Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 8 › Lesson 8.1

8.1 Plastic hinge and shape factor

Structural Analysis Chapter 8: Plastic analysis Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Describe how a steel section yields under increasing moment, from first yield to the fully plastic state, and explain what a plastic hinge is and how it differs from a real pin.
  • Find the elastic modulus Ze, the plastic modulus Zp, the plastic neutral axis and the shape factor S = Zp/Ze for rectangular, circular, diamond, I- and T-sections.
  • Use the moment–curvature relation and the shape factor to find first-yield and collapse loads of a determinate beam and the length of the yielded zone.

Theory

Mild and structural steels have a long yield plateau: once the strain passes the yield strain εy = fy/E, the stress stays close to fy while the strain grows to ten or more times εy before strain hardening begins. Plastic analysis uses this ductility. It idealises steel as elastic–perfectly plastic, with stress equal to Eε up to fy and equal to fy beyond, in tension and in compression alike. Sign convention for this chapter: in beams, sagging moments are positive and hogging moments negative; in portal frames, a moment is positive when it causes tension on the inside face of the frame. In a mechanism every plastic hinge rotates in the same sense as its plastic moment, so the work absorbed at a hinge is always Mp times the size of its rotation, counted positive.

Bend a beam section and keep increasing the moment. At first the stress varies linearly from the neutral axis, and the outer fibres reach fy at the first-yield moment My = fy Ze. Beyond this, yielding spreads inwards from the top and bottom while an elastic core remains near the neutral axis. In the limit the whole section has yielded, half in tension and half in compression, and the moment can rise no further: this is the plastic moment Mp = fy Zp. The section can then rotate freely while still carrying Mp. That region of large, concentrated rotation at constant moment is the plastic hinge.

From first yield to the plastic hingesectionfyfirst yield, Myfy2cpartly plasticfyplastic, MpPNAIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 8.1: A rectangular section and its bending stresses at first yield (moment My), when partly plastic with an elastic core of depth 2c, and when fully plastic (moment Mp, plastic neutral axis PNA). Indiacon original, not to scale.

A plastic hinge is not a pin. It carries a moment, Mp, not zero; it rotates only in the sense of that moment; and if the moment is reduced the section unloads elastically and the hinge locks again. Because the moment is the same everywhere on the yielded section, the plastic neutral axis is the line that divides the cross-section into two equal areas, which for an unsymmetrical section is not the elastic (centroidal) axis.

The ratio S = Zp/Ze = Mp/My is the shape factor. It depends only on the shape: 1.5 for a solid rectangle, 16/(3π) ≈ 1.70 for a solid circle, 2.0 for a square bent about its diagonal (a diamond), about 1.27 for a thin circular tube and about 1.10–1.15 for rolled and welded I-sections bent about the major axis, because most of their material already sits near the extreme fibres. The shape factor measures the reserve of moment beyond first yield in one section; the redistribution of moments between sections in an indeterminate structure, studied in lessons 8.2 and 8.3, is a further reserve on top of it.

Derivation

  1. Elastic–perfectly plastic material: σ = Eε for |ε| ≤ εy and |σ| = fy beyond. Plane sections remain plane, so strain varies linearly with the distance y from the neutral axis, ε = φy, where φ is the curvature.
  2. First yield (rectangle b × h): the extreme fibre at y = h/2 reaches fy, the stress is linear, and M = fy I/(h/2) = fy bh²/6 = My, with Ze = bh²/6.
  3. Partly plastic: yielding has reached the depth where |y| = c, the half-depth of the elastic core. Taking moments of the stress blocks, M = fy b(h²/4 − c²/3). The curvature is φ = εy/c, so as c falls φ grows without limit.
  4. Fully plastic: c → 0 gives Mp = fy bh²/4, so Zp = bh²/4 and S = (bh²/4)/(bh²/6) = 1.5. In terms of curvature, M/Mp = 1 − (1/3)(φy/φ)², which approaches 1 only as φ becomes very large.
  5. Any section: with no axial force, the tension and compression forces must balance, fy A_t = fy A_c, so the plastic neutral axis divides the area into two equal halves. Then Zp = A/2 × (ȳ_t + ȳ_c), where ȳ_t and ȳ_c are the distances from that axis to the centroids of the two halves.
  6. Applying this to a solid circle of diameter d gives Zp = d³/6 and Ze = πd³/32, so S = 16/(3π) = 1.70; for a diamond of diagonal D (a square bent about a diagonal), Zp = bD²/12 and Ze = bD²/24 with b the width at mid-depth, so S = 2.0.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • First-yield moment: My = fy Ze (kN m, with fy in N/mm² and Ze in mm³ divided by 10⁶)
  • Plastic moment: Mp = fy Zp (kN m)
  • Shape factor: S = Zp/Ze = Mp/My (dimensionless)
  • Rectangle b × h: Ze = bh²/6, Zp = bh²/4, S = 1.5 (mm³)
  • Solid circle of diameter d: Ze = πd³/32, Zp = d³/6, S = 16/(3π) = 1.70
  • Doubly symmetric I-section: Zp = 2 b_f t_f (D/2 − t_f/2) + t_w h_w²/4 (mm³)
  • Partly plastic rectangle: M = fy b(h²/4 − c²/3), with c the half-depth of the elastic core (kN m)
  • Yielded length at collapse of a simply supported beam: central point load L(1 − 1/S); uniform load L√(1 − 1/S) (m)
Assumptions and limits
  • Elastic–perfectly plastic material with the same yield stress in tension and compression; strain hardening is ignored, which is slightly safe.
  • Plane sections remain plane; the section does not buckle locally or laterally before Mp is reached, so it must be compact enough (plastic class) and restrained.
  • No axial force and no high shear at the section; both reduce the plastic moment and need a reduced Mp.
  • Residual stresses from rolling or welding change the moment at first yield but not Mp itself.
  • Limits: the idealisation does not apply to brittle materials, to cold-worked steel without a yield plateau, or to slender sections that buckle locally before yielding; reinforced concrete has limited rotation capacity, so its codes allow only limited redistribution.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • The plastic hinge and the shape factor are results of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American steel codes, side by side and not ranked, use the plastic modulus to define bending resistance of compact sections, classify sections by width-to-thickness ratios that decide whether a plastic hinge can form and rotate, and require ductile steel with a clear yield plateau for plastic design; their limits and factors are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: welded I-section)

Problem. A welded I-section has flanges 250 × 16 mm and a web 468 × 10 mm (overall depth 500 mm). The steel has fy = 250 N/mm². Find Ze, Zp, the shape factor, My and Mp about the major axis.

  1. Area A = 2 × 250 × 16 + 468 × 10 = 8 000 + 4 680 = 12 680 mm².
  2. Second moment of area: I = [250 × 500³ − 240 × 468³]/12 = 554.10 × 10⁶ mm⁴; Ze = I/250 = 2.2164 × 10⁶ mm³.
  3. Plastic modulus (equal-area axis at mid-depth): Zp = 2 × 250 × 16 × (250 − 8) + 10 × 468²/4 = 1 936 000 + 547 560 = 2.4836 × 10⁶ mm³. The flanges give 78 per cent of it.
  4. Shape factor S = 2.4836/2.2164 = 1.12.
  5. My = 250 × 2.2164 × 10⁶ = 554.1 kN m; Mp = 250 × 2.4836 × 10⁶ = 620.9 kN m.

Answer. Ze = 2.216 × 10⁶ mm³, Zp = 2.484 × 10⁶ mm³, S = 1.12; My = 554.1 kN m, Mp = 620.9 kN m

Example 2 (exam style: T-section, unequal axes)

Problem. A T-section has a flange 150 × 20 mm and a web 180 × 10 mm (overall depth 200 mm), fy = 250 N/mm². Find the elastic and plastic neutral axes, Ze (for first yield), Zp and the shape factor.

  1. Area A = 3 000 + 1 800 = 4 800 mm². Elastic neutral axis from the top: ȳ = (3 000 × 10 + 1 800 × 110)/4 800 = 47.5 mm.
  2. I = 150 × 20³/12 + 3 000 × 37.5² + 10 × 180³/12 + 1 800 × 62.5² = 16.21 × 10⁶ mm⁴. First yield is at the web tip, 152.5 mm from the axis: Ze = 16.21 × 10⁶/152.5 = 106.3 × 10³ mm³.
  3. Plastic neutral axis: each half must have 2 400 mm². The flange alone has 3 000 mm², so the axis lies in the flange at 2 400/150 = 16.0 mm from the top.
  4. Zp = 150 × 16²/2 + 150 × 4²/2 + 1 800 × (4 + 90) = 19 200 + 1 200 + 169 200 = 189.6 × 10³ mm³.
  5. S = 189.6/106.3 = 1.78. My = 250 × 106.3 × 10³ = 26.57 kN m; Mp = 250 × 189.6 × 10³ = 47.40 kN m.

Answer. Elastic axis 47.5 mm and plastic axis 16.0 mm below the top; Ze = 106.3 × 10³ mm³, Zp = 189.6 × 10³ mm³, S = 1.78

Example 3 (site style: reserve and yielded length)

Problem. A simply supported 6 m steel beam uses the section of Example 1 and is restrained against lateral buckling. Find the central point load at first yield and at collapse, and the length of beam that has yielded at collapse. Repeat for a uniform load.

  1. Central point load: M_max = WL/4. First yield W_y = 4My/L = 4 × 554.1/6 = 369.4 kN; collapse W_c = 4Mp/L = 4 × 620.9/6 = 413.9 kN (a 12 per cent reserve, equal to S − 1, because a determinate beam collapses when one hinge forms).
  2. At collapse M(x) = 2Mp x/L from each support; the section has yielded where M ≥ My, from x = L/(2S) to midspan on each side.
  3. Yielded length = L(1 − 1/S) = 6 × (1 − 1/1.1205) = 0.645 m, centred under the load.
  4. Uniform load: w_y = 8My/L² = 123.1 kN/m and w_c = 8Mp/L² = 138.0 kN/m.
  5. At collapse M(x) = 4Mp x(L − x)/L², and M ≥ My over a length L√(1 − 1/S) = 6 × 0.3280 = 1.968 m about midspan, a much longer yielded zone than under the point load.

Answer. Point load: 369.4 kN at first yield, 413.9 kN at collapse, yielded length 0.645 m; uniform load: 123.1 and 138.0 kN/m, yielded length 1.97 m

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Check that the section is compact enough for a plastic hinge and is laterally restrained; otherwise plastic analysis does not apply.
  2. Find the elastic neutral axis, I and Ze from the extreme fibre that yields first.
  3. Find the plastic neutral axis as the equal-area axis (it coincides with the centroid only for sections symmetric about the bending axis).
  4. Compute Zp as the sum of first moments of the two halves about the plastic neutral axis; then Mp = fy Zp and My = fy Ze.
  5. Compute S = Zp/Ze and compare with the typical values for the shape as a check.
  6. Use Mp in the collapse analysis of lessons 8.2 and 8.3; use My (or the code’s elastic limit) where yielding must be avoided under service loads.

Site notes

  • Plastic hinges need room to rotate: avoid splices, holes and welded attachments at the points where hinges are expected, usually at supports and under heavy point loads.
  • Check the mill certificate: plastic design depends on a real yield plateau and good elongation, so steel grade and test results matter more than for elastic design.
  • Lateral restraint (bracing, purlins, or a slab connected to the compression flange) is needed close to every hinge, or the beam will twist out of plane before Mp is reached.
  • Bolt holes in the tension flange near a hinge reduce the plastic moment; account for them or move them.
  • When strengthening an existing beam by welding plates, the plastic neutral axis moves; recompute Zp for the combined section rather than adding moduli.
Common mistakes
  • Using the centroidal axis as the plastic neutral axis for an unsymmetrical section such as a T or a channel bent about its minor axis; the plastic axis is the equal-area axis.
  • Treating a plastic hinge as a pin with zero moment; it carries Mp.
  • Confusing the shape factor with the load factor: S is a property of the section, while the load factor in plastic design compares collapse load with working load.
  • Ignoring axial force or high shear, both of which lower the plastic moment of the section.
  • Taking Ze from the wrong fibre for an unsymmetrical section; first yield happens at the fibre farther from the elastic neutral axis.
Quick check

Shape factors fall in a narrow band for each family: 1.10–1.15 for I-sections about the major axis, 1.5 for solid rectangles, about 1.5–1.6 for I-sections about the minor axis, 1.70 for solid circles, about 1.27 for thin tubes and 2.0 for a diamond. A T-section typically gives 1.7–1.9. A value outside the band for its shape points to an arithmetic or axis error.

Summary

  • Elastic–perfectly plastic steel lets a section carry moment beyond first yield until the whole section yields at Mp = fy Zp.
  • A plastic hinge carries Mp and rotates in one sense; it is not a pin.
  • The plastic neutral axis divides the section into two equal areas.
  • S = Zp/Ze: 1.5 for a rectangle, 1.70 for a circle, 2.0 for a diamond, about 1.12 for an I-section.
  • In a determinate beam one hinge causes collapse, so the reserve beyond first yield equals S − 1; indeterminate structures gain more through redistribution.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the shape factor of a solid circular bar.

Zp = d³/6, Ze = πd³/32, so S = 32/(6π) = 16/(3π) = 1.70.

2A square of side a is bent about a diagonal. What is its shape factor?

As a diamond of depth D = a√2 and mid-depth width b = a√2: Zp = bD²/12 and Ze = bD²/24, so S = 2.0.

3A 100 × 200 mm steel bar (fy = 250 N/mm²) is bent about its strong axis by 225 kN m. How deep is the elastic core?

225 × 10⁶ = 250 × 100 × (200²/4 − c²/3), so c²/3 = 1 000 and c = 54.8 mm; core depth 2c = 109.5 mm.

4Find Mp and My of a 150 × 300 mm solid steel section with fy = 250 N/mm², bent about the strong axis.

Zp = 150 × 300²/4 = 3.375 × 10⁶ mm³, Mp = 843.75 kN m; Ze = 2.25 × 10⁶ mm³, My = 562.5 kN m.

5Why is the shape factor of a thin circular tube (about 1.27) lower than that of a solid bar (1.70)?

Almost all the tube’s material is already near the extreme fibre, so first yield already uses most of its strength; the solid bar has much material near the axis that only works once yielding spreads.

6Give three ways in which a plastic hinge differs from a pin.

It carries the moment Mp instead of zero; it rotates only in the sense of Mp; and it locks again and behaves elastically if the moment drops.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.