7.5 Theories of failure
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why a failure theory is needed to compare a two- or three-dimensional stress state with a strength measured in a simple tension test.
- State and apply the maximum principal stress, maximum principal strain, maximum shear stress, total strain energy and distortion energy theories, and know which suits ductile and which suits brittle materials.
- Use the equivalent-stress forms √(σ² + 4τ²) and √(σ² + 3τ²) for beam webs, welds and shafts under combined bending and torsion, and find the factor of safety or the size needed.
Theory
A tension test gives one number for the strength of a material: the yield stress f_y for a ductile steel or the tensile strength f_t for a brittle material such as cast iron or plain concrete. A real point in a structure is usually under two or three principal stresses at once, found with the methods of lessons 7.1 to 7.3. We cannot test every combination of stresses, so we need a rule that says which single quantity causes failure. That rule is a theory of failure. It picks a quantity (a stress, a strain or an energy), works out its value at failure in the simple tension test, and says the material fails in any stress state when that quantity reaches the same value. Sign convention as in this chapter: tension positive, principal stresses ordered σ₁ ≥ σ₂ ≥ σ₃.
The maximum principal stress theory (Rankine) says failure occurs when the largest principal stress reaches the tensile strength, or the most compressive one reaches the compressive strength. It ignores the other principal stresses. The maximum principal strain theory (Saint-Venant) says failure occurs when the largest principal strain, ε₁ = [σ₁ − ν(σ₂ + σ₃)]/E, reaches the strain at failure in tension, f/E. These two theories describe brittle materials reasonably well, because brittle materials break by separation across the plane of greatest tension.
Ductile metals such as structural steel yield by slip along planes of high shear, so the shear stress or the energy of distortion is the right quantity. The maximum shear stress theory (Tresca, also called Guest's theory) says yielding begins when the greatest shear stress, (σ_max − σ_min)/2 taken over all three principal stresses, reaches f_y/2. The total strain energy theory (Haigh) uses the whole elastic energy stored per unit volume. The distortion energy theory (von Mises, or Huber–von Mises–Hencky) uses only the part of that energy that changes the shape of the element, not its volume, and says yielding begins when it reaches its value at yield in the tension test.
Tests on thin steel tubes under combined tension and torsion fall close to the von Mises prediction, with Tresca slightly on the safe side by up to about 15 per cent. In the σ₁–σ₂ plane (plane stress) the Tresca limit is a hexagon and the von Mises limit is an ellipse through the corners of the hexagon. A hydrostatic stress, equal in all directions, causes no distortion and no shear, so neither theory predicts yielding under it, which matches the behaviour of metals. Rankine's theory is unsafe for ductile materials in shear: it predicts yield in pure shear at τ = f_y, while steel actually yields at about 0.58 f_y. For soils, rock and concrete under compression, a friction-based criterion such as Mohr–Coulomb is used instead (soil and rock mechanics chapters).
Derivation
- Rankine: failure when σ₁ = f_t (or |σ₃| = f_c in compression). In pure shear σ₁ = τ, σ₂ = −τ, so the shear strength predicted is τ_y = f_y.
- Saint-Venant: ε₁ = [σ₁ − ν(σ₂ + σ₃)]/E; in the tension test at failure ε = f_y/E, so the condition is σ₁ − ν(σ₂ + σ₃) = f_y. Pure shear: τ(1 + ν) = f_y, so τ_y = f_y/(1 + ν).
- Tresca: the greatest shear stress is (σ₁ − σ₃)/2 with σ₁ ≥ σ₂ ≥ σ₃; in the tension test at yield it is f_y/2, so σ₁ − σ₃ = f_y. In plane stress σ₃ = 0 must be included, so for σ₁ and σ₂ of the same sign the condition is the larger of |σ₁| and |σ₂| = f_y, and for opposite signs it is |σ₁ − σ₂| = f_y. Pure shear: τ_y = f_y/2.
- Total strain energy per unit volume for a linear elastic material: U = [σ₁² + σ₂² + σ₃² − 2ν(σ₁σ₂ + σ₂σ₃ + σ₃σ₁)]/(2E). In the tension test U = f_y²/(2E), giving Haigh's condition σ₁² + σ₂² + σ₃² − 2ν(σ₁σ₂ + σ₂σ₃ + σ₃σ₁) = f_y². Pure shear: 2τ²(1 + ν) = f_y², τ_y = f_y/√[2(1 + ν)].
- Split U into a volume-change part U_v = (1 − 2ν)(σ₁ + σ₂ + σ₃)²/(6E) and a distortion part U_d = (1 + ν)[(σ₁ − σ₂)² + (σ₂ − σ₃)² + (σ₃ − σ₁)²]/(6E); their sum is U. In the tension test U_d = (1 + ν)f_y²/(3E), so von Mises' condition is ½[(σ₁ − σ₂)² + (σ₂ − σ₃)² + (σ₃ − σ₁)²] = f_y². Pure shear: 3τ² = f_y², τ_y = f_y/√3 = 0.577 f_y.
- Plane stress (σ₃ = 0): von Mises becomes σ₁² − σ₁σ₂ + σ₂² = f_y². For a beam or shaft element with normal stress σ and shear stress τ, σ₁,₂ = σ/2 ± √(σ²/4 + τ²), so σ₁σ₂ = −τ² and σ₁ + σ₂ = σ. Then von Mises gives σ_eq = √(σ² + 3τ²) and Tresca gives σ₁ − σ₂ = √(σ² + 4τ²).
- For a solid circular shaft with bending moment M and torque T, σ = 32M/(πd³) and τ = 16T/(πd³). Tresca then gives (32/πd³)√(M² + T²) and von Mises gives (32/πd³)√(M² + 0.75T²): the equivalent bending moments of shaft design.
Rankine: σ₁ ≤ f_t (and |σ₃| ≤ f_c)Saint-Venant: σ₁ − ν(σ₂ + σ₃) ≤ f_yTresca: σ₁ − σ₃ ≤ f_y (σ₁ ≥ σ₂ ≥ σ₃); beam element √(σ² + 4τ²) ≤ f_y; shaft M_e = √(M² + T²)Haigh: σ₁² + σ₂² + σ₃² − 2ν(σ₁σ₂ + σ₂σ₃ + σ₃σ₁) ≤ f_y²von Mises: ½[(σ₁ − σ₂)² + (σ₂ − σ₃)² + (σ₃ − σ₁)²] ≤ f_y²; plane stress σ₁² − σ₁σ₂ + σ₂² ≤ f_y²; beam element √(σ² + 3τ²) ≤ f_y; shaft M_e = √(M² + 0.75T²)Shear yield predicted: Rankine f_y; Saint-Venant f_y/(1 + ν); Tresca 0.5 f_y; Haigh f_y/√[2(1 + ν)]; von Mises 0.577 f_yFactor of safety = f_y/σ_eq. Units: stresses in N/mm² (MPa); M and T in N·mm with d in mm
- The material is homogeneous and isotropic, with the same yield stress in tension and compression for the ductile theories.
- The simple tension test represents the failure of the material; f_y or f_t is known from tests.
- Linear elastic behaviour up to the onset of yield (needed for the strain and energy theories).
- Static loading at normal temperature; fatigue, impact, creep and very low temperatures need separate criteria.
- Limits: Tresca and von Mises predict the onset of yield, not collapse; brittle materials with different tensile and compressive strengths, and soils, rock and concrete in compression, need Mohr–Coulomb or similar criteria; stress concentrations and cracks need fracture mechanics.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Theories of failure are mechanics; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Steel design in Indian, European and American practice checks members, webs and welds under combined normal and shear stress with equivalent-stress or interaction checks that rest on the distortion energy idea; the exact expressions, partial safety factors and limits are those of the code used for the project and are not reproduced here.
- Concrete, soil and rock design in all three practices use friction-based strength criteria rather than the metal yield theories.
- Side by side, not ranked: Indian, European and American practice use the same mechanics described in this lesson.
Worked examples
Problem. An element in the web of a steel plate girder carries a bending stress σ = 120 N/mm² and a shear stress τ = 60 N/mm². The steel has f_y = 250 N/mm² and ν = 0.3. Find the factor of safety against yield by each of the five theories.
- Principal stresses: σ₁,₂ = 60 ± √(60² + 60²) = 60 ± 84.85, so σ₁ = 144.85 and σ₂ = −24.85 N/mm²; σ₃ = 0.
- Rankine: σ_eq = 144.85, FoS = 250/144.85 = 1.73. Saint-Venant: 144.85 + 0.3 × 24.85 = 152.31, FoS = 1.64.
- Tresca: σ₁ − σ₂ = 169.71 = √(120² + 4 × 60²), FoS = 250/169.71 = 1.47.
- Haigh: σ₁² + σ₂² − 2ν σ₁σ₂ = 21 600 + 0.6 × 3600 = 23 760, σ_eq = 154.14, FoS = 1.62.
- von Mises: σ_eq = √(120² + 3 × 60²) = √25 200 = 158.75, FoS = 250/158.75 = 1.57. For ductile steel the von Mises value is the realistic one; Tresca is the more cautious of the two.
Answer. FoS: Rankine 1.73, Saint-Venant 1.64, Tresca 1.47, Haigh 1.62, von Mises 1.57
Problem. The wall of a steel water pressure pipe carries a hoop stress of 150 N/mm² and a longitudinal stress of 75 N/mm², both tensile; the radial stress at the outer surface is zero. f_y = 250 N/mm². Find the factor of safety by Tresca and by von Mises, and show the error if σ₃ is ignored.
- Principal stresses: σ₁ = 150, σ₂ = 75, σ₃ = 0 N/mm².
- Tresca: greatest difference is σ₁ − σ₃ = 150 N/mm², so FoS = 250/150 = 1.67.
- If only the in-plane difference σ₁ − σ₂ = 75 is used, the FoS would wrongly come out as 3.33, twice the true value.
- von Mises: σ_eq = √(150² − 150 × 75 + 75²) = √16 875 = 129.90 N/mm², FoS = 250/129.90 = 1.92.
- Both stresses are tensile, so the element is in the corner region of the hexagon where Tresca and von Mises differ most.
Answer. Tresca FoS 1.67 (not 3.33); von Mises FoS 1.92
Problem. A solid steel shaft of a winch on a bridge erection gantry carries a bending moment M = 3 kN·m and a torque T = 4 kN·m. f_y = 250 N/mm² and a factor of safety of 2 is required. Find the diameter by Tresca and by von Mises.
- Allowable equivalent stress = 250/2 = 125 N/mm².
- Tresca: M_e = √(3² + 4²) = 5 kN·m; d³ = 32 × 5 × 10⁶/(π × 125) = 407 437 mm³, d = 74.1 mm.
- von Mises: M_e = √(3² + 0.75 × 4²) = √21 = 4.583 kN·m; d³ = 32 × 4.583 × 10⁶/(π × 125) = 373 424 mm³, d = 72.0 mm.
- Check at d = 75 mm: σ = 32 × 3 × 10⁶/(π × 75³) = 72.4 N/mm², τ = 16 × 4 × 10⁶/(π × 75³) = 48.3 N/mm², √(σ² + 3τ²) = 110.6 N/mm² < 125.
- A 75 mm shaft satisfies both theories; keyways and shoulders need stress concentration and fatigue checks in addition.
Answer. Tresca d = 74.1 mm, von Mises d = 72.0 mm; adopt 75 mm
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the stresses at the critical point from the loads (bending, axial, shear, torsion, pressure).
- Find the three principal stresses, including σ₃ = 0 at a free surface, and order them σ₁ ≥ σ₂ ≥ σ₃.
- Choose the theory: von Mises (or Tresca for a cautious check) for ductile metals; Rankine or Mohr–Coulomb for brittle materials.
- Compute the equivalent stress for the chosen theory.
- Compare with f_y or f_t: factor of safety = strength/equivalent stress, or size the member for the required factor of safety.
Site notes
- Plate girder webs near supports and over piers carry high bending and shear together; welds and splices there are checked for the combined equivalent stress, not for each stress separately.
- Winch, crane and pump shafts on site are bent by rope or belt pull and twisted by the drive; worn keyways and sharp shoulders, not the plain shaft, are where they crack.
- Cast iron fittings and old cast iron water mains are brittle: they break suddenly across the plane of greatest tension, so ground movement and water hammer that add bending are dangerous for them.
- Yield at one point of a ductile steel member is not collapse; codes use the onset-of-yield theories for elastic checks and plastic methods for the ultimate state.
- Using the maximum principal stress theory for ductile steel in shear, which overestimates the shear strength by about 70 per cent.
- Leaving out σ₃ = 0 in Tresca when σ₁ and σ₂ have the same sign, which can double the predicted factor of safety.
- Writing √(σ² + 4τ²) for von Mises (it is √(σ² + 3τ²)) or mixing up the two equivalent moments.
- Using the metal yield theories for concrete, soil or rock in compression, where friction and confinement govern.
- Comparing an equivalent stress with the ultimate strength of a ductile metal when the check is for yield.
For ductile steel, von Mises: σ_eq = √(σ² + 3τ²) and shear yields at about 0.58 f_y; Tresca uses √(σ² + 4τ²) and 0.5 f_y and is safe by up to about 15 per cent.
Summary
- A failure theory turns a multiaxial stress state into one equivalent stress that can be compared with the simple tension test.
- Rankine and Saint-Venant suit brittle materials; Tresca and von Mises suit ductile metals.
- Tresca: σ₁ − σ₃ ≤ f_y; von Mises: ½[(σ₁ − σ₂)² + (σ₂ − σ₃)² + (σ₃ − σ₁)²] ≤ f_y².
- Beam and shaft forms: √(σ² + 4τ²) and √(σ² + 3τ²); equivalent moments √(M² + T²) and √(M² + 0.75T²).
- Hydrostatic stress causes no yield in Tresca or von Mises; σ₃ = 0 at a free surface must not be forgotten.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A steel element is in pure shear τ = 100 N/mm²; f_y = 250 N/mm². Find the factor of safety by Tresca and by von Mises.
Tresca: shear yield 125 N/mm², FoS = 1.25. von Mises: shear yield 250/√3 = 144.3 N/mm², FoS = 1.44.
2σ₁ = 200 N/mm², σ₂ = 100 N/mm², σ₃ = 0; f_y = 250 N/mm². Find the equivalent stress and FoS by Tresca and von Mises.
Tresca: σ₁ − σ₃ = 200, FoS = 1.25. von Mises: √(200² − 200 × 100 + 100²) = 173.2 N/mm², FoS = 1.44.
3A grey cast iron fitting has σ = 30 N/mm² (bending tension) and τ = 40 N/mm². Tensile strength 150 N/mm². Find the FoS by the maximum principal stress theory.
σ₁ = 15 + √(15² + 40²) = 15 + 42.72 = 57.72 N/mm², FoS = 150/57.72 = 2.60.
4Why is the maximum principal stress theory unsafe for a ductile steel in pure shear?
In pure shear σ₁ = τ, so the theory predicts yield at τ = f_y, but steel yields at about 0.58 f_y because slip on planes of high shear, not tension, causes yielding.
5σ₁ = 100 N/mm², σ₂ = −100 N/mm², σ₃ = 0, ν = 0.3. Find the equivalent stress by Saint-Venant, Haigh, von Mises and Tresca.
Saint-Venant 100 + 30 = 130; Haigh √(10 000 + 10 000 + 0.6 × 10 000) = 161.2; von Mises √30 000 = 173.2; Tresca 200 N/mm².
6Show that a hydrostatic stress σ₁ = σ₂ = σ₃ = p causes no yielding by von Mises.
All three differences σ₁ − σ₂, σ₂ − σ₃ and σ₃ − σ₁ are zero, so the distortion energy is zero whatever p is; only the volume changes.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.