Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 9 › Lesson 9.3

9.3 Eccentric loading and the secant formula

Strength of Materials Chapter 9: Columns and combined stresses Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Derive the deflected shape, the maximum deflection and the maximum bending moment of a pin-ended column loaded at an eccentricity e at both ends.
  • Derive and apply the secant formula σ_max = (P/A)[1 + (ec/r²) sec((L_e/2r)√(P/(EA)))] for the peak compressive stress.
  • Explain why stress in an eccentrically loaded slender column grows faster than the load, and find the load that first causes yield.

Theory

Real columns are rarely loaded exactly through their centroid. A beam framing into one side, a crane bracket, a bearing set slightly off line or a column that is not quite straight all make the load act at some eccentricity e. The load then produces a bending moment P e from the start, the column bends, and the bending moves the column axis further from the line of the load, which increases the moment again. Unlike the ideal Euler column, an eccentrically loaded column deflects at every load, and the deflection grows rapidly as P approaches the Euler load. Sign convention for this lesson: P is the magnitude of the compressive load, y is the deflection of the axis away from the line of the load, and stresses are reported with compression positive (a negative value means tension).

For a pin-ended column with equal eccentricities e at both ends, the moment at a section is P(e + y). Solving the bending equation gives a symmetric curve with the largest deflection at mid-height, δ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1], where k = √(P/(EI)). The largest moment, at mid-height, is M_max = P(e + δ) = P e sec(kL/2). The factor sec(kL/2) is the moment amplification: it is 1 at zero load and grows without limit as kL/2 approaches π/2, that is as P approaches the Euler load π²EI/L².

Peδ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1]M max = P(e + δ)σ max (compression)σ min, tension if negativeIndiacon original
Figure 9.3: Eccentrically loaded pin-ended column: the deflection δ adds to the eccentricity e, so the mid-height moment is P e sec(kL/2) and the peak stress follows the secant formula. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Adding the direct stress P/A to the bending stress M_max c/I at the most compressed fibre, at distance c from the neutral axis, and writing I = Ar², gives the secant formula σ_max = (P/A)[1 + (ec/r²) sec((L/2r)√(P/(EA)))]. The group ec/r² is the eccentricity ratio. For a short column the secant term is close to 1 and the formula becomes the combined-stress result of lesson 9.4. For a slender column the secant term makes σ_max a non-linear function of P: doubling the load can more than triple the peak stress.

Because σ_max is not proportional to P, a factor of safety cannot be applied to the stress. The safe approach is to find the load P_y that makes σ_max equal to the yield stress and then divide that load by the factor of safety. The secant formula also explains code practice: an initially crooked column behaves much like a straight column with an equivalent eccentricity, and buckling curves for real columns can be built by choosing that eccentricity from tests. For other end conditions the formula is used with the effective length L_e in place of L.

Derivation

  1. Pin-ended column of length L, load P at eccentricity e at both ends, y measured from the original straight axis towards the side away from the load line. Moment at a section M = −P(e + y), so EI y″ + P y = −P e; with k² = P/(EI): y″ + k² y = −k² e.
  2. General solution: y = A sin kx + B cos kx − e. Boundary conditions y(0) = 0 gives B = e; y(L) = 0 gives A sin kL + e cos kL − e = 0, so A = e(1 − cos kL)/sin kL = e tan(kL/2).
  3. So y = e[tan(kL/2) sin kx + cos kx − 1] = e[cos(k(x − L/2))/cos(kL/2) − 1], symmetric about mid-height.
  4. Maximum deflection at x = L/2: δ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1].
  5. Maximum moment M_max = P(e + δ) = P e sec(kL/2); with kL/2 = (π/2)√(P/P_e), the amplification sec(kL/2) → ∞ as P → P_e.
  6. Peak compressive stress σ_max = P/A + M_max c/I = (P/A)[1 + (ec/r²) sec(kL/2)], and kL/2 = (L/2)√(P/(EI)) = (L/(2r))√(P/(EA)): the secant formula. The least stress at mid-height is (P/A)[1 − (ec/r²) sec(kL/2)], tension if negative.
  7. First yield: set σ_max = f_y and solve the transcendental equation for P_y numerically; the safe load is P_y divided by the factor of safety.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • k = √(P/(EI)); kL/2 = (L/(2r))√(P/(EA)) = (π/2)√(P/P_e)
  • Deflected shape y = e[cos(k(x − L/2))/cos(kL/2) − 1]
  • Mid-height deflection δ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1]
  • Maximum moment M_max = P e sec(kL/2)
  • Secant formula σ_max = (P/A)[1 + (ec/r²) sec((L_e/(2r))√(P/(EA)))]
  • Short column (sec → 1): σ = (P/A)(1 ± ec/r²)
  • Units: P in N, e, c, r, L in mm, E and σ in N/mm², M in N mm
Assumptions and limits
  • Initially straight, prismatic column; load applied at the same eccentricity e at both ends, on the same side (single curvature), in a plane of symmetry.
  • Pin ends (for other ends use the effective length L_e in place of L as an approximation).
  • Linear elastic material up to first yield; small deflections (curvature y″).
  • Bending occurs about one principal axis; the column is braced against buckling about the other axis.
  • Limits: gives the load at first yield, not the collapse load, which is somewhat higher; unequal end eccentricities or double curvature need a different solution; local and torsional buckling are not covered.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • The secant formula is mechanics; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Columns carrying axial load with moment are designed in Indian, European and American practice with interaction checks between axial force and bending, in which the moment is amplified for slenderness (second-order effects) and the axial capacity comes from the buckling curve; the expressions and factors are set in each code and are not reproduced here.
  • Side by side, not ranked: all three practices recognise the moment amplification that the secant formula shows exactly for the ideal pin-ended case.

Worked examples

Example 1 (shed column with a crane bracket)

Problem. A pin-ended steel column of a shed is 5 m long, braced about its weak axis. About the axis of bending A = 6000 mm², I = 5.0 × 10⁷ mm⁴ and the extreme fibre is at c = 125 mm. A load of 400 kN acts at an eccentricity of 150 mm at both ends. E = 200 000 N/mm². Find the mid-height deflection, the maximum moment and the peak stresses.

  1. r² = I/A = 8333 mm² (r = 91.3 mm); ec/r² = 150 × 125/8333 = 2.25.
  2. k = √(400 000/(200 000 × 5 × 10⁷)) = 2.0 × 10⁻⁴ per mm; kL/2 = 2.0 × 10⁻⁴ × 2500 = 0.500; sec 0.5 = 1.1395.
  3. δ = 150 × (1.1395 − 1) = 20.9 mm; M_max = 400 × 0.150 × 1.1395 = 68.4 kN m (against P e = 60.0 kN m).
  4. σ_max = (400 000/6000)(1 + 2.25 × 1.1395) = 66.67 × 3.564 = 237.6 N/mm² (compression).
  5. σ_min = 66.67(1 − 2.564) = −104.3 N/mm², that is 104.3 N/mm² tension on the far face; ignoring the amplification would give 216.7 N/mm² peak compression, 9 per cent low.

Answer. δ = 20.9 mm, M_max = 68.4 kN m, σ_max = 237.6 N/mm² compression, σ_min = 104.3 N/mm² tension

Example 2 (load at first yield and the safe load)

Problem. For the column of Example 1, with yield stress 250 N/mm², find the load P_y at which the most compressed fibre first yields (same e = 150 mm), and the safe load with a factor of safety of 1.5 on that load.

  1. Solve (P/6000)[1 + 2.25 sec(2500√(P/(10¹³)))] = 250 numerically (trial values or a calculator solver).
  2. P = 400 kN gives 237.6 N/mm²; P = 420 kN gives 250.6 N/mm²; the root is P_y = 418.9 kN.
  3. Check: kL/2 = 0.5117, sec = 1.1469, σ_max = 69.82 × (1 + 2.25 × 1.1469) = 250.0 N/mm².
  4. Safe load = 418.9/1.5 = 279.3 kN.
  5. Applying a factor of 1.5 to the stress instead (250/1.5 = 166.7 N/mm²) would give a different load, because σ_max is not proportional to P; the factor belongs on the load.

Answer. P_y = 418.9 kN; safe load 279.3 kN

Example 3 (slab prop with an off-centre load)

Problem. A 2.5 m scaffold-tube prop (48.3 mm × 4.0 mm, A = 556.7 mm², I = 137 676 mm⁴, c = 24.15 mm, Euler load 43.5 kN) is pin-ended and carries 15 kN from a slab soffit through a head plate set 10 mm off centre. Find the peak stress, then the peak stress if the load doubles to 30 kN.

  1. r² = 137 676/556.7 = 247.3 mm²; ec/r² = 10 × 24.15/247.3 = 0.977.
  2. 15 kN: P/P_e = 0.345, kL/2 = (π/2)√0.345 = 0.923, sec = 1.656; δ = 10 × 0.656 = 6.6 mm; σ_max = (15 000/556.7)(1 + 0.977 × 1.656) = 26.94 × 2.618 = 70.5 N/mm².
  3. 30 kN: P/P_e = 0.690, kL/2 = 1.305, sec = 3.803; δ = 28.0 mm; σ_max = 53.89 × (1 + 0.977 × 3.803) = 254.0 N/mm², at yield.
  4. Doubling the load multiplied the peak stress by 3.6, because the deflection grew from 6.6 to 28.0 mm.
  5. Centre the head plates, keep props plumb and stay well below the Euler load; the extra moment from a small offset grows sharply near it.

Answer. 15 kN: σ_max = 70.5 N/mm², δ = 6.6 mm; 30 kN: σ_max = 254.0 N/mm², δ = 28.0 mm (3.6 times the stress for twice the load)

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find A, I, r and c about the axis of bending, the effective length, and the eccentricity e.
  2. Compute the Euler load P_e and check P < P_e.
  3. Compute kL/2 = (L_e/(2r))√(P/(EA)) and sec(kL/2).
  4. Find δ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1], M_max = P e sec(kL/2) and σ_max, σ_min from the secant formula.
  5. For design, solve σ_max = f_y for P_y and divide the load by the factor of safety; check the other axis for buckling as in lesson 9.1.

Site notes

  • Check bearing and bracket positions against the drawings; a load moved 50 mm off line on a slender column can raise its peak stress far more than in proportion.
  • Props, shores and temporary columns should be loaded through centred head plates and kept plumb; a prop leaning out of plumb carries its load at an eccentricity that grows along its height.
  • Steel columns delivered bent or damaged in handling behave as eccentrically loaded columns; measure their bow before erection.
  • When a column visibly bows under load, it is close to its limit: unload it and add bracing or props before investigating.
Common mistakes
  • Using sec of an angle in degrees instead of radians.
  • Applying the factor of safety to the stress, which is unsafe because σ_max grows faster than P.
  • Using the short-column formula (P/A)(1 + ec/r²) for a slender column, missing the amplification.
  • Using r about the wrong axis: the secant formula uses r and c about the axis of bending, while buckling about the other axis must be checked separately.
  • Forgetting that the far face may go into tension, which matters for brittle materials and connections.
Quick check

Moment amplification sec((π/2)√(P/P_e)) is 1.41 at a quarter of the Euler load and 2.25 at half of it, so keep eccentrically loaded slender columns well below P_e.

Summary

  • Eccentric load bends a column from the start; deflection grows quickly as P → P_e.
  • δ = e[sec(kL/2) − 1], M_max = P e sec(kL/2), kL/2 = (π/2)√(P/P_e).
  • Secant formula: σ_max = (P/A)[1 + (ec/r²) sec((L_e/2r)√(P/(EA)))].
  • Stress is not proportional to load; apply the factor of safety to the load at first yield.
  • Short columns reduce to (P/A)(1 ± ec/r²), the subject of lesson 9.4.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A pin-ended column 3 m long has A = 4000 mm², I = 2.0 × 10⁷ mm⁴ and c = 100 mm; it carries 300 kN at 50 mm eccentricity. E = 200 000 N/mm². Find sec(kL/2), the mid-height deflection and σ_max.

kL/2 = 1500√(300 000/(4 × 10¹²)) = 0.411, sec = 1.091; δ = 50 × 0.091 = 4.5 mm; r² = 5000 mm², ec/r² = 1.0; σ_max = 75(1 + 1.0 × 1.091) = 156.8 N/mm².

2What is the moment amplification factor when P = 0.25 P_e?

kL/2 = (π/2)√0.25 = π/4; sec(π/4) = 1.414.

3What happens to the deflection of an eccentrically loaded pin-ended column as P approaches the Euler load?

sec(kL/2) → ∞ as kL/2 → π/2, so the deflection and moment grow without limit.

4A short concrete pedestal 400 mm × 400 mm carries 320 kN at 40 mm eccentricity about one axis. Find the extreme stresses (amplification negligible).

P/A = 2.0 N/mm²; ec/r² = 6e/d = 0.6; σ = 2.0 × 1.6 = 3.2 and 2.0 × 0.4 = 0.8 N/mm², both compression.

5Why is the safe load found by dividing P_y by the factor of safety rather than by limiting σ_max to f_y divided by the factor?

Because σ_max rises faster than P; limiting the stress would give a different and inconsistent margin against first yield, while factoring the load gives the stated margin.

6A column has P/P_e = 0.5. By what factor is the mid-height moment larger than P e?

kL/2 = (π/2)√0.5 = 1.111; sec 1.111 = 2.25, so M_max = 2.25 P e.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.