Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 8 › Lesson 8.2

8.2 Collapse loads of beams

Structural Analysis Chapter 8: Plastic analysis Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State the static (lower-bound), kinematic (upper-bound) and uniqueness theorems of plastic collapse and explain what each gives.
  • Find collapse loads of simply supported, propped, fixed and continuous beams by the mechanism (virtual work) method, including the hinge position under distributed load.
  • Confirm a collapse load by drawing a statically admissible bending moment diagram with |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.

Theory

An indeterminate beam does not fail when its most stressed section reaches Mp. That section becomes a plastic hinge and keeps carrying Mp while it rotates, and further load is carried by the rest of the beam, as if one restraint had been removed. Each new hinge lowers the degree of indeterminacy by one. When enough hinges have formed to turn the beam, or one span of it, into a mechanism, the deflection grows without further load: this is the collapse load. For a beam of degree of indeterminacy r, a complete mechanism needs r + 1 hinges, though a partial mechanism in one span can need fewer. Sign convention for this chapter: in beams, sagging moments are positive and hogging moments negative; in portal frames, a moment is positive when it causes tension on the inside face of the frame. In a mechanism every plastic hinge rotates in the same sense as its plastic moment, so the work absorbed at a hinge is always Mp times the size of its rotation, counted positive.

Three theorems make the calculation easy. The kinematic theorem: the load found from any assumed mechanism, by equating the external work to the internal work at the hinges, is greater than or equal to the true collapse load. The static theorem: the load for which any bending moment diagram can be found that is in equilibrium with the loads and nowhere exceeds Mp is less than or equal to the true collapse load. The uniqueness theorem: a load that satisfies both, that is a mechanism together with a moment diagram within ±Mp everywhere, is the true collapse load.

Propped cantilever: collapse mechanismwMpMp0.414 LLw_c = 11.66 Mp/L²Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 8.2: A propped cantilever under uniform load w and its collapse mechanism: plastic hinges at the fixed end and at 0.414L from the simple support, giving w_c = 11.66 Mp/L². Indiacon original, not to scale.

In the mechanism method the beam is treated as rigid segments joined at hinges, and a small virtual displacement is given to the mechanism. The external work is the sum of each load times the deflection at its point (for a distributed load, w times the area swept by the beam). The internal work is the sum of Mp times the hinge rotation at every hinge. Equating the two gives the collapse load of that mechanism. All possible mechanisms are tried, and the lowest load governs. Hinges form only at supports with moment restraint, under point loads, where the section changes, and at the point of maximum moment under distributed load, whose position must be found by minimising the load.

Plastic collapse loads do not depend on the stiffness EI, on small support settlements or on the order in which hinges form, because the collapse moment diagram is fixed by equilibrium alone. This makes plastic analysis attractive for continuous steel beams. The elastic history still matters for service checks: deflection at working load, and whether the first hinges have enough rotation capacity to keep rotating while later hinges form.

Derivation

  1. Virtual work for a mechanism: give the mechanism a small rotation θ. For each rigid segment, deflections are linear in θ; at each hinge i the relative rotation is a multiple k_i θ.
  2. External work W_e = Σ P_j δ_j + Σ ∫ w δ dx; internal work W_i = Σ Mp_i |k_i| θ. Setting W_e = W_i gives the collapse load of that mechanism; θ cancels.
  3. Fixed-ended beam with central point load P: hinges at both ends (rotation θ) and under the load (2θ), deflection δ = θL/2. Then P(θL/2) = Mp(θ + 2θ + θ), so P_c = 8Mp/L. With uniform load the area swept is θL²/4, so w_c = 16Mp/L².
  4. Propped cantilever with uniform load, fixed at one end and simply supported at the other: put the span hinge at a distance x from the simple support and let its deflection be δ. The segment rotations are δ/x and δ/(L − x); the fixed-end hinge rotates δ/(L − x) and the span hinge δ/x + δ/(L − x).
  5. Then w δ L/2 = Mp δ[1/x + 2/(L − x)], so w = 2Mp(L + x)/[L x(L − x)]. Setting dw/dx = 0 gives x² + 2Lx − L² = 0, so x = (√2 − 1)L = 0.414L and w_c = 2(3 + 2√2)Mp/L² = 11.66 Mp/L².
  6. Fixed-ended beam with a point load P at distances a and b from the ends: hinges at the two ends and under the load give P_c = 2Mp L/(ab). For continuous beams each span is checked as its own beam mechanism, with hinges at the internal supports and in the span; the lowest load governs, and the moment diagram is then checked in every other span.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Virtual work: Σ P δ + Σ ∫ w δ dx = Σ Mp |φ| (kN m on both sides)
  • Simply supported span: P_c = 4Mp/L (central point load); w_c = 8Mp/L² (uniform)
  • Fixed-ended span: P_c = 8Mp/L; w_c = 16Mp/L²; eccentric point load P_c = 2Mp L/(ab)
  • Propped cantilever: P_c = 6Mp/L (central point load); w_c = 11.66 Mp/L² with the span hinge at 0.414L from the simple support
  • End span of a continuous beam (simple outer support, continuous inner support, equal Mp): same as the propped cantilever
  • Interior span of a continuous beam with equal Mp: same as a fixed-ended span
  • Number of hinges for a complete mechanism: r + 1, where r is the degree of static indeterminacy
  • Static check: |M(x)| ≤ Mp at every section at the collapse load (kN m)
Assumptions and limits
  • Elastic–perfectly plastic sections with hinges of negligible length that can rotate as far as needed (ductile, compact, laterally restrained sections).
  • Loads increase proportionally (all in fixed ratio) and are static; repeated or reversed loading can cause incremental collapse or alternating plasticity at a lower load.
  • Deflections are small, so equilibrium is written on the undeformed beam; there is no instability before collapse.
  • Axial and shear forces are small enough not to reduce Mp; where they are large, a reduced plastic moment is used.
  • Limits: the method gives the ultimate load only; service deflections, fatigue and the rotation capacity of the first hinges need separate checks, and concrete beams are allowed only limited redistribution because their hinges have little rotation capacity.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Plastic collapse of beams is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American steel codes, side by side and not ranked, permit plastic global analysis of continuous beams when sections are of the plastic class, members are restrained at hinge locations and the steel is ductile; concrete codes allow a limited redistribution of elastic moments instead; their values are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: propped cantilever)

Problem. A propped cantilever of span 6 m is fixed at A and simply supported at B, with Mp = 200 kN m throughout. Find the collapse load (a) for a central point load and (b) for a uniformly distributed load, with the hinge position.

  1. (a) Hinges at A and under the load C. Give A a rotation θ: δ_C = 3θ, segment CB rotates θ, so the hinge at C rotates 2θ.
  2. Virtual work: P × 3θ = Mp(θ + 2θ) = 3Mp θ, so P_c = Mp = 6Mp/L = 200 kN.
  3. (b) Span hinge at distance x from B: w = 2Mp(L + x)/[L x(L − x)], which is least at x = (√2 − 1) × 6 = 2.485 m from B (3.515 m from A).
  4. w_c = 11.657 × 200/6² = 64.76 kN/m.
  5. Static check for (b): with M_A = −200 kN m the reaction at B is R_B = wL/2 − 200/6 = 194.3 − 33.3 = 160.9 kN; the sagging moment is greatest where the shear is zero, at x = R_B/w = 2.485 m from B, and equals R_B²/(2w) = 200 kN m = Mp, so |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.

Answer. (a) P_c = 200 kN; (b) w_c = 64.76 kN/m with the span hinge 2.485 m from the simple support

Example 2 (site style: two-span floor beam)

Problem. A steel floor beam ABC is continuous over B and simply supported at A and C. Span AB = 6 m carries a central point load P; span BC = 8 m carries a uniform load of P/8 per metre (the same total). Mp = 180 kN m throughout. Find the collapse value of P and check the moments in the other span.

  1. Span AB (hinges at B and under the load): P × 3θ = Mp(θ + 2θ), so 3P = 3 × 180 and P = 180 kN.
  2. Span BC behaves as a propped cantilever with the hinge 0.414 × 8 = 3.31 m from C: w_c = 11.657 × 180/8² = 32.78 kN/m, which needs P = 8w = 262.3 kN.
  3. Span AB governs: P_c = 180 kN, so w = 22.5 kN/m on BC, with M_B = −180 kN m.
  4. Check span BC: R_C = (22.5 × 8 × 4 − 180)/8 = 67.5 kN; maximum sagging moment where the shear is zero, 67.5/22.5 = 3.0 m from C, equal to 67.5²/(2 × 22.5) = 101.25 kN m < 180 kN m.
  5. Span AB at collapse: R_A = (180 × 3 − 180)/6 = 60 kN, M under the load = 180 kN m = Mp. Reactions R_A = 60, R_B = 232.5, R_C = 67.5 kN, total 360 kN as applied.

Answer. P_c = 180 kN (span AB mechanism); span BC is within Mp, with a largest sagging moment of 101.25 kN m

Example 3 (site style: fixed beam with two point loads)

Problem. A fixed-ended beam AB spans 9 m with Mp = 120 kN m. It carries W at C, 3 m from A, and 1.5W at D, 6 m from A. Find the collapse value of W and the hinge positions.

  1. Mechanism 1, hinges at A, C, B: δ_C = 3θ; segment CB rotates θ/2, so δ_D = 1.5θ and the hinge rotations are θ, 1.5θ, 0.5θ. W × 3θ + 1.5W × 1.5θ = Mp × 3θ gives W = 3 × 120/5.25 = 68.57 kN.
  2. Mechanism 2, hinges at A, D, B: δ_D = 6θ, segment DB rotates 2θ, δ_C = 3θ; hinge rotations θ, 3θ, 2θ. W × 3θ + 1.5W × 6θ = Mp × 6θ gives W = 6 × 120/12 = 60.0 kN.
  3. Mechanism 2 gives the lower load: W_c = 60 kN (loads 60 and 90 kN).
  4. Static check: the simply supported (free) moments are 210 kN m at C and 240 kN m at D. With M_A = M_B = −120 kN m, M_C = 210 − 120 = 90 kN m and M_D = 240 − 120 = 120 kN m = Mp.
  5. |M| ≤ 120 kN m everywhere, so W_c = 60 kN is the true collapse load. An elastic–plastic analysis with equal EI gives the same answer, with hinges forming first at B (W = 45 kN), then at A (49.1 kN) and finally at D (60 kN).

Answer. W_c = 60 kN, with hinges at A, B and under the 1.5W load

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the degree of indeterminacy r and list the possible hinge positions: fixed supports, internal supports, point loads, changes of section and points of maximum moment under distributed load.
  2. Sketch each possible mechanism (for continuous beams, a beam mechanism in each span).
  3. For each mechanism write the external and internal virtual work in terms of one rotation θ and solve for the collapse load; minimise over the hinge position where a distributed load acts.
  4. Take the lowest load as the trial collapse load.
  5. Draw the bending moment diagram at that load, using the hinge moments and equilibrium, and confirm |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.
  6. If the check fails somewhere, a mechanism was missed: put a hinge at the overstressed section and repeat.

Site notes

  • Plastic design of continuous floor beams usually gives lighter sections than elastic design, because the support and span moments are both brought up to Mp.
  • Hinges at internal supports form first and must keep rotating while span hinges develop; keep the bottom flange there braced, because it is in compression and prone to buckling.
  • Collapse loads do not change with small support settlements, but service deflections and cracking of finishes do; check them at working load with an elastic analysis.
  • Where a heavy point load is moved after design (for example a relocated plant item), recheck the mechanism in that span; the governing mechanism can change.
  • Avoid site welding, cut-outs and splices at the hinge points marked on the design drawings.
Common mistakes
  • Missing a mechanism and taking a higher load as the answer; the kinematic theorem only gives an upper bound, so the static check is needed.
  • Placing the span hinge at midspan under uniform load in a propped span; the correct position is 0.414L from the simple support, and the midspan guess overestimates the load by about 3 per cent.
  • Using hinge rotations without signs or with the wrong ratios; draw the mechanism and get each rotation from the deflections.
  • Putting a plastic hinge at a simple support, where the moment is zero.
  • Assuming that the elastic moment diagram, scaled up, gives the collapse load; redistribution changes the ratio of support to span moments.
Quick check

For equal Mp, collapse loads under uniform load are 8, 11.66 and 16 Mp/L² for simply supported, propped and fixed spans; under a central point load they are 4, 6 and 8 Mp/L. A continuous-beam answer should sit between the simply supported and fixed values for the same span. The ratio of plastic collapse load to the load at which the first hinge forms lies between 1.0 and about 1.5 for beams of uniform section: 1.0 for a fixed beam with a central point load, 1.33 for a fixed beam under uniform load and 1.46 for a propped cantilever under uniform load; a ratio far outside this range points to a missed mechanism.

Summary

  • A beam collapses when enough plastic hinges form to make a mechanism, not when the first section yields.
  • The kinematic theorem gives upper bounds, the static theorem lower bounds; a load that satisfies both is exact.
  • Mechanism method: external work of the loads equals Σ Mp |θ| at the hinges; take the lowest load over all mechanisms.
  • Standard results: fixed 8Mp/L and 16Mp/L², propped 6Mp/L and 11.66Mp/L², simply supported 4Mp/L and 8Mp/L².
  • Always finish with the static check |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A fixed-ended beam of span 8 m has Mp = 150 kN m. Find the collapse value of a central point load.

P_c = 8Mp/L = 8 × 150/8 = 150 kN.

2A fixed-ended beam of span 6 m with Mp = 135 kN m carries a uniform load. Find w_c.

w_c = 16Mp/L² = 16 × 135/36 = 60 kN/m.

3A propped cantilever of span 5 m has Mp = 100 kN m. Find the collapse uniform load and the span hinge position.

w_c = 11.657 × 100/25 = 46.63 kN/m, with the hinge 0.414 × 5 = 2.07 m from the simple support.

4A fixed-ended beam of span 6 m carries a point load 2 m from one end; Mp = 90 kN m. Find P_c.

P_c = 2Mp L/(ab) = 2 × 90 × 6/(2 × 4) = 135 kN.

5A fixed-ended 6 m beam must carry a factored uniform load of 40 kN/m at collapse. What plastic modulus is needed with fy = 250 N/mm², before any material factor?

Mp = wL²/16 = 40 × 36/16 = 90 kN m; Zp = 90 × 10⁶/250 = 360 × 10³ mm³.

6How many plastic hinges does a fixed-ended beam with one point load need for collapse, and why?

Three: the beam is indeterminate to degree 2 for transverse load, and r + 1 = 3 hinges (two ends and under the load) make it a mechanism.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.