6.3 Combined bending and torsion
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Combine the bending stress 32 M/(π d³) and the torsional shear stress 16 T/(π d³) at the surface of a circular shaft and find the principal stresses and maximum shear stress.
- Use the equivalent bending moment and equivalent torque to design shafts under combined bending and torsion by the maximum principal stress, maximum shear stress and distortion energy theories.
- Recognise how reinforced concrete beams in torsion are treated by the empirical equivalent shear and equivalent moment of IS 456:2000.
Theory
Most real shafts carry bending as well as torque. A pulley or gear pulls sideways on the shaft, the shaft's own weight bends it between bearings, and a winch drum shaft is bent by the rope tension it is also turning. At the outer surface of a solid circular shaft, bending gives a normal stress σ = 32 M/(π d³) along the axis and torsion gives a shear stress τ = 16 T/(π d³) on the same plane. The surface point therefore sits in plane stress, and the stresses that govern failure are the principal stresses, treated fully in lessons 7.2 and 7.3 (principal stresses and Mohr's circle).
For plane stress with σ in one direction, zero in the other and shear τ, the principal stresses are σ/2 ± √((σ/2)² + τ²) and the maximum shear stress is √((σ/2)² + τ²). Substituting the shaft expressions gives a neat result: σ₁ = 16 (M + √(M² + T²))/(π d³) and τ_max = 16 √(M² + T²)/(π d³). These have exactly the form of a pure bending stress and a pure torsion stress, so we define an equivalent bending moment M_e = ½ (M + √(M² + T²)) and an equivalent torque T_e = √(M² + T²).
Which one to use depends on how the material fails. Brittle materials fail when the largest principal stress reaches the tensile strength (the maximum principal stress theory), so M_e governs. Ductile steels yield in shear, so the maximum shear stress theory, using T_e, or the distortion energy (von Mises) theory is used. The von Mises equivalent stress for this stress state is √(σ² + 3τ²) = 32 √(M² + 0.75 T²)/(π d³). These theories are treated fully in lesson 7.5 on theories of failure; here they are applied to circular shafts.
Reinforced concrete beams also carry torsion, for example spandrel beams that support a slab or canopy on one side and ring beams of circular tanks. Concrete cracks in a spiral pattern and the elastic shaft theory does not describe its strength. Concrete codes therefore use empirical rules that convert the torque into an additional shear and an additional bending moment, designed with the usual shear and flexure methods. The idea is the same as for shafts, one combined action replaced by equivalent simple actions, but the expressions are calibrated on tests of reinforced concrete beams.
Derivation
- At the surface of a solid shaft: σ = M y/I = M (d/2)/(π d⁴/64) = 32 M/(π d³); τ = T (d/2)/(π d⁴/32) = 16 T/(π d³).
- Plane stress with σ_x = σ, σ_y = 0, τ_xy = τ: σ₁,₂ = σ/2 ± √((σ/2)² + τ²); τ_max = √((σ/2)² + τ²).
- Substitute: σ/2 = 16 M/(π d³), so √((σ/2)² + τ²) = 16 √(M² + T²)/(π d³).
- σ₁ = 16 (M + √(M² + T²))/(π d³) = 32 M_e/(π d³) with M_e = ½ (M + √(M² + T²)).
- τ_max = 16 √(M² + T²)/(π d³) = 16 T_e/(π d³) with T_e = √(M² + T²).
- Distortion energy: σ_vm = √(σ² + 3τ²) = (32/(π d³)) √(M² + 0.75 T²).
- Design diameters: maximum shear stress theory d = (16 T_e/(π τ_allow))^(1/3); maximum principal stress theory d = (32 M_e/(π σ_allow))^(1/3).
- Checks: if T = 0, M_e = M and T_e = M; if M = 0, T_e = T, the results of pure bending and pure torsion.
σ_b = 32 M/(π d³), τ = 16 T/(π d³) (N/mm²; M and T in N·mm, d in mm)σ₁,₂ = σ/2 ± √((σ/2)² + τ²); τ_max = √((σ/2)² + τ²)Equivalent bending moment M_e = ½ (M + √(M² + T²)), σ₁ = 32 M_e/(π d³)Equivalent torque T_e = √(M² + T²), τ_max = 16 T_e/(π d³)Von Mises: σ_vm = √(σ² + 3τ²) = (32/(π d³)) √(M² + 0.75 T²)IS 456:2000 cl. 41.3 (limit state, rectangular RC beam): equivalent shear V_e = V_u + 1.6 T_u/bIS 456:2000 cl. 41.4.2: M_e1 = M_u + M_t with M_t = T_u (1 + D/b)/1.7; if M_t > M_u, the compression face is also designed for M_e2 = M_t − M_u
- Solid circular shaft, linear elastic, with the largest bending and torsion stresses occurring together at the outer surface of the critical section.
- Direct shear from the transverse force is neglected; it is zero at the outer fibre where the bending stress is largest.
- Axial thrust, where present, adds P/A to σ; it is not included in the equivalent moment formulas above.
- Fatigue from the rotating bending stress, which reverses every revolution, and stress concentration are checked separately.
- The reinforced concrete expressions apply only to reinforced concrete members designed to that code and are not derived from elastic shaft theory.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The combination of bending and torsion stresses in a circular shaft is mechanics; no design code governs the derivation of M_e and T_e, and the choice of failure theory follows the material.
- For reinforced concrete beams, IS 456:2000 cl. 41.3 replaces the torque by an equivalent shear V_e = V_u + 1.6 T_u/b, and cl. 41.4.2 adds an equivalent moment M_t = T_u (1 + D/b)/1.7 to the bending moment, M_e1 = M_u + M_t, with compression-face steel for M_e2 = M_t − M_u when M_t exceeds M_u. The resulting shear and flexure design is taken up in the RCC design lesson on torsion.
- Side by side, not ranked: EN 1992-1-1 and ACI 318 design reinforced concrete for torsion with a space-truss model of a thin-walled tube, with closed links and longitudinal bars calculated separately; steel codes such as IS 800:2007, EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 check combined stresses in steel members with their own interaction rules.
Worked examples
Problem. A winch drum shaft on a bridge erection gantry is 80 mm in diameter. At the critical section it carries a bending moment of 3 kN·m from the rope pull and a torque of 4 kN·m. Find the bending and shear stresses, the principal stresses and the maximum shear stress, and check them with M_e and T_e.
- σ = 32 × 3 × 10⁶/(π × 80³) = 59.7 N/mm²; τ = 16 × 4 × 10⁶/(π × 80³) = 39.8 N/mm².
- √((σ/2)² + τ²) = √(29.84² + 39.79²) = 49.7 N/mm².
- σ₁ = 29.8 + 49.7 = 79.6 N/mm²; σ₂ = 29.8 − 49.7 = −19.9 N/mm²; τ_max = 49.7 N/mm².
- Check: T_e = √(3² + 4²) = 5 kN·m and M_e = ½ (3 + 5) = 4 kN·m; 32 M_e/(π d³) = 79.6 N/mm² and 16 T_e/(π d³) = 49.7 N/mm², which agree.
Answer. σ₁ = 79.6 N/mm², σ₂ = −19.9 N/mm², τ_max = 49.7 N/mm²
Problem. A hoist shaft must carry M = 2 kN·m and T = 3 kN·m at the same section. Allowable shear stress 50 N/mm² and allowable normal stress 80 N/mm². Find the diameter by the maximum shear stress theory and by the maximum principal stress theory.
- T_e = √(2² + 3²) = 3.606 kN·m. Maximum shear stress theory: d = (16 × 3.606 × 10⁶/(π × 50))^(1/3) = 71.6 mm.
- M_e = ½ (2 + 3.606) = 2.803 kN·m. Maximum principal stress theory: d = (32 × 2.803 × 10⁶/(π × 80))^(1/3) = 70.9 mm.
- The larger, 71.6 mm, governs. Adopt 75 mm. For a ductile steel shaft the shear-based result is the appropriate one.
Answer. 71.6 mm (shear theory) and 70.9 mm (principal stress theory); adopt 75 mm
Problem. A reinforced concrete spandrel beam 300 mm wide and 600 mm deep (effective depth 550 mm) supports a cantilever canopy on one side. At the critical section the factored actions are V_u = 80 kN, T_u = 25 kN·m and M_u = 110 kN·m. Find the equivalent shear, the equivalent nominal shear stress and the equivalent moment.
- Equivalent shear (IS 456:2000 cl. 41.3): V_e = V_u + 1.6 T_u/b = 80 + 1.6 × 25/0.3 = 213.3 kN.
- Equivalent nominal shear stress = V_e/(b d) = 213.3 × 10³/(300 × 550) = 1.29 N/mm²; the shear design with this stress follows the RCC lesson on torsion.
- M_t = T_u (1 + D/b)/1.7 = 25 × (1 + 600/300)/1.7 = 44.1 kN·m (cl. 41.4.2).
- M_e1 = M_u + M_t = 110 + 44.1 = 154.1 kN·m for the tension steel. Since M_t < M_u, no separate compression-face moment M_e2 is needed.
- The torque raises the design shear by 167 % and the design moment by 40 %, which is why spandrel beams need closed links and extra bars.
Answer. V_e = 213.3 kN (1.29 N/mm²); M_e1 = 154.1 kN·m; M_e2 not required
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the bending moment M and torque T at the critical sections (often at a pulley, gear or support).
- Compute σ = 32 M/(π d³) and τ = 16 T/(π d³), or work directly with M_e and T_e.
- Choose the failure theory to suit the material: shear or distortion energy for ductile steel, principal stress for brittle material.
- For design, find d from T_e (and from M_e if required) and adopt the larger standard size.
- For reinforced concrete members, convert T_u to V_e and M_e1 by the code rules and design for shear and flexure.
Site notes
- Spandrel and edge beams carrying canopies, chajjas or cantilever slabs are twisted as well as bent; closed links with hooks anchored into the core are essential.
- Winch and hoist shafts on gantries are bent by rope pull and twisted by the drive; check them at the drum and at the coupling.
- Pulleys and gears placed close to bearings reduce the bending moment and so the required shaft size.
- A rotating shaft sees reversing bending stress every revolution, so fatigue cracks start at keyways and shoulders; inspect these during maintenance.
- Adding the bending and torsion stresses directly instead of combining them as principal stresses.
- Using T_e with the maximum principal stress theory or M_e with the maximum shear stress theory.
- Forgetting that the bending stress in a rotating shaft reverses every revolution.
- Applying the elastic shaft formulas to cracked reinforced concrete beams, or the concrete code expressions to steel shafts.
- Using kN·m and N·mm in the same expression.
T_e = √(M² + T²) and M_e = ½ (M + T_e). With M = 3 and T = 4, T_e = 5 and M_e = 4 — a handy check. Setting T = 0 must return M_e = M.
Summary
- At the surface of a shaft, bending gives σ = 32 M/(π d³) and torsion τ = 16 T/(π d³).
- Their combination gives σ₁ = 32 M_e/(π d³) and τ_max = 16 T_e/(π d³).
- M_e = ½ (M + √(M² + T²)) and T_e = √(M² + T²).
- Ductile shafts are designed with T_e (or von Mises); brittle materials with M_e.
- Reinforced concrete beams use the empirical IS 456:2000 equivalents V_e and M_e1 instead of elastic shaft theory.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Find T_e and M_e for M = 4 kN·m and T = 3 kN·m.
T_e = √(16 + 9) = 5 kN·m; M_e = ½ (4 + 5) = 4.5 kN·m.
2A 60 mm solid shaft carries M = 1.5 kN·m and T = 2 kN·m. Find τ_max and σ₁.
T_e = 2.5 kN·m, M_e = 2.0 kN·m. τ_max = 16 × 2.5 × 10⁶/(π × 216 000) = 58.9 N/mm²; σ₁ = 32 × 2.0 × 10⁶/(π × 216 000) = 94.3 N/mm².
3Find the von Mises equivalent stress for the shaft of Example 1.
σ_vm = √(59.7² + 3 × 39.8²) = 91.2 N/mm², or (32/(π × 80³)) × √(3² + 0.75 × 4²) × 10⁶ = 91.2 N/mm².
4Why are ductile steel shafts usually designed with the maximum shear stress or distortion energy theory?
Ductile steel yields by slip on planes of high shear, so a shear-based or distortion energy criterion predicts the start of yielding better than the largest normal stress, which suits brittle materials.
5Show that the equivalent moment and torque reduce correctly when there is no torque.
With T = 0, T_e = √(M²) = M and M_e = ½ (M + M) = M, so σ₁ = 32 M/(π d³) and τ_max = 16 M/(π d³) = σ/2, the pure bending results.
6A reinforced concrete beam 250 mm wide and 500 mm deep carries V_u = 60 kN, T_u = 15 kN·m and M_u = 50 kN·m. Find V_e and M_e1 by IS 456:2000.
V_e = 60 + 1.6 × 15/0.25 = 156 kN. M_t = 15 × (1 + 500/250)/1.7 = 26.5 kN·m; M_e1 = 50 + 26.5 = 76.5 kN·m. M_t < M_u, so M_e2 is not required.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.