Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.6

1.6 Strain energy and impact loading

Strength of Materials Chapter 1: Simple stress and strain Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Define strain energy, resilience, proof resilience and modulus of resilience, and calculate them for an axially loaded bar.
  • Show that a load applied suddenly produces twice the stress of the same load applied gradually.
  • Derive and use the impact stress formula σ = (P/A)[1 + √(1 + 2AEh/(PL))] for a load falling onto a collar, and judge when the simple approximations apply.

Theory

When a load stretches a bar it does work, and in an elastic bar that work is stored as strain energy, much as a spring stores energy. Remove the load and the energy is given back as the bar returns to its original length. For a load applied gradually, from zero up to P, the force rises in step with the extension, so the work is the area of a triangle on the load-extension graph: half the final load times the final extension. Energy methods built on this idea are among the most powerful tools in structural analysis, and they begin with this simple bar.

The energy stored per unit volume, σ²/(2E), is called the strain energy density. The total energy a member can store without permanent set is its proof resilience, found by putting the elastic limit (in practice the yield stress) for σ; per unit volume this is the modulus of resilience. A material with a high yield stress and a low modulus stores more energy elastically; mild steel stores about 0.16 N·mm per mm³ at 250 N/mm². Members meant to absorb shocks, such as crash barriers, buffers and lifting gear, are judged on energy, not only on strength.

PhcollarL, A, EU = ½ P δδPσ = (P/A)[1 + √(1 + 2h/δst)]Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.6: A load falling onto the collar of a hanger, and strain energy as the area under the load-extension line. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Not all loads arrive gradually. If a load is placed on a member all at once, for example when the slack in a lifting rod is taken up instantly, the load does full work P δ through the extension, but the bar stores only half the final force times δ. Equating the two shows that the bar must stretch to twice the static extension, so the peak stress is twice the static value. The bar then vibrates about the static position and settles there as damping removes the extra energy.

If the load falls through a height h before it strikes a collar on the bar, the energy to be absorbed is larger still: the weight times the fall plus the extension. Equating this to the strain energy gives a quadratic in the stress, whose answer shows that even a short drop can multiply the stress many times. The result also has a surprising design lesson: for a given impact energy, a longer or larger bar (more volume) carries a lower stress, because the energy is spread through more material. That is why bolts that take shocks are often made long with a reduced shank.

Derivation

  1. Gradual load from 0 to P: work done = ½ P δ = strain energy U.
  2. With δ = PL/(AE): U = P²L/(2AE). With σ = P/A and V = AL: U = σ²V/(2E) = ½ σ ε V.
  3. Proof resilience U_p = f_y² V/(2E); modulus of resilience u_p = f_y²/(2E) (energy per unit volume at the elastic limit).
  4. Sudden load P (no fall): work done by the constant load = P δ, energy stored = σ²AL/(2E). With δ = σL/E: P σL/E = σ²AL/(2E), so σ = 2P/A, twice the static stress.
  5. Falling load P through height h onto a collar: P(h + δ) = σ²AL/(2E), with δ = σL/E.
  6. Rearranging: (AL/2E) σ² − (PL/E) σ − P h = 0. Taking the positive root: σ = (P/A)[1 + √(1 + 2AEh/(PL))].
  7. Since the static extension δ_st = PL/(AE), the formula can be written σ = σ_st [1 + √(1 + 2h/δ_st)]; h = 0 gives back σ = 2P/A.
  8. When h is much larger than δ: σ ≈ √(2EPh/(AL)), so σ varies as 1/√(volume). A load moving with velocity v is treated with an equivalent height h = v²/(2g).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Strain energy (gradual load) U = ½ P δ = P²L/(2AE) = σ²V/(2E)
  • Strain energy density u = σ²/(2E) = ½ σ ε; modulus of resilience f_y²/(2E)
  • Proof resilience U_p = f_y² V/(2E)
  • Suddenly applied load: σ = 2P/A; δ = 2PL/(AE)
  • Falling load: σ = (P/A)[1 + √(1 + 2AEh/(PL))] = σ_st[1 + √(1 + 2h/δ_st)]; δ = σL/E
  • Large h: σ ≈ √(2EPh/(AL)); moving load: h = v²/(2g)
  • Units: N and mm give U in N·mm (1 J = 1000 N·mm); u in N·mm/mm³ = N/mm²
Assumptions and limits
  • The bar is linear elastic and the stress stays below the elastic limit; otherwise the energy stored is not recovered and the formulas no longer apply.
  • The stress is uniform along the bar at every instant; stress waves and inertia of the bar are ignored (the bar's mass is small compared with the falling load).
  • No energy is lost in the impact (no sound, heat or local plastic deformation at the collar), so the answer is on the safe side.
  • The collar and the support are rigid; flexible supports absorb part of the energy and reduce the stress.
  • Loads act along the axis; impact on beams is treated with the same energy balance using the beam's stiffness.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • No design code governs strain energy or the impact formula; they follow from conservation of energy and Hooke's law.
  • The modulus used here is the IS 800:2007 cl. 2.2.4.1 value for structural steel, E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²; side by side, EN 1993-1-1 cl. 3.2.6 takes E = 210 000 N/mm². These are not ranked here.
  • Design codes for cranes, bridges and lifting gear allow for dynamic and impact effects through factors on the static load set in their loading provisions; those factors are covered in the loading and bridge subjects, not derived from this idealised formula.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: load falling on a hanger)

Problem. A vertical steel hanger 3 m long with a cross-sectional area of 400 mm² has a collar at its lower end. A load of 5 kN falls 10 mm onto the collar. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the maximum stress and extension, and compare with the same load applied gradually.

  1. Static stress σ_st = 5000/400 = 12.5 N/mm²; static extension δ_st = 5000 × 3000/(400 × 2.0 × 10⁵) = 0.1875 mm.
  2. 2AEh/(PL) = 2 × 400 × 2.0 × 10⁵ × 10/(5000 × 3000) = 106.67 (equal to 2h/δ_st = 20/0.1875).
  3. σ = 12.5 × [1 + √(1 + 106.67)] = 12.5 × (1 + 10.376) = 142.2 N/mm².
  4. Extension δ = σL/E = 142.2 × 3000/2.0 × 10⁵ = 2.133 mm.
  5. Energy check: P(h + δ) = 5000 × 12.133 = 60 665 N·mm; σ²AL/(2E) = 142.2² × 400 × 3000/(4.0 × 10⁵) = 60 665 N·mm.
  6. A 10 mm drop raises the stress about 11.4 times above the gradual-load value.

Answer. σ = 142.2 N/mm²; δ = 2.13 mm; about 11.4 times the static stress

Example 2 (site style: sudden load on a crane hook rod)

Problem. The steel rod of a crane hook block is 1.5 m long and 30 mm in diameter. A 50 kN load hanging in slack slings is picked up so that the full weight comes on the rod at once, without any drop. Take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the peak stress, the peak extension and the strain energy stored.

  1. A = π × 30²/4 = 706.86 mm²; static stress = 50 000/706.86 = 70.74 N/mm².
  2. Suddenly applied: σ = 2P/A = 141.47 N/mm².
  3. Peak extension δ = σL/E = 141.47 × 1500/2.0 × 10⁵ = 1.061 mm.
  4. Energy stored at the peak U = σ²V/(2E) = 141.47² × 706.86 × 1500/(4.0 × 10⁵) = 53 052 N·mm ≈ 53.1 J, equal to the work P δ = 50 000 × 1.061.
  5. Lifting smoothly (gradual load) halves the peak stress; slack slings snatched tight do the opposite.

Answer. σ = 141.5 N/mm² (twice static); δ = 1.06 mm; U ≈ 53.1 J

Example 3 (site style: energy capacity of a tie rod)

Problem. A mild steel tie rod 16 mm in diameter and 4 m long has a yield stress of 250 N/mm²; take E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm². Find the modulus of resilience, the proof resilience, and the greatest height from which a 1 kN weight may fall onto a collar at its end without yielding the rod.

  1. Modulus of resilience = f_y²/(2E) = 250²/(4.0 × 10⁵) = 0.156 N·mm/mm³.
  2. Volume V = 201.06 × 4000 = 804 248 mm³; proof resilience = 0.15625 × 804 248 = 125 664 N·mm ≈ 125.7 J.
  3. Extension at yield δ_y = f_y L/E = 250 × 4000/2.0 × 10⁵ = 5 mm.
  4. Energy balance at yield: P(h + δ_y) = U_p, so h = 125 664/1000 − 5 = 120.7 mm.

Answer. u = 0.156 N·mm/mm³; proof resilience ≈ 125.7 J; h ≈ 121 mm

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the static stress P/A and static extension PL/(AE) first.
  2. Decide how the load arrives: gradual (factor 1), sudden with no fall (factor 2), falling through h, or moving with velocity v (h = v²/2g).
  3. For impact, compute 2h/δ_st and σ = σ_st[1 + √(1 + 2h/δ_st)]; find δ = σL/E.
  4. Check the energy balance P(h + δ) = σ²V/(2E) as a guard against arithmetic errors.
  5. Compare the peak stress with the yield stress; if exceeded, the elastic formula is not valid and the member or the arrangement must change.

Site notes

  • Snatch loads from slack slings or ropes can double the force or worse; lifting plans call for taking up slack slowly before the main lift.
  • Shock-absorbing members (buffers, crash barriers, fall-arrest systems) are rated by energy; their stiffness is chosen so that the energy is absorbed at an acceptable force.
  • Long bolts with a reduced shank (turned down to near the root diameter) store more energy at the same peak stress than short bolts, which is why they are used where shocks occur.
  • Dropping steel plates or precast units even a short height onto supports or hangers creates high impact stresses; set loads down gently.
Common mistakes
  • Using ½ P δ for a suddenly applied load and missing the factor of 2 on stress.
  • Leaving out the extension δ in the falling-load energy P(h + δ), which matters when h is small.
  • Using the approximate formula √(2EPh/(AL)) when h is not large compared with δ_st.
  • Mixing N·mm and J (1 J = 1000 N·mm).
  • Assuming a stronger, stiffer or shorter member always resists impact better; for the same energy, more volume at uniform stress gives lower stress.
Quick check

Impact factor = 1 + √(1 + 2h/δ_st): it is exactly 2 for a sudden load (h = 0), and even a drop of ten times the static extension gives about 5.6. If the computed peak stress exceeds yield, the elastic answer is not valid.

Summary

  • Strain energy U = ½ P δ = σ²V/(2E); modulus of resilience f_y²/(2E).
  • A suddenly applied load gives twice the static stress and extension.
  • Falling load: σ = (P/A)[1 + √(1 + 2AEh/(PL))].
  • For the same impact energy, more volume at uniform stress means lower stress.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the modulus of resilience of mild steel with f_y = 250 N/mm² and E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm².

f_y²/(2E) = 62 500/400 000 = 0.156 N·mm/mm³.

2A steel rod 2 m long with A = 500 mm² carries 20 kN applied gradually. Find the strain energy. What would it be if the load were applied suddenly? (E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²)

Gradual: U = P²L/(2AE) = 20 000² × 2000/(2 × 500 × 2.0 × 10⁵) = 4000 N·mm = 4 J. Sudden: stress doubles to 80 N/mm², so U = 16 J.

3A 2 kN weight falls 100 mm onto a collar at the end of a steel rod 2 m long with A = 1000 mm². Find the maximum stress (E = 2.0 × 10⁵ N/mm²) and compare with the approximate formula.

2AEh/(PL) = 10 000; σ = 2 × (1 + √10 001) = 202.0 N/mm². Approximate √(2EPh/(AL)) = 200 N/mm².

4Why does a longer rod carry a lower impact stress than a short one of the same section, for the same falling weight and height?

For large h, σ ≈ √(2EPh/(AL)): the energy is spread through a larger volume, so the stress needed to store it is lower.

5A 1 kN load moving down at 1 m/s is suddenly stopped by a rod. What equivalent drop height should be used?

h = v²/(2g) = 1²/(2 × 9.81) = 0.051 m = 51 mm.

6A bolt has its plain shank turned down to the root diameter of the thread. Why does this help it absorb shock loads?

The stress becomes nearly uniform along the length, so the whole volume stores energy at the peak stress; with a thick shank the energy is concentrated in the thread and the bolt yields there first.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.