9.2 Rankine-Gordon formula
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why Euler's formula overestimates the strength of short and intermediate columns, and how the Rankine-Gordon formula blends crushing and buckling.
- Derive the Rankine-Gordon formula from 1/P = 1/P_c + 1/P_e and the theoretical Rankine constant a = σ_c/(π²E).
- Use the formula to find the load-carrying capacity of steel and cast-iron columns over the full range of slenderness, with a factor of safety.
Theory
Euler's load is correct only for long, slender columns in the elastic range. As the slenderness ratio λ falls, π²E/λ² grows without limit, and for a very short column it predicts loads far above the crushing load σ_c A, which is impossible. A very short column fails by crushing or yielding, a very long one by elastic buckling, and columns in between fail by a mixture of the two, at loads lower than either limit alone because the material starts to yield while the column is bending. Sign convention as in lesson 9.1: P is the magnitude of the compressive load.
Rankine proposed a simple empirical rule that joins the two limits smoothly: the reciprocal of the failure load is the sum of the reciprocals of the crushing load P_c = σ_c A and the Euler load P_e = π²EI/L_e². When the column is very short, P_e is huge, 1/P_e is negligible and the formula gives P_c. When it is very long, P_e is small compared with P_c and the formula gives P_e. In between, it gives less than both.
Rearranging gives the Rankine-Gordon formula P = σ_c A/(1 + aλ²), where λ = L_e/r and a = σ_c/(π²E) is the Rankine constant. With the theoretical constant, the Rankine stress at λ = π√(E/σ_c) is exactly half the crushing stress, the point where the crushing and Euler curves cross. Older textbooks and handbooks list Rankine constants fitted to tests on particular materials, which differ somewhat from the theoretical value; in this lesson the constant is always found from σ_c and E so that every number can be traced.
The formula is a teaching and checking tool. It shows clearly how strength falls from crushing to buckling as λ grows, and it gives reasonable estimates for simple steel, cast-iron and timber struts. Modern steel and concrete codes instead use buckling curves that account explicitly for initial crookedness, residual stresses and the shape of the section, but they rest on the same idea of a strength that moves from yield at low slenderness to the Euler load at high slenderness.
Derivation
- Assume the failure load P satisfies 1/P = 1/P_c + 1/P_e, with P_c = σ_c A (crushing load) and P_e = π²EI/L_e² (Euler load).
- Then P = P_c P_e/(P_c + P_e) = P_c/(1 + P_c/P_e).
- P_c/P_e = σ_c A L_e²/(π²E I) = (σ_c/(π²E)) × (L_e²/r²), using I = A r².
- With a = σ_c/(π²E) and λ = L_e/r: P = σ_c A/(1 + aλ²), and the Rankine stress is σ_R = P/A = σ_c/(1 + aλ²).
- Limits: λ → 0 gives P → σ_c A; λ → ∞ gives P → σ_c A/(aλ²) = π²E A/λ² = P_e, so both limits are recovered.
- Crossover: P_c = P_e when λ² = π²E/σ_c, that is λ_c = π√(E/σ_c), and there aλ_c² = 1, so P = P_c/2: the Rankine load is half of both.
- For every λ > 0, P is less than both P_c and P_e, because 1/P exceeds each of 1/P_c and 1/P_e.
1/P = 1/P_c + 1/P_e with P_c = σ_c A and P_e = π²EI/L_e²P = σ_c A/(1 + aλ²), Rankine stress σ_R = σ_c/(1 + aλ²)Theoretical Rankine constant a = σ_c/(π²E)λ = L_e/r, r = √(I/A)At λ_c = π√(E/σ_c): P = P_c/2 = P_e/2Safe (working) load = P/(factor of safety)Units: P in N, σ_c and E in N/mm², A in mm², λ dimensionless
- The column is straight and centrally loaded; the empirical formula is meant to allow loosely for small imperfections.
- σ_c is the crushing or yield stress of the material in compression, and E its elastic modulus.
- Effective length chosen from the end conditions as in lesson 9.1; uniform section.
- With the theoretical constant, the formula gives half the crushing load at λ = π√(E/σ_c), which is on the conservative side of tests for many materials but not fitted to any particular one.
- Limits: an empirical blend, not a derivation from mechanics; it does not model residual stresses, section shape or local buckling, and modern codes use buckling curves instead. Use it for understanding, checks and simple struts.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The Rankine-Gordon formula is a classical empirical relation; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Steel columns are designed in Indian, European and American practice with column buckling curves for different section shapes that blend yield and elastic buckling and allow for crookedness and residual stresses; the curve shapes and imperfection factors are set in each code and are not reproduced here.
- Side by side, not ranked: all three practices move from the squash load at low slenderness to the Euler load at high slenderness, which is the same idea the Rankine-Gordon formula expresses.
Worked examples
Problem. The scaffold tube of lesson 9.1 Example 1 (48.3 mm × 4.0 mm, A = 556.7 mm², I = 137 676 mm⁴, r = 15.73 mm) is a 2.5 m pin-ended prop. Take σ_c = 250 N/mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm². Find the Rankine-Gordon load and the safe load with a factor of safety of 2.
- a = σ_c/(π²E) = 250/(π² × 200 000) = 1/7896.
- λ = 2500/15.73 = 159.0; aλ² = 159.0²/7896 = 3.20.
- P_c = 250 × 556.7 = 139.2 kN; P_e = 43.5 kN (lesson 9.1).
- P = 139.2/(1 + 3.20) = 33.1 kN; check 1/(1/139.2 + 1/43.5) = 33.1 kN.
- Safe load = 33.1/2 = 16.6 kN, against 43.5 kN from Euler alone: the blend matters even for a fairly slender tube.
Answer. P = 33.1 kN (Euler 43.5 kN, crushing 139.2 kN); safe load 16.6 kN
Problem. For a steel with σ_c = 250 N/mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm², compare the Rankine stress with the smaller of the crushing stress and the Euler stress at λ = 50, 88.9 and 200.
- a = 1/7896 as in Example 1.
- λ = 50: σ_R = 250/(1 + 2500/7896) = 189.9 N/mm²; Euler 789.6 would exceed crushing, so the smaller limit is 250; ratio 0.76.
- λ = 88.9 (= π√(E/σ_c)): σ_R = 250/2 = 125.0 N/mm²; Euler gives 250, the same as crushing; ratio 0.50.
- λ = 200: σ_R = 250/(1 + 40 000/7896) = 41.2 N/mm²; Euler 49.3; ratio 0.84.
- The largest reduction is at the crossover slenderness, where real columns are most sensitive to imperfections, and Rankine approaches Euler for very slender columns.
Answer. σ_R = 189.9, 125.0 and 41.2 N/mm² at λ = 50, 88.9 and 200 (0.76, 0.50 and 0.84 of the smaller simple limit)
Problem. A hollow cast-iron column in an old station canopy has outside diameter 200 mm and inside diameter 160 mm, and is 4.5 m long with both ends taken as fixed (L_e = 0.5L). Tests on the metal give σ_c = 550 N/mm² and E = 100 000 N/mm². Find the Rankine-Gordon load and the safe load with a factor of safety of 4, as a first check before a detailed assessment.
- A = π(200² − 160²)/4 = 11 310 mm²; I = π(200⁴ − 160⁴)/64 = 46.37 × 10⁶ mm⁴; r = √(I/A) = 64.0 mm.
- L_e = 0.5 × 4500 = 2250 mm; λ = 2250/64.0 = 35.1.
- a = 550/(π² × 100 000) = 1/1794; aλ² = 35.1²/1794 = 0.688.
- P = 550 × 11 310/(1 + 0.688) = 6 220 kN/1.688 = 3 685 kN; P_e = π² × 100 000 × 46.37 × 10⁶/2250² = 9 040 kN, and 1/(1/6220 + 1/9040) = 3 685 kN agrees.
- Safe load = 3 685/4 = 921 kN. Cast iron is brittle and weak in tension, so the assessment must also look for cracks, blow-holes and any eccentric load from brackets or gutters.
Answer. P = 3 685 kN; safe load about 921 kN with a factor of safety of 4
Step-by-step procedure
- Find A, I and the least r of the section, and the effective length from the end conditions.
- Compute λ = L_e/r.
- Find the Rankine constant a = σ_c/(π²E) from the material's crushing (or yield) stress and E.
- Compute P = σ_c A/(1 + aλ²), and check it against 1/(1/P_c + 1/P_e).
- Divide by the factor of safety for the safe load, or use the result as a check on a code buckling-curve design.
Site notes
- Old cast-iron and wrought-iron columns in stations, mills and bridges are often reused; their strength must be checked from tests on the actual metal, not assumed.
- Shoring and backpropping of slabs use tubes and props whose usable load falls steeply with height; always read the load against the extended length.
- A column that is slightly bent from handling or impact has lost part of its capacity, most at intermediate slenderness; straighten or replace it.
- When a column is lengthened (raising a roof or adding a storey), its slenderness and therefore its capacity change; recheck it.
- Using Euler's formula for intermediate columns, where it is unsafe.
- Using the yield stress in P_c but a fitted Rankine constant for a different material, so the formula no longer meets the Euler limit.
- Forgetting to square λ in the denominator.
- Taking the effective length of a fixed-ended column as 0.5L in a real structure without checking how rigid the ends are.
- Applying the factor of safety twice, once to σ_c and again to P.
Rankine-Gordon gives half the crushing load at λ = π√(E/σ_c) and approaches Euler for slender columns; it is never above either limit.
Summary
- Short columns crush, long ones buckle, intermediate ones fail by both together.
- 1/P = 1/P_c + 1/P_e gives P = σ_c A/(1 + aλ²), a = σ_c/(π²E).
- The formula recovers P_c as λ → 0 and P_e as λ → ∞, and gives P_c/2 at the crossover.
- Fitted constants from tests differ from the theoretical one; state which is used.
- Codes use buckling curves on the same idea; Rankine is a useful check.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find the theoretical Rankine constant for a material with σ_c = 320 N/mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm².
a = 320/(π² × 200 000) = 1/6169.
2Show that the Rankine-Gordon formula gives the crushing load for very short columns and the Euler load for very long ones.
As λ → 0, aλ² → 0 and P → σ_c A. As λ → ∞, P → σ_c A/(aλ²) = π²E A/λ² = π²EI/L_e² = P_e.
3A pin-ended solid steel rod of 40 mm diameter is 2 m long; σ_c = 250 N/mm², E = 200 000 N/mm². Find P_c, P_e and the Rankine load.
A = 1256.6 mm², P_c = 314.2 kN; P_e = 62.0 kN; P = 1/(1/314.2 + 1/62.0) = 51.8 kN.
4At what slenderness ratio is the Rankine load half the crushing load, for σ_c = 250 N/mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm²?
λ = π√(E/σ_c) = 88.9.
5Find the Rankine stress at λ = 100 for σ_c = 250 N/mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm².
a = 1/7896; σ_R = 250/(1 + 10 000/7896) = 110.3 N/mm².
6Why do handbook Rankine constants for a material differ from σ_c/(π²E)?
They are fitted to column tests, which include crookedness, eccentricity and residual stresses; the theoretical constant only joins the two ideal limits.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.