8.1 Thin cylinders and spheres
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Derive the hoop (circumferential) and longitudinal stresses in a thin cylinder and the membrane stress in a thin sphere under internal pressure.
- Size the wall of a pipe, penstock or spherical tank for a given pressure, allowable stress and joint efficiency.
- Find the changes in diameter, length and volume of a pressurised thin cylinder or sphere, as needed in pipeline hydrotests.
Theory
Pipes, penstocks, pressure tanks and spherical storage vessels hold fluid under pressure. The pressure pushes the wall outwards and the wall resists by tension. When the wall thickness t is small compared with the diameter d, usually t below about d/20, the tension can be taken as uniform through the thickness. Such a shell is a thin cylinder or thin sphere, and its stresses follow from simple free-body diagrams, with no need to know how the stress varies through the wall. Sign convention as in Chapter 7: tension positive.
Cut a cylinder of length L along its axis into two halves. The pressure p acting on the projected area d × L tries to split the halves apart, and two wall strips of area t × L resist. The resisting stress is the hoop or circumferential stress σ_c = pd/(2t). Now cut the cylinder across its axis. The pressure on the end cap, of area πd²/4, is resisted by the wall ring of area πd × t, giving the longitudinal stress σ_l = pd/(4t). The hoop stress is twice the longitudinal stress, which is why an over-pressurised pipe usually splits along its length.
A thin sphere has the same geometry in every direction. Any plane through the centre cuts it into two hemispheres, and the same balance as for the cylinder end gives σ = pd/(4t) in all directions in the wall. For the same diameter, pressure and allowable stress a sphere needs only half the wall thickness of a cylinder, which is why large pressurised gas stores are spherical. The radial stress in the wall varies from −p on the inside to zero (or atmospheric) on the outside; for thin shells it is small compared with σ_c and is neglected.
Plates are joined by welded or riveted seams that may be weaker than the solid plate. The ratio of seam strength to plate strength is the joint efficiency η. A longitudinal seam carries the hoop stress, so σ_c = pd/(2tη_l); a circumferential seam carries the longitudinal stress, so σ_l = pd/(4tη_c). The wall also strains. With E and ν from lesson 1.3, the hoop strain ε_c = (σ_c − ν σ_l)/E gives the increase in diameter, the longitudinal strain ε_l = (σ_l − ν σ_c)/E the increase in length, and the volumetric strain is ε_v = 2ε_c + ε_l. This tells us how much extra water must be pumped into a pipe during a pressure test just to fill its expansion.
Derivation
- Hoop stress: for a half cylinder of length L, the resultant of internal pressure normal to the cut plane is ∫ p (d/2) sin φ L dφ from 0 to π = p d L. Equilibrium with two wall strips: 2 σ_c t L = p d L, so σ_c = pd/(2t).
- Longitudinal stress: pressure on the end cap p × πd²/4 is resisted by σ_l × πd t (the wall ring, using d for the mean circumference of a thin wall), so σ_l = pd/(4t).
- Sphere: p × πd²/4 = σ × πd t, so σ = pd/(4t) in every direction in the wall.
- Joint efficiency: σ_c = pd/(2tη_l) for the longitudinal seam and σ_l = pd/(4tη_c) for the circumferential seam; the safe pressure is the smaller of p = 2tση_l/d and p = 4tση_c/d.
- Strains of a closed cylinder (σ_l = σ_c/2): ε_c = (σ_c − νσ_l)/E = pd(2 − ν)/(4tE); ε_l = (σ_l − νσ_c)/E = pd(1 − 2ν)/(4tE); volume V = πd²L/4 so δV/V = 2ε_c + ε_l = pd(5 − 4ν)/(4tE).
- Sphere: ε = (σ − νσ)/E = pd(1 − ν)/(4tE) in every direction, δV/V = 3ε = 3pd(1 − ν)/(4tE).
- Maximum shear in a cylinder wall: in-plane (σ_c − σ_l)/2 = pd/(8t); taking the radial stress σ₃ ≈ 0 at the outer face, the absolute maximum is σ_c/2 = pd/(4t).
Hoop stress σ_c = pd/(2t); with seam efficiency σ_c = pd/(2tη_l)Longitudinal stress σ_l = pd/(4t); with seam efficiency σ_l = pd/(4tη_c)Thin sphere σ = pd/(4t); required thickness t = pd/(4ση)Cylinder: δd/d = pd(2 − ν)/(4tE), δL/L = pd(1 − 2ν)/(4tE), δV/V = pd(5 − 4ν)/(4tE)Sphere: δV/V = 3pd(1 − ν)/(4tE)Pressure from head: p = ρ g h (1000 kg/m³ × 9.81 m/s² × h m, in N/m²; divide by 10⁶ for N/mm²)Units: p and σ in N/mm²; d and t in mm
- Wall thickness small compared with diameter, about t ≤ d/20, so the stress is uniform through the thickness.
- Radial stress neglected; ends closed so the longitudinal stress acts (for a pipe with free sliding joints and no end thrust, σ_l is set by the pipe restraint instead).
- Uniform internal pressure; the weight of the fluid, wind, soil load and supports are treated separately.
- Linear elastic, isotropic material for the strain results; seams accounted for by joint efficiency.
- Limits: thick walls need Lamé's theory (lesson 8.2); external pressure on thin shells causes buckling, which these stress formulas do not cover; local bending at end caps, supports, nozzles and stiffener rings needs separate checks.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Thin-shell membrane stresses are mechanics; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Penstocks, water mains and pressure vessels are designed in Indian, European and American practice to the pipeline, penstock or pressure vessel code named in the project specification; those codes set allowable stresses, joint efficiencies, corrosion allowances, surge pressures and minimum thicknesses, and these values are not reproduced here.
- Side by side, not ranked: all three practices start from the same hoop and longitudinal stress balance shown in this lesson.
Worked examples
Problem. A steel penstock of internal diameter 1.8 m carries water under a static head of 120 m at its lowest point. The allowable stress in the plate is 120 N/mm² and the longitudinal welded seam has an efficiency of 0.9. Find the plate thickness for the static pressure, and the stresses in the adopted plate.
- p = ρ g h = 1000 × 9.81 × 120 = 1 177 200 N/m² = 1.177 N/mm².
- t = pd/(2ση_l) = 1.177 × 1800/(2 × 120 × 0.9) = 2119/216 = 9.81 mm; adopt 10 mm (before any corrosion allowance and surge pressure from water hammer, which are added as the project code requires).
- Check thin: t/d = 10/1800 = 1/180, well below 1/20.
- Hoop stress at the seam = 1.177 × 1800/(2 × 10 × 0.9) = 117.7 N/mm² ≤ 120; in the plate away from the seam 105.9 N/mm².
- Longitudinal stress (closed by anchor blocks and valves) = 1.177 × 1800/(4 × 10) = 53.0 N/mm².
Answer. p = 1.177 N/mm², t = 9.81 mm, adopt 10 mm; σ_c = 117.7 N/mm² at the seam, σ_l = 53.0 N/mm²
Problem. A 6 m length of steel water main between closed test ends has internal diameter 1000 mm and wall 8 mm, and is tested at p = 1.0 N/mm². E = 200 000 N/mm², ν = 0.3. Find the stresses, the increase in diameter and length, and the extra water needed to fill the pipe's expansion.
- σ_c = 1.0 × 1000/(2 × 8) = 62.5 N/mm²; σ_l = 31.25 N/mm².
- ε_c = (62.5 − 0.3 × 31.25)/200 000 = 265.6 × 10⁻⁶; δd = 1000 × 265.6 × 10⁻⁶ = 0.266 mm.
- ε_l = (31.25 − 0.3 × 62.5)/200 000 = 62.5 × 10⁻⁶; δL = 6000 × 62.5 × 10⁻⁶ = 0.375 mm.
- ε_v = 2 × 265.6 × 10⁻⁶ + 62.5 × 10⁻⁶ = 593.8 × 10⁻⁶; V = π × 1.0² × 6/4 = 4.712 m³.
- δV = 4.712 × 593.8 × 10⁻⁶ = 0.002 80 m³ = 2.80 litres, in addition to the water compressed by the pressure itself.
Answer. σ_c = 62.5, σ_l = 31.25 N/mm²; δd = 0.266 mm, δL = 0.375 mm; about 2.80 litres for the expansion
Problem. A spherical steel storage tank of internal diameter 12 m is designed for an internal pressure of 0.8 N/mm². The allowable stress is 140 N/mm² and the welded seams have an efficiency of 0.85. Find the shell thickness and compare it with a cylinder of the same diameter.
- Sphere: t = pd/(4ση) = 0.8 × 12 000/(4 × 140 × 0.85) = 9600/476 = 20.2 mm; adopt the next plate thickness above this.
- Cylinder of the same diameter (hoop governs): t = pd/(2ση) = 9600/238 = 40.3 mm, twice the sphere.
- Thin check for the sphere: t/d = 20.2/12 000 = 1/594.
- Stress in a 22 mm sphere shell away from seams = 0.8 × 12 000/(4 × 22) = 109.1 N/mm².
- The civil engineer designs the foundation and the column legs for the weight of steel plus contents and the test load, with the shell thickness taken from this calculation.
Answer. Sphere t = 20.2 mm (cylinder would need 40.3 mm); 22 mm shell has σ = 109.1 N/mm²
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the design pressure: static head p = ρgh at the lowest point plus surge or test pressure as the project specification requires.
- Check that the shell is thin (t ≤ d/20); otherwise go to Lamé's theory.
- Compute the required thickness from the hoop stress (cylinder) or membrane stress (sphere), dividing by the seam efficiency.
- Add the corrosion allowance and round up to an available plate thickness; check the longitudinal stress and the circumferential seams.
- Find strains and volume change if needed (hydrotest water, joint movement), and check external pressure and handling separately.
Site notes
- Hydrotest pipelines in sections with closed, anchored ends; the end caps carry the full end thrust p × πd²/4, which is large even at moderate pressures.
- Pressure increases downhill: the thickest penstock plates and highest test pressures are at the lowest point, near the powerhouse.
- Bleed all air before a hydrotest; trapped air is compressible and makes pressure readings and volume checks meaningless, and stores energy that is dangerous if a pipe fails.
- Thin shells under external pressure (empty buried pipes, penstocks drained quickly, vacuum from fast valve closure) fail by buckling at stresses far below yield; stiffener rings and vacuum valves deal with that.
- Using the longitudinal formula pd/(4t) for the hoop stress, which underestimates it by half.
- Mixing head in metres with pressure in N/mm² (10 m of water is about 0.098 N/mm², not 1 N/mm²).
- Using radius instead of diameter in σ_c = pd/(2t), giving half the stress.
- Applying the joint efficiency of the circumferential seam to the hoop stress.
- Using thin-shell formulas for thick walls (t > d/20) or for external pressure, where buckling governs.
Hoop stress pd/(2t) is twice the longitudinal stress pd/(4t); a sphere carries pd/(4t) everywhere, so it needs half the cylinder's wall.
Summary
- Thin shells (t ≤ about d/20) carry pressure by uniform membrane tension.
- Cylinder: σ_c = pd/(2t), σ_l = pd/(4t); sphere: σ = pd/(4t).
- Seams: divide by the joint efficiency of the seam that carries the stress.
- Volumetric strain: cylinder pd(5 − 4ν)/(4tE), sphere 3pd(1 − ν)/(4tE).
- Pressure from head p = ρgh; external pressure is a buckling problem, not covered by these formulas.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A cylinder of d = 500 mm and t = 10 mm carries p = 2 N/mm². Find σ_c, σ_l, the in-plane maximum shear and the absolute maximum shear (σ₃ = 0).
σ_c = 50 N/mm², σ_l = 25 N/mm²; in-plane τ_max = 12.5 N/mm²; absolute τ_max = 25 N/mm².
2Is a pipe of internal diameter 300 mm with a 20 mm wall thin?
t/d = 20/300 = 1/15, more than 1/20, so it should be treated as a thick cylinder by Lamé's theory.
3A cylinder d = 800 mm, t = 8 mm, allowable stress 100 N/mm², longitudinal seam efficiency 0.8, circumferential seam efficiency 0.5. Find the safe pressure.
Longitudinal seam: p = 2 × 8 × 100 × 0.8/800 = 1.6 N/mm². Circumferential seam: p = 4 × 8 × 100 × 0.5/800 = 2.0 N/mm². Safe pressure 1.6 N/mm².
4A thin sphere d = 2 m, t = 10 mm, p = 1.5 N/mm², E = 200 000 N/mm², ν = 0.3. Find the stress and the volumetric strain.
σ = 1.5 × 2000/40 = 75 N/mm²; δV/V = 3 × 75 × 0.7/200 000 = 7.875 × 10⁻⁴.
5Why do over-pressurised pipes usually split along their length?
The hoop stress, which acts round the circumference and pulls the wall apart along a longitudinal line, is twice the longitudinal stress.
6A rising main of internal diameter 600 mm and wall 6 mm is under a head of 50 m. Find the hoop stress.
p = 1000 × 9.81 × 50 = 0.4905 N/mm²; σ_c = 0.4905 × 600/12 = 24.5 N/mm².
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.