Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.1

1.1 Working stress method

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 1: Design philosophies Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain the idea behind the working stress method: elastic behaviour at service load, permissible stresses and one factor of safety on each material.
  • Use the modular ratio and the transformed cracked section to find the neutral axis, the lever arm, the stresses and the moment of resistance of a singly reinforced rectangular beam.
  • Classify a section as balanced, under-reinforced or over-reinforced and design a simple beam by the working stress method, and state where the method is still used and why it was replaced for general design.

Theory

The working stress method (WSM) is the oldest of the three design philosophies used for reinforced concrete. It assumes that, under the loads the structure actually carries in service, both concrete and steel behave elastically: stress is proportional to strain. Safety is introduced in one place only, by keeping the computed stresses below permissible stresses that are a fraction of the material strengths. The ratio of strength to permissible stress is the factor of safety, and it is applied to the materials while the loads are used at their working (unfactored) values.

Reinforced concrete is a composite of two materials with very different stiffness. Because the bars are bonded to the concrete, both see the same strain at the level of the steel, so the steel stress is m times the concrete stress that would exist at that level, where m is the modular ratio. Replacing the steel area Ast by an equivalent concrete area m Ast turns the section into one homogeneous material, the transformed section, to which ordinary beam theory applies. Concrete below the neutral axis is assumed cracked and carries no tension.

Working stress method: elastic cracked sectionNAbdkdεcεsstrainσcbc (max)CT = Ast σstjdstressIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.1: Working stress design of a singly reinforced rectangular beam: the cracked transformed section, the linear strain diagram, and the triangular concrete stress with compression C at kd/3 from the top and steel tension T, separated by the lever arm jd. Indiacon original, not to scale.

In IS 456:2000 the modular ratio is not simply Es/Ec. It is taken as m = 280/(3σcbc), where σcbc is the permissible compressive stress in concrete in bending. This lower effective concrete stiffness allows, in part, for creep under sustained load, which transfers stress from concrete to steel over time. A useful consequence is that m σcbc = 93.33 N/mm² for every grade, so the balanced neutral-axis depth depends only on the permissible steel stress.

A section is balanced when the concrete reaches σcbc and the steel reaches σst at the same time. With less steel than that the section is under-reinforced: the steel reaches its permissible stress first and the concrete is under-stressed. With more steel it is over-reinforced: the concrete governs and part of the steel is wasted. WSM is simple and gives good control of stresses and cracking at service load, which is why it is still used for liquid-retaining structures and for many service-stress checks. Its weaknesses are that one factor of safety cannot reflect the different uncertainty in dead load, imposed load and material strength, that it says nothing directly about the real collapse load (concrete is not elastic near failure), and that it tends to give heavier sections. For these reasons general building design moved to the limit state method of lesson 1.2.

Derivation

  1. Assumptions (IS 456:2000 Annex B, B-1.3): plane sections remain plane; all tension is carried by the steel; stress–strain behaviour of both materials under working loads is linear; the modular ratio is m = 280/(3σcbc).
  2. Strain compatibility: with neutral-axis depth x = kd, the strain at the top fibre and at the steel are in the ratio x : (d − x). Since σs = Es εs and σc = Ec εc, the steel stress equals m times the concrete stress at the steel level: σs = m σc (d − x)/x.
  3. Neutral axis: the first moment of the transformed section about the neutral axis is zero, b x²/2 = m Ast (d − x). This quadratic gives x for a given section, independent of the load.
  4. Balanced (critical) neutral axis: put σc = σcbc and σs = σst in step 2, giving kc = xc/d = m σcbc/(m σcbc + σst). For M20 and Fe 415, kc = 93.33/(93.33 + 230) = 0.289.
  5. Lever arm and moment of resistance: the compression C = ½ σcbc b x acts at x/3 from the top, so the lever arm is jd = d − x/3, that is j = 1 − k/3. For a balanced section M = ½ σcbc kc jc b d² = R b d², with R = ½ σcbc kc jc (N/mm²); for M20 and Fe 415, jc = 0.904 and R = 0.913 N/mm².
  6. Steel area: from T = C, Ast σst = ½ σcbc b x, so the balanced steel ratio is pt,bal = 100 × ½ σcbc kc/σst (0.439 per cent for M20 and Fe 415), and for design Ast = M/(σst j d). For a given section, if x is less than xc the steel governs and M = Ast σst (d − x/3); if x exceeds xc the concrete governs and M = ½ σcbc b x (d − x/3).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Modular ratio (IS 456 Annex B): m = 280/(3σcbc), with σcbc in N/mm² (dimensionless)
  • Neutral axis of a given section: b x²/2 = m Ast (d − x) (x in mm)
  • Balanced neutral-axis factor: kc = m σcbc/(m σcbc + σst); lever-arm factor j = 1 − k/3 (dimensionless)
  • Balanced moment of resistance: M = R b d², R = ½ σcbc kc jc (N/mm²; M in N mm)
  • Steel area for a moment M: Ast = M/(σst j d) (mm²)
  • Cracked moment of inertia: Icr = b x³/3 + m Ast (d − x)² (mm⁴); stresses fc = M x/Icr and fs = m M (d − x)/Icr (N/mm²)
  • Under-reinforced (x < xc): M = Ast σst (d − x/3); over-reinforced (x > xc): M = ½ σcbc b x (d − x/3) (N mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • Loads are working (service) loads, used without load factors; safety comes only from the permissible stresses.
  • Concrete and steel are linearly elastic up to the permissible stresses, and plane sections remain plane with perfect bond between steel and concrete.
  • Concrete in tension is ignored below the neutral axis (cracked section); the uncracked section is used only for special checks such as liquid-tightness.
  • The code value of m includes an allowance for creep, so it is not the short-term ratio Es/Ec (with Ec = 5 000 √fck, M25 gives Es/Ec = 8, whereas 280/(3 × 8.5) = 10.98).
  • Limits: WSM does not predict the collapse load, cannot give different margins for loads of different reliability, and is not suited to redistribution of moments, ductility checks or earthquake design. Use it where the governing code allows it (IS 456:2000 cl. 18.2.2: where the limit state method cannot be conveniently adopted) and for service-stress checks.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 18.2.1 makes the limit state method the normal method of design, and cl. 18.2.2 permits the working stress method of Annex B where the limit state method cannot be conveniently adopted. Annex B, B-1.3 lists the assumptions and the modular ratio m = 280/(3σcbc); B-2.1 with Table 21 gives permissible stresses in concrete (σcbc = 7.0 N/mm² for M20, 8.5 for M25 and 10.0 for M30); B-2.2 with Table 22 gives permissible stresses in steel (σst = 230 N/mm² for Fe 415 bars and 140 N/mm² for mild steel bars up to 20 mm).
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 6.2.3.1 gives the short-term modulus of concrete Ec = 5 000 √fck and cl. 5.6.3 takes Es = 200 kN/mm²; the Annex B note explains that the Annex B modular ratio differs from Es/Ec because it allows for long-term effects.
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: current European (EN 1992-1-1) and American (ACI 318) concrete codes design for strength in a limit state or strength format and use elastic cracked-section stresses mainly for serviceability, such as stress limits and crack control; liquid-retaining structures in all three systems still rely on service-stress or crack-width checks. Their values are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: moment of resistance of a given beam)

Problem. A beam 250 mm wide with an effective depth of 450 mm has three 16 mm bars (Ast = 603 mm²). Concrete M20 (σcbc = 7.0 N/mm², m = 13.33) and Fe 415 steel (σst = 230 N/mm²). Find the neutral axis, state whether the section is under- or over-reinforced, and find its moment of resistance.

  1. Ast = 3 × π × 16²/4 = 603.2 mm²; m Ast = 13.33 × 603.2 = 8 042 mm².
  2. Neutral axis: 250 x²/2 = 8 042 (450 − x), that is 125 x² + 8 042 x − 3 619 000 = 0, so x = 141.0 mm.
  3. Balanced depth xc = 0.289 × 450 = 129.9 mm. Since x = 141.0 mm exceeds xc, the section is over-reinforced and the concrete reaches σcbc first.
  4. With fc = 7.0 N/mm² at the top, the steel stress is m × 7.0 × (450 − 141.0)/141.0 = 204.5 N/mm², below 230 N/mm².
  5. Moment of resistance M = ½ × 7.0 × 250 × 141.0 × (450 − 141.0/3) = 49.7 × 10⁶ N mm = 49.7 kN m.
  6. For comparison, a balanced section of the same size resists 0.913 × 250 × 450² = 46.2 kN m with Ast,bal = 0.439 % × 250 × 450 = 494 mm².

Answer. x = 141 mm > xc = 130 mm, over-reinforced; M = 49.7 kN m (steel stress 204.5 N/mm² at that moment)

Example 2 (design style: lintel beam)

Problem. Design a simply supported beam of 5.0 m effective span, 230 mm wide, carrying a working load of 20 kN/m including its own weight, using M20 concrete and Fe 415 steel by the working stress method. Check the stresses in the chosen section.

  1. Working moment M = 20 × 5.0²/8 = 62.5 kN m.
  2. Balanced constants for M20 and Fe 415: kc = 0.289, jc = 0.904, R = 0.913 N/mm².
  3. Required effective depth d = √(M/(R b)) = √(62.5 × 10⁶/(0.913 × 230)) = 545.5 mm; adopt d = 550 mm (overall depth 600 mm).
  4. Steel Ast = M/(σst j d) = 62.5 × 10⁶/(230 × 0.904 × 550) = 547 mm²; provide three 16 mm bars, 603 mm².
  5. Check: m Ast = 8 042 mm², so 115 x² = 8 042 (550 − x) gives x = 164.2 mm and Icr = 230 × 164.2³/3 + 8 042 × (550 − 164.2)² = 1 536 × 10⁶ mm⁴.
  6. fc = 62.5 × 10⁶ × 164.2/(1 536 × 10⁶) = 6.68 N/mm² ≤ 7.0 and fs = 13.33 × 62.5 × 10⁶ × 385.8/(1 536 × 10⁶) = 209.2 N/mm² ≤ 230: both within the permissible stresses.

Answer. 230 × 600 mm beam (d = 550 mm) with three 16 mm bars; fc = 6.68 N/mm², fs = 209 N/mm²

Example 3 (site style: service stresses in an existing beam)

Problem. An existing beam 300 mm wide, d = 500 mm, has four 20 mm bars and is made of M25 concrete. It carries a service moment of 80 kN m. Find the concrete and steel stresses using the code modular ratio, and again using the short-term ratio Es/Ec, and comment.

  1. Ast = 4 × π × 20²/4 = 1 256.6 mm². Code ratio m = 280/(3 × 8.5) = 10.98, so m Ast = 13 799 mm².
  2. 150 x² = 13 799 (500 − x) gives x = 173.3 mm; Icr = 300 × 173.3³/3 + 13 799 × 326.7² = 1 993 × 10⁶ mm⁴.
  3. fc = 80 × 10⁶ × 173.3/(1 993 × 10⁶) = 6.96 N/mm² (permissible 8.5) and fs = 10.98 × 80 × 10⁶ × 326.7/(1 993 × 10⁶) = 144.0 N/mm² (permissible 230).
  4. Short-term ratio: Ec = 5 000 √25 = 25 000 N/mm², Es/Ec = 8.0; then x = 152.6 mm, fc = 7.78 N/mm² and fs = 141.7 N/mm².
  5. The steel stress hardly changes (2 per cent) but the concrete stress changes by about 12 per cent: the modular ratio matters mainly for the concrete stress, and the code ratio represents long-term behaviour.

Answer. Code m: fc = 6.96 N/mm², fs = 144 N/mm²; with Es/Ec = 8: fc = 7.78 N/mm², fs = 142 N/mm²; both within permissible values

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the working (unfactored) loads and the maximum working moment M.
  2. Read σcbc for the concrete grade and σst for the steel, and compute m = 280/(3σcbc).
  3. Compute the balanced constants kc, jc and R, and the required effective depth d = √(M/(R b)); round up and fix the overall depth from cover, link and bar size.
  4. Compute Ast = M/(σst j d) and choose bars; check minimum and maximum steel and bar spacing.
  5. For the chosen section find x from b x²/2 = m Ast (d − x), then Icr, fc and fs, and confirm both are within the permissible stresses.
  6. Check shear, bond and deflection by the matching working stress provisions, and record the section as under- or over-reinforced.

Site notes

  • WSM survives in practice mainly for water tanks, sumps and other liquid-retaining structures, where low service stresses keep cracks narrow and the structure watertight; check which method the project specification calls for.
  • When checking an old building designed before the limit state era, read the drawings with WSM in mind: steel stresses were limited at service load, so the sections are often deeper than a modern limit state design would give.
  • Service stress checks (for example steel stress under sustained load for crack control) use the same cracked-section calculation, so the transformed section is still a daily tool even in limit state offices.
  • Do not mix methods in one member: loads, partial factors and permissible stresses belong to one philosophy each.
  • Over-reinforcing a WSM section does not add much strength, because the concrete then governs; extra bars only add congestion.
Common mistakes
  • Using m = Es/Ec in a code WSM calculation instead of m = 280/(3σcbc).
  • Applying load factors to the loads and then also using permissible stresses, which double counts safety.
  • Taking moments about the wrong point: in WSM the compression acts at x/3 from the top, not at 0.42x as in the limit state stress block.
  • Calculating the moment of resistance from the steel alone when the section is over-reinforced (x greater than xc).
  • Including the concrete below the neutral axis in Icr for a cracked section.
Quick check

For M20 and Fe 415 in WSM, kc ≈ 0.29, jc ≈ 0.90 and R ≈ 0.91 N/mm², and balanced steel is about 0.44 per cent of b d. A quick depth estimate is d ≈ √(M/(0.91 b)); for a 230 mm wide beam, d in mm is roughly 69 √M with M in kN m. For steel ratios between 0.15 and 1.5 per cent of b d in M20 the lever arm stays between about 0.85d and 0.94d; a value outside that range means the neutral axis should be rechecked.

Summary

  • WSM keeps service-load stresses below permissible stresses; safety sits in one factor on the material strengths.
  • The transformed section with m = 280/(3σcbc) turns reinforced concrete into one elastic material; concrete in tension is ignored.
  • Balanced constants k, j and R depend only on σcbc and σst; for M20 and Fe 415 they are about 0.29, 0.90 and 0.91 N/mm².
  • Under-reinforced sections are governed by the steel, over-reinforced ones by the concrete.
  • IS 456:2000 makes the limit state method normal and keeps WSM in Annex B for cases where the limit state method cannot be conveniently adopted; liquid-retaining structures and service-stress checks still use it.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the modular ratio for M30 concrete with σcbc = 10.0 N/mm².

m = 280/(3 × 10.0) = 9.33.

2Find kc, jc and R for M20 concrete and Fe 415 steel.

kc = 93.33/(93.33 + 230) = 0.289, jc = 1 − 0.289/3 = 0.904, R = ½ × 7.0 × 0.289 × 0.904 = 0.913 N/mm².

3What is the balanced steel percentage for M20 and Fe 415 in WSM?

pt = 100 × ½ × 7.0 × 0.289/230 = 0.44 per cent.

4Find the balanced moment of resistance of a 230 mm wide beam with d = 500 mm, M20 and Fe 415.

M = 0.913 × 230 × 500² = 52.5 × 10⁶ N mm = 52.5 kN m.

5Why is the code modular ratio higher than the short-term ratio Es/Ec?

Because it allows for creep: under sustained load the concrete's effective modulus falls, so more of the stress moves to the steel, which a larger m represents.

6Give two reasons why general building design moved from WSM to the limit state method.

One factor of safety cannot reflect the different uncertainty in dead load, imposed load and material strength, and elastic analysis does not show the real collapse load or reserve strength, so WSM sections are often heavier without a known safety margin.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.