2.3 Unit load method for beams and frames
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Derive the unit load method from the principle of virtual work and state what the unit load represents.
- Find deflections and rotations of beams and rigid frames with δ = ∫ M m/(EI) dx, using product integrals for common moment diagram shapes.
- Handle frames with several members by taking each member in turn with one sign convention and adding the contributions.
Theory
The unit load method, also called the dummy load method or Maxwell-Mohr method, is the most used hand method for deflections. To find the movement of a point in a chosen direction, put a single unit load (1 kN) at that point in that direction on the unloaded structure and find its bending moment m. The deflection under the real loads is then δ = ∫ M m/(EI) dx, where M is the bending moment from the real loads. For a rotation the unit load is replaced by a unit couple. Sign convention for this lesson: in beams M and m are positive when sagging; in frames they are positive when they cause tension on the inside face; a positive δ is in the direction of the unit load.
The method comes from virtual work, not from energy, so it is more general than it looks. The unit load and its internal moments m form an equilibrium system; the real structure under the real loads supplies a compatible set of deformations, the curvatures M/EI. The principle of virtual work says that the external work of the unit load moving through the real deflection equals the internal work of m on the real curvatures: 1 × δ = ∫ m (M/EI) dx. The real deformations need not come from loads at all: temperature curvature or settlement can be used in the same way.
For beams and frames bending dominates, so only the moment term is normally kept. The integral of a product of two diagrams over a member of constant EI can be done without integrating by using standard product results: a rectangle times a rectangle gives L M m, a rectangle times a triangle gives L M m/2, two triangles with their peaks at the same end give L M m/3 and at opposite ends L M m/6, two triangles peaking at midspan give L M m/3, and the parabola of a uniformly loaded simple span times a central triangle gives 5 L M m/12. Here M and m are the peak values of each diagram on that member.
In a frame each member is taken in turn, with its own coordinate along the member but a single sign convention for the whole frame, and the contributions are added. Corners keep the inside face inside, so a column moment that puts tension on the inside at the top continues into the beam with the same sign. Axial and shear terms can be added as ∫ N n/(EA) dx and ∫ α_s V v/(GA) dx where they matter, for example in tall slender columns or deep members, but they are usually small. The method gives one displacement per unit load case, so a full deflected shape needs several unit load cases or a different method.
Derivation
- Virtual work principle for a deformable body: if a system of forces in equilibrium is given any compatible set of small displacements and deformations, the external virtual work equals the internal virtual work.
- Choose the virtual force system: a unit load at point i in the direction wanted, with its reactions and its internal moments m(x). It satisfies equilibrium.
- Choose the real displacements: the actual deflected shape of the structure under the real loads, with curvature κ = M/EI at each section (bending only).
- External virtual work: the unit load moves through the real deflection δ_i, giving 1 × δ_i; the reactions do no work at unyielding supports.
- Internal virtual work: on a length dx the moment m turns through the real relative rotation κ dx, giving ∫ m M/(EI) dx. Equating, δ_i = ∫ M m/(EI) dx; with a unit couple, θ_i = ∫ M m_θ/(EI) dx.
- Product integral for a simple span with uniform load and a unit load at midspan: M = w x(L − x)/2 and m = x/2 on the left half, so δ = (2/EI)∫₀^{L/2} (w x(L − x)/2)(x/2) dx = 5wL⁴/(384EI), which equals (5/12) L (wL²/8)(L/4)/EI.
Beams and frames: δ = ∫ M m/(EI) dx; rotation θ = ∫ M m_θ/(EI) dx (m_θ from a unit couple)With axial and shear terms: δ = ∫ M m/(EI) dx + ∫ N n/(EA) dx + ∫ α_s V v/(GA) dxProduct integrals (constant EI, peak values M and m, member length L): rectangle × rectangle L M m; rectangle × triangle L M m/2; triangles peaking at the same end L M m/3; at opposite ends L M m/6Parabola of a uniformly loaded span (zero at the ends) × central triangle: 5 L M m/12; × rectangle: 2 L M m/3Cantilever parabola (zero at the tip) × triangle (zero at the tip): L M m/4Units: M in kN m, m in m (moment per unit load), EI in kN m², L in m gives δ in m
- Small displacements and linear elastic members, so curvature is M/EI and the original geometry is used.
- Supports are unyielding; support movement adds a term −Σ r Δ, where r is the unit-load reaction and Δ the real settlement in its direction.
- Bending only, unless axial and shear terms are added; plane sections remain plane.
- Product integrals assume constant EI over each member; members with varying EI must be split or integrated directly.
- Limits: the method gives deflections, not stresses, and needs one unit load case per displacement; it does not apply once members yield or buckle.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The unit load method is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all accept elastic deflection calculations by virtual work, using effective stiffness that allows for cracking or creep where the material calls for it; how that stiffness and the deflection limits are set is left to each practice's own codes and is not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A simply supported beam of span 8 m carries a uniform load of 25 kN/m. EI = 1.2 × 10⁵ kN m². Find the midspan deflection and the slope at the left support by the unit load method.
- Real moment: parabola with peak wL²/8 = 25 × 64/8 = 200 kN m at midspan.
- Unit load at midspan: triangle with peak L/4 = 2 m. Product integral 5 L M m/12 = 5 × 8 × 200 × 2/12 = 1333.3 kN m³.
- δ = 1333.3/(1.2 × 10⁵) = 0.0111 m = 11.1 mm, which is span/720 and equals 5wL⁴/(384EI).
- Unit couple at the left support: m falls linearly from 1 at the left to 0 at the right. ∫ M m dx = ∫₀^8 (25x(8 − x)/2)(1 − x/8) dx = wL³/24 = 533.3 kN m².
- θ = 533.3/(1.2 × 10⁵) = 0.00444 rad, in the direction of the unit couple (the beam end turns into the span).
Answer. Midspan deflection 11.1 mm; end slope 0.00444 rad
Problem. A concrete entrance canopy cantilevers 2.5 m from a wall. Its strip of 1 m width carries 6 kN/m (self-weight, finishes and imposed load) and an edge upstand of 4 kN at the tip. Take EI = 6000 kN m² per metre width (a cracked-section value supplied by the designer). Find the tip deflection.
- Unit load at the tip: m = x, a triangle from 0 at the tip to 2.5 m at the wall (x from the tip).
- Uniform load: M = w x²/2, a parabola from 0 at the tip to 18.75 kN m at the wall. Product L M m/4 = 2.5 × 18.75 × 2.5/4 = 29.30 kN m³ (= wL⁴/8).
- Tip load: M = P x, a triangle from 0 to 10 kN m. Product L M m/3 = 2.5 × 10 × 2.5/3 = 20.83 kN m³ (= PL³/3).
- δ = (29.30 + 20.83)/6000 = 0.00836 m = 8.4 mm downward.
- Long-term creep would increase this; the designer's stiffness, not the uncracked value, must be used, and the wall rotation at the root adds to it.
Answer. Tip deflection about 8.4 mm
Problem. A rectangular frame ABCD has columns AB and DC 4 m high and beam BC 6 m long, all with EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m². A is pinned, D is on a roller that can slide horizontally. A horizontal load of 20 kN acts at B towards C. Find the horizontal movement of D.
- Reactions: A_x = 20 kN against the load; moments about A give D_y = 20 × 4/6 = 13.33 kN up and A_y = 13.33 kN down.
- Real M (inside tension positive): column AB, M = 20y from 0 at A to 80 kN m at B; beam BC, from 80 kN m at B falling linearly to 0 at C; column DC, M = 0 (the roller has no horizontal reaction).
- Unit horizontal load at D, pointing away from A: A_x = 1 against it, vertical reactions zero (the load acts at the level of A). m: column AB, y from 0 to 4; beam BC, 4 throughout; column DC, y from 0 at D to 4 at C.
- Products: AB, triangles peaking at the same end, L M m/3 = 4 × 80 × 4/3 = 426.7; BC, rectangle × triangle, L M m/2 = 6 × 80 × 4/2 = 960; DC, 0.
- δ_D = (426.7 + 960)/(2 × 10⁴) = 0.0693 m = 69.3 mm, positive, so D slides away from A. Fixing the base at D would remove most of this movement, which is why temporary frames on rollers need bracing.
Answer. D slides 69.3 mm away from A
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the reactions and the real bending moment M in every member; draw the M diagram with the sign convention stated.
- Remove the real loads; apply a unit load at the point and in the direction of the displacement wanted (a unit couple for a rotation).
- Find the reactions and the m diagram for the unit load, with the same sign convention.
- For each member, evaluate ∫ M m/(EI) dx by product integrals or direct integration; split members where EI or the diagram shape changes.
- Add the member contributions; a positive total means movement in the direction of the unit load. Add support-movement or temperature terms if present.
Site notes
- Measured deflections of concrete members are usually larger than elastic hand values because of cracking, creep and shrinkage; compare like with like, using the stiffness the designer assumed.
- Pre-camber of formwork for long spans and cantilevers is set from calculated deflections; check that the camber shown on the drawing has been built in before concreting.
- Frames on sliding or roller bearings can sway far more than fixed frames; temporary works on rollers must be braced or tied until the permanent restraints are in place.
- Deflection readings in load tests are taken at points chosen in advance; the unit load method gives the expected value at exactly those points.
- Using different sign conventions for M and m in a member, or changing the convention between members of a frame.
- Applying the product integral formula when the diagrams change shape within a member; split the member first.
- Using the wrong shape factor for a cantilever parabola (L M m/4) and a simple-span parabola (5 L M m/12 with a central triangle).
- Forgetting the reactions of the unit load, which also cause moments in the members.
- Ignoring support settlement or rotation that the real structure has.
For a simple span under uniform load, midspan deflection divided by end slope is 5L/16, and the deflection is 5/48 of M L²/EI where M = wL²/8. If a hand answer breaks either ratio, check the product integrals. Valid for prismatic simple spans under full uniform load.
Summary
- Unit load method: δ = ∫ M m/(EI) dx, from virtual work.
- m is the moment caused by a unit load (or unit couple) at the point and in the direction wanted.
- Product integrals replace integration for standard diagram shapes on members of constant EI.
- Frames: one sign convention for all members, inside face tension positive, contributions added.
- Axial, shear, temperature and settlement terms can be added when they matter.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A simply supported beam of span 5 m carries a central point load of 60 kN; EI = 5 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the midspan deflection with product integrals.
Both diagrams are triangles peaking at midspan: L M m/3 = 5 × 75 × 1.25/3 = 156.25; δ = 156.25/(5 × 10⁴) = 3.13 mm.
2Find the tip slope of a 3 m cantilever under 8 kN/m; EI = 1.5 × 10⁴ kN m².
Unit couple at the tip gives m = 1 everywhere; ∫ (w x²/2) dx = wL³/6 = 36; θ = 36/(1.5 × 10⁴) = 0.0024 rad.
3A simple span of 6 m carries equal and opposite end couples of 40 kN m that bend it into uniform sagging. EI = 3 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the midspan deflection.
Rectangle × central triangle: ½ × 6 × 40 × 1.5 = 180; δ = 180/(3 × 10⁴) = 6.0 mm (= M L²/8EI).
4A 4 m cantilever carries 20 kN at midspan; EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the tip deflection.
Real M is zero over the outer half and a triangle over the inner half; δ = 5PL³/(48EI) = 5 × 20 × 64/(48 × 2 × 10⁴) = 6.67 mm.
5Why are axial terms usually left out when finding the sway of a low-rise frame?
Members are very stiff axially compared with their bending stiffness over the same length, so axial shortening is small beside the bending deformation and hardly changes the sway. It is kept for tall slender frames and for trusses.
6Your unit load calculation gives δ = −3 mm. What does it mean?
The point moves 3 mm in the direction opposite to the unit load you applied; the magnitude is correct.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.