Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.5

2.5 Points of contraflexure

Strength of Materials Chapter 2: Shear force and bending moment Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Define a point of contraflexure and tell it apart from a point where the moment is merely zero, such as a simple support or a free end.
  • Locate the points of contraflexure of overhanging beams by solving M(x) = 0, and use the standard locations for fixed and propped beams under a uniform load.
  • Explain why these points matter for bar curtailment, laps and splices, and for approximate analysis of frames.

Theory

A point of contraflexure is a section where the bending moment changes sign, from sagging to hogging or the reverse. At that section the moment is zero, but a zero moment alone is not enough: at a simple support or a free end the moment is zero without changing sign, and those points are not called points of contraflexure. The word describes the curvature of the beam, which follows the moment, so the deflected shape changes from concave upward to concave downward there.

Because curvature is proportional to bending moment (lesson 3.1 shows that 1/R = M/EI), a point of contraflexure on the BMD is a point of inflection on the deflected shape. The two terms are often used as if they were the same, which is correct for a prismatic beam. Simply supported beams and cantilevers with all loads acting downward have moment of one sign everywhere and so have no point of contraflexure. They appear in overhanging beams, propped cantilevers, fixed beams, continuous beams and frames, wherever part of the member hogs over a support and part sags in the span.

ABCdeflected shapepoint of contraflexuresagginghoggingIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 2.5: Point of contraflexure: the bending moment changes sign and the deflected shape changes curvature at the same section. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For a determinate overhanging beam the points are found exactly by writing M(x) for the span and solving M(x) = 0. For indeterminate beams the moments come from structural analysis, but a few results are worth remembering: a propped cantilever with a uniform load has its point of contraflexure at L/4 from the fixed end, and a beam fixed at both ends with a uniform load has two, at 0.211L from each end. In the approximate analysis of building frames under lateral load (the portal and cantilever methods) points of contraflexure are assumed at mid-height of columns and mid-span of beams, which makes the frame statically determinate.

On site the point of contraflexure is where hogging steel at the top of an RCC beam can begin to stop and where the bottom steel takes over, so codes fix how far bars must run past it. In steel and timber, splices placed near a point of contraflexure carry little moment and are cheaper to make. In precast and composite work, joints are often placed near these points for the same reason. Locating them correctly is therefore not just an exam exercise.

Derivation

  1. Overhanging beam: supports A and B a distance L apart, overhang a beyond B, uniform load w over the whole length L + a.
  2. Moments about B: R_A L = wL²/2 − wa²/2, so R_A = w(L² − a²)/(2L).
  3. In the span, M(x) = R_A x − wx²/2. Setting M = 0 (x ≠ 0): x = 2R_A/w = (L² − a²)/L from A.
  4. Check against lesson 2.3, Example 3 (L = 6 m, a = 2 m): x = (36 − 4)/6 = 5.333 m, as found there.
  5. Fixed-ended beam with uniform load (end moments −wL²/12 from structural analysis): M(x) = wLx/2 − wx²/2 − wL²/12.
  6. Setting M = 0: x² − Lx + L²/6 = 0, so x = L/2 ± L/(2√3) = 0.2113L and 0.7887L.
  7. Propped cantilever, fixed at A and propped at B, uniform load (prop reaction 3wL/8 from structural analysis): measuring x from B, M = 3wLx/8 − wx²/2, zero at x = 3L/4, that is L/4 from the fixed end. The largest sagging moment is 9wL²/128 at 3L/8 from the prop.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Point of contraflexure: M = 0 and M changes sign
  • Overhang a beyond a span L, UDL w over L + a: x = (L² − a²)/L from the far support
  • Equal overhangs a each side of span L, UDL over L + 2a: M at x from a support = w(L + 2a)x/2 − w(x + a)²/2
  • Fixed-fixed beam, UDL: x = 0.2113L and 0.7887L; end moment −wL²/12; mid-span moment +wL²/24
  • Propped cantilever, UDL: x = L/4 from the fixed end; fixed-end moment −wL²/8; max sagging 9wL²/128 at 3L/8 from the prop
  • Units: m, kN, kN/m, kN·m
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic, prismatic members, so the point of inflection of the deflected shape coincides with the point of contraflexure.
  • Small deflections.
  • For fixed and propped beams the supports are perfectly rigid and unyielding; any rotation or settlement of a support moves the points of contraflexure.
  • The loading is the one fixed arrangement analysed; under moving or pattern loading the points move, and design uses the range of positions.
  • The fixed-beam and propped-cantilever results are taken from indeterminate analysis, treated in the structural analysis subject.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 26.2.3.4: at least one-third of the tension reinforcement provided for negative moment at a support shall extend beyond the point of inflection for a distance not less than the effective depth of the member, 12 times the bar diameter, or one-sixteenth of the clear span, whichever is greatest.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 26.2.3.3 (c) also limits the diameter of positive-moment bars at simple supports and at points of inflection through the development length check L_d ≤ M₁/V + L₀ at a point of inflection, where L₀ there is the greater of the effective depth and 12 times the bar diameter.
  • Side by side, not ranked: ACI 318 has a provision with the same three limits (d, 12 bar diameters and one-sixteenth of the clear span) for negative-moment bars beyond the point of inflection; EN 1992-1-1 handles curtailment through a shifted moment envelope instead of a named rule at the point of inflection.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style: span with one overhang and a tip load)

Problem. A beam ABC is simply supported at A and B, 5 m apart, and overhangs 1.5 m beyond B to a free end C. It carries 8 kN/m over AB only and a 20 kN point load at C. Find the reactions, the largest sagging and hogging moments, and the point of contraflexure.

  1. Moments about A: R_B × 5 = 8 × 5 × 2.5 + 20 × 6.5 = 100 + 130 = 230, so R_B = 46 kN; R_A = 40 + 20 − 46 = 14 kN.
  2. In AB: V = 14 − 8x and M = 14x − 4x².
  3. Zero shear at x = 1.75 m: largest sagging moment = 14 × 1.75 − 4 × 1.75² = 24.5 − 12.25 = 12.25 kN·m.
  4. Hogging moment over B: M_B = 14 × 5 − 4 × 25 = −30 kN·m (check from C: −20 × 1.5 = −30 kN·m).
  5. M = 0 in the span where 14x − 4x² = 0, so x = 3.5 m from A. The moment changes sign there, so this is the point of contraflexure. (M = 0 at A and C too, but without a change of sign.)

Answer. R_A = 14 kN, R_B = 46 kN; +12.25 kN·m at 1.75 m; −30 kN·m at B; contraflexure 3.5 m from A

Example 2 (exam style: equal overhangs)

Problem. A beam 10 m long rests on two supports placed 2 m in from each end and carries 10 kN/m over its whole length. Find the support and mid-span moments and the positions of the points of contraflexure.

  1. By symmetry each reaction = 10 × 10/2 = 50 kN.
  2. Moment over each support = −10 × 2²/2 = −20 kN·m (hogging).
  3. Mid-span moment = 50 × 3 − 10 × 5²/2 = 150 − 125 = 25 kN·m (sagging); this equals wL²/8 − wa²/2 = 45 − 20 = 25 kN·m.
  4. With x measured from the left support into the 6 m span: M = 50x − 5(x + 2)² = −5x² + 30x − 20.
  5. M = 0 gives x² − 6x + 4 = 0, so x = 3 ± √5 = 0.764 m and 5.236 m from the left support, 4.472 m apart and symmetric about mid-span.

Answer. Support moments −20 kN·m; mid-span +25 kN·m; contraflexure 0.764 m inside each support

Example 3 (site style: top bars of a fixed-ended RCC beam)

Problem. An RCC beam of clear span 6 m is cast monolithically with stiff columns and may be treated as fixed at both ends. It carries a factored uniform load of 25 kN/m. Using the fixed-beam results, find the end and mid-span moments and the points of contraflexure, and the minimum extension of the continuing top bars past those points if the effective depth is 450 mm and the bars are 16 mm.

  1. End moments = −wL²/12 = −25 × 36/12 = −75 kN·m; mid-span moment = +wL²/24 = 25 × 36/24 = 37.5 kN·m.
  2. Points of contraflexure at 0.2113L = 0.2113 × 6 = 1.268 m from each support.
  3. Check: M(1.268) = 25 × 6 × 1.268/2 − 25 × 1.268²/2 − 75 = 95.1 − 20.1 − 75 ≈ 0.
  4. Extension beyond the point of inflection (IS 456:2000 cl. 26.2.3.4) = greatest of d = 450 mm, 12 × 16 = 192 mm and 6000/16 = 375 mm, so 450 mm.
  5. At least one-third of the top bars at each support must therefore run at least 1.268 + 0.45 = 1.72 m from the support (measured on the span, before adding any anchorage into the column).

Answer. −75 kN·m at the ends, +37.5 kN·m at mid-span; contraflexure 1.268 m from each end; continuing top bars to at least 1.72 m

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Draw the BMD (lessons 2.2 to 2.4) and look for any change of sign.
  2. For each segment that changes sign, write M(x) and solve M(x) = 0 for roots inside that segment.
  3. Reject roots at simple supports or free ends where the sign does not change.
  4. Report each point of contraflexure by its distance from a named support.
  5. For indeterminate beams, take the moments from analysis, then apply the same steps.
  6. Use the positions for detailing: curtailment and extension of top and bottom bars, lap and splice positions.

Site notes

  • Top bars over supports of continuous and fixed RCC beams are cut using the point of contraflexure plus the code extension; a bar bending schedule that stops them short of this is a common and serious error.
  • Laps in main bars should not be placed at points of maximum moment; near points of contraflexure the moment is small, but check the shear there, as it is usually not small.
  • Steel beam splices and precast joints placed near points of contraflexure carry mainly shear and little moment, which makes the connection simpler.
  • Points of contraflexure move when a span is loaded and its neighbour is not (pattern loading), so detailing uses the envelope, not a single analysis.
  • If a support of a continuous beam settles, the hogging moment over it drops and the points of contraflexure move towards that support; settlement cracks often show this change.
Common mistakes
  • Calling the zero-moment point at a simple support or free end a point of contraflexure.
  • Expecting a point of contraflexure in a simply supported beam or a cantilever with only downward loads.
  • Solving M(x) = 0 with the equation of the wrong segment and accepting a root outside that segment.
  • Using the overhanging-beam formula for a fixed or continuous beam without first finding the support moments.
  • Stopping top bars exactly at the point of contraflexure without the code extension.
Quick check

In a beam fixed at both ends under a uniform load the points of contraflexure sit about one-fifth of the span (0.211L) from each end; in a propped cantilever, one-quarter of the span from the fixed end. A computed position far from these for similar loading points to an error in the support moments.

Summary

  • A point of contraflexure is where the moment changes sign; it is a point of inflection of the deflected shape.
  • Zero moment at a simple support or free end is not contraflexure.
  • Find it by solving M(x) = 0 in the segment where the sign changes.
  • Key positions: 0.211L (fixed-fixed, UDL), L/4 from the fixed end (propped cantilever, UDL), (L² − a²)/L for a single overhang.
  • It controls bar curtailment and the location of laps and splices.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Does a simply supported beam carrying only downward loads have a point of contraflexure? Give a reason.

No. Its moment is sagging everywhere between the supports and is zero only at the supports, where it does not change sign.

2A beam has supports 6 m apart and an overhang of 3 m beyond one support, with a uniform load over the whole 9 m. Where is the point of contraflexure?

x = (L² − a²)/L = (36 − 9)/6 = 4.5 m from the far support (1.5 m from the support next to the overhang).

3A beam fixed at both ends has a span of 9 m and a uniform load. Where are the points of contraflexure?

At 0.2113 × 9 = 1.90 m from each end.

4A propped cantilever of span 8 m carries a uniform load of 12 kN/m. Find the fixed-end moment, the point of contraflexure and the maximum sagging moment, using the standard results.

Fixed-end moment = −12 × 64/8 = −96 kN·m; contraflexure at 8/4 = 2 m from the fixed end; max sagging = 9 × 12 × 64/128 = 54 kN·m at 3 m from the prop.

5A beam of total length 9 m rests on supports placed 1.5 m in from each end, with 20 kN/m over the whole length. Find the support and mid-span moments and the points of contraflexure.

R = 90 kN each. Support moments = −20 × 1.5²/2 = −22.5 kN·m. Mid-span = 20 × 36/8 − 22.5 = 67.5 kN·m. With x from a support: M = 90x − 10(x + 1.5)² = −10x² + 60x − 22.5 = 0, x = 3 ± √6.75 = 0.402 m and 5.598 m from that support.

6Top bars of 20 mm diameter run over the support of a continuous RCC beam with effective depth 500 mm and clear span 7.2 m. Find the minimum extension of the continuing one-third of these bars beyond the point of inflection under IS 456:2000 cl. 26.2.3.4.

Greatest of d = 500 mm, 12 × 20 = 240 mm and 7200/16 = 450 mm, so 500 mm.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.