1.2 Stress-strain behaviour of steel and concrete
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Read the stress-strain curve of mild steel: limit of proportionality, yield point and plateau, strain hardening, ultimate stress, necking and fracture.
- Explain why high-strength deformed bars are specified by 0.2 % proof stress, and measure ductility by percentage elongation, reduction of area and the ratio of ultimate to yield stress.
- Describe the non-linear compression curve of concrete, its moduli, and the idealised parabolic-rectangular curve used in limit state design, deriving the average stress 0.36 fck and centroid 0.42 xu of the stress block.
Theory
A tensile test pulls a standard specimen at a slow, controlled rate and records load against extension. Dividing load by the original area and extension by the gauge length turns the record into an engineering stress-strain curve, a fingerprint of the material that does not depend on the specimen size. Mild steel gives the classic curve: a straight line up to the limit of proportionality, where Hooke's law holds and the slope is E; a sudden yield point, after which the strain grows at almost constant stress along the yield plateau; then strain hardening, where the stress rises again to the ultimate (tensile) stress; and finally necking, where the deformation localises, the load falls and the bar fractures.
The yield plateau of mild steel can stretch to ten or more times the elastic strain, and strain hardening then adds reserve strength. This ductility is what gives steel structures their warning before failure: they sag and stretch visibly rather than snapping. Cold-worked and micro-alloyed high-strength deformed bars do not show a sharp yield point; their curve bends over gradually. For them a 0.2 % proof stress is used: draw a line parallel to the elastic slope from a strain of 0.002 and read the stress where it meets the curve. Ductility is quantified by the percentage elongation after fracture, the percentage reduction of area at the neck, and the ratio of ultimate to yield stress, which must be high enough for plastic hinges to spread in earthquake-resistant frames.
Concrete behaves very differently. In compression its curve is non-linear from fairly low stress, because microcracks at the interface between the cement paste and the aggregate grow as the load rises. The curve reaches a peak stress at a strain of about 0.002 and then descends; in a beam, where the compression zone is supported by less stressed concrete below it, crushing is taken to occur at a strain of about 0.0035. In tension concrete is weak and brittle, cracking at roughly one tenth of its compressive strength, which is why reinforcement is placed wherever tension occurs. Because the curve is not straight, concrete has several moduli: the initial tangent modulus, the tangent modulus at a given stress, and the secant modulus from the origin to a chosen working stress, which is the value codes give as Ec.
Engineering stress uses the original area, so the curve of steel appears to fall after the ultimate point even though the material at the neck is still getting stronger. True stress uses the current area and, up to necking, follows from constancy of volume during plastic flow: σ_true = σ(1 + ε) and ε_true = ln(1 + ε). Design is done with engineering values, but the true curve explains necking and is used in advanced analysis. For limit state design the real curves are replaced by idealised ones: for concrete a parabola up to a strain of 0.002 followed by a constant stress up to 0.0035, and for steel a linear-elastic line followed by a plateau at the design yield stress.
Derivation
- 0.2 % proof stress: total strain at the proof stress f_0.2 is ε = 0.002 + f_0.2/E (plastic offset plus elastic part).
- True stress: during plastic flow volume is constant, A L = A₀ L₀, so A = A₀/(1 + ε). Then σ_true = P/A = (P/A₀)(1 + ε) = σ(1 + ε).
- True strain: summing increments dL/L from L₀ to L gives ε_true = ln(L/L₀) = ln(1 + ε).
- Idealised concrete curve for design: f = f_max[2(ε/0.002) − (ε/0.002)²] for 0 ≤ ε ≤ 0.002, and f = f_max for 0.002 ≤ ε ≤ 0.0035, with f_max = 0.67 fck/1.5 ≈ 0.446 fck.
- In a beam the strain varies linearly from 0.0035 at the top to zero at the neutral axis depth xu, so the parabola occupies the lower (0.002/0.0035) xu = (4/7) xu and the rectangle the upper (3/7) xu.
- Area of the stress block per unit width: rectangle 0.446 fck × (3/7) xu plus parabola (2/3) × 0.446 fck × (4/7) xu = 0.446 fck × (17/21) xu = 0.361 fck xu, written 0.36 fck xu.
- Centroid of the block from the compression face: [rectangle area × (3/14) xu + parabola area × ((3/7) xu + (3/8)(4/7) xu)] ÷ total area = (99/238) xu ≈ 0.416 xu, written 0.42 xu.
- Total compression in a rectangular beam of width b: C = 0.36 fck b xu acting at 0.42 xu below the top.
Engineering stress σ = P/A₀; engineering strain ε = ΔL/L₀Percentage elongation = (L_f − L₀)/L₀ × 100; reduction of area = (A₀ − A_f)/A₀ × 100Proof stress strain ε = 0.002 + f_0.2/ETrue stress σ_t = σ(1 + ε); true strain ε_t = ln(1 + ε) (valid up to necking)Concrete short-term modulus (IS 456:2000) Ec = 5000 √fck (N/mm², fck in N/mm²)Modular ratio (short term) m = Es/Ec, with Es = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²Stress block: C = 0.36 fck b xu at 0.42 xu from the compression face (b, xu in mm, C in N)
- Curves are for slow (quasi-static) loading at room temperature; fast loading raises strength, fire lowers it, and sustained load causes creep in concrete.
- Engineering stress and strain use the original dimensions; true values differ only at large plastic strains.
- The idealised design curves are simplifications for calculating strength; they are not the measured curve of any particular batch.
- Concrete tensile strength is ignored in limit state flexural design; it still matters for cracking and deflection checks.
- The secant modulus of concrete depends on aggregate type, age and stress level; code formulas are estimates that measured values can differ from.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- IS 456:2000 cl. 6.2.3.1 gives the short-term static modulus of concrete as Ec = 5000 √fck, with fck the characteristic cube strength in N/mm².
- IS 456:2000 cl. 5.6.3 takes the modulus of elasticity of reinforcing steel as Es = 200 kN/mm².
- IS 456:2000 cl. 38.1 sets the assumptions for flexure at the limit state of collapse, including a maximum compressive strain of 0.0035 in bending and idealised design stress-strain curves for concrete and for steel; the stress block derived above follows from them.
- IS 1786:2008 covers high-strength deformed bars by grade (Fe 415, Fe 500, Fe 550, Fe 600 and their D and S variants), the grade number being the minimum 0.2 % proof stress or yield stress in N/mm²; IS 2062:2011 covers hot rolled structural steel grades such as E250 and E350, named by minimum yield stress.
- Side by side: EN 1992-1-1 cl. 3.1.3 gives a mean secant modulus Ecm = 22(fcm/10)^0.3 GPa from mean cylinder strength fcm = fck + 8 N/mm²; ACI 318-19 §19.2.2 gives Ec = 4700 √f′c N/mm² from cylinder strength. They use different strength measures (cylinder, not cube), so values are not directly comparable and are not ranked here.
Worked examples
Problem. A mild steel specimen of 12 mm diameter and 60 mm gauge length gives a yield load of 28.3 kN and a maximum load of 46.5 kN. After fracture the gauge length is 75.6 mm and the neck diameter 7.8 mm. Find the yield stress, ultimate stress, percentage elongation, percentage reduction of area and the ratio of ultimate to yield stress.
- A₀ = π × 12² / 4 = 113.10 mm².
- Yield stress = 28 300 / 113.10 = 250.2 N/mm².
- Ultimate stress = 46 500 / 113.10 = 411.2 N/mm².
- Elongation = (75.6 − 60) / 60 × 100 = 26.0 %.
- Reduction of area = 1 − (7.8/12)² = 1 − 0.4225 = 57.8 %.
- fu/fy = 411.2 / 250.2 = 1.64: a very ductile steel, typical of a 250 N/mm² grade.
Answer. fy = 250 N/mm²; fu = 411 N/mm²; elongation 26 %; reduction of area 57.8 %; fu/fy = 1.64
Problem. An M25 concrete column 3.2 m high carries a sustained service stress of 8 N/mm². Estimate its immediate elastic shortening using the IS 456 short-term modulus, and state why the long-term shortening will be larger.
- Ec = 5000 √25 = 25 000 N/mm².
- ε = σ/Ec = 8 / 25 000 = 3.2 × 10⁻⁴.
- Shortening = 3.2 × 10⁻⁴ × 3200 = 1.024 mm.
- Under sustained load creep adds strain over months, and drying shrinkage adds more, so the final shortening is typically a few times the elastic value; in tall buildings this differential shortening between columns and cores is checked.
Answer. Elastic shortening ≈ 1.02 mm (creep and shrinkage increase it later)
Problem. A rectangular beam 230 mm wide in M20 concrete has a neutral axis depth xu = 150 mm at the limit state of collapse. Using the idealised IS 456 concrete curve, find the depth of the parabolic part of the stress block, the total compressive force and its depth below the top.
- The strain is 0.002 at (0.002/0.0035) xu = 0.5714 × 150 = 85.7 mm above the neutral axis; the parabola occupies this lower 85.7 mm and the constant-stress part the top 64.3 mm.
- Average stress over xu (derivation): 0.446 × 17/21 fck = 0.361 fck ≈ 0.36 fck.
- C = 0.36 × 20 × 230 × 150 = 248 400 N = 248.4 kN.
- Depth of C below the top: 0.42 xu = 0.42 × 150 = 63 mm.
Answer. Parabolic part 85.7 mm; C = 248.4 kN at 63 mm below the top
Step-by-step procedure
- Measure the specimen (diameter or width and thickness) and mark the gauge length before testing.
- Load at the specified slow rate, recording load and extension; note the yield load (or the curve for proof stress) and the maximum load.
- Convert to engineering stress and strain using the original area and gauge length.
- Find E from the straight part, fy (or the 0.2 % proof stress by the offset line) and fu.
- After fracture, fit the pieces together and measure final gauge length and neck diameter; compute elongation and reduction of area.
- For concrete, test cubes for strength; where stiffness matters (deflection, prestress, tall buildings), measure the modulus on cylinders with strain gauges rather than relying only on the formula.
Site notes
- Every lot of reinforcement should come with a mill test certificate; site sampling checks yield or proof stress, tensile strength, elongation and bend or rebend behaviour against the grade ordered.
- A bar that cracks on a bend test is brittle even if its strength is high; do not use it in seismic zones where ductility matters.
- Heating TMT bars to bend them destroys the tempered outer layer and lowers strength; bend cold, on a mandrel of the specified diameter.
- Concrete stiffness rises more slowly than strength in the first days; early striking of formwork is decided on strength, but deflection of slabs struck early is governed by the low early modulus and creep.
- Reading the 0.2 % proof stress at a total strain of 0.002 instead of drawing the offset line parallel to the elastic slope.
- Assuming concrete is linear up to its crushing strength; it is non-linear from about a third to a half of its strength.
- Using cube strength in a formula written for cylinder strength (or the reverse) when comparing codes.
- Treating the descending part of the engineering curve as weakening of the steel; it is the neck reducing the area.
- Confusing the short-term modular ratio Es/Ec with the long-term ratio that allows for creep.
Concrete Ec = 5000 √fck gives about 22 to 32 GPa for M20 to M40, so the short-term modular ratio Es/Ec is about 6 to 9; steel is roughly 7 to 9 times stiffer than ordinary concrete.
Summary
- Mild steel: elastic line, yield plateau, strain hardening, ultimate, necking, fracture.
- HYSD bars: no sharp yield, so 0.2 % proof stress; ductility from elongation, reduction of area and fu/fy.
- Concrete: non-linear, peak near 0.002 strain, crushing near 0.0035 in bending; weak in tension.
- IS 456: Ec = 5000 √fck, Es = 200 kN/mm²; stress block 0.36 fck b xu at 0.42 xu.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A deformed bar has a 0.2 % proof stress of 500 N/mm² and E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². What is the total strain at the proof stress?
ε = 0.002 + 500 / 200 000 = 0.0045.
2Find the IS 456 short-term modulus of M30 concrete.
Ec = 5000 √30 = 27 386 N/mm² ≈ 27.4 GPa.
3At an engineering strain of 0.15 a steel specimen carries an engineering stress of 400 N/mm² (before necking). Find the true stress and true strain.
σ_t = 400 × 1.15 = 460 N/mm²; ε_t = ln 1.15 = 0.140.
4Why is the compression curve of concrete non-linear from low stress?
Microcracks at the paste-aggregate interface start growing at moderate stress and multiply as load rises, so strain grows faster than stress.
5A 10 mm specimen with 50 mm gauge length measures 61 mm after fracture. Find the percentage elongation.
(61 − 50) / 50 × 100 = 22 %.
6Find the short-term modular ratio for M25 concrete with Es = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm².
Ec = 25 000 N/mm²; m = 200 000 / 25 000 = 8.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
- A. M. Neville, Properties of Concrete, Pearson, 5th edition, 2011.