kN/mm² (short term), find the stresses in concrete and steel, the share of load taken by the steel and the elastic shortening of a 3 m storey height.

  1. As = 8 × π × 20²/4 = 2513.3 mm²; net Ac = 160 000 − 2513.3 = 157 486.7 mm².
  2. Ec = 5000 √25 = 25 000 N/mm²; m = 200 000/25 000 = 8.
  3. Equivalent area = Ac + m As = 157 486.7 + 8 × 2513.3 = 177 592.9 mm².
  4. σ_c = 1 500 000/177 592.9 = 8.45 N/mm²; σ_s = 8 × 8.45 = 67.6 N/mm².
  5. Steel share = 67.57 × 2513.3/1 500 000 = 11.3 % of the load (with only 1.57 % of the area).
  6. Shortening = (8.446/25 000) × 3000 = 1.01 mm. With creep, the steel stress and shortening rise over time.

Answer. σ_c = 8.45 N/mm²; σ_s = 67.6 N/mm²; steel carries 11.3 %; shortening 1.01 mm

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Draw the member with all loads and supports; if it is fixed at both ends, note that it is statically indeterminate.
  2. Cut the member in each segment and find the internal force by equilibrium (tension positive).
  3. For each segment with constant P, A and E compute P L/(A E); integrate where the area varies continuously.
  4. For compound members write equilibrium (sum of forces) and compatibility (equal strains or zero total elongation), then solve.
  5. Check the largest stress in each material against its limit, and the total deformation against what the structure can accept.

Site notes

  • Column shortening in tall buildings is uneven: heavily reinforced columns and lightly reinforced walls shorten differently, so floor slabs are cambered or levelled in stages.
  • Concrete-filled steel tubes use both materials well: the tube confines the concrete and the concrete stops the tube buckling inward.
  • Threaded rods are weakest at the thread root; use the tensile stress area, not the nominal shank area, for stress, but the shank area for stretch over the plain length.
  • Long hanging cables, drill rods and lift ropes stretch under their own weight; include it in level and length calculations.
Common mistakes
  • Using the total load in every segment instead of the internal force found by a cut.
  • Using the mean diameter for a tapered bar's elongation.
  • Splitting load between materials in proportion to area instead of to A × E.
  • Using the gross area of concrete in a column without subtracting the steel area (small error at low steel ratios, larger at high).
  • Forgetting that a bar fixed at both ends needs a compatibility equation; statics alone has too many unknowns.
Quick check

In an RCC column at service load the steel stress is about m times the concrete stress; with 1 % steel and m = 8 the steel carries about 7.5 % of the load in the short term (m p/(1 − p + m p)). Creep raises this share over time.

Summary

  • Stepped bars: δ = Σ P_i L_i/(A_i E_i), using the internal force in each segment.
  • Tapered round bar δ = 4PL/(π E d₁ d₂); self-weight δ = ρ g L²/(2E).
  • Compound bars: equilibrium plus equal strain; load shares in proportion to A E.
  • Fixed-fixed bars: zero total elongation gives the extra equation.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A steel bar has two segments each 500 mm long, of 20 mm and 10 mm diameter, and carries 10 kN tension. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the total elongation.

δ = (10 000 × 500/200 000) × (1/314.16 + 1/78.54) = 0.398 mm.

2A steel rod (ρ = 7850 kg/m³, E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²) hangs 100 m down a shaft. Find its elongation under its own weight and the maximum stress.

δ = ρ g L²/(2E) = 7850 × 9.81 × 100²/(2 × 2 × 10¹¹) = 1.93 mm; maximum stress ρ g L = 7.70 N/mm² at the top.

3A short concrete-filled steel tube has As = 3000 mm² (Es = 200 GPa) and Ac = 30 000 mm² (Ec = 30 GPa) and carries 600 kN. Find the load and stress in each material.

Steel 600 × 600 000/1 500 000 = 240 kN, σ_s = 80 N/mm²; concrete 360 kN, σ_c = 12 N/mm².

4A uniform bar 3 m long is fixed at both ends and carries an axial load of 60 kN at 1 m from the left end. Find the reactions.

R_L = 60 × 2/3 = 40 kN; R_R = 60 × 1/3 = 20 kN (the nearer support takes more).

5A flat steel plate 10 mm thick tapers in width from 100 mm to 50 mm over 1 m and carries 50 kN. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find its elongation.

δ = PL ln(b₁/b₂)/[E t (b₁ − b₂)] = 50 000 × 1000 × ln 2/(200 000 × 10 × 50) = 0.347 mm.

6Why does the steel stress in an RCC column increase over time under constant load?

Concrete creeps and shrinks but steel does not; to keep the strains equal, load transfers from concrete to steel.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.