6.2 Two-hinged arches
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain why a two-hinged arch is statically indeterminate to the first degree and choose the horizontal thrust as the redundant.
- Derive H = ∫M₀ y ds/EI ÷ ∫y² ds/EI from the unit-load method (or Castigliano's theorem) and evaluate it in closed form for a parabolic rib with I = I_c sec θ.
- Find the thrust and moments for full-span, half-span and point loads, and the extra thrust from temperature change, rib shortening and spreading of the abutments.
Theory
Remove the crown hinge of lesson 6.1 and the arch becomes a continuous curved rib pinned at its two springings. It now has four reaction components and only three equations of statics, so it is indeterminate to the first degree. The usual choice of redundant is the horizontal thrust H: release the horizontal restraint at B (put B on rollers), and the released structure is a curved simply supported beam that would spread outward under load. H is the force that pushes B back to its original position. Sign convention for this chapter: loads act downward; vertical reactions are positive upward; the horizontal thrust H of an arch is positive when the abutment pushes inward on the arch, and cable tension is positive; a bending moment that causes tension on the inner (lower) face of an arch rib is positive (sagging) and the opposite is negative (hogging); x is measured from the left support, the rise y of an arch upward from the springing line and the sag of a cable downward from the chord joining its supports.
The compatibility condition is that the horizontal movement of B is zero. Under the loads alone the moment in the released arch is M₀ = M_beam, the simple-beam moment, and B moves outward by ∫M₀ y ds/EI (unit-load method, lesson 2.3, with a unit horizontal force at B giving moment −y). A unit inward force at B moves it inward by ∫y² ds/EI. Setting the total movement to zero gives H = ∫M₀ y ds/EI ÷ ∫y² ds/EI, the same as minimising the strain energy with respect to H by Castigliano's second theorem (lesson 2.2). The final moment is again M = M₀ − H y.
The integrals are easy for a parabolic rib if the second moment of area grows towards the springings as I = I_c sec θ, where I_c is the value at the crown. Then ds/I = dx/I_c, and both integrals become plain integrals along the span. Under a uniform load over the whole span H = wL²/(8h) and the parabola is again funicular. A point load W at a distance a = kL from A gives H = (5WL/(8h)) k(1 − k)(1 + k − k²), which is 25WL/(128h) for a load at the crown, smaller than the three-hinged value WL/(4h), so the two-hinged rib carries a sagging crown moment of 7WL/128. A uniform load over half the span gives H = wL²/(16h), half the full-span value by symmetry and superposition.
Because the arch is indeterminate, anything that changes the span changes the thrust. A rise in temperature tries to lengthen the rib; the abutments resist and H increases by αΔT L EI_c/∫y² dx, which for the parabolic rib is 15EI_cαΔT/(8h²). Outward spreading of the abutments by δ reduces H by δEI_c/∫y² dx. Shortening of the rib under its own compression also reduces H slightly; it is included by adding ∫cos²θ ds/(EA) to the denominator, a small term for most arches but important in flat, slender ribs.
Derivation
- Release the horizontal restraint at B. Under the loads the released arch has moment M₀(x) = M_beam(x) and B moves horizontally by Δ₀ = ∫M₀ m ds/EI, where m = −y is the moment from a unit inward horizontal force at B.
- A unit inward force at B alone moves B by f = ∫m² ds/EI = ∫y² ds/EI (flexibility coefficient).
- Compatibility, B does not move: Δ₀ + H f = 0, so H = ∫M₀ y ds/EI ÷ ∫y² ds/EI (add ∫cos²θ ds/(EA) to the denominator for rib shortening). Castigliano: ∂U/∂H = 0 with U = ∫(M₀ − H y)² ds/(2EI) gives the same result.
- Parabolic rib y = 4h x(L − x)/L² with I = I_c sec θ, so ds/I = dx/I_c: ∫₀ᴸ y² dx = (16h²/L⁴) ∫₀ᴸ x²(L − x)² dx = (16h²/L⁴)(L⁵/30) = 8h²L/15.
- Full uniform load: ∫₀ᴸ (w x(L − x)/2)(4h x(L − x)/L²) dx = whL³/15, so H = (whL³/15)/(8h²L/15) = wL²/(8h), and M = 0 everywhere, as for the three-hinged arch.
- Point load W at a = kL: integrating M₀ y over the two segments gives ∫M₀ y dx = (WhL²/3) k(1 − k)(1 + k − k²), so H = (5WL/(8h)) k(1 − k)(1 + k − k²); k = 1/2 gives 25WL/(128h). Temperature: the free horizontal movement αΔT L must be cancelled, so H_t = αΔT L EI_c/(8h²L/15) = 15EI_cαΔT/(8h²).
Thrust (unit-load method): H = ∫M₀ y ds/EI ÷ [∫y² ds/EI + ∫cos²θ ds/(EA)] (kN)Moment: M = M₀ − H y (kN m), M₀ = simple-beam momentParabolic rib, I = I_c sec θ: ∫₀ᴸ y² dx = 8h²L/15 (m³)Full uniform load w: H = wL²/(8h); half-span uniform load: H = wL²/(16h)Point load W at a = kL: H = (5WL/(8h)) k(1 − k)(1 + k − k²); crown load: H = 25WL/(128h), crown moment 7WL/128Temperature: H_t = αΔT L EI_c/∫y² dx = 15EI_cαΔT/(8h²); abutment spread δ: ΔH = −δEI_c/∫y² dx (kN; EI_c in kN m²)
- Plane arch pinned at both springings at the same level; the abutments do not yield unless a spreading δ is stated.
- Linear elastic material and small deflections; the unloaded geometry is used throughout.
- Bending deformation governs; axial shortening is added as a correction and shear deformation is neglected.
- For the closed-form results the rib is parabolic with I = I_c sec θ (deeper towards the springings), so that ds/I = dx/I_c.
- Limits: for a rib of constant section or a circular rib the integrals are evaluated numerically (Simpson's rule over 8 to 12 segments is usually enough). Very flat or slender ribs need the rib-shortening term and a buckling check, and large deflections need second-order analysis.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Two-hinged arch analysis follows from compatibility and the energy theorems; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, give the design temperature ranges, load combinations and member rules for arch bridges and arched roofs in their own loading, concrete and steel codes; those values are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A two-hinged parabolic arch of span 30 m and rise 6 m has I = I_c sec θ. A point load of 80 kN acts at a quarter of the span from A. Find H, the moment under the load and the moment at the crown.
- k = 7.5/30 = 0.25; 5WL/(8h) = 5 × 80 × 30/48 = 250 kN; k(1 − k)(1 + k − k²) = 0.25 × 0.75 × 1.1875 = 0.2227.
- H = 250 × 0.2227 = 55.66 kN.
- V_A = 80 × 22.5/30 = 60 kN, V_B = 20 kN. Under the load y = 4 × 6 × 7.5 × 22.5/30² = 4.5 m.
- M under the load = 60 × 7.5 − 55.66 × 4.5 = 450 − 250.5 = +199.5 kN m.
- At the crown: M₀ = 20 × 15 = 300 kN m; M = 300 − 55.66 × 6 = −34.0 kN m (hogging).
Answer. H = 55.7 kN; M = +199.5 kN m under the load and −34.0 kN m at the crown
Problem. A parabolic arch of span 40 m and rise 8 m (I = I_c sec θ) is built as a two-hinged arch. Find H and the crown moment for (i) 20 kN/m over the left half and (ii) a single 100 kN load at the crown, and compare with the three-hinged values of lesson 6.1.
- (i) Half-span load: H = wL²/(16h) = 20 × 40²/128 = 250 kN. Crown moment = 2 000 − 250 × 8 = 0, so the moments are the same ±500 kN m as in the three-hinged arch.
- Check by integration: ∫₀^20 (300x − 10x²) y dx + ∫20^40 100(40 − x) y dx = 341 333 kN m³, and dividing by ∫y² dx = 8 × 64 × 40/15 = 1 365.3 m³ gives 250 kN.
- (ii) Crown load: two-hinged H = 25 × 100 × 40/(128 × 8) = 97.66 kN; three-hinged H = 100 × 40/(4 × 8) = 125 kN.
- Two-hinged crown moment = 50 × 20 − 97.66 × 8 = 218.75 kN m (= 7WL/128); the three-hinged crown moment is zero by definition.
- Without a crown hinge the rib carries part of the point load by bending, so the thrust is about 22 per cent lower.
Answer. (i) H = 250 kN in both arches; (ii) H = 97.7 kN (two-hinged) against 125 kN (three-hinged), crown moment 218.75 kN m
Problem. A two-hinged parabolic steel arch of span 40 m and rise 8 m has EI_c = 4.0 × 10⁵ kN m² (I = I_c sec θ) and α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C. Find the extra thrust and crown moment for a temperature rise of 25 °C, and the loss of thrust if an abutment yields outward by 10 mm.
- ∫y² dx = 8h²L/15 = 8 × 64 × 40/15 = 1 365.3 m³ (with ds/I = dx/I_c).
- Temperature: H_t = αΔT L EI_c/∫y² dx = 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 25 × 40 × 4.0 × 10⁵/1 365.3 = 3.52 kN (same as 15EI_cαΔT/(8h²)).
- Crown moment from H_t: −3.52 × 8 = −28.1 kN m (hogging); at the springings it is zero.
- Abutment spread 10 mm: ΔH = −0.010 × 4.0 × 10⁵/1 365.3 = −2.93 kN, giving a sagging crown moment of +23.4 kN m.
- Both effects are small next to the load thrust here, but they grow with EI_c and fall with h², so flat stiff arches are the sensitive ones.
Answer. H_t = 3.52 kN and −28.1 kN m at the crown for +25 °C; a 10 mm spread removes 2.93 kN of thrust
Step-by-step procedure
- Release the horizontal restraint at one springing and choose H as the redundant.
- Write M₀ (simple-beam moment) and the rib height y along the span; decide how I varies (I_c sec θ for the closed forms).
- Evaluate ∫M₀ y ds/EI and ∫y² ds/EI, by the closed forms for a parabolic rib or by Simpson's rule otherwise; add the rib-shortening term if the rib is flat.
- H = ratio of the two integrals; add the temperature thrust and subtract any abutment spread.
- Moments M = M₀ − H y; normal thrust and radial shear from the slope of the rib, as in lesson 6.1.
- Check: a full uniform load on a parabolic rib must give M = 0, and the thrusts of separate load cases must add up to the thrust of the combined loading (superposition).
Site notes
- Two-hinged steel arches and arched portal roofs are common because they are stiffer than three-hinged arches and need no crown hinge detail, but their abutments must not spread: a tie at springing level or rock foundations are used to hold the span.
- Bearings at the springings are true pins (or curved rocker plates) and must allow rotation; a seized bearing turns the arch into a fixed arch with different moments.
- Temperature thrust is locked in at the closing temperature, so the rib is usually closed at a recorded mean temperature and the design range is measured from it.
- Survey the span between springings during and after construction; a few millimetres of spread changes the thrust and the crown moment measurably in a stiff rib.
- Using the three-hinged formula H = M_C,beam/h for a two-hinged arch; without a crown hinge the thrust comes from compatibility.
- Dropping the sign of m = −y, which gives a negative thrust under gravity load.
- Using dx instead of ds/I when the rib does not have I = I_c sec θ.
- Quoting 25WL/(128h) for a uniform load; it is the thrust from a single point load at the crown (a half-span uniform load gives wL²/(16h)).
- Ignoring temperature and abutment movement, which do stress a two-hinged arch.
For a parabolic two-hinged arch with I = I_c sec θ, the thrust for a crown point load is 25/32 (about 0.78) of the three-hinged thrust WL/(4h), for a point load at a quarter of the span it is about 11 per cent above the three-hinged value, and for a full or half-span uniform load the two are equal; a two-hinged thrust far outside this band signals an arithmetic slip.
Summary
- A two-hinged arch has one redundant, usually the horizontal thrust H.
- H = ∫M₀ y ds/EI ÷ ∫y² ds/EI from the zero-spread condition (unit-load method or Castigliano).
- For a parabolic rib with I = I_c sec θ: ∫y² dx = 8h²L/15, full load H = wL²/(8h), half-span load wL²/(16h), crown point load 25WL/(128h).
- Temperature rise adds H_t = 15EI_cαΔT/(8h²); abutment spread and rib shortening reduce H.
- Moments follow from M = M₀ − H y, as in every arch.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A two-hinged parabolic arch (I = I_c sec θ) of span 25 m and rise 5 m carries 16 kN/m over the whole span. Find H and the moment at the quarter point.
H = 16 × 25²/(8 × 5) = 250 kN; M = 0 everywhere, the funicular case.
2A two-hinged parabolic arch of span 24 m and rise 4 m carries 120 kN at the crown. Find H and the crown moment.
H = 25 × 120 × 24/(128 × 4) = 140.6 kN; crown moment 7WL/128 = 7 × 120 × 24/128 = 157.5 kN m (sagging).
3Why is a two-hinged arch indeterminate to the first degree?
It has four reaction components (two at each pin) and three equations of equilibrium, with no internal hinge to give a fourth condition.
4Express H for a point load W at a quarter of the span as a multiple of WL/h.
H = (5/8) × 0.25 × 0.75 × 1.1875 WL/h = 0.139 WL/h.
5A parabolic two-hinged arch of span 30 m and rise 6 m has EI_c = 3 × 10⁵ kN m². Find the thrust from a 20 °C rise (α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C).
∫y² dx = 8 × 36 × 30/15 = 576 m³; H_t = 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 20 × 30 × 3 × 10⁵/576 = 3.75 kN.
6How does rib shortening change the thrust, and when does it matter?
It adds ∫cos²θ ds/(EA) to the denominator, so H falls a little; it matters for flat ribs with a small rise-to-span ratio and slender sections.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.