Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 8 › Lesson 8.2

8.2 Thick cylinders by Lamé's theory

Strength of Materials Chapter 8: Thin and thick cylinders Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Derive Lamé's equations σ_r = A − B/r² and σ_θ = A + B/r² for a thick cylinder from equilibrium and compatibility.
  • Find the radial, hoop and longitudinal stresses in a thick cylinder under internal and external pressure, and size the wall for an allowable hoop stress.
  • Judge when the thin-cylinder formula is adequate and when it is unsafe, for jacks, high-pressure pipes and pressure tunnel linings.

Theory

When the wall is thick, roughly t above d/20, the hoop stress is no longer uniform through the wall: it is largest at the inner face and smaller at the outer face, and the radial stress, from −p at the inside to the outside pressure, is no longer negligible. Hydraulic jacks for post-tensioning and bridge lifting, high-pressure grout and test lines, pressure shafts and concrete linings of pressure tunnels are thick cylinders. Lamé's theory gives the stresses at every radius. Sign convention as in Chapter 7: tension positive, so a pressure is a negative radial stress.

Consider a thin ring of the wall between radii r and r + dr. The hoop stress σ_θ acts on its cut ends, and the radial stress σ_r acts on its inner and outer faces with slightly different values. Equilibrium of this ring gives one equation linking σ_r and σ_θ. A second relation comes from the deformation: if a cross-section far from the ends stays plane, the longitudinal strain ε_z is the same at every radius, and with a uniform longitudinal stress this makes σ_r + σ_θ the same at every radius. Together these give Lamé's equations σ_r = A − B/r² and σ_θ = A + B/r², with the constants A and B fixed by the pressures on the two faces.

pabrab0σθ = A + B/r²σr = A − B/r²: −p at a, 0 at bIndiacon original
Figure 8.2: Thick cylinder under internal pressure: hoop stress largest at the bore and radial stress from −p at the bore to zero outside (Lamé), not to scale. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For internal pressure p alone on a cylinder of inner radius a and outer radius b, A = pa²/(b² − a²) and B = pa²b²/(b² − a²). The hoop stress is tensile everywhere and largest at the inner face, σ_θ(a) = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²). The radial stress goes from −p at the inner face to zero at the outer face. With closed ends the longitudinal stress is uniform and equal to A. The shear stress is largest at the inner face, (σ_θ − σ_r)/2 = pb²/(b² − a²).

Adding wall thickness helps less and less. As b grows very large the inner hoop stress falls only towards p itself, so a single cylinder can never carry a pressure above its allowable hoop stress however thick it is. For very high pressures, engineers use compound cylinders, one shrunk onto another, or pre-yielding of the bore (autofrettage), both of which lock compressive hoop stress into the inner layer. For moderate thickness, the thin formula with the mean diameter gives a hoop stress close to the Lamé inner-face value, but the thin formula with the inner diameter can be well on the unsafe side.

Derivation

  1. Ring element of unit length between r and r + dr, angle dφ: radial equilibrium gives (σ_r + dσ_r)(r + dr)dφ − σ_r r dφ − 2σ_θ dr sin(dφ/2) = 0, which simplifies to dσ_r/dr + (σ_r − σ_θ)/r = 0.
  2. Compatibility: plane sections remain plane, so ε_z = [σ_z − ν(σ_r + σ_θ)]/E is constant; with σ_z uniform, σ_r + σ_θ = 2A, a constant.
  3. Substitute σ_θ = 2A − σ_r: dσ_r/dr + 2(σ_r − A)/r = 0, so r² dσ_r/dr + 2rσ_r = 2Ar, i.e. d(r²σ_r)/dr = 2Ar.
  4. Integrate: r²σ_r = Ar² − B, so σ_r = A − B/r² and σ_θ = A + B/r² (Lamé's equations).
  5. Boundary conditions σ_r(a) = −p_i and σ_r(b) = −p_o give A = (p_i a² − p_o b²)/(b² − a²) and B = (p_i − p_o)a²b²/(b² − a²).
  6. Internal pressure only: σ_θ(a) = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²), σ_θ(b) = 2pa²/(b² − a²); closed ends: σ_z × π(b² − a²) = p πa², so σ_z = pa²/(b² − a²) = A.
  7. Thickness for an allowable hoop stress σ (internal pressure only): σ = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²) gives b/a = √[(σ + p)/(σ − p)], which exists only if p < σ.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • σ_r = A − B/r², σ_θ = A + B/r²; σ_r + σ_θ = 2A at every radius
  • A = (p_i a² − p_o b²)/(b² − a²), B = (p_i − p_o)a²b²/(b² − a²)
  • Internal pressure only: σ_θ,max = σ_θ(a) = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²); σ_θ(b) = 2pa²/(b² − a²); τ_max = pb²/(b² − a²) at r = a
  • Closed ends: σ_z = p_i a²/(b² − a²) (internal pressure only)
  • External pressure only: σ_θ(a) = −2p_o b²/(b² − a²) (largest compression, at the inner face)
  • Wall for allowable hoop stress σ: b/a = √[(σ + p)/(σ − p)]
  • Units: p and σ in N/mm²; radii a, b, r in mm (or any one consistent length unit)
Assumptions and limits
  • Long cylinder, sections far from the ends, which remain plane (constant longitudinal strain).
  • Homogeneous, isotropic, linear elastic material; stresses below yield.
  • Uniform pressures on the inner and outer faces; axisymmetric geometry and loading.
  • Small deformations; body forces such as self-weight neglected.
  • Limits: near end caps, nozzles and supports local bending adds stresses; external pressure on fairly thin walls can cause buckling before the Lamé stresses reach the strength; concrete linings crack in tension and then the rock or reinforcement shares the load, which elastic Lamé stresses do not capture.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Lamé's equations are mechanics; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • High-pressure pipes, jacks and pressure vessels are designed in Indian, European and American practice to the pressure vessel, pipeline or equipment code named in the project specification, and pressure tunnel linings to the owner's tunnel design criteria; their safety factors and limits are not reproduced here.
  • Side by side, not ranked: the thick-wall stress distribution used in all three practices is the Lamé solution shown in this lesson.

Worked examples

Example 1 (cylinder of a post-tensioning jack)

Problem. The steel cylinder of a hydraulic post-tensioning jack has an internal diameter of 100 mm and an external diameter of 150 mm, and works at an oil pressure of 40 N/mm². Find the hoop stresses at the inner and outer faces, the maximum shear stress, the longitudinal stress with closed ends, and compare with the thin-cylinder formula.

  1. a = 50 mm, b = 75 mm; b² − a² = 5625 − 2500 = 3125 mm².
  2. A = 40 × 2500/3125 = 32 N/mm²; B = 40 × 2500 × 5625/3125 = 180 000 N.
  3. σ_θ(a) = 32 + 180 000/2500 = 104 N/mm²; σ_θ(b) = 32 + 180 000/5625 = 64 N/mm²; σ_r(a) = −40, σ_r(b) = 0.
  4. τ_max at the bore = (104 + 40)/2 = 72 N/mm²; σ_z = A = 32 N/mm².
  5. Thin formula: with the inner diameter 40 × 100/(2 × 25) = 80 N/mm² (23 per cent low, unsafe); with the mean diameter 40 × 125/50 = 100 N/mm².

Answer. σ_θ = 104 N/mm² at the bore and 64 N/mm² outside; τ_max = 72 N/mm²; σ_z = 32 N/mm²; thin formula with inner diameter 80 N/mm² (unsafe)

Example 2 (wall thickness of a high-pressure rock-anchor test line)

Problem. A steel pressure cylinder used for testing rock anchors has a bore of 200 mm and a working pressure of 30 N/mm². The allowable hoop stress is 90 N/mm². Find the wall thickness by Lamé's theory and compare with the thin-cylinder result.

  1. a = 100 mm; b/a = √[(90 + 30)/(90 − 30)] = √2 = 1.414.
  2. b = 141.4 mm, so t = b − a = 41.4 mm.
  3. Check: σ_θ(a) = 30 × (141.4² + 100²)/(141.4² − 100²) = 30 × 30 000/10 000 = 90 N/mm².
  4. Thin formula with the inner diameter: t = pd/(2σ) = 30 × 200/180 = 33.3 mm, which would overstress the bore.
  5. Outer-face hoop stress with t = 41.4 mm: 2 × 30 × 100²/10 000 = 60 N/mm².

Answer. t = 41.4 mm by Lamé (thin formula 33.3 mm, unsafe)

Example 3 (concrete lining of a pressure tunnel)

Problem. A circular pressure tunnel of a hydropower scheme has a concrete lining with inner radius 2.0 m and outer radius 2.4 m. In operation the internal water pressure is 0.5 N/mm² and the groundwater pressure outside is 0.2 N/mm². Taking the lining alone (no help from the rock), find the hoop stresses at both faces in operation and at the inner face when the tunnel is emptied.

  1. b² − a² = 5.76 − 4.00 = 1.76 m². A = (0.5 × 4.00 − 0.2 × 5.76)/1.76 = 0.482 N/mm²; B = 0.3 × 4.00 × 5.76/1.76 = 3.927 N/mm² × m².
  2. σ_θ(a) = 0.482 + 3.927/4.00 = 1.464 N/mm² (tension); σ_θ(b) = 0.482 + 3.927/5.76 = 1.164 N/mm²; check σ_r(a) = −0.5, σ_r(b) = −0.2.
  3. With the internal pressure alone σ_θ(a) would be 0.5 × 9.76/1.76 = 2.77 N/mm²; the outside water pressure reduces it by almost half.
  4. Tunnel emptied, external 0.2 N/mm² only: σ_θ(a) = −2 × 0.2 × 5.76/1.76 = −1.31 N/mm² (compression).
  5. A tensile hoop stress of this size can crack plain concrete, so in practice the rock is made to share the pressure (contact and consolidation grouting) or the lining is reinforced or steel-lined; the Lamé value shows how much load the lining alone would see.

Answer. Operation σ_θ = 1.46 N/mm² at the inner face and 1.16 N/mm² at the outer face; emptied −1.31 N/mm²

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Collect the radii a and b and the internal and external pressures (with closed or open ends).
  2. Check thickness: if t > about d/20, use Lamé rather than the thin formula.
  3. Find A and B from the two boundary conditions on σ_r.
  4. Compute σ_r and σ_θ at the inner and outer faces (and σ_z for closed ends), then the maximum shear at the bore.
  5. Check the critical (inner) point with a theory of failure from lesson 7.5, or size b from b/a = √[(σ + p)/(σ − p)].

Site notes

  • Post-tensioning and lifting jacks are proof-tested by their maker; on site, never exceed the rated pressure, keep gauges calibrated and keep people out of line with the jack.
  • High-pressure hoses and grout lines should be restrained; a burst releases stored energy suddenly.
  • Pressure tunnel linings rely on tight contact with sound rock; contact and consolidation grouting behind the lining is what makes the rock share the internal pressure.
  • When a pressure tunnel or shaft is emptied quickly, external groundwater pressure is no longer balanced, and linings and steel liners must be checked for that case, including buckling of steel liners.
Common mistakes
  • Using the thin formula with the inner diameter for a thick wall, which underestimates the bore hoop stress.
  • Using the outer-face hoop stress as the maximum; the bore is the critical point.
  • Taking the radial stress as zero at the inner face; it equals −p there.
  • Thinking that a thicker wall can carry any pressure; the bore hoop stress never falls below p.
  • Getting the sign of B wrong for external pressure, which makes the hoop stress tensile instead of compressive.
Quick check

In a thick cylinder the bore is critical: σ_θ(a) = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²) and σ_r(a) = −p; σ_r + σ_θ is the same at every radius.

Summary

  • Thick walls (t > about d/20) have hoop stress varying through the wall and significant radial stress.
  • Lamé: σ_r = A − B/r², σ_θ = A + B/r², from ring equilibrium and constant longitudinal strain.
  • Internal pressure: hoop stress largest at the bore, p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²); closed-end longitudinal stress pa²/(b² − a²).
  • External pressure causes compressive hoop stress, largest at the bore, −2p_o b²/(b² − a²).
  • The bore hoop stress cannot fall below p; very high pressures need compound or pre-stressed cylinders.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A thick cylinder has a = 60 mm, b = 100 mm and internal pressure 50 N/mm². Find the hoop stress at the bore and outer face and the maximum shear.

b² − a² = 6400; σ_θ(a) = 50 × 13 600/6400 = 106.25 N/mm²; σ_θ(b) = 50 × 7200/6400 = 56.25 N/mm²; τ_max = (106.25 + 50)/2 = 78.1 N/mm².

2Find the ratio b/a for an internal pressure of 40 N/mm² and an allowable hoop stress of 100 N/mm².

b/a = √(140/60) = 1.528.

3For the cylinder of question 1, what is σ_r + σ_θ at any radius, and what is the closed-end longitudinal stress?

σ_r + σ_θ = 2A = 2 × 50 × 3600/6400 = 56.25 N/mm² everywhere; σ_z = A = 28.1 N/mm².

4Why can a single thick cylinder never carry an internal pressure above its allowable hoop stress?

σ_θ(a) = p(b² + a²)/(b² − a²) is always greater than p and tends to p as b becomes very large, so p must be less than the allowable stress.

5a = 100 mm, b = 110 mm, p = 10 N/mm². Compare the Lamé bore hoop stress with the thin formula using the mean diameter.

Lamé: 10 × (12 100 + 10 000)/2100 = 105.2 N/mm². Thin, mean diameter 210 mm, t = 10 mm: 10 × 210/20 = 105.0 N/mm², within 0.3 per cent.

6A cylinder with a = 50 mm and b = 100 mm carries an external pressure of 20 N/mm² only. Find the hoop stress at the bore.

σ_θ(a) = −2 × 20 × 10 000/7500 = −53.3 N/mm² (compression).

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.