1.2 Static and kinematic indeterminacy
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Find the degree of static indeterminacy of plane trusses, beams and rigid frames by the member-joint formulas and by the closed-loop method, including the effect of internal hinges.
- Find the degree of kinematic indeterminacy (number of independent joint displacements) of plane frames and beams, with and without axial deformation.
- Explain why the force method needs the static degree and the displacement methods need the kinematic degree.
Theory
A structure is statically determinate when the equations of equilibrium alone give all reactions and member forces. In a plane each free body gives three equations (ΣF_x = 0, ΣF_y = 0, ΣM = 0), and each pin joint of a truss gives two. When there are more unknown forces than independent equations, the structure is statically indeterminate, and the excess is the degree of static indeterminacy D_s, the number of redundants. The extra equations needed come from compatibility of deformations, which is why indeterminate analysis needs member stiffness. Sign convention as in lesson 1.1: x to the right, y up, anticlockwise positive, tension positive.
For a plane pin-jointed truss with m members, r reaction components and j joints, the unknowns are m + r and the equations 2j, so D_s = m + r − 2j. For a plane rigid-jointed frame each member has three unknown end actions once its end forces are related by equilibrium, and each rigid joint gives three equations, so D_s = 3m + r − 3j − c, where c is the number of releases provided by internal hinges or rollers (a hinge joining n members releases n − 1 moments). A quicker way for frames is to count closed loops: a closed rigid ring is three times indeterminate, so D_s = 3C − c, where C is the number of closed loops formed with the ground taken as one body.
Kinematic indeterminacy counts the other side of the problem: the number of independent joint displacements (translations and rotations) that are unknown once the supports are fixed in position. A plane rigid joint can translate in x and y and rotate, three degrees of freedom; a truss joint has two. So for a plane frame D_k = 3j − r, and for a plane truss D_k = 2j − r. In most building frames axial shortening of members is small compared with bending deformation, and members are taken as axially rigid; each such member removes one independent displacement, so D_k = 3j − r − m. What remains are the joint rotations and the sway (side-sway) translations of each storey.
The two degrees choose the method. The force method (consistent deformations, three-moment equation) takes the redundant forces as unknowns, so its work grows with D_s. The displacement methods (slope deflection, moment distribution, the stiffness matrix method) take the joint displacements as unknowns, so their work grows with D_k. A fixed-ended portal frame is three times statically indeterminate and, with axially rigid members, also has three kinematic unknowns (two joint rotations and one sway); a tall multi-bay frame has far more redundants than displacements, which is why computer programs use the stiffness method. Indeterminacy by itself is not a fault: redundant structures are usually stiffer and can redistribute force if one part is overloaded.
Derivation
- Truss: each pin joint gives two equilibrium equations, so there are 2j equations in total. The unknowns are the m member forces and the r reaction components. If m + r = 2j the structure can be determinate; the excess D_s = m + r − 2j is the number of redundants.
- Rigid frame: cut every member at its ends. Each member has six end actions, but its own three equilibrium equations leave three independent unknowns per member, 3m in all; with r reactions the unknowns are 3m + r.
- Each rigid joint (including support joints) gives three equilibrium equations, 3j in all. Each internal release adds one equation (moment zero at the hinge), so D_s = 3m + r − 3j − c.
- Closed-loop check: a single closed rigid ring has three unknown internal actions at any cut, so it is three times indeterminate; with C loops (ground counted as one rigid body) D_s = 3C − c gives the same result.
- Kinematic degree: each free plane rigid joint has three possible displacements and each truss joint two; the support restraints remove r of them, so D_k = 3j − r for frames and 2j − r for trusses.
- Axially rigid members: if a member cannot change length, the displacements of its two ends along its axis are equal, which removes one unknown per member: D_k = 3j − r − m. The remaining unknowns are joint rotations and sway displacements.
Plane truss D_s = m + r − 2j; plane rigid frame D_s = 3m + r − 3j − c; beam D_s = r − 3 − cClosed-loop method D_s = 3C − c (ground counted as one body)Space truss D_s = m + r − 3j; space frame D_s = 6m + r − 6jKinematic: plane frame D_k = 3j − r; plane truss D_k = 2j − rAxially rigid members: D_k = 3j − r − m (rotations plus independent sways)Hinge joining n members releases n − 1 moments; m members, j joints (supports included), r reaction components, c releases
- Plane structures with loads in their plane; space structures need six equations per body (space truss D_s = m + r − 3j, space frame D_s = 6m + r − 6j).
- Joints are ideal pins (trusses) or perfectly rigid (frames); every internal hinge or release is counted in c.
- The structure is stable: the formulas count unknowns and equations but do not detect a badly arranged structure (lesson 1.4).
- For kinematic counts with axially rigid members, member shortening is small compared with bending deformation, which holds for ordinary beams and frames but not for trusses, arches or tall slender columns.
- Limits: a positive D_s is a property of the model; if a joint modelled as rigid is in fact flexible, the real degree differs, and the counts give no information about the size of the redundant forces.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Static and kinematic indeterminacy are counted from statics and geometry alone; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all treat redundancy as a property of the analysis model and encourage alternative load paths for robustness; how redundancy enters design checks is set in each practice's own codes and is not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. Find the degree of static indeterminacy of: (a) a simple roof truss with 6 joints and 9 members on a pin and a roller; (b) a bridge truss with 8 joints and 15 members (two panels have crossed diagonals) on a pin and a roller; (c) the truss of (a) made continuous over a third support, a pin and two rollers.
- (a) m = 9, r = 3, j = 6: D_s = 9 + 3 − 12 = 0, statically determinate (a simple truss has m = 2j − 3).
- (b) m = 15, r = 3, j = 8: D_s = 15 + 3 − 16 = 2; each extra diagonal in a crossed panel is one redundant.
- (c) m = 9, r = 2 + 1 + 1 = 4, j = 6: D_s = 9 + 4 − 12 = 1, externally indeterminate by one (the middle reaction).
- The count says nothing about how the members are arranged; each truss must also pass the stability check of lesson 1.4.
Answer. (a) 0, determinate; (b) 2, internally indeterminate; (c) 1, externally indeterminate
Problem. Find D_s for a single-bay portal frame (two columns and one beam) when (a) both bases are fixed, (b) both bases are pinned, (c) both bases are pinned and there is a hinge at midspan of the beam, (d) both bases are fixed with a hinge at midspan of the beam, and (e) a two-bay, two-storey building frame with three fixed bases.
- (a) m = 3, j = 4, r = 6: D_s = 9 + 6 − 12 = 3; one closed loop with the ground, 3 × 1 = 3.
- (b) r = 4: D_s = 9 + 4 − 12 = 1.
- (c) The hinge adds a joint and splits the beam: m = 4, j = 5, r = 4, c = 1: D_s = 12 + 4 − 15 − 1 = 0, the determinate three-hinged frame.
- (d) m = 4, j = 5, r = 6, c = 1: D_s = 12 + 6 − 15 − 1 = 2.
- (e) Columns 3 per storey × 2 = 6, beams 2 per storey × 2 = 4, so m = 10; joints 3 base + 6 = 9; r = 3 × 3 = 9: D_s = 30 + 9 − 27 = 12. Closed loops with the ground = 4, and 3 × 4 = 12, which agrees.
Answer. (a) 3; (b) 1; (c) 0; (d) 2; (e) 12
Problem. Find the kinematic degree, with and without axial deformation, of (a) the fixed-base portal of Example 2(a), (b) the pinned-base portal of Example 2(b), (c) the two-bay, two-storey frame of Example 2(e), and (d) a three-span continuous beam fixed at the left end and on rollers at the other three supports.
- (a) j = 4, r = 6, m = 3: D_k = 12 − 6 = 6 with axial deformation (three per top joint); axially rigid D_k = 6 − 3 = 3, the two top rotations and one sway.
- (b) r = 4: D_k = 12 − 4 = 8; axially rigid 8 − 3 = 5, two base rotations, two top rotations and one sway.
- (c) j = 9, r = 9, m = 10: D_k = 27 − 9 = 18; axially rigid 18 − 10 = 8, six joint rotations and two storey sways.
- (d) j = 4, r = 3 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 6, m = 3: axially rigid D_k = 12 − 6 − 3 = 3, the rotations at the three roller supports; its static degree is r − 3 = 3 as well.
- The two-bay frame has 12 redundants but only 8 displacement unknowns, so a displacement method is shorter.
Answer. (a) 6 and 3; (b) 8 and 5; (c) 18 and 8; (d) 3 rotations
Step-by-step procedure
- Draw the line model and number the joints, including support joints and the ends of every internal hinge.
- Count m, j, r and the releases c (a hinge joining n members gives n − 1).
- Apply the right formula: m + r − 2j for trusses, 3m + r − 3j − c for frames, r − 3 − c for beams; check frames by the closed-loop count.
- For the displacement method, count D_k = 3j − r (or 2j − r for trusses), then subtract m if members are axially rigid; list the unknowns as named rotations and sways.
- Check stability separately (lesson 1.4) before using the counts to choose a method.
Site notes
- Adding a brace, infill wall or stiff partition changes the real indeterminacy of a frame and the forces in it; record such changes for the designer.
- Removing a member of a redundant truss or frame during repairs is only safe after the remaining structure has been checked as a new system with one fewer redundant.
- Support settlement and temperature produce forces only in indeterminate structures; a determinate structure simply moves, which can guide where to place movement joints.
- Hinges and expansion joints shown on drawings must be built to rotate or slide; a grouted-up joint adds a redundant that the design did not expect.
- Forgetting to count support joints in j for frames, or counting a fixed support's three reactions as two.
- Counting one release for a hinge where three members meet; it gives two.
- Using the truss formula for a rigid-jointed frame, or the reverse.
- Taking D_s = 0 as proof of stability.
- Subtracting m for axial rigidity in a truss, where axial deformation is the only deformation.
For rigid frames count closed loops: each loop (ground included) is 3 redundants, minus one per release. For a regular building frame with b bays, s storeys and fixed bases this gives 3bs, and with axially rigid members the kinematic degree is the number of non-support joints plus s sways. Valid for plane frames with rigid joints and fixed bases.
Summary
- D_s counts redundant forces; D_k counts unknown joint displacements.
- Truss D_s = m + r − 2j; frame D_s = 3m + r − 3j − c; closed loops D_s = 3C − c.
- Frame D_k = 3j − r, or 3j − r − m with axially rigid members.
- Force methods suit low D_s, displacement methods low D_k.
- Counts do not prove stability; check the arrangement.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A plane truss has 12 joints and 21 members, supported on a pin and a roller. Find D_s.
D_s = 21 + 3 − 24 = 0: statically determinate if stable.
2A truss has 8 joints and 13 members on a pin, a roller and one more roller at midspan. Find D_s.
r = 4: D_s = 13 + 4 − 16 = 1.
3Find D_s for a single-bay, two-storey frame with fixed bases.
m = 6 (4 columns, 2 beams), j = 6, r = 6: D_s = 18 + 6 − 18 = 6; two closed loops give 3 × 2 = 6.
4Find the kinematic degree of the frame in question 3 with and without axial deformation.
With axial deformation D_k = 18 − 6 = 12; axially rigid D_k = 12 − 6 = 6, four joint rotations and two sways.
5A three-hinged portal has pinned bases and a hinge at the crown. Show that it is determinate.
m = 4, j = 5, r = 4, c = 1: D_s = 12 + 4 − 15 − 1 = 0.
6Why is a displacement method usually preferred for a tall multi-bay building frame?
Its static degree (3 per closed loop) grows much faster than the number of joint rotations and storey sways, so the displacement method has fewer unknowns and is easy to program.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.