8.3 Collapse loads of portal frames
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Identify the independent mechanisms of a single-bay portal frame (beam and sway) and form the combined mechanism by adding them so that a hinge cancels.
- Find collapse loads of fixed-base and pinned-base portals under vertical and horizontal loads, with different plastic moments in beam and columns and with distributed load on the beam.
- Use the equilibrium equations of the frame to find the moments at sections without hinges and confirm |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.
Theory
A portal frame has more possible mechanisms than a beam, because the frame can sway as well as bend. The critical sections of a single-bay portal with a point load on the beam are the two column bases (if fixed), the two beam–column joints and the point under the load. If there are n critical sections and the frame is indeterminate to degree r, there are n − r independent mechanisms. For a fixed-base portal n = 5 and r = 3, giving two independent mechanisms: the beam mechanism and the sway mechanism. Combining them, so that the hinge at the windward joint cancels, gives the combined mechanism, which often governs. Sign convention for this chapter: in beams, sagging moments are positive and hogging moments negative; in portal frames, a moment is positive when it causes tension on the inside face of the frame. In a mechanism every plastic hinge rotates in the same sense as its plastic moment, so the work absorbed at a hinge is always Mp times the size of its rotation, counted positive.
In the beam mechanism the columns stay still and the beam collapses between hinges at its ends and under the load, just as a fixed-ended beam. In the sway mechanism the beam moves sideways without bending, and the columns rotate with hinges at their tops and, for fixed bases, at their bottoms. In the combined mechanism the windward joint stays rigid, so the left column and the left part of the beam rotate together, the beam dips at the span hinge, and the leeward joint and the column base or bases hinge. Its virtual work equation is the sum of the beam and sway equations, minus the work of the hinge that has closed.
At a joint where two members meet, the hinge forms in the weaker member, so the plastic moment used at a joint is the smaller of the beam and column values. Where three or more members meet, a joint mechanism, in which the joint rotates and every member end hinges, is a further independent mechanism. When the vertical load is distributed along the beam, the span hinge position in the combined mechanism is not at midspan and must be found by minimising the load, as for the propped cantilever in lesson 8.2.
After the lowest mechanism load is found, the equilibrium equations give the moments at the sections where no hinge has formed. If every one is within ±Mp of its member, the uniqueness theorem confirms the collapse load. These equilibrium equations are the virtual work equations of the independent mechanisms written in terms of the moments themselves, so they hold for any moment distribution in equilibrium, elastic or plastic.
Derivation
- Number the critical sections of a fixed-base portal: 1 at the left base A, 2 at the left joint B, 3 under the beam load E (midspan), 4 at the right joint C and 5 at the right base D. Column height h, span L, horizontal load H at beam level, vertical load V at midspan; moments positive with tension inside.
- Beam mechanism (hinges 2, 3, 4 with rotations θ, 2θ, θ): V(L/2)θ = Mp(θ + 2θ + θ), so V = 8Mp/L. The matching equilibrium equation is −M2 + 2M3 − M4 = VL/2.
- Sway mechanism (hinges 1, 2, 4, 5, each rotating θ): H hθ = 4Mp θ, so H = 4Mp/h. Equilibrium equation: −M1 + M2 − M4 + M5 = Hh.
- Combined mechanism = beam + sway, with the hinge at section 2 closing: hinges 1, 3, 4, 5 with rotations θ, 2θ, 2θ, θ. Work: H hθ + V(L/2)θ = 6Mp θ. Equilibrium equation: −M1 + 2M3 − 2M4 + M5 = Hh + VL/2.
- Pinned bases: M1 = M5 = 0, so there are n = 3 critical sections (B, E, C) and r = 1, giving 3 − 1 = 2 independent mechanisms: the beam mechanism (V = 8Mp/L as before) and the sway mechanism with hinges at B and C (Hh = 2Mp). The combined mechanism has hinges at E and C, each rotating 2θ: Hh + VL/2 = 4Mp.
- Uniform load w on the beam in the combined mechanism with the span hinge at distance x from B: the beam deflection area is θxL/2 and the hinge rotations at E and C are θL/(L − x), so λ-proportional loads give Hh + wxL/2 = Mp[2 + 2L/(L − x)] for a fixed base, minimised over x.
Independent mechanisms: number = n − r (critical sections minus degree of indeterminacy)Fixed-base portal: beam V_c = 8Mp/L; sway H_c = 4Mp/h; combined Hh + VL/2 = 6Mp (kN, kN m)Pinned-base portal: beam V_c = 8Mp/L; sway Hh = 2Mp; combined Hh + VL/2 = 4MpBeam equilibrium: −M_B + 2M_E − M_C = VL/2 (kN m)Sway equilibrium: −M_A + M_B − M_C + M_D = Hh (kN m), with M_A = M_D = 0 for pinned basesDifferent plastic moments: use the smaller of beam and column Mp at a joint hingeUniform beam load, combined mechanism: minimise the load over the span hinge position x
- Rigid joints, elastic–perfectly plastic members with hinges of negligible length and enough rotation capacity.
- Loads increase in proportion (one load factor λ for all loads) and are static.
- First-order theory: equilibrium on the undeformed frame. Frame instability and the P–Δ effect of vertical load acting on the sway deflection are ignored.
- Axial forces in the columns are small enough not to reduce Mp; heavily loaded columns need a reduced plastic moment.
- Limits: slender or heavily loaded frames can fail by instability below the plastic collapse load, so codes require a second-order or stability check; the members must be compact and restrained against out-of-plane buckling at the hinges.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Plastic collapse of portal frames is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American steel codes, side by side and not ranked, permit plastic global analysis of portal frames with plastic-class sections, lateral restraint at hinges and ductile steel, and require frame stability to be checked, for example by second-order analysis or by limits on the elastic critical load; their criteria and factors are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A fixed-base portal has columns 4 m high and a beam of 6 m span, all with Mp = 100 kN m. It carries a vertical load 60λ kN at midspan and a horizontal load 30λ kN at the level of the beam. Find the collapse load factor and check the moments.
- Beam mechanism: 60λ × 3 = 4 × 100, so λ = 2.222.
- Sway mechanism: 30λ × 4 = 4 × 100, so λ = 3.333.
- Combined mechanism (hinges at A, E, C, D): 30λ × 4 + 60λ × 3 = 6 × 100, so 300λ = 600 and λ = 2.000. This is the lowest.
- Moments at collapse: M_A = −100, M_E = +100, M_C = −100, M_D = +100 kN m. Beam equation: −M_B + 200 + 100 = 120 × 6/2 = 360, so M_B = −60 kN m. Sway equation: 100 + M_B + 100 + 100 = 60 × 4 = 240 gives the same M_B = −60 kN m.
- |M_B| = 60 kN m < 100 kN m, and all other critical sections are at ±Mp: the collapse load factor is λ_c = 2.00 (V = 120 kN, H = 60 kN). An elastic–plastic analysis with equal EI forms hinges at C (λ = 1.73), E (1.76), D (1.79) and A (2.00).
Answer. λ_c = 2.00 by the combined mechanism; M_B = 60 kN m (tension outside) is within Mp
Problem. A pinned-base portal shed frame has columns 5 m high with Mp = 150 kN m and a beam of 8 m span with Mp = 200 kN m. Working loads are 100 kN at midspan and 40 kN horizontally at beam level. Find the load factor against collapse.
- Joint hinges form in the weaker member, the column (150 kN m).
- Beam mechanism (hinges at B, E, C with rotations θ, 2θ, θ): 100λ × 4 = 150 + 2 × 200 + 150 = 700, so λ = 1.75.
- Sway mechanism (hinges at B and C): 40λ × 5 = 150 + 150, so λ = 1.50.
- Combined mechanism (hinges at E and C, each rotating 2θ): 40λ × 5 + 100λ × 4 = 2 × 200 + 2 × 150, so 600λ = 700 and λ = 1.167.
- Check M_B: with M_E = +200 and M_C = −150, the beam equation gives −M_B + 400 + 150 = 100 × 1.167 × 4 = 466.7, so M_B = +83.3 kN m; the sway equation gives M_B + 150 = 40 × 1.167 × 5 = 233.3, the same 83.3 kN m < 150 kN m. So λ_c = 1.167.
Answer. λ_c = 1.17 (combined mechanism); the sway and beam mechanisms alone give 1.50 and 1.75
Problem. The fixed-base portal of Example 1 (h = 4 m, L = 6 m, Mp = 100 kN m) carries a uniform load of 20λ kN/m on the beam and 30λ kN horizontally at beam level. Find the collapse load factor and the position of the span hinge.
- Beam mechanism: hinges at B, C and midspan: 20λ × 6²/16 = 100 gives λ = 2.222. Sway: λ = 400/120 = 3.333.
- Combined mechanism with the span hinge at x from B: 120λ + 20λ × x × 6/2 = 100[2 + 12/(6 − x)], which simplifies to λ = (10/3)(12 − x)/[(6 − x)(2 + x)].
- dλ/dx = 0 gives x² − 24x + 60 = 0, so x = 12 − 2√21 = 2.835 m from B, and λ = (10/3) × 9.165/(3.165 × 4.835) = 1.996.
- With the hinge assumed at midspan (x = 3 m) the combined mechanism gives λ = 2.000, an upper bound only 0.2 per cent high.
- Static check: sway equation 100 + M_B + 100 + 100 = 120 × 1.996 gives M_B = −60.4 kN m. Along the beam M(s) = M_B + (M_C − M_B)s/L + w s(L − s)/2 with w = 39.93 kN/m has its peak at s = 2.835 m, equal to +100 kN m. All moments are within ±Mp, so λ_c = 1.996.
Answer. λ_c = 1.996 with the span hinge 2.835 m from the windward joint (midspan guess 2.000)
Step-by-step procedure
- Mark the critical sections: column bases (if fixed), joints, point loads, and the unknown peak position under distributed load.
- Count n and the degree of indeterminacy r; list the n − r independent mechanisms (beam, sway, and joint mechanisms where three or more members meet).
- Write the virtual work equation for each independent mechanism, using the smaller Mp at each joint.
- Combine mechanisms so that hinges cancel and the internal work falls; minimise over any hinge whose position is unknown.
- Take the lowest load factor and find the moments at the remaining sections from the equilibrium equations.
- Confirm |M| ≤ Mp at every section; if not, try the mechanism suggested by the overstressed section.
Site notes
- Portal frames for sheds and warehouses are often designed plastically; the haunches at the eaves are there to keep the hinge in the rafter away from the joint and its bolts.
- Bracing and fly braces near expected hinges stop the inside flange buckling, which is in compression under gravity load at the eaves.
- Column bases detailed as pinned on drawings but built with a stiff base plate and four bolts behave partly fixed; the plastic collapse load is then higher, but base bolts must carry the extra moment.
- Wind uplift reverses the moments; check the frame under the uplift combination too, where different hinges form.
- Before fixing heavy services or a crane to an existing portal, rerun the combined mechanism with the new loads; added horizontal load lowers the governing load factor quickly.
- Checking only the beam and sway mechanisms and missing the combined mechanism, which usually governs when both vertical and horizontal loads act.
- Using the beam Mp at a joint where the column is weaker; the hinge forms in the weaker member.
- Wrong hinge rotations in the combined mechanism: the span hinge and the leeward joint rotate 2θ, the bases θ, and the windward joint not at all.
- Assuming the span hinge is at midspan under uniform load in the combined mechanism; the true position moves towards the windward joint.
- Stopping at the mechanism load without the static check, or ignoring frame instability for tall or heavily loaded frames.
For a fixed-base portal with Mp the same everywhere, the beam mechanism gives V = 8Mp/L and the sway H = 4Mp/h; the combined mechanism governs when Hh and VL/2 are both significant, when Hh lies between one half and two times VL/2. For pinned bases the sway capacity is halved and the combined mechanism governs whenever Hh is less than VL/2. If the static check gives more than Mp at the windward joint, or anywhere else, look for a missed mechanism.
Summary
- Independent mechanisms of a portal: beam and sway (plus joint mechanisms where three or more members meet); their number is n − r.
- The combined mechanism is the sum of beam and sway with the windward joint hinge cancelled; it often governs.
- Fixed base: 8Mp/L, 4Mp/h and Hh + VL/2 = 6Mp; pinned base: 8Mp/L, 2Mp/h and Hh + VL/2 = 4Mp.
- Use the smaller Mp at a joint; minimise over hinge position under distributed load.
- Finish with the equilibrium equations and the check |M| ≤ Mp everywhere.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A fixed-base portal has columns 5 m high and Mp = 150 kN m throughout. Find the horizontal load at beam level that causes sway collapse.
H_c = 4Mp/h = 4 × 150/5 = 120 kN.
2The same frame has pinned bases. Find the sway collapse load.
H_c = 2Mp/h = 2 × 150/5 = 60 kN.
3How many independent mechanisms does a fixed-base single-bay portal with one point load on the beam have, and which are they?
n = 5 critical sections and r = 3, so two: the beam mechanism and the sway mechanism. The combined mechanism is their sum, not an extra independent one.
4A fixed-base portal beam of span 8 m has Mp = 120 kN m. Find the central vertical load for beam collapse.
V_c = 8Mp/L = 8 × 120/8 = 120 kN.
5In Example 1 the horizontal load is doubled to 60λ kN. Find the new collapse load factor and M_B.
Beam 2.222; sway 400/240 = 1.667; combined 600/(240 + 180) = 1.429, which governs. Beam equation: −M_B + 300 = 60 × 1.429 × 3 = 257.1, so M_B = +42.9 kN m, within Mp.
6Why is the static check needed after finding the lowest mechanism load?
The mechanism method gives an upper bound only. If the moments at all sections are within ±Mp at that load, the static theorem also holds, and by the uniqueness theorem the load is the true collapse load.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.