Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Reinforced Concrete Design › Chapter 4 › Lesson 4.2

4.2 Crack width control

Reinforced Concrete Design Chapter 4: Limit state of serviceability Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain why flexural cracks are expected in reinforced concrete and which factors control their width: steel stress, cover, bar spacing and the distance of the surface point from the nearest bar.
  • State the crack-width limits of IS 456:2000 cl. 35.3.2 (0.3 mm, 0.2 mm and 0.1 mm) and the bar-spacing rules that are deemed to control cracking without calculation (cl. 26.3.3).
  • Calculate the design surface crack width by Annex F, including the tension-stiffening correction to the steel strain, and choose bar arrangements that meet a given limit.

Theory

A reinforced concrete beam is designed on the assumption that the concrete below the neutral axis cracks (lesson 1.1 and Chapter 2). Cracks are therefore normal and harmless when they are fine. They become a problem when they are wide enough to be seen and alarm users, to let water, chlorides and carbon dioxide reach the steel, or to leak in a liquid-retaining structure. Crack control is the second serviceability limit state, checked under service loads like deflection (lesson 4.1).

Three things decide how wide a flexural crack is at the surface. The first is the steel strain: the crack opening is roughly the steel strain multiplied by the crack spacing, so high-strength steel working at a high service stress gives wider cracks. The second is the distance from the surface point to the nearest bar: concrete close to a bar is held together by bond, so cracks are narrowest directly over a bar and widest midway between widely spaced bars and at the corners of a section. The third is the cover: a thicker cover places the surface further from the steel and widens the crack at the surface, even though it protects the steel better.

Crack width: distance to the nearest barneutral axisxh − xacr (green): point tonearest bar surfaceCmin (clear cover)flexural crackIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 4.2: Crack width depends on the distance acr from the surface point to the nearest bar, the minimum cover Cmin and the depth h − x of the cracked tension zone (Annex F of IS 456:2000). Indiacon original, not to scale.

IS 456:2000 cl. 35.3.2 says that cracking should not adversely affect appearance or durability. Where cracking is not harmful, the surface width of cracks should not in general exceed 0.3 mm. Where members are exposed to the weather, continuously exposed to moisture or in contact with soil or ground water, an upper limit of 0.2 mm is suggested, and for particularly aggressive environments such as the severe category of Table 3 the assessed width should not in general exceed 0.1 mm. The same clause stresses that crack-width calculation is a guide to good arrangement of bars, not a precise prediction.

For ordinary members the code controls cracking indirectly through bar spacing. Cl. 26.3.3 limits the clear distance between bars near the tension face of beams (through a table depending on redistribution and steel grade) and, for slabs, limits main bar spacing to three times the effective depth or 300 mm, whichever is smaller, and distribution bar spacing to five times the effective depth or 300 mm (the value as amended by Amendment No. 1; the original printing said 450 mm). Where the width has to be shown below a particular value, Annex F gives a formula. This lesson uses it to compare bar arrangements; liquid-retaining structures have their own more detailed rules.

Derivation

  1. Cracked elastic section at service load: with m = Es/Ec, the neutral axis depth x satisfies b x²/2 = m As (d − x) and Icr = b x³/3 + m As (d − x)². The steel stress is fs = m M (d − x)/Icr and its strain εs = fs/Es (Es = 200 kN/mm², Ec from cl. 6.2.3.1, as Annex F directs).
  2. Strain at the level considered, ignoring tension in the concrete: by plane sections ε1 = εs (a′ − x)/(d − x), where a′ is the distance from the compression face to the point where the crack width is wanted (a′ = h at the soffit).
  3. Tension stiffening: between cracks the concrete still carries some tension. Annex F models this as a triangular tensile stress zero at the neutral axis and 1 N/mm² at the level of the steel in the short term (0.55 N/mm² in the long term). Dividing the resulting force by the steel area and by Es reduces the strain; for a rectangular tension zone the code expression is εm = ε1 − b (h − x)(a′ − x)/[3 Es As (d − x)].
  4. Crack width: Annex F gives the design surface crack width wcr = 3 acr εm/[1 + 2 (acr − Cmin)/(h − x)], where acr is the distance from the point considered to the surface of the nearest longitudinal bar and Cmin the minimum cover to the longitudinal bar. Close to a bar acr ≈ Cmin and wcr ≈ 3 Cmin εm; far from bars the denominator limits the growth.
  5. Validity: the formula applies provided the strain in the tension steel does not exceed 0.8 fy/Es (Annex F). For Fe 415 this is 0.00166 and for Fe 500 it is 0.002.
  6. Geometry of acr: for a point on the soffit midway between two bars at centre spacing s, with the bar centre at a height c above the soffit, acr = √((s/2)² + c²) − φ/2; at a corner of the section with the bar centre c from both faces, acr = √2 c − φ/2; directly below a bar, acr = c − φ/2 = Cmin.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Neutral axis and steel stress: b x²/2 = m As (d − x); fs = m M (d − x)/Icr (mm; N/mm²)
  • Strain at the surface ignoring stiffening: ε1 = (fs/Es)(a′ − x)/(d − x) (dimensionless)
  • Average strain with stiffening: εm = ε1 − b (h − x)(a′ − x)/[3 Es As (d − x)] (dimensionless; b, h, x, a′, d in mm, Es in N/mm², As in mm²)
  • Design crack width: wcr = 3 acr εm/[1 + 2 (acr − Cmin)/(h − x)] (mm)
  • Validity: εs ≤ 0.8 fy/Es (dimensionless); limits 0.3, 0.2 and 0.1 mm
  • Distance to the nearest bar: midway acr = √((s/2)² + c²) − φ/2; corner acr = √2 c − φ/2 (mm)
  • Slab spacing (cl. 26.3.3): main bars ≤ 3d and ≤ 300 mm; distribution bars ≤ 5d and ≤ 300 mm (mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • Service loads with partial safety factor 1.0; the moment used is the service moment at the section considered.
  • Steel and concrete are elastic in tension and compression with Es = 200 kN/mm² and Ec from cl. 6.2.3.1 (Annex F); the tension stiffening is taken as the code triangle with 1 N/mm² short term or 0.55 N/mm² long term at the steel level.
  • Cracks are flexural, perpendicular to the main bars; inclined shear cracks and cracks from restraint of shrinkage or temperature need separate treatment.
  • The formula assumes the steel strain is below 0.8 fy/Es; it estimates a characteristic surface width, not the width of every crack.
  • Limits: Annex F is a guide for arranging bars and avoiding gross errors (cl. 35.3.2); liquid-retaining structures, members under direct tension and early-age thermal cracking are designed by their own methods, which this lesson does not cover.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 35.3.2 (cracking should not adversely affect appearance or durability; Annex F may be used where a particular width is required; surface width in general not more than 0.3 mm where cracking is not harmful, 0.2 mm suggested for members exposed to weather, moisture, soil or ground water, 0.1 mm for particularly aggressive environments such as the severe category of Table 3).
  • IS 456:2000 Annex F (design surface crack width wcr = 3 acr εm/[1 + 2 (acr − Cmin)/(h − x)], valid while the steel strain is limited to 0.8 fy/Es; εm = ε1 − b (h − x)(a′ − x)/[3 Es As (d − x)], with stiffening of 1 N/mm² short term reducing to 0.55 N/mm² long term; Es = 200 kN/mm² and Ec from cl. 6.2.3.1); cl. 26.3.3 (b) slab bar spacing 3d or 300 mm for main bars and 5d or 300 mm for distribution bars after Amendment No. 1.
  • Indian, European and American practice are listed side by side and not ranked: the European concrete code (EN 1992-1-1) calculates crack width as a maximum crack spacing times the mean strain difference between steel and concrete, and also gives tables of maximum bar diameter and spacing that avoid calculation; the American code (ACI 318) controls flexural cracking mainly through a maximum bar spacing that depends on the service steel stress and the clear cover, without a calculated width. Their coefficients differ and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: Annex F crack width)

Problem. The beam of lesson 4.1 Example 2 (300 × 600 mm, d = 550 mm, four 20 mm bars, M25, Fe 415) carries a service moment of 135 kN m. The clear cover to the bars is 40 mm at the soffit and the sides, so the bar centres are 50 mm from both faces. Find the short-term crack width directly below a bar, midway between bars and at the bottom corner.

  1. From lesson 4.1: m = 8, x = 161.4 mm, Icr = 1.939 × 10⁹ mm⁴. fs = 8 × 135 × 10⁶ × 388.6/1.939 × 10⁹ = 216.5 N/mm²; εs = 0.001083, below 0.8 × 415/200 000 = 0.00166, so Annex F applies.
  2. At the soffit: ε1 = 0.001083 × 438.6/388.6 = 0.001222; stiffening term = 300 × 438.6 × 438.6/(3 × 200 000 × 1 257 × 388.6) = 0.000197; εm = 0.001025.
  3. Bar centre spacing = (300 − 2 × 50)/3 = 66.7 mm. Distances: below a bar acr = 50 − 10 = 40 mm; midway acr = √(33.3² + 50²) − 10 = 50.1 mm; corner acr = √2 × 50 − 10 = 60.7 mm.
  4. wcr below a bar = 3 × 40 × 0.001025/1 = 0.123 mm; midway = 3 × 50.1 × 0.001025/(1 + 2 × 10.1/438.6) = 0.147 mm; corner = 3 × 60.7 × 0.001025/(1 + 2 × 20.7/438.6) = 0.171 mm.
  5. The largest value, 0.17 mm at the corner, is within 0.3 mm and also within the 0.2 mm suggested for an exposed member. Long term (0.55 N/mm² stiffening) εm = 0.001113 and the midway value becomes 0.160 mm.

Answer. Largest short-term crack width about 0.17 mm (corner): within 0.3 mm and 0.2 mm

Example 2 (design style: choosing bars for an exposed beam)

Problem. An exposed beam 300 × 600 mm in M25 concrete carries a service moment of 180 kN m (factored 270 kN m) with 40 mm clear cover. Three 25 mm Fe 500 bars satisfy strength. Check the 0.2 mm limit and find an arrangement that meets it without making the section over-reinforced.

  1. Three 25 mm Fe 500 (1 473 mm², d = 547.5 mm): xu = 0.87 × 500 × 1 473/(0.36 × 25 × 300) = 237.3 mm ≤ 0.46 d = 251.9 mm; Mu = 286.9 kN m ≥ 270 kN m, so strength is fine.
  2. Service: x = 171.8 mm, fs = 249.3 N/mm², εm = 0.001255; midway acr = 59.1 mm gives 0.204 mm and corner acr = 61.7 mm gives 0.211 mm: both exceed 0.2 mm.
  3. Four 22 mm Fe 500 (1 521 mm²) bring the soffit midway value to 0.173 mm, but the corner stays at 0.202 mm, just over the limit; more Fe 500 steel is limited by xu,max.
  4. Four 25 mm Fe 415 (1 963 mm², d = 547.5 mm): xu = 262.5 mm ≤ 0.48 d = 262.8 mm and Mu = 309.9 kN m ≥ 270 kN m. At service, x = 192.7 mm, fs = 189.7 N/mm², midway acr = 49.2 mm gives 0.137 mm and corner acr = 61.7 mm gives 0.162 mm.
  5. The lower-grade steel needs more area for the same strength, so it works at a lower service stress and the cracks are narrower: four 25 mm Fe 415 bars meet 0.2 mm.

Answer. Three 25 mm Fe 500: 0.211 mm (fails); four 25 mm Fe 415: 0.162 mm (meets 0.2 mm)

Example 3 (site style: slab bars over a pump room)

Problem. The 150 mm roof slab of a pump room (clear cover 20 mm, M20, Fe 415) carries a service moment of 9 kN m per metre (factored 13.5 kN m), needing 316 mm² per metre. The drawing offers either 10 mm bars at 240 mm or 8 mm bars at 150 mm. Compare their crack widths and check the slab spacing rules.

  1. 10 mm at 240 mm: 327 mm²/m, d = 125 mm, x = 24.3 mm, fs = 235.2 N/mm², εm = 0.000669; midway acr = √(120² + 25²) − 5 = 117.6 mm; wcr = 3 × 117.6 × 0.000669/(1 + 2 × 97.6/125.7) = 0.092 mm.
  2. 8 mm at 150 mm: 335 mm²/m, d = 126 mm, x = 24.6 mm, fs = 228.0 N/mm², εm = 0.000639; midway acr = √(75² + 24²) − 4 = 74.7 mm; wcr = 0.076 mm.
  3. Both are within 0.2 mm, and within 0.1 mm should the room be classed as particularly aggressive; the 8 mm bars at 150 mm give about 17 per cent narrower cracks for almost the same steel.
  4. Spacing rules (cl. 26.3.3 (b)): main bars ≤ 3d = 375 mm and ≤ 300 mm, so both spacings are allowed; distribution bars at most 5d or 300 mm.

Answer. 10 mm at 240 mm: about 0.09 mm; 8 mm at 150 mm: about 0.08 mm; both acceptable

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Decide the limit from cl. 35.3.2: 0.3 mm where cracking is not harmful, 0.2 mm for exposed or moist members, 0.1 mm for particularly aggressive environments.
  2. For routine members, satisfy the bar spacing rules of cl. 26.3.3 and the cover rules; this is deemed to control cracking.
  3. Where a calculation is needed, find the cracked elastic section under the service moment: x, Icr, fs and εs; check εs ≤ 0.8 fy/Es.
  4. Find ε1 at the surface point, subtract the tension-stiffening term to get εm (short term or long term).
  5. Compute acr at the critical points (corners, midway between bars, side faces of deep beams) and evaluate wcr; compare the largest value with the limit.
  6. If it fails, use more bars of smaller diameter, reduce bar spacing, lower the steel stress (more steel or a lower grade within the ductility limit) or deepen the section; do not reduce cover below the durability requirement.

Site notes

  • Fix bars at the spacing drawn: bunching bars to leave a gap for a pipe or a conduit creates a wide-crack zone between groups.
  • Keep the cover to the drawing: extra cover widens surface cracks, too little cover shortens the life of the steel.
  • Fine shrinkage cracks that appear within hours of casting are a curing problem, not a flexural one; cure promptly and protect from wind and sun.
  • Map cracks with a crack-width gauge or card and record their width and pattern before deciding on repairs; flexural cracks are widest at the tension face and at midspan of beams.
  • Wide cracks in exposed members should be sealed or injected only after their cause is known, otherwise they reopen.
Common mistakes
  • Checking the crack width only midway between bars and forgetting the corners, which often govern.
  • Using the long-term stiffening value where the short-term is meant, or applying the formula when the steel strain exceeds 0.8 fy/Es.
  • Thinking that thicker cover reduces surface crack width; it increases it, even though it is needed for durability.
  • Replacing many small bars by a few large ones of the same area without rechecking spacing and crack width.
  • Quoting the computed crack width as an exact prediction; cl. 35.3.2 calls it guidance for arranging bars.
Quick check

With 40 mm clear cover and steel at about 200 to 250 N/mm² under service load, Annex F gives crack widths of roughly 0.12 to 0.22 mm in ordinary beams; the corner bar distance √2 c − φ/2 is usually the critical one. For the same steel area, smaller bars at closer spacing shorten acr midway between bars almost in proportion to the spacing; in Example 3 this cuts the crack width by about 17 per cent.

Summary

  • Flexural cracks are expected in reinforced concrete; their width, not their presence, is controlled.
  • IS 456 cl. 35.3.2 limits the surface crack width to 0.3 mm in general, suggests 0.2 mm for exposed or moist members and 0.1 mm for particularly aggressive environments.
  • Annex F gives wcr = 3 acr εm/[1 + 2 (acr − Cmin)/(h − x)], with εm reduced from the cracked-section strain for tension stiffening, valid while εs ≤ 0.8 fy/Es.
  • Crack width grows with steel stress, cover and distance from the nearest bar; more, smaller and closer bars reduce it.
  • For slabs, main bars at no more than 3d or 300 mm and distribution bars at no more than 5d or 300 mm control cracking without calculation.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1What crack widths does cl. 35.3.2 give for a harmless case, an exposed member and a particularly aggressive environment?

0.3 mm, 0.2 mm and 0.1 mm.

2What is the steel strain limit for using Annex F with Fe 500 steel?

0.8 × 500/200 000 = 0.002.

3A 20 mm corner bar has its centre 60 mm from both faces. Find acr at the corner.

√2 × 60 − 10 = 74.9 mm.

4Find wcr for acr = 50 mm, Cmin = 40 mm, h − x = 440 mm and εm = 0.001.

3 × 50 × 0.001/(1 + 2 × 10/440) = 0.143 mm.

5What is the maximum spacing of main bars in a slab with d = 125 mm?

The smaller of 3 × 125 = 375 mm and 300 mm: 300 mm.

6Why do more bars of a smaller diameter reduce crack width for the same steel area?

They reduce the distance from any surface point to the nearest bar (acr), so bond holds the concrete together over more of the tension face.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • S. U. Pillai, D. Menon, Reinforced Concrete Design, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2009.
  • P. C. Varghese, Limit State Design of Reinforced Concrete, Prentice Hall of India (PHI Learning), 2nd edition, 2008.
  • J. K. Wight, J. G. MacGregor, Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and Design, Pearson, 6th edition, 2012.
  • R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley and Sons, 1975.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.