Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 3 › Lesson 3.4

3.4 Introduction to unsymmetrical bending

Strength of Materials Chapter 3: Bending stresses Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Recognise when bending is unsymmetrical: the plane of the loads does not contain a principal axis of the cross-section, or the section has no axis of symmetry at all.
  • Resolve a bending moment into components about the principal axes, add the two bending stresses, and locate the inclined neutral axis of a doubly symmetric section.
  • Find the product of inertia and the principal second moments of area of an angle section, and use the general bending formula to find the true extreme stresses.

Theory

Lesson 3.1 assumed that the loads act in a plane of symmetry of the section. Then the beam bends in that same plane, the neutral axis is perpendicular to it, and σ = M y/I is the whole story. Many real members break that assumption. A purlin sits on a sloping roof, so the vertical roof load acts at an angle to the purlin's own axes. A steel angle used as a lintel has no axis of symmetry in the vertical plane. A beam erected slightly out of plumb sees its load a few degrees off its web. In all these cases the bending is called unsymmetrical, or skew.

Every cross-section, whatever its shape, has two perpendicular axes through its centroid about which the product of inertia I_xy = ∫x y dA is zero. These are the principal axes, and the second moments of area about them, I_u and I_v, are the largest and smallest values for any centroidal axis. An axis of symmetry is always a principal axis, which is why symmetric sections are easy. A moment acting about a principal axis makes the beam bend about that same axis. A moment about any other axis makes it bend about both principal axes at once, and the beam deflects partly sideways.

roof slope 30°wneutral axisCTM_x = M cos θ (strong axis)M_y = M sin θ (weak axis)σ = M_x/Z_x + M_y/Z_ytan β = (I_x/I_y) tan θβ > θ: neutral axis swingstowards the weak axisIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 3.4: Unsymmetrical bending of a purlin: the vertical load is resolved onto the strong and weak axes, the two bending stresses add at opposite corners, and the neutral axis tilts more steeply than the load. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The method follows from superposition. Resolve the applied moment into components about the two principal axes, find the bending stress from each component with the simple bending formula, and add them with their signs. The neutral axis is the line where this sum is zero. It is no longer perpendicular to the plane of the loads; it swings towards the weak axis of the section, because the section is more flexible about that axis. For a deep, narrow section a small tilt of the load can raise the extreme stress a lot, since the weak-axis section modulus is small.

When the centroidal axes chosen are not principal, for example the horizontal and vertical axes of an angle, there are two equivalent routes. Either find the principal axes and resolve the moment onto them, or use the general bending formula that works directly with I_x, I_y and I_xy. Both give the same stresses. The common error is to treat an angle as if it bent about its horizontal axis and use σ = M y/I_x; this can understate the peak stress and even put tension and compression on the wrong fibres. Unsymmetrical bending also raises the question of where the load must act so that the beam bends without twisting; that point is the shear centre of lesson 4.3.

Derivation

  1. Take centroidal axes x (horizontal) and y (vertical) and assume plane sections remain plane, so the bending stress in a linear elastic beam is a linear function of position: σ = a + b x + c y, with tension taken as positive.
  2. Axial equilibrium, ∫σ dA = a A + b ∫x dA + c ∫y dA = a A = 0, because x and y pass through the centroid. So a = 0 and σ = b x + c y.
  3. Define the moment components as M_x = ∫σ y dA and M_y = ∫σ x dA. Substituting gives M_x = b I_xy + c I_x and M_y = b I_y + c I_xy, where I_x = ∫y² dA, I_y = ∫x² dA and I_xy = ∫x y dA.
  4. Solving the two equations: c = (M_x I_y − M_y I_xy)/(I_x I_y − I_xy²) and b = (M_y I_x − M_x I_xy)/(I_x I_y − I_xy²). Hence σ = [(M_x I_y − M_y I_xy) y + (M_y I_x − M_x I_xy) x]/(I_x I_y − I_xy²), the general bending formula.
  5. If the axes are principal (I_xy = 0) it reduces to σ = M_x y/I_x + M_y x/I_y: two simple bending stresses added. The neutral axis, σ = 0, is the line y = −(M_y I_x)/(M_x I_y) x.
  6. For a doubly symmetric section carrying a moment M whose vector is inclined at θ to the x axis, the components have magnitudes M cos θ and M sin θ, and the neutral axis makes an angle β with the x axis given by tan β = (I_x/I_y) tan θ. Because I_x > I_y for a deep section, β > θ: the neutral axis swings towards the weak axis.
  7. Principal values come from the transformation of I with axis rotation: I_u, I_v = (I_x + I_y)/2 ± √{[(I_x − I_y)/2]² + I_xy²}, with the principal direction at tan 2θ_p = −2 I_xy/(I_x − I_y), measured anticlockwise from the x axis. For an equal angle I_x = I_y, so the principal axes are at 45° and I_u, I_v = I_x ± |I_xy|.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Product of inertia: I_xy = ∫x y dA (mm⁴); zero about any axis of symmetry
  • Principal values: I_u, I_v = (I_x + I_y)/2 ± √{[(I_x − I_y)/2]² + I_xy²} (mm⁴)
  • Principal direction: tan 2θ_p = −2 I_xy/(I_x − I_y)
  • Principal or doubly symmetric axes: σ = M_x y/I_x + M_y x/I_y (N/mm²)
  • General formula (any centroidal axes): σ = [(M_x I_y − M_y I_xy) y + (M_y I_x − M_x I_xy) x]/(I_x I_y − I_xy²)
  • Neutral axis of a doubly symmetric section: tan β = (I_x/I_y) tan θ
  • Hand check with section moduli: σ_max = M_x/Z_x + M_y/Z_y for a rectangle or I-section (the two peaks meet at a corner)
  • Units: M in N·mm, I in mm⁴, x and y in mm, σ in N/mm²; sign convention in the general formula: tension positive, M_x = ∫σ y dA, M_y = ∫σ x dA
Assumptions and limits
  • All the assumptions of simple bending in lesson 3.1 hold: linear elastic, homogeneous material, plane sections remain plane, small deflections and slender proportions.
  • Loads pass through the shear centre of the section, so the member bends without twisting; a load applied elsewhere adds torsion, which is outside this lesson.
  • The member is restrained against lateral-torsional buckling, or the stresses are low enough that buckling does not govern.
  • Section properties are those of the idealised shape; root fillets, toe rounding and rolling tolerances of real rolled sections change the values slightly, so design uses tabulated properties.
  • Limits: the method gives elastic stresses only. It does not cover yielding of the outer fibres, thin-walled sections that warp under torsion, or curved members.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Unsymmetrical bending is mechanics and is not set by any design code; the formulas in this lesson are the elastic basis that codes build on.
  • Steel design in IS 800:2007 checks members bent about both axes with an interaction of the two moment ratios; for the bending strength about one axis it uses the section moduli of lesson 3.2, cl. 8.2.1.2.
  • Side by side, not ranked: EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 also check biaxial bending with interaction expressions of the moment ratios about the two principal axes.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: purlin on a sloping roof)

Problem. A timber purlin 100 mm wide and 150 mm deep spans 3 m between rafters on a roof sloping at 30°. Its depth is set perpendicular to the roof slope. It carries a vertical load of 1.2 kN/m. Find the maximum bending stress and the inclination of the neutral axis, and compare with the stress if the load acted in the plane of the depth.

  1. M = wL²/8 = 1.2 × 3²/8 = 1.35 kN·m about a horizontal axis.
  2. The section axes are tilted 30° to the horizontal, so the components are M_x = 1.35 cos 30° = 1.169 kN·m about the strong axis and M_y = 1.35 sin 30° = 0.675 kN·m about the weak axis.
  3. Z_x = 100 × 150²/6 = 3.75 × 10⁵ mm³ and Z_y = 150 × 100²/6 = 2.50 × 10⁵ mm³.
  4. σ_max = 1.169 × 10⁶/3.75 × 10⁵ + 0.675 × 10⁶/2.50 × 10⁵ = 3.12 + 2.70 = 5.82 N/mm², at two opposite corners (one in tension, one in compression).
  5. Load in the plane of the depth: σ = 1.35 × 10⁶/3.75 × 10⁵ = 3.60 N/mm². The 30° tilt raises the peak stress by about 62%.
  6. Neutral axis: I_x = 2.8125 × 10⁷ mm⁴, I_y = 1.25 × 10⁷ mm⁴, tan β = (I_x/I_y) tan 30° = 2.25 × 0.577 = 1.299, β = 52.4° from the strong axis, far more than the 30° tilt of the load.

Answer. σ_max = 5.82 N/mm² (3.60 if the load were in the plane of the depth); neutral axis at 52.4° to the strong axis

Example 2 (site style: a beam erected out of plumb)

Problem. The welded I-section of lesson 3.2 (flanges 200 × 20 mm, web 360 × 10 mm, overall depth 400 mm) carries a sagging moment of 150 kN·m. Because of an erection error, its web is 5° out of vertical. Find the extreme bending stress and compare it with the stress in the plumb beam.

  1. I_x = (200 × 400³ − 190 × 360³)/12 = 3.279 × 10⁸ mm⁴. I_y = 2 × 20 × 200³/12 + 360 × 10³/12 = 2.670 × 10⁷ mm⁴, about 12 times smaller.
  2. Components: M_x = 150 cos 5° = 149.4 kN·m and M_y = 150 sin 5° = 13.07 kN·m.
  3. σ from M_x at the flange edge: 149.4 × 10⁶ × 200/3.279 × 10⁸ = 91.1 N/mm². σ from M_y at the flange tip (x = 100 mm): 13.07 × 10⁶ × 100/2.670 × 10⁷ = 49.0 N/mm².
  4. At the flange tip where both are of the same sign: σ = 91.1 + 49.0 = 140.1 N/mm².
  5. Plumb beam: σ = 150 × 10⁶ × 200/3.279 × 10⁸ = 91.5 N/mm². A 5° tilt raises the peak stress by about 53%, and the neutral axis tilts by tan⁻¹(12.28 × tan 5°) = 47.1°.

Answer. σ_max = 140.1 N/mm² against 91.5 N/mm² when plumb

Example 3 (angle lintel: the product of inertia matters)

Problem. An equal angle 100 × 100 × 10 mm (idealised as two rectangles with no root fillet: one leg 100 × 10 mm horizontal at the bottom, the other 10 × 90 mm standing on it at the left) spans as a lintel and carries a sagging moment of 2 kN·m from vertical loads. Find the section properties and the true extreme stresses, and compare with the naive σ = M y/I_x.

  1. Area A = 1000 + 900 = 1900 mm². Centroid from the outer faces: x̄ = ȳ = (1000 × 50 + 900 × 5)/1900 = 28.68 mm.
  2. I_x = I_y = 1.800 × 10⁶ mm⁴ (parallel axis theorem for both rectangles). I_xy = Σ A x_c y_c = 1000 × (21.32)(−23.68) + 900 × (−23.68)(26.32) = −1.066 × 10⁶ mm⁴.
  3. Principal axes are at 45°: I_u = 1.800 + 1.066 = 2.866 × 10⁶ mm⁴ and I_v = 1.800 − 1.066 = 0.734 × 10⁶ mm⁴.
  4. Sign convention of the general formula: sagging gives tension below the centroid, so M_x = −2 × 10⁶ N·mm and M_y = 0. Then σ = (M_x I_y y − M_x I_xy x)/(I_x I_y − I_xy²) with x, y measured from the centroid.
  5. Heel (outer corner, x = y = −28.68 mm): σ = +78.1 N/mm² (tension). Top of the vertical leg, inner face (x = −18.68, y = 71.32 mm): σ = −103.1 N/mm² (compression). Tip of the horizontal leg, bottom face (x = 71.32, y = −28.68 mm): σ = −23.2 N/mm², in compression even though it is below the centroid.
  6. Naive σ = M y/I_x would give 31.9 N/mm² tension along the whole bottom face and 79.2 N/mm² compression at the top: the peak compression is underestimated by about 23%, the peak tension by more than half, and the sign at the toe of the horizontal leg is wrong. The neutral axis is inclined at about 30.6° to the horizontal.

Answer. I_u = 2.866 × 10⁶, I_v = 0.734 × 10⁶ mm⁴; peaks +78.1 N/mm² at the heel and −103.1 N/mm² at the top of the vertical leg

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Locate the centroid and choose centroidal axes; for a symmetric section take them along the axes of symmetry.
  2. Find I_x, I_y and I_xy. If I_xy = 0 the axes are principal; otherwise find the principal axes and I_u, I_v, or plan to use the general formula.
  3. Resolve the applied moment into components about the chosen axes, keeping signs to a stated convention.
  4. Compute the stress at every corner or extreme point of the section by superposition or by the general formula; the peaks are where the neutral axis is farthest away.
  5. Locate the neutral axis (σ = 0) to see which fibres are in tension and which in compression.
  6. Check that the load passes through the shear centre; if not, add the effect of torsion or provide restraint.
  7. Compare the peak stresses with the permissible or design values, or use the code interaction check for biaxial bending.

Site notes

  • Purlins on sloping roofs bend about both axes. Sag rods or ties between purlins at mid-span or third points cut the weak-axis span and the weak-axis moment, which is why they appear on most industrial sheds.
  • A beam set even a few degrees out of plumb picks up a weak-axis moment; check verticality of webs at erection and do not leave temporary packing that tilts the member.
  • Angle lintels over openings deflect sideways as well as down if they are not restrained; tie them into the masonry or use them in pairs back to back.
  • Hollow circular and square box sections bend equally well in all directions, so they are preferred for poles, masts and members whose load direction changes, such as sign gantries under wind.
Common mistakes
  • Using σ = M y/I_x for an angle or Z-section, ignoring the product of inertia.
  • Adding the stresses from the two moment components at different corners instead of at the same point.
  • Assuming the neutral axis is perpendicular to the plane of loading.
  • Forgetting that a deep, narrow section is very weak about its minor axis, so a small tilt of the load matters.
  • Mixing sign conventions between I_xy and the moment components in the general formula.
Quick check

For a rectangle or I-section bent about both axes, σ_max = M_x/Z_x + M_y/Z_y at a corner. If a hand result for an angle or Z-section agrees with σ = M y/I_x, the product of inertia has probably been ignored. Valid for linear elastic beams loaded through the shear centre.

Summary

  • Bending is unsymmetrical when the moment does not act about a principal axis of the section.
  • Principal axes have zero product of inertia; axes of symmetry are always principal.
  • Resolve the moment onto the principal axes and add the two bending stresses, or use the general formula with I_x, I_y and I_xy.
  • The neutral axis tilts towards the weak axis, so peak stresses can be much higher than in symmetric bending.
  • Angles and Z-sections need the product of inertia; ignoring it gives wrong peaks and even wrong signs.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A timber beam 80 mm wide and 160 mm deep carries M_x = 3 kN·m about its strong axis and M_y = 1 kN·m about its weak axis at the same section. Find the maximum bending stress.

Z_x = 80 × 160²/6 = 3.413 × 10⁵ mm³, Z_y = 160 × 80²/6 = 1.707 × 10⁵ mm³. σ_max = 3 × 10⁶/3.413 × 10⁵ + 1 × 10⁶/1.707 × 10⁵ = 8.79 + 5.86 = 14.65 N/mm² at a corner.

2For the beam in question 1, find the angle of the neutral axis to the strong axis.

tan θ = M_y/M_x = 1/3; I_x/I_y = (160/80)² = 4; tan β = 4 × 1/3 = 1.333, β = 53.1°.

3What is the product of inertia of a rectangle about its centroidal axes parallel to its sides, and why?

Zero. Each axis is an axis of symmetry, so for every element at (x, y) there is a matching element at (−x, y) and the products x y cancel.

4A section has I_x = I_y = 1.8 × 10⁶ mm⁴ and I_xy = −1.06 × 10⁶ mm⁴ about its centroidal axes. Find the principal second moments of area and the direction of the principal axes.

I_u, I_v = 1.8 ± 1.06 = 2.86 × 10⁶ and 0.74 × 10⁶ mm⁴. With I_x = I_y, tan 2θ_p is infinite, so the principal axes are at 45° to x and y.

5A solid circular steel post of 100 mm diameter carries bending moments of 3 kN·m and 4 kN·m about two perpendicular axes. Find the maximum bending stress.

Every diameter of a circle is a principal axis, so combine the moments first: M = √(3² + 4²) = 5 kN·m. σ = 32 M/(π d³) = 32 × 5 × 10⁶/(π × 100³) = 50.9 N/mm².

6Why are sag rods fitted between purlins on a sloping roof?

The roof load has a component parallel to the slope that bends the purlin about its weak axis. Sag rods give the purlin intermediate support in that direction, cutting the weak-axis span and moment and so the combined peak stress and sideways deflection.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.