3.3 Composite (flitched) beams
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain how two materials fixed together bend as one beam, with the same strain at the same level but different stresses.
- Use the modular ratio m = E₁/E₂ to build an equivalent (transformed) section and apply the bending equation to it.
- Find the moment of resistance of a flitched timber beam, decide which material governs, and size steel flitch plates for strengthening.
Theory
A flitched beam is a timber beam strengthened by steel plates, either bolted to both sides or set into a slot in the middle, so that timber and steel bend together. The idea goes back to older roofs and floors, and it is still used to strengthen existing timber joists without changing their depth. The same reasoning applies to any beam made of two materials joined so that they cannot slip: steel and concrete, steel and aluminium, or a timber beam with a steel strap.
Because the parts are bolted tightly, plane sections stay plane across the whole composite section, so the strain at any level is the same in both materials. The stresses are not the same, because each material follows its own Hooke's law. Steel is about twenty times stiffer than structural timber, so at the same strain it carries about twenty times the stress. At any level y, σ_steel = m σ_timber, where m = E_steel/E_timber is the modular ratio.
The neat way to handle this is the equivalent or transformed section. Replace the steel by timber that would carry the same force at the same strain: keep the depth of each strip of steel, but multiply its width by m. The transformed section is all timber, so the ordinary bending equation applies to it, with its neutral axis through the centroid of the transformed area and its I computed for the transformed shape. Stresses found from it are timber stresses; multiply by m wherever there is steel to get the true steel stress.
Each material has its own permissible stress, so one of them reaches its limit first. When the plates are as deep as the timber, the extreme fibres of both are at the same distance from the neutral axis, so the ratio of their stresses is m, and comparing m times the timber limit with the steel limit shows at once which governs. A design in which both reach their limits together is economical. The bolts or connectors must carry the longitudinal shear between the parts; without them the timber and steel would bend separately and the composite action would be lost.
Derivation
- Let the timber have modulus E_t and the steel E_s, and let m = E_s/E_t.
- Plane sections remain plane through the whole section: at distance y from the neutral axis the strain is ε = y/R in both materials.
- Stresses: σ_t = E_t y/R and σ_s = E_s y/R = m σ_t at the same level.
- Axial equilibrium: E_t ∫y dA_t + E_s ∫y dA_s = 0, that is ∫y dA_t + m ∫y dA_s = 0, so the neutral axis passes through the centroid of the section in which each steel area is multiplied by m.
- Moment: M = (E_t/R)(I_t + m I_s) = E_t I_eq/R, where I_eq = I_t + m I_s is the second moment of area of the transformed (all-timber) section about that neutral axis.
- Hence σ_t = M y/I_eq in timber and σ_s = m M y/I_eq in steel; the moment shared by the two parts is in the ratio I_t : m I_s.
- For a symmetric flitched beam with plates the same depth d as the timber: equivalent width b_eq = b_t + m b_s and M = σ_t b_eq d²/6, where σ_t is the timber stress at the extreme fibre.
m = E_s/E_t (modular ratio, dimensionless)σ_s = m σ_t at the same distance from the neutral axisTransformed section: steel width × m, depth unchangedI_eq = I_t + m I_s (mm⁴, in timber units)σ_t = M y/I_eq; σ_s = m M y/I_eq (N/mm²)Plates and timber of equal depth d: b_eq = b_t + m b_s; M = σ_t b_eq d²/6Governing material: steel governs if m × (timber limit) > steel limit, at equal extreme-fibre distancesUnits: E and σ in N/mm², b and d in mm, M in N·mm
- Both materials are linear elastic within their permissible stresses.
- Timber and steel are connected so that no slip occurs; plane sections remain plane through the whole composite section.
- The modular ratio is taken as constant; in practice the timber modulus varies with species, grade, moisture content and duration of load, so m is an approximation.
- Bending is about a principal axis of a section symmetric about the plane of loading (plates placed symmetrically).
- Shear transfer by the bolts, bearing of the bolts on timber, lateral stability of thin plates and long-term creep of timber are separate checks not covered by this calculation.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The transformed-section method is mechanics and is not fixed by any design code. Permissible stresses and moduli for timber depend on species and grade and are set by the timber design code in use; the values in this lesson are stated with each problem for illustration and are not code values.
- The same modular-ratio idea is used for working-stress design of reinforced concrete and for the elastic checks of steel-concrete composite beams.
- Side by side, not ranked: Eurocode 5 (timber), EN 1994-1-1 and AISC 360 (steel-concrete composite) all use transformed or equivalent sections for elastic stiffness and stresses, each with its own rules for long-term moduli and connectors.
Worked examples
Problem. A flitched beam has a timber section 150 mm wide × 300 mm deep with a steel plate 10 mm × 300 mm bolted to each side. E_s = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm², E_t = 1 × 10⁴ N/mm². Permissible stresses: timber 8 N/mm², steel 150 N/mm². Find the moment of resistance and the share carried by each material.
- m = 2 × 10⁵/1 × 10⁴ = 20.
- Equivalent timber width b_eq = 150 + 20 × 20 = 550 mm (both plates, 20 mm in total).
- If timber reaches 8 N/mm², the steel at the same depth would be 20 × 8 = 160 N/mm² > 150, so steel governs: σ_s = 150 N/mm² and σ_t = 150/20 = 7.5 N/mm².
- M = σ_t b_eq d²/6 = 7.5 × 550 × 300²/6 = 7.5 × 8.25 × 10⁶ = 6.188 × 10⁷ N·mm = 61.88 kN·m.
- Timber share = 7.5 × 150 × 300²/6 = 16.88 kN·m; steel share = 150 × 20 × 300²/6 = 45.00 kN·m (72.7 per cent); total 61.88 kN·m.
Answer. M = 61.88 kN·m, steel governs; timber 16.88 kN·m, steel 45.00 kN·m
Problem. Two timber pieces, each 100 mm wide × 300 mm deep, are bolted on either side of a steel plate 12 mm thick and 200 mm deep, with the centre of the plate at mid-depth of the timber. m = 20. Permissible stresses: timber 8 N/mm², steel 150 N/mm². Find the moment of resistance.
- The section is symmetric, so the neutral axis is at mid-depth; the total timber width is 2 × 100 = 200 mm.
- I_t = 200 × 300³/12 = 4.5 × 10⁸ mm⁴; I_s = 12 × 200³/12 = 8.0 × 10⁶ mm⁴; I_eq = I_t + m I_s = 4.5 × 10⁸ + 20 × 8.0 × 10⁶ = 6.1 × 10⁸ mm⁴.
- Try timber at its limit: σ_t = 8 N/mm² at y = 150 mm. Steel extreme fibre is at y = 100 mm: σ_s = m × 8 × 100/150 = 106.7 N/mm² < 150, so timber governs.
- M = σ_t I_eq/y = 8 × 6.1 × 10⁸/150 = 3.253 × 10⁷ N·mm = 32.53 kN·m.
Answer. M = 32.53 kN·m, timber governs (steel at 106.7 N/mm²)
Problem. An old timber floor joist 100 mm × 250 mm spans 4 m simply supported and must carry more load. Steel plates 6 mm × 250 mm are to be bolted to both sides. Take m = 20, timber limit 7 N/mm² and steel limit 140 N/mm². Find the safe uniform load before and after strengthening.
- Before: M = 7 × 100 × 250²/6 = 7.292 × 10⁶ N·mm = 7.29 kN·m; w = 8M/L² = 8 × 7.29/16 = 3.65 kN/m.
- After: b_eq = 100 + 20 × 12 = 340 mm. Timber at 7 N/mm² puts the steel at 20 × 7 = 140 N/mm², exactly its limit, so both govern together (a balanced design).
- M = 7 × 340 × 250²/6 = 2.479 × 10⁷ N·mm = 24.79 kN·m; w = 8 × 24.79/16 = 12.40 kN/m.
- Gain: 12.40/3.65 = 3.4 times. The bolts must be designed for the longitudinal shear, and deflection, bearing at the supports and the condition of the old timber must be checked.
Answer. Safe load rises from 3.65 kN/m to 12.40 kN/m (3.4 times); balanced design
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the modular ratio m = E_s/E_t for the materials in use.
- Draw the transformed section: multiply the width of each steel part by m, keeping depths and positions.
- Locate the neutral axis at the centroid of the transformed section and compute I_eq.
- At each material's extreme fibre, find the stress that would occur if the other material were at its limit, and decide which governs.
- Compute M = σ_t I_eq/y for timber at the governing level (or σ_s I_eq/(m y) for steel).
- Check bolt spacing for longitudinal shear, bearing, deflection with I_eq and long-term effects in the timber.
Site notes
- Drill bolt holes through timber and plates together, and fit bolts snugly; loose bolts let the parts slip and much of the composite strength is lost.
- Old timber can hide rot or insect damage where the plates are to be fixed; inspect and probe before strengthening, and treat or replace weak timber.
- Plates must bear on the supports or be connected to them; a plate that stops short of the support carries no reaction and may pull out its end bolts.
- Paint or galvanise the steel and keep moisture away from the joint; corrosion and wet timber shorten the life of a flitched beam.
- Multiplying the steel depth by m instead of its width, which changes I wrongly.
- Using one stress limit for both materials instead of checking each.
- Forgetting to convert timber stresses from the transformed section back to steel stresses by multiplying by m.
- Placing the neutral axis at mid-depth of an unsymmetric composite section instead of at the centroid of the transformed section.
- Ignoring the bolts: without shear connection the parts bend separately and the beam carries far less.
With plates the full depth of the timber, if m times the timber limit is close to the steel limit the design is balanced; if it is far above, steel governs and the timber is under-used. With m = 20, as in the examples here, full-depth steel plates carry well over half of the moment.
Summary
- In a composite beam the strain is the same at the same level in both materials; the stresses differ in the ratio of their moduli.
- Transform the stiffer material into the other by multiplying its width by m = E₁/E₂.
- Apply M/I = σ/y to the transformed section; multiply by m to get the stress in the transformed material.
- Check which material reaches its limit first; a balanced section reaches both together.
- Composite action depends on connectors that prevent slip.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1What is the modular ratio of steel (E = 2 × 10⁵ N/mm²) to timber (E = 1.2 × 10⁴ N/mm²), and what does it mean physically?
m = 2 × 10⁵/1.2 × 10⁴ = 16.7. At the same strain, the steel carries 16.7 times the stress of the timber.
2A timber beam 120 mm × 240 mm has steel plates 8 mm × 240 mm bolted to both sides. With m = 20, timber limit 8 N/mm² and steel limit 150 N/mm², find the moment of resistance.
b_eq = 120 + 20 × 16 = 440 mm. Timber at 8 would put steel at 160 > 150, so steel governs and σ_t = 7.5 N/mm². M = 7.5 × 440 × 240²/6 = 3.168 × 10⁷ N·mm = 31.68 kN·m.
3In a flitched beam with m = 20, the timber stress at a level 100 mm above the neutral axis is 6 N/mm². What is the steel stress at the same level?
σ_s = 20 × 6 = 120 N/mm² (same strain, stress in proportion to E).
4In Example 1 of this lesson, what fraction of the total moment is carried by the steel plates?
45.00/61.88 = 0.727, about 73 per cent.
5A timber beam 100 mm wide × 200 mm deep has a steel plate 100 mm wide × 10 mm thick fixed under its bottom face, with m = 20. Find the position of the neutral axis and I of the transformed section in timber units.
Transformed plate width = 2000 mm, area 20 000 mm² at 5 mm above the bottom of the plate; timber 20 000 mm² at 110 mm. ȳ = (20 000 × 110 + 20 000 × 5)/40 000 = 57.5 mm above the bottom of the plate. I = 100 × 200³/12 + 20 000 × 52.5² + 2000 × 10³/12 + 20 000 × 52.5² = 1.771 × 10⁸ mm⁴.
6Why are bolts essential in a flitched beam, and what force do they carry?
They make the timber and steel bend as one section by preventing slip along the interface. They carry the longitudinal (horizontal) shear between the parts, which is largest near the supports where the shear force is largest.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.