Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.3

1.3 Principle of superposition

Structural Analysis Chapter 1: Fundamentals of structural analysis Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State the principle of superposition and the two conditions on which it rests: linear elastic material and small displacements.
  • Use superposition to combine reactions, moments and deflections from separate load cases, support settlement and other actions.
  • Recognise when superposition fails (material yielding, large or second-order displacements, cables, contact and lift-off, strain energy) and what to do instead.

Theory

The principle of superposition says that the response of a structure to several actions applied together equals the sum of its responses to each action applied alone. The response can be a reaction, a member force, a bending moment, a stress or a displacement. It lets an engineer break a complicated loading into simple cases with known results, solve each separately, and add them. It is also the foundation of influence lines, of the force method (where the effect of each redundant is added to that of the loads), and of load combinations, in which separately analysed dead, imposed, wind and temperature effects are multiplied by factors and added. Sign convention as in lesson 1.1: forces up and to the right positive, anticlockwise moments positive, sagging bending moment positive, deflection positive downward when quoted for beams.

Superposition holds when the structure is linear: every response is directly proportional to the load that causes it. Two conditions make this true. The material must follow Hooke's law (stress proportional to strain, no yielding, cracking or creep within the step considered). The displacements must be small enough that equilibrium can be written on the original, undeformed geometry, so that the lever arms of the loads do not change as the structure deflects. When both hold, the stiffness relation K u = F is linear, and the response to F₁ + F₂ is u₁ + u₂.

+=δ₁δ₂δ₁ + δ₂Indiacon original
Figure 1.3: Superposition on a simply supported beam: the deflection under both loads equals the sum of the deflections under each load alone, while the beam stays linear elastic. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Superposition fails when either condition fails. A steel beam loaded beyond first yield, or a concrete member after cracking, is materially non-linear. A slender column or strut carrying axial load while it bends is geometrically non-linear: the axial force acts through the lateral deflection and adds a moment P × δ, which itself depends on the deflection, so the effect of axial and lateral loads together exceeds the sum of their separate effects. Cables change shape with the load, supports that can lift off or gaps that close change the structure itself, and strain energy is quadratic in load, so energies cannot be added.

Within its limits superposition is exact, not approximate, and it extends to actions other than loads. A support settlement, a temperature change or a lack of fit in an indeterminate structure produces its own set of forces, which can be added to those from the loads. The order in which loads are applied then does not matter, and a load case can be reused after scaling. Beyond the limits, the structure must be analysed for each combination of loads as a whole, by second-order or non-linear analysis, or a linear result must be amplified for the second-order effect.

Derivation

  1. For a linear elastic structure each displacement is proportional to the load: Δ = f P, where f is a flexibility coefficient that depends only on the geometry, the supports and EI or EA.
  2. For several loads, each causes its own displacement at a point: Δ = f₁P₁ + f₂P₂ + … = Σ f_i P_i, which is the principle of superposition written for displacements; the same holds for reactions and internal forces.
  3. Beam proof: the elastic curve satisfies EI v⁗ = q(x). If v₁ satisfies it for q₁ and v₂ for q₂, both with the same homogeneous support conditions (v = 0, v′ = 0 or v″ = 0), then v₁ + v₂ satisfies EI v⁗ = q₁ + q₂ with the same conditions, because the equation and the conditions are linear.
  4. Settlement: a prescribed support movement Δ is a non-homogeneous boundary condition; its effect, solved with no load, is added to the effect of the loads solved with Δ = 0.
  5. Geometric non-linearity: for a strut with axial load P and lateral load giving the free moment M₀(x), EI v″ = −(M₀ + P v). The moment depends on the product P × v, so the response is not proportional to the loads applied together; the commonly used amplification δ ≈ δ₀/(1 − P/P_e) shows that the deflection grows faster than linearly as P approaches the Euler load P_e.
  6. Strain energy: for a linear spring of stiffness k, U = P²/(2k). With two loads P₁ and P₂ at the same point, U = (P₁ + P₂)²/(2k) = P₁²/(2k) + P₂²/(2k) + P₁P₂/k, so the energies of separate cases cannot be added; only forces and displacements superpose.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Superposition: response to (F₁ + F₂) = response to F₁ + response to F₂; scaling: response to λF = λ × response to F
  • Flexibility form Δ = Σ f_i P_i; stiffness form K u = F
  • Simply supported beam: M_mid = wL²/8 + PL/4, δ_mid = 5wL⁴/(384EI) + PL³/(48EI) (uniform load w and central point load P)
  • Propped cantilever (fixed A, prop B): R_B = 3wL/8 from load; a prop settlement Δ reduces R_B by 3EIΔ/L³
  • Second-order amplification (approximate): δ ≈ δ₀/(1 − P/P_e)
  • Units: w in kN/m, P in kN, L in m, EI in kN m², δ and Δ in m (quoted in mm)
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic material: stress proportional to strain, with no yielding, cracking, creep or slip in the range considered.
  • Small displacements: equilibrium written on the undeformed geometry, with rotations small enough that sin θ ≈ θ.
  • The structural system does not change with load: no supports lifting off, no gaps closing, no members going slack (as cables and tension-only bracing can).
  • Loads are applied statically; the same supports and member properties are used in every load case to be added.
  • Limits: does not apply to collapse (plastic) analysis, to second-order effects in slender columns and sway frames, to cables and membranes, to soil and contact problems, or to strain energy and other quadratic quantities.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Superposition is a result of linear elasticity; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all allow load effects from separate linear analyses to be added in load combinations, and all require second-order or non-linear analysis, or amplification of first-order results, where deflections or material non-linearity change the forces; the load factors, combination rules and limits are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (beam with uniform and point loads)

Problem. A simply supported steel floor beam of span 8 m has EI = 60 000 kN m². It carries a uniform load of 10 kN/m and a point load of 40 kN at midspan from a cross beam. Find the midspan bending moment and deflection by superposition.

  1. Uniform load alone: M = wL²/8 = 10 × 64/8 = 80 kN m; δ = 5wL⁴/(384EI) = 5 × 10 × 4096/(384 × 60 000) = 0.00889 m = 8.89 mm.
  2. Point load alone: M = PL/4 = 40 × 8/4 = 80 kN m; δ = PL³/(48EI) = 40 × 512/(48 × 60 000) = 0.00711 m = 7.11 mm.
  3. Both together: M = 80 + 80 = 160 kN m; δ = 8.89 + 7.11 = 16.0 mm.
  4. Both maxima occur at midspan, so they add directly; if they occurred at different sections, the responses would be added section by section.
  5. Check: 16.0 mm is span/500, a reasonable floor deflection, and the bending stress must stay elastic for the result to hold.

Answer. M = 160 kN m and δ = 16.0 mm at midspan

Example 2 (where superposition fails: a strut with side load)

Problem. A pin-ended steel strut has Euler load P_e = 800 kN. A lateral load alone gives a midspan moment M₀ = 20 kN m and a deflection δ₀ = 5 mm. Using δ ≈ δ₀/(1 − P/P_e), find the deflection and the moment M₀ + Pδ when an axial load P = 240 kN and then P = 480 kN acts together with the lateral load, and compare with superposition.

  1. Superposition: the axial load alone keeps the ideal strut straight and causes no bending, so superposition predicts M = 20 kN m and δ = 5 mm whatever P is.
  2. P = 240 kN (P/P_e = 0.3): δ = 5/0.7 = 7.14 mm; M = 20 + 240 × 0.00714 = 21.71 kN m, 8.6 per cent above the superposed value.
  3. P = 480 kN (P/P_e = 0.6): δ = 5/0.4 = 12.5 mm; M = 20 + 480 × 0.0125 = 26.0 kN m, 30 per cent above.
  4. Doubling P raised the added moment from 1.71 to 6.0 kN m, 3.5 times, so the response is not proportional to the load.
  5. Such members need second-order analysis or amplified moments; superposition of first-order results is unsafe here.

Answer. δ = 7.14 mm and M = 21.71 kN m at 240 kN; δ = 12.5 mm and M = 26.0 kN m at 480 kN; superposition gives 5 mm and 20 kN m in both cases

Example 3 (load plus settlement on a propped cantilever)

Problem. A cantilever balcony beam is fixed at A and propped at B, span 6 m, EI = 40 000 kN m², carrying 20 kN/m. The prop B then settles 10 mm. Find the prop reaction and the fixed-end moment by superposing the load case and the settlement case.

  1. Load case (no settlement): R_B = 3wL/8 = 3 × 20 × 6/8 = 45 kN; M_A = wL²/8 = 90 kN m (hogging).
  2. Settlement case (no load): a settlement of the prop is the same as removing a tip force of 3EIΔ/L³ = 3 × 40 000 × 0.010/216 = 5.56 kN from a cantilever, so R_B falls by 5.56 kN and M_A rises by 5.56 × 6 = 33.3 kN m.
  3. Superposed: R_B = 45 − 5.56 = 39.44 kN; R_A = 20 × 6 − 39.44 = 80.56 kN.
  4. M_A = 90 + 33.3 = 123.3 kN m (hogging); check directly: M_A = wL²/2 − R_B L = 360 − 39.44 × 6 = 123.3 kN m.
  5. A 10 mm settlement raised the fixed-end moment by 37 per cent, which shows why settlement matters in indeterminate structures.

Answer. R_B = 39.44 kN, R_A = 80.56 kN, M_A = 123.3 kN m hogging (90 kN m before settlement)

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Check that the structure stays linear for the loads considered: stresses below the elastic limit, small deflections, no slack members or lift-off, and axial loads well below buckling.
  2. Split the loading into simple cases, including settlement, temperature and lack of fit, each with known results or easy to analyse.
  3. Analyse each case on the same structure with the same sign convention.
  4. Add the responses at each section or point (reactions, moments, deflections), keeping signs.
  5. Check the result against an equilibrium or deflection check of the combined case, and check that the combined stresses still satisfy the linearity assumption.

Site notes

  • Loads added during construction (stacked material, props removed early) combine with the dead load by superposition only while the structure is elastic; cracking or yielding during construction changes the later response.
  • Measured support settlements can be fed into the analysis as a separate case and added to the load effects; record them with dates.
  • Slender props and shores under side load from wind or impact do not obey superposition; check them with the amplified moment or with the supplier's combined-load data.
  • Tension-only bracing rods go slack under reversal; their effect cannot be added from separate load cases without checking which rods are active.
Common mistakes
  • Adding the maximum moments of two load cases that occur at different sections as if they were at the same section.
  • Superposing results after yielding or cracking, or for a slender strut with axial load.
  • Adding strain energies of separate load cases.
  • Using different support conditions in two load cases and then adding them.
  • Losing the sign of settlement or temperature effects when combining them with load effects.
Quick check

Superposition is safe while responses scale with load: double a load case and check that every answer doubles. For compression members compute the amplification 1/(1 − P/P_e), which is 1.11 at P/P_e = 0.1 and 2.0 at 0.5; when it is noticeably above 1, adding first-order results underestimates the moments and a second-order check is needed. Valid for elastic, small-displacement structures.

Summary

  • Response to loads together = sum of responses to each load alone, for linear structures.
  • Needs linear elastic material and small displacements on the undeformed geometry.
  • Applies to reactions, forces, moments, stresses and deflections, and to settlement and temperature cases.
  • Fails for yielding, cracking, cables, lift-off, second-order effects and strain energy.
  • Used in influence lines, the force method and load combinations.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A 3 m cantilever carries 10 kN at the tip and 4 kN/m along its length. Find the fixed-end moment by superposition.

M = 10 × 3 + 4 × 3²/2 = 30 + 18 = 48 kN m (hogging).

2A simply supported beam of span 6 m carries 30 kN at 2 m and 20 kN at 4 m from A. Find the reactions by superposition.

R_A = 30 × 4/6 + 20 × 2/6 = 20 + 6.67 = 26.67 kN; R_B = 50 − 26.67 = 23.33 kN.

3A simply supported beam of span 5 m, EI = 50 000 kN m², carries 12 kN/m and a central point load of 20 kN. Find the midspan deflection.

5 × 12 × 625/(384 × 50 000) = 1.95 mm plus 20 × 125/(48 × 50 000) = 1.04 mm, total 2.99 mm.

4A spring of stiffness 2 kN/mm carries two loads of 4 kN at the same point. Compare the true strain energy with the sum of the energies of the two loads applied separately.

True U = 8²/(2 × 2) = 16 kN mm = 16 J; separately 4 J each, sum 8 J. Energies do not superpose.

5A fixed-fixed beam of span 5 m, EI = 30 000 kN m², has one support settle 5 mm. Find the end moments caused by the settlement, to be added to the load moments.

M = 6EIΔ/L² = 6 × 30 000 × 0.005/25 = 36 kN m at each end (opposite senses).

6Give three situations in which superposition must not be used.

Any three of: after yielding or cracking; slender compression members or sway frames with second-order effects; cables and membranes; supports that lift off or gaps that close; tension-only bracing; strain energy or other quadratic quantities.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.