3.4 Lack of fit, settlement and temperature effects
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Find the forces set up in indeterminate structures by support settlement, temperature change and lack of fit, using the force method with known movements on the right-hand side.
- Use the standard results 6EIΔ/L² and 12EIΔ/L³ for a fixed beam, 3EIΔ/L² and 3EIΔ/L³ for a propped cantilever, EAαΔT for a restrained bar and EIαΔT/d for a temperature gradient.
- Add a settlement term to the three-moment equation and explain why these effects matter in indeterminate structures but not in determinate ones.
Theory
A statically determinate structure can adjust its shape freely: if a support settles, a member is made slightly too long, or the temperature changes, it moves but no forces arise (lesson 2.4). An indeterminate structure cannot, because its redundant restraints resist the movement. The forces that arise depend on stiffness: double EI and the settlement moments double. This is the reverse of load effects, where stiffness changes the deflection but not the forces in a determinate structure. Sign convention for this lesson: sagging moment positive; settlement Δ and support movement δ positive downward; reactions positive upward; member forces positive in tension; a member too long has positive lack of fit.
The force method handles all three effects in the same way. Release the redundants, find the movement of the primary structure at each release caused by the effect (a settlement is itself a known movement at the support; a member too long by e moves the joints by Σ n e; a temperature rise gives e = αΔT L), and write compatibility as Σ f_ij X_j = (required movement) − Δ_i0. For a support that settles by Δ, the required movement at that release is Δ rather than zero. No new theory is needed, only care with signs.
Some results are worth remembering. A fixed beam whose one end settles by Δ relative to the other, with no rotation at either end, takes an S-shaped curve with end moments 6EIΔ/L², hogging at one end and sagging at the other, and end shears 12EIΔ/L³. A propped cantilever whose prop settles by Δ loses 3EIΔ/L³ of prop reaction and gains 3EIΔ/L² of hogging moment at the wall. A bar fixed between rigid supports and heated by ΔT carries EAαΔT in compression; a fixed beam with a linear temperature difference ΔT through its depth d tries to curve by αΔT/d, and full fixity leaves it straight with a constant moment EIαΔT/d.
In continuous beams settlement enters the three-moment equation as an extra term on the right-hand side: for constant EI, M_A L₁ + 2M_B(L₁ + L₂) + M_C L₂ = −6A₁x̄₁/L₁ − 6A₂x̄₂/L₂ + 6EI[(δ_B − δ_A)/L₁ + (δ_B − δ_C)/L₂], with δ downward. A settling interior support reduces its own hogging moment and shifts load to its neighbours. Because these forces are proportional to stiffness, they are often reduced in practice by flexible details such as bearings, movement joints or deliberately released connections, and they fall over time in concrete as creep relaxes the stresses.
Derivation
- Fixed beam AB, end B settles Δ with both ends kept from rotating: the deflected shape v(x) = Δ(3x²/L² − 2x³/L³) satisfies v(0) = v'(0) = 0, v(L) = Δ, v'(L) = 0, and has no load between the ends.
- Moment M = −EI v'' (v downward, sagging positive): v'' = Δ(6/L² − 12x/L³), so M_A = −6EIΔ/L² and M_B = +6EIΔ/L²; the shear is constant, V = 12EIΔ/L³.
- Propped cantilever, prop settles Δ: compatibility at the prop, Δ_B0 − R L³/(3EI) = Δ, so the prop reaction falls by 3EIΔ/L³ and the wall moment becomes more hogging by 3EIΔ/L².
- Restrained bar heated by ΔT: free extension αΔT L must be cancelled by N L/(EA), so N = −EAαΔT (compression).
- Temperature gradient: free curvature αΔT/d; a fixed beam must stay straight, so the end moments supply curvature −αΔT/d over the whole span, M = EIαΔT/d (constant), with no deflection.
- Lack of fit in a truss with one redundant member force X: compatibility X f₁₁ + Σ n e = 0, where e is the lack of fit (positive too long) or αΔT L, so X = −Σ n e/f₁₁.
Fixed beam, relative settlement Δ: M = 6EIΔ/L² (hogging at the higher end, sagging at the lower end), V = 12EIΔ/L³ (EI in kN m², Δ and L in m)Propped cantilever, prop settles Δ: ΔR = −3EIΔ/L³, ΔM_wall = −3EIΔ/L² (more hogging)Restrained bar, temperature rise ΔT: N = −EAαΔT, σ = −EαΔT (kN, mm², N/mm²)Fixed beam with temperature difference ΔT through depth d: M = EIαΔT/d, no deflectionThree-moment equation with settlement (constant EI): M_A L₁ + 2M_B(L₁ + L₂) + M_C L₂ = −6A₁x̄₁/L₁ − 6A₂x̄₂/L₂ + 6EI[(δ_B − δ_A)/L₁ + (δ_B − δ_C)/L₂]Truss with one redundant: X = −(Σ n e)/f₁₁, e = lack of fit or αΔT L; f₁₁ = Σ n² L/(AE)
- Linear elastic behaviour and small displacements; superposition with load effects holds.
- Settlements, temperature changes and lack of fit are known in advance and applied slowly.
- Temperature changes are uniform along each member (and linear through the depth for gradients); α and E constant.
- Supports other than the moving one are unyielding.
- Limits: in concrete, creep over time relaxes settlement and temperature forces substantially, and cracking lowers EI; the elastic values here are upper bounds for short-term effects.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Settlement, temperature and lack-of-fit forces in this lesson are results of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, include these effects in design; the design temperature ranges, coefficients of expansion, settlement allowances and load factors are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A beam of span 6 m is fixed at both ends (EI = 4 × 10⁴ kN m²). The column under end B settles 10 mm while neither end rotates. (a) Find the settlement moments and shears. (b) Combine with a uniform load of 20 kN/m.
- (a) M = 6EIΔ/L² = 6 × 4 × 10⁴ × 0.010/36 = 66.67 kN m: M_A = −66.67 kN m (hogging), M_B = +66.67 kN m (sagging).
- Shear V = 12EIΔ/L³ = 12 × 4 × 10⁴ × 0.010/216 = 22.22 kN: R_A = +22.22 kN, R_B = −22.22 kN (the settling support pulls the beam down).
- Check: M_B = M_A + R_A L = −66.67 + 22.22 × 6 = +66.67 kN m.
- (b) Load alone: −wL²/12 = −60 kN m at each end. Combined: M_A = −60 − 66.67 = −126.67 kN m; M_B = −60 + 66.67 = +6.67 kN m.
- A 10 mm settlement more than doubles the hogging moment at A: the end that does not settle takes the extra moment.
Answer. (a) ±66.67 kN m, shear 22.22 kN; (b) M_A = −126.67 kN m, M_B = +6.67 kN m
Problem. A propped cantilever of span 6 m (EI = 3 × 10⁴ kN m²) carries 20 kN/m. The prop settles 12 mm. Find the prop reaction, the wall moment and the largest sagging moment, and compare with an unyielding prop.
- Unyielding prop: R = 3wL/8 = 45 kN, M_A = −wL²/8 = −90 kN m, M_max = 9wL²/128 = +50.63 kN m.
- Settlement effect: ΔR = 3EIΔ/L³ = 3 × 3 × 10⁴ × 0.012/216 = 5.0 kN, so R = 45 − 5 = 40 kN.
- Wall moment: M_A = 40 × 6 − 20 × 36/2 = 240 − 360 = −120 kN m (the change is 3EIΔ/L² = 30 kN m).
- Largest sagging: zero shear at 40/20 = 2 m from the prop, M = 40 × 2 − 20 × 2²/2 = +40 kN m.
- A 12 mm settlement raises the wall moment by a third and moves moment away from the span to the fixed end.
Answer. R = 40 kN, M_A = −120 kN m, M_max = +40 kN m (45 kN, −90 kN m, +50.63 kN m without settlement)
Problem. In the three-rod hanger of lesson 3.1 (vertical rod 3 m, outer rods at 30°, A = 500 mm², E = 200 kN/mm², α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C), with no external load: (a) the vertical rod is made 2 mm too short and forced into place; (b) instead, the vertical rod alone warms by 25 °C. Find the rod forces in each case.
- Redundant X = tension in the vertical rod. Under X the outer rods carry −X/(2 cos 30°) and the joint rises X L/(2AE cos³30°); the vertical rod stretches X L/(AE). With L/(AE) = 3000/(500 × 200) = 0.030 mm/kN, f₁₁ = 0.030(1 + 1/(2 × 0.6495)) = 0.0531 mm/kN.
- (a) Compatibility: the stretch plus the joint rise must close the 2 mm gap: 0.0531 X = 2, so X = +37.67 kN (tension); outer rods −37.67/(2 × 0.866) = −21.75 kN (compression).
- (b) Free extension of the vertical rod αΔT L = 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 25 × 3000 = 0.90 mm, the same as being 0.90 mm too long: 0.0531 X = −0.90, X = −16.95 kN (compression); outer rods +9.79 kN (tension).
- Checks: joint equilibrium 2 × 21.75 × 0.866 = 37.67 kN and 2 × 9.79 × 0.866 = 16.95 kN.
- These locked-in forces add to the load forces of lesson 3.1 (43.50 and 32.62 kN under 100 kN): a 2 mm error is as serious as a large share of the working load.
Answer. (a) vertical rod +37.67 kN, outer rods −21.75 kN; (b) vertical rod −16.95 kN, outer rods +9.79 kN
Step-by-step procedure
- Identify the effect: settlement (a known support movement), temperature (e = αΔT L or a curvature αΔT/d) or lack of fit (e = Δ).
- Release the redundants and find the primary-structure movement at each release caused by the effect.
- Write compatibility with the required movement (the settlement, or zero) on the right-hand side; solve for the redundants.
- Use the standard results where they apply (6EIΔ/L², 3EIΔ/L³, EAαΔT, EIαΔT/d) and add the effects to the load results by superposition.
- Check signs physically: a settling support loses reaction, and a heated restrained bar goes into compression.
Site notes
- Differential settlement between neighbouring columns or piers is a design load for continuous and fixed structures; foundation choices that keep it small also keep these moments small.
- Restrained concrete members cracking soon after casting are often showing temperature and shrinkage restraint, not load; movement joints and pour sequences relieve it.
- Fit-up errors in steel bracing or hangers that are forced with jacks or drifts lock in forces; report mismatches rather than forcing members into place.
- Jacking a propped cantilever or a continuous girder at a support is a deliberate settlement in reverse: it can be used to adjust moments, but only with a calculated jacking movement and monitoring.
- Assuming settlement or temperature causes forces in a determinate structure.
- Using the wrong sign for Δ: a settling prop reduces its reaction.
- Forgetting that settlement forces are proportional to EI, so a stiffer member attracts larger forces.
- Using the free extension αΔT L as a force, without the stiffness term.
- Ignoring creep relaxation in long-term concrete checks, or ignoring the short-term peak.
A fixed beam settlement moment 6EIΔ/L² is twice the propped-cantilever wall moment 3EIΔ/L² for the same span, stiffness and settlement, and the fixed-beam shear 12EIΔ/L³ is four times the prop reaction change 3EIΔ/L³. Valid for prismatic members with unyielding other supports.
Summary
- Indeterminate structures resist imposed movements, so settlement, temperature and lack of fit cause forces.
- Force method: compatibility with the known movement on the right-hand side.
- Fixed beam 6EIΔ/L² and 12EIΔ/L³; propped cantilever 3EIΔ/L² and 3EIΔ/L³.
- Restrained bar EAαΔT; temperature gradient EIαΔT/d with no deflection.
- These forces scale with stiffness and are added to load effects by superposition.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A fixed beam of span 5 m (EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m²) has one end settling 8 mm. Find the end moments and the shear.
M = 6 × 2 × 10⁴ × 0.008/25 = 38.4 kN m (hogging at the higher end, sagging at the lower); V = 12 × 2 × 10⁴ × 0.008/125 = 15.36 kN.
2An unloaded cantilever of span 4 m (EI = 1.6 × 10⁴ kN m²) has a new prop installed at the tip and jacked up 5 mm. Find the prop force and the root moment.
R = 3EIΔ/L³ = 3 × 1.6 × 10⁴ × 0.005/64 = 3.75 kN upward; root moment 3.75 × 4 = +15 kN m (sagging, = 3EIΔ/L²).
3A steel bar of area 2000 mm² is fixed between rigid supports and heated by 40 °C; E = 200 kN/mm², α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C. Find the force and stress.
N = EAαΔT = 200 × 2000 × 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 40 = 192 kN compression; σ = 96 N/mm².
4A fixed beam 0.6 m deep (EI = 5 × 10⁴ kN m²) has its top 15 °C warmer than its bottom; take α = 10 × 10⁻⁶ per °C. Find the restraint moment and the deflection.
M = EIαΔT/d = 5 × 10⁴ × 10 × 10⁻⁶ × 15/0.6 = 12.5 kN m, constant along the span; deflection zero.
5A two-span beam (6 m + 6 m, EI = 3 × 10⁴ kN m²), unloaded, has its middle support settle 10 mm. Find M_B and the change in the reactions.
Three-moment: 2M_B(12) = 6 × 3 × 10⁴ × (0.010/6 + 0.010/6) = 600, M_B = +25 kN m (sagging). R_A = R_C = +25/6 = +4.17 kN, R_B = −8.33 kN (the settling support loses 8.33 kN).
6In Example 3(a), the vertical rod is 2 mm too long instead. Find the forces.
X = −2/0.0531 = −37.67 kN (vertical rod in compression); outer rods +21.75 kN (tension).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.